Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which is the best country for an NHS doctor to Immigrate?

113 replies

JetRocket · 25/10/2021 12:12

Just looking for advice on which are the best/easiest countries for an NHS doctor midway through specialist training (finished CT3) to immigrate to?

We have 2 small children and only speak English fluently.

Anyone who has done it before, would be very pleased to hear your thoughts. Never thought we’d consider it but after 2 years of beyond hideous treatment we just can’t cope anymore our families mental health and work life balance is in shambles.

OP posts:
PinkiOcelot · 25/10/2021 13:26

@Snoopsnoggysnog so would it have been better had the OP written would I be unreasonable to emigrate whilst still in training?! FFS!!
@Mantlemoose who the hell has shat in your cornflakes?!! Shitty response!

MrsColon · 25/10/2021 13:22

New Zealand is excellent, my best mate moved there a few years ago. Better pay, fewer hours, hugely better lifestyle.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 25/10/2021 13:19

Dd is a medical student so no actual experience of yours yet. However, she's been doing some research into this as she plans on moving abroad (we're in Ireland) for a while, at least. She had just looked at it from a post grad perspective while still training.

The US is really crap apparently when still training. No work life balance. Australia seems far and away the best. The Netherlands is also a very good option but you would have to learn Dutch and brexit might mean it's no longer an option for you.

Someone upthread suggested Ireland. It's not great here either while still training so I wouldn't recommend it.

Fizzbangwallop · 25/10/2021 13:16

Before you decide to emigrate, is it worth considering going LTFT for a better work/life balance? Also some areas of the UK are much nicer (and cheaper!) to live and work in than others.

orangeautumnleaves · 25/10/2021 13:03

@LowlandLucky

Are you planning on paying back the cost of the training you have had so far ?
Do you mean the degree that she paid 9K in tuition fees per annum for, for at least 5 years so £45K, just for the privilege to serve on the NHS?

The debt most Drs now graduate with in close to £80K so what exactly should she be paying?

RedMarauder · 25/10/2021 12:57

OP the people I know have gone and stayed in Canada, New Zealand and Australia but all of them had completed their training. Others who had a bit of back and forth have gone to Gibraltar and Australia.

Casamilano · 25/10/2021 12:57

I worked in Australia as a Registered Nurse/midwife. Absolutely loved it. You’ll probably be living in the city so no worries re wildlife. You just have to keep an eye out for the spiders.

RedMarauder · 25/10/2021 12:54

@LowlandLucky

Are you planning on paying back the cost of the training you have had so far ?
You mean the training while the OP was treating patients undergoing life and death situations? Or do you just mean the training the OP got as an undergraduate student?
LowlandLucky · 25/10/2021 12:51

Are you planning on paying back the cost of the training you have had so far ?

bringmelaughter · 25/10/2021 12:35

@Mantlemoose

Oh no don't go, we need you. There I've said it, off you pop now. Do you really think other people all over the world aren't in the same position. You're a doctor, you signed up for what you had to do..I pity the care home staff, the supermarket workers and such like paid considerably less than you are. And no I didn't clap for you and yes I have used the nhs lots but that's what I pay tax for!
No people did not sign up to the poor working conditions they’re in. This demonstrates a total lack of insight or willingness to understand.

People in the NHS are the first to have concerns about social care workers, we see the awful working conditions there often at first hand or when talking to our social care colleagues. It doesn’t mean that people in the NHS are less likely to be pushed beyond their limits just because colleagues are also treated badly. People have been pushed beyond their limits.

Have a look at volunteering in the NHS then you could come back with an informed view.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 25/10/2021 12:35

Why is this in AIBU?

Sunshineshow · 25/10/2021 12:35

We’ve lived in a few countries, whenever we’ve used the health care in those countries the doctors and nurses all spoke English pretty fluently as well as their native language as a matter of course, and maybe another. As a sole English speaker you are a bit limited.

Cameleongirl · 25/10/2021 12:35

I’m not a medic myself but know a couple of doctors who’ve emigrated to North America. I’d start by researching whether your qualifications are recognized in a particular country/what you need to do to become licensed in a certain country. That would obviously be a huge factor. Canada’s health service is woefully overstretched from what I understand, I’m not sure you’d be trading up moving there. The US is better quality of life-wise for doctors, but you definitely have to take exams to gain your license-I know two people who’ve done it and it takes a while.

Sorry these are negative suggestions, but perhaps it helps you to cross them off your list!

pooonastick · 25/10/2021 12:35

Made the move to Australia and have no regrets from a professional perspective. Feel free to pm me .

PaddingtonsHat · 25/10/2021 12:34

@Mantlemoose

Oh no don't go, we need you. There I've said it, off you pop now. Do you really think other people all over the world aren't in the same position. You're a doctor, you signed up for what you had to do..I pity the care home staff, the supermarket workers and such like paid considerably less than you are. And no I didn't clap for you and yes I have used the nhs lots but that's what I pay tax for!
So because you are a doctor and paid for your years of training and responsibility, you should put up with working conditions that make you unhappy?
Scirocco · 25/10/2021 12:34

Come to Scotland (if you aren't already here, in which case, stay in Scotland)! The healthcare system is different from England in a number of key ways which in my experience make it a better system to work in (not perfect by any means, but better). There are lots of training placements, specialty doctor jobs and locum opportunities in most specialities. We've got cities, towns, rural areas, and the wildlife is pretty civilised - plus, even in our biggest cities you're still less than an hour away from some stunning countryside.

Despite the accents, we do speak English and the training systems/qualifications are the same as south of the border.

Mummydoctor · 25/10/2021 12:33

I have a friend who moved to Australia after completing GP training. She is much happier there than any of the rest of our cohort, but depends on how easily you’ll settle away from family/support network.

I’m on a useful FB page specifically for doctors looking for alternative career paths. If you message me I could share with you.

Fetarabbit · 25/10/2021 12:29

Realistically, Australia is probably the best bet, NZ is a wonderful country but due to several factors at your level you'd be unlikely to find anything. Conditions aren't a tonne better to be honest, but if you want a change worth a look into. Avoid America.

Ozanj · 25/10/2021 12:29

Another option if you want improved work life balance is to move into hedge fund management (health funds). As a qualified doctor you could just email the managers directly for opportunities & they would probably be really interested.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/10/2021 12:29

Ireland? English speaking, in the EU and not too far from home.

orangeautumnleaves · 25/10/2021 12:27

@Mantlemoose

Oh no don't go, we need you. There I've said it, off you pop now. Do you really think other people all over the world aren't in the same position. You're a doctor, you signed up for what you had to do..I pity the care home staff, the supermarket workers and such like paid considerably less than you are. And no I didn't clap for you and yes I have used the nhs lots but that's what I pay tax for!
Really? I think many other counties have far better working conditions than the NHS so why shouldn't health care professionals leave? It's a brain drain on the state for sure but the tories should have thought about that before depleting the NHS of its resources and squeezing it so tight to bursting point.

Absolutely no HCP should feel any loyalty to stay especially if it's affecting their mental health and quality of life.

FireFLYing19 · 25/10/2021 12:24

@Mantlemoose

Oh no don't go, we need you. There I've said it, off you pop now. Do you really think other people all over the world aren't in the same position. You're a doctor, you signed up for what you had to do..I pity the care home staff, the supermarket workers and such like paid considerably less than you are. And no I didn't clap for you and yes I have used the nhs lots but that's what I pay tax for!
Why on earth are you replying with such an unhelpful comment? Keep your sour thoughts to yourself if you are going to be of no help. What is wrong with some people?!
Ozanj · 25/10/2021 12:24

I know several junior doctor (CT3) who went to India to complete their training and then later returned to the UK as consultants. All of them just spoke English and said they really enjoyed completing their specialisms there. (None of them were / wanted to be GPs)

Another option is Australia but as a CT3 you may need to be tied to specific geographic areas. Not sure if this has changed post covid

I wouldn’t recommend Canada yet because from my friend’s experience you often have to take on further studies / revalidate every 5 years depending on speciality. You might be better off waiting until after you have completed your specialism in the UK.

EileenGC · 25/10/2021 12:24

I’m in Germany and have a few friends who moved to the healthcare system here, from other countries. The conditions are great and quality of life is good from what they say. But you do need to learn German very well before being allowed to start working in a hospital for example.

showmethegin · 25/10/2021 12:24

@Mantlemoose

Oh no don't go, we need you. There I've said it, off you pop now. Do you really think other people all over the world aren't in the same position. You're a doctor, you signed up for what you had to do..I pity the care home staff, the supermarket workers and such like paid considerably less than you are. And no I didn't clap for you and yes I have used the nhs lots but that's what I pay tax for!
Did that make you feel better?