Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if DS can leave school 10 minutes early?

64 replies

ScamTheSchool · 25/10/2021 14:11

DD9 has wanted to do an activity forever, and there is finally a class for her age group that I can get her to. If I have the car and if DH works from home so Ds 11, primary, can come home from school to someone.
DH said fine, he can arrange to work from home that day each week, no problem - I'll have the car and he will be home for DS.

Of course, now it's actually reality, he has said he can't possibly work from home that day and it's ridiculous for me to expect him to arrange his working week around our timetable. Problem being, I now have no one home for DS and potentially no car. We do have alternative transport, a scooter he bought so he wouldn't have to use the train to commute. This was not an issue last year, but apparently expecting him to take the scooter on the couple of days I need the car and he has to go into the office this year is because I want him to die Confused

If Ds is out on time and if there is no traffic we should be able to drive there with five mins to spare. But it's the first session and we don't know exactly where it is and Dd doesn't want to be late. Would it be totally wrong to ask if DS can miss the last 10 minutes of class (music lesson) this week so we can leave when we'd originally planned to leave?

OP posts:
stillonthattightrope · 25/10/2021 17:21

Big not bit

stillonthattightrope · 25/10/2021 17:20

If your husband is going to be such a dick, can you have a second car? I know that's a bit extra cost but might be worth it not to have to rely on him?

If it were me I'd be telling my partner I'm having the car because I need it more but I wouldn't have to because he's a reasonable person.

SoniaFouler · 25/10/2021 16:58

Through year 8 to year 9 I always missed the last lesson on a Thursday (Maths in year 8 and History in year 9) to attend an after school activity and it wasn’t an issue with school, but this was back in 2001 and I think schools are more strict now from what I hear. You could ask, but they will probably say no.

Kotatsu · 25/10/2021 16:49

Christ my ex did that - although around me getting a job one minute it was sure, I can do the drop offs and flexitime so I'm in an hour later (which would actually also have halved his commute time), then once I was offered something it was 'oh no, we have flexi, but they don't really want anyone to use it, I couldn't possibly take responsibility for my own kids).. our relationship hobbled on a few more years, but I think that was the beginning of me realising the utterly self-absorbed fucker he was.

How angry are you - can you set an ultimatum? Take the car as suggested above?

If not then sure my kids school would be fine with me grabbing DS (also 11) 5 minutes early if needed on a day - they are a particularly family-friendly school though.

Hellocatshome · 25/10/2021 16:18

I would say it was ok as a one off to ask but will it really be a one off?. Tbh your DH sounds like a twunt.

girlmom21 · 25/10/2021 16:18

Fuck him - take the car. Leave the house early in the morning with the car if you need to. Why should DD miss out because he's a selfish prick?

ScamTheSchool · 25/10/2021 16:14

And I find the scooter heavy and hard to manage so I'm not willing to take the DC on it as I don't think I could cope with the added weight. It's 15-20 mins away depending on traffic, which will be less the earlier I leave.

OP posts:
ScamTheSchool · 25/10/2021 16:12

How far from school is the activity? Could you get DD there then go back for DS?
Yes potentially if I have the car. Not really if I have to taxi there.

OP posts:
ScamTheSchool · 25/10/2021 16:11

Has he thought about how many of us who has actually worked (among other people) throughout the pandemic?! Guess what, we’re still here and still not working from home!
He means from having to drive(? Ride?) the scooter in the dark/bad/cold weather rather than COVID.

Why can’t your husband work from home (or use the scooter) for just the first session?
Because he's arranged for a meeting in the office, despite me reminding him, putting it in the family diary, DD talking incessantly about it.... So, I don't see why he shouldn't take the scooter. Although I do admit it doesn't seem very inviting. But it's one of the reasons he bought it.

OP posts:
Viciouslybashed · 25/10/2021 16:09

I would take the car early in the morning so he has to use the scooter or work from home. Not fair if him at all.

girlmom21 · 25/10/2021 16:02

Your husband is a selfish arse. Poor kids.

How far from school is the activity? Could you get DD there then go back for DS?

Crazycakelady17 · 25/10/2021 16:01

Your DH sounds controlling
I think your DS in y6 and 11 should be fine for a few hours but you know him best.
My DH committed to finishing early on a Thursday and working later on a Friday to make up the hours so DD could go horse riding as I don’t drive I would be livid if he back tracked on that not a issue anymore as she’s in the next class up so later so he can finish as normal now
What will happen in sept when DS goes to high school with this activity as the high schools
Usually have different finish times to primary

HalzTangz · 25/10/2021 15:59

Can you drive to the place before the first class so you know where it is and how long it will take? Why wait until the first class to do this

icedcoffees · 25/10/2021 15:56

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

I would just turn around to dh and say

"You assured me you could wfh on a Tuesday. I booked the class because you told me you will be here. You are letting your dd down - in order for her to attend the group, you need to do what you said you could do. Your choices are either work from home that day, or get yourself to work and back in a way which leaves me the car. Let me know by the time you go to bed which of these two options you are going to choose"

Then just walk away.

This.

Don't let your DH backtrack and make things complicated for you. He agreed to WFH so now he needs to go through with it.

appleturnovers · 25/10/2021 15:53

it's ridiculous for me to expect him to arrange his working week around our timetable

Hang on, is this your husband, and the father of your children, or is it a flatmate or lodger? It's just that phrasing it like that makes it sound as though the children are solely your problem and he has no responsibility for them at all, and that can't be right, so I wondered if I'd misunderstood...

e do have alternative transport, a scooter he bought so he wouldn't have to use the train to commute. This was not an issue last year, but apparently expecting him to take the scooter on the couple of days I need the car and he has to go into the office this year is because I want him to die

Your husband is a selfish c*.

benelephant · 25/10/2021 15:51

OP I feel for you. You and DH are supposed to be a team working together to fit everything in. I've been in your position. I'm afraid to say it was never resolved, DP became more and more awkward and we had to split up. If this is a regular thing then you have a bigger problem than not being able to get to the group. In the short-term I'd say it's ok to collect five mins early this time but not for any other weeks. Good luck however you sort it out.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 25/10/2021 15:42

I would just turn around to dh and say

"You assured me you could wfh on a Tuesday. I booked the class because you told me you will be here. You are letting your dd down - in order for her to attend the group, you need to do what you said you could do. Your choices are either work from home that day, or get yourself to work and back in a way which leaves me the car. Let me know by the time you go to bed which of these two options you are going to choose"

Then just walk away.

CheesyMother · 25/10/2021 15:41

Why can’t your husband work from home (or use the scooter) for just the first session? He’s an arse, but would he perhaps be slightly less of an arse for one week?

Wintermagic · 25/10/2021 15:41

and he has to go into the office this year is because I want him to die

Your husband really need to get a grip. Has he thought about how many of us who has actually worked (among other people) throughout the pandemic?! Guess what, we’re still here and still not working from home! Entitled behaviour like this annoys the shit out of me.

MatildaJayne · 25/10/2021 15:28

A key on a zippy wire attached to the inside of his school bag or inside his coat pocket? Only on that one day a week. 2 hours at home alone is fine for a Y6 child who will be going to secondary school soon, imo. But you know your DS best, of course.

ScamTheSchool · 25/10/2021 15:17

aside from that it does sound like this class is not really convenient all round .
Why? If, as agreed, DH is working from home then I can leave 40 minutes before DD's class starts.

OP posts:
Floralnomad · 25/10/2021 15:13

Your husband sounds like a right twat , aside from that it does sound like this class is not really convenient all round .

ScamTheSchool · 25/10/2021 15:08

I scouted out the building and parking but it looked closed so still don't know where she has to go once inside.

Can’t your DS at age 11, walk home from school and let himself in and be home alone for an hour or so
Yes and no. He doesn't want the responsibility of a key. If I don't have the car, I'd have to get a taxi, then I can't really afford a taxi back and then a taxi back to get DD (25 each way). So he'd be alone 2-2.5 hours which is too long.

OP posts:
MatildaJayne · 25/10/2021 14:58

Oh, and your ‘D’ H is a twat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread