Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a teddy a problem - advice from Muslim mumsnetters please!

132 replies

Teddyhelp · 25/10/2021 14:24

I ordered some flowers for a Muslim colleague who has just had a baby. I saw you could add a lovely stuffed bunny so I added that to the order. A bit later, I suddenly had a thought that this might not be okay so I googled it and it might not. I'm on hold trying to cancel the order but can anyone advise me if this will be completely unacceptable if the order gets delivered??? Causing any offence is the last thing I want to do. Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HappySM1 · 28/12/2021 22:33

@Phineyj

We do have a sizeable Muslim minority in this country but i) it's a minority and ii) very unevenly spread around the country. Why is it surprising that someone would seek advice before buying a gift? I did before choosing a Bat Mitsvah (sp?) gift for a Jewish friend's daughter. I've only needed to buy one once.
Totally agree. I don't go around asking whether Christians would be offended by something or not, because I am one, and I know.

I ask about other religions (Islam & Judaism, mainly) because although I know a fair amount I want to check for any unknown unknowns.

It's similar to asking guests you don't know that we'll if they have any allergies or dislikes. Or realising someone is a recovering alcoholic before giving them a bottle of wine.

You want to get it right because you care and are interested to learn more about them.

I don't think it's about offending or not offending someone, more about disappointing someone because you couldn't be bothered to do some research.

Pollypocket2021 · 28/12/2021 19:25

It’s permitted for children/ children’s toys. No problem.

jamandmarmalade · 26/10/2021 01:02

exactly @saltinesandcoffeecups and it's how we learn, no?
I would never have intended to cause offence to the dentist.

I think the fact that OP is checking to see if the teddy bear would have caused offence to the recipient is considerate and respectful. I can't see it as tip toeing just a way of learning and kindness to her colleague.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/10/2021 00:53

@jamandmarmalade

I’m with you… the more holidays and celebrations the better.

I went to many Bar Mitzvahs as a child, a local Rabbi came into my Catholic school and explained (with food) Passover, we used to celebrate Lunar New Year in my office, have been invited to wonderful work lunches to celebrate Diwali, shared a US Thanksgiving meal with newly emigrated Persians who brought their traditional foods to share.

Bring ‘em on. I’ll celebrate with anyone who wants to share!

Hey, and if I can ask a simple question to learn and make an effort to understand… I say piss off to anyone who tries to make feel bad for it.

MrsSiba · 26/10/2021 00:15

I'm Muslim and soft toys are regularly given as gifts for newborns, no problem there. You are doing a kind and thoughtful thing and anyone, Muslim or not, worth their salt would graciously accept in the manner it is given ☺️

Feedingthebirds1 · 26/10/2021 00:09

I have learned about the major religious holidays of leading religions, such as Eid ul-Fitr, as well as Ramadan, Diwali, Holi, as well as main Christian celebrations as a child, and thought this was quite usual general knowledge.

I think that's the nub of this thread. Where does general knowledge end and particular knowledge begin? I know about the main holidays, but there's a lot more to every religion than that.

At the university where I lecture there was a huge debate a few years ago when businesses and institutions everywhere, including us, were introducing photographic ID badges on lanyards. Some serious representations were made by mosque leaders that we shouldn't have them. That Muslims were not allowed to have their photograph taken, and that they were not allowed to see photographs of others either so no-one, regardless of religion, should wear one.

Therefore I understand the OP wanting to clarify the teddy/rabbit. And a lot of posters will have learned a bit more detail about Islamic beliefs from this thread.

Sleeplessem · 25/10/2021 22:16

@OnceuponaRainbow18

Huh why wouldn’t it be ok? And I’m a teacher of RE!
It’s actually quite a prevalent albeit conservative belief, particularly with those who identify as Salafi. I posted some links above.
BudrosBudrosGalli · 25/10/2021 21:44

@Zwellers

BudrosBudrosGalli. I will confess I wouldnt have a clue that the picture you put up was anything to do with Judaism. In fact I have never knowingly met anyone Jewish. So ignorance maybe but not wilful. I think some people forget that not everyone lives in a multicultural city.
Fair enough. Although I did head the image with 'Shana Tova'. I have learned about the major religious holidays of leading religions, such as Eid ul-Fitr, as well as Ramadan, Diwali, Holi, as well as main Christian celebrations as a child, and thought this was quite usual general knowledge.
GladAllOver · 25/10/2021 21:35

Yeah I think it’s v common to have images for Ali (ra) and the other Shia imams
Thank you both for the explanation. It does seem strange they interpret the rules this way, but it's not for me to judge.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 25/10/2021 20:19

Huh why wouldn’t it be ok? And I’m a teacher of RE!

yoghurtdaily · 25/10/2021 20:19

I'm muslim. We give each other teddies. When babies are born. Me and my sis in law don't stop giving teddies.

Don't think on it!

Sleeplessem · 25/10/2021 20:17

@Elopelo

Someone also mentioned images of religious leaders from Iran- I don’t know for certain as I am a Sunni Muslim but I think Shiah Muslims do allow illustrations of religious figures.
Yeah I think it’s v common to have images for Ali (ra) and the other Shia imams xx
Elopelo · 25/10/2021 20:13

Someone also mentioned images of religious leaders from Iran- I don’t know for certain as I am a Sunni Muslim but I think Shiah Muslims do allow illustrations of religious figures.

Elopelo · 25/10/2021 20:12

Sorry that last post was for @LondonerRandomName did try to quote your post but didn’t work.

Elopelo · 25/10/2021 20:11

Well yes that’s what I said in my original post that when it comes to kids toys and bears there is no problem and the prohibition doesn’t apply. You can check the Hadith re: Aishah and her dolls.

jamandmarmalade · 25/10/2021 19:41

@WorraLiberty

Isn't it being considerate?

But this is the whole point.

Most of the Muslim parents at the school/neighbours in the street, don't want 'special consideration'. They just want to live like every other parent and be treated the same.

Especially when 9 times out of 10, being considerate normally ends in the person saying "Because I don't want to offend".

It makes my best friend want to bang her head off the wall, because she feels like it makes people think Muslims are so easily offended.

I beg to differ. I gleefully wished my dentist (from the Lebanon) 'Merry Christmas' and the silent thunder fixed glare I received you would have thought i'd asked him for a kidney.

The entire dental surgery was decked out with decorations and christmas cards. There are many muslim and Jewish dentists there.
I tried to treat him the same as everyone else. I apologised, put on my coat and skidaddled. Christmas is the season of goodwill to all men.

If someone had wished me Happy Eid I would have taken it in the spirit it was intended. Sad

Lemonsandlemonade · 25/10/2021 19:35

@Elopelo

Hi OP. I’m Muslim and I can tell you that the teddy will be fine and will be much appreciated by your colleague. I wish I had colleagues as nice as you!

For previous posters asking, majority of Muslims do not like to have pictures or images of animate beings in their homes etc, this is because of many prohibitions dealing with drawings or images of faces etc, it’s just something that traditionally Muslims don’t do/like. It all goes back to the idea of not knowing what God/angels/Prophets look like. It’s why traditional Islamic art is usually made up of calligraphy and geometric patterns.

However when it comes to kids toys etc there is no issue.

I didn’t know this thanks for the information.

OP I’m sure it’s fine!

Sleeplessem · 25/10/2021 19:12

Also
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/islamqa.info/amp/en/answers/23445

Sleeplessem · 25/10/2021 19:09

Teddy bear is fine and is a lovely idea

Some v strict Muslims do believe you shouldn’t have thinks that are a true likeness to any living thing. This extends to toys, photos, dolls etc. I would say that of all the Muslims I’ve met (I am Muslim too) even those who are quite conservative do have commercially available toys for their children.

Ruling if you’re interested is below

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/islamqa.info/amp/en/answers/9473

MissTrip82 · 25/10/2021 19:09

[quote EileenGC]@treesandweeds there are also many branches of Christianity that don’t agree with Halloween celebrations, or choose not to mark Christmas in any special way (I’m not talking Jehovah Witnesses asking the school to refrain from singing about Santa Claus - just people not decorating or doing cards).

Do you go around thinking about the preferences or beliefs of non-Muslims too? Because it we’re being considerate, let’s not make it an exclusive thing for certain groups.

In my religion we don’t do Halloween, Christmas, Easter, and would try to avoid Harry Potter and Stranger Things for example, especially when it comes to the kids. My neighbours and colleagues at work have no idea about some of my beliefs and I wouldn’t think it inconsiderate if they gifted me something related to any of the above. I also don’t drink, but because I’m white no one thinks that it could ever offend me to receive a bottle of wine.[/quote]
Really?

I don’t give anyone wine unless I know they drink it, because I know many people do not. Equally I wouldn’t give people who I thought were Pentecostal Christians a range of gifts including anything vaguely supernatural, as I just don’t know if they’d be comfortable and there’s many other gifts to choose from.

So I get you think you’ve sprung a ‘gotcha’, but in fact many people are considerate of all others when it comes to gift-giving. I’m surprised you’ve not encountered anyone who thinks before they give a gift.

What a shame to try and make the OP feel that she’s in the wrong here.

NatriumChloride · 25/10/2021 19:06

😂

Somuchgoo · 25/10/2021 18:59

This is totally outing for any old flatmates of mine, but I once had a delivery that was sent to me by accident. Well more dropped on my doorstep, brand new in the packaging.

It was an Islamic Prayer Bear - a cuddly bear, that when you pressed his tummy, paws etc would teach Arabic phrases/prayers etc.

So I'm guessing they are fine

Zwellers · 25/10/2021 18:57

BudrosBudrosGalli. I will confess I wouldnt have a clue that the picture you put up was anything to do with Judaism. In fact I have never knowingly met anyone Jewish. So ignorance maybe but not wilful. I think some people forget that not everyone lives in a multicultural city.

LondonerRandomName · 25/10/2021 18:56

@Elopelo

Hi OP. I’m Muslim and I can tell you that the teddy will be fine and will be much appreciated by your colleague. I wish I had colleagues as nice as you!

For previous posters asking, majority of Muslims do not like to have pictures or images of animate beings in their homes etc, this is because of many prohibitions dealing with drawings or images of faces etc, it’s just something that traditionally Muslims don’t do/like. It all goes back to the idea of not knowing what God/angels/Prophets look like. It’s why traditional Islamic art is usually made up of calligraphy and geometric patterns.

However when it comes to kids toys etc there is no issue.

Not a single Muslim I know would think anything of a stuffed toy. It is literally just that. And I am saying that as one and grown up in an "Islamic". It is not a thing at all.
Saltpepperbutter · 25/10/2021 18:50

Not the point at all, but am I only person left who thinks teddies are just bears? Stuffed rabbits are… rabbits. When did all stuffed toys start being teddies?