Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which is the best country for an NHS doctor to Immigrate?

113 replies

JetRocket · 25/10/2021 12:12

Just looking for advice on which are the best/easiest countries for an NHS doctor midway through specialist training (finished CT3) to immigrate to?

We have 2 small children and only speak English fluently.

Anyone who has done it before, would be very pleased to hear your thoughts. Never thought we’d consider it but after 2 years of beyond hideous treatment we just can’t cope anymore our families mental health and work life balance is in shambles.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DrBlobby999 · 25/05/2022 05:59

@TinkysWinky
Well done for leaving! Ive been very sad about leaving the NHS up until recently. I also work in management for our very large county and can see no change in the toxic culture of squeezing people's good will until they are drained. A very good friend of mine, and by far the best GP I've worked with, has recently been signed off with burnout. Very eye-opening for me as if they are struggling then no hope for me!
I'm starting to look forward to leaving now as I hope DH will be less stressed. Tbh he's been a different person since he got the job. Like a weights been lifted off him! We are just waiting for the final bits of paperwork and then adiós :)
I do worry about the loved ones I'm leaving behind. Access to healthcare is utterly abysmal should they ever need it.

Musicaltheatremum · 25/05/2022 05:25

MamsellMarie · 25/10/2021 19:08

I'm in Scotland and still no one gets to see their GP face to face. Everything's behind - scans, ultrasounds etc Not sure whereabouts they other poster was.

I'm seeing all my patients face to face now. Scotland. Have been since November.

TinkysWinky · 24/05/2022 23:41

Good luck @DrBlobby999! I left the NHS 6 months ago for a completely different industry (non medical role). The NHS is haemorrhaging talent at an alarming rate, due to understaffing and horrendous working conditions. I was a high achiever, top of the year at medical school, a qualified and experienced GP. No longer was I willing to prop up a failing system with my own personal responsibility and the sacrifice of my personal life. Just in case anyone remains unclear on this - you can thank us all leaving to the Tory government who have systematically underfunded and underresourced the NHS with their own goals in mind (privatisation!) to the stage that the staff, clinical and non-clinical are at breaking point.

DrBlobby999 · 24/05/2022 18:57

Hi @JetRocket
What happened? Have you decided where you are heading?
DP and I are both GPs about to move to the middle east imminently! So glad to be leaving the UK behind

Taytotots · 26/10/2021 09:52

@Onesailwait no we want the OP on the other Canadian coast - gp shortage bad here too! Grin Although I am lucky enough to have one and found the system much quicker than nhs (and I have had cancer treatment here and couldn't fault it). Different provinces have different rules on requalifying. My GPs are from UK and had to pick where they moved to carefully.

User112 · 26/10/2021 09:41

Don’t rule out Canada yet. Someone in my extended friends circle moved to Halifax in Nova Scotia (both GPs) and are really happy there

Ozanj · 26/10/2021 09:35

Ye I have cousins who moved from the NHS to Canada. It is very much same shit different country and a lot of native Canadian consultants prefer to live there but work along the US side of the border - but that option is only available if you have US recognised qualifications.

gogohm · 25/10/2021 22:11

My friends moved to Canada but he was already a consultant. It's really hard to move to the USA. I would be wary of the grass is greener phenomenon- health services everywhere have been really stretched and until you are fully qualified you will need to work with their training system which may be quite different and even if pay is higher, you may have far higher costs eg insurance, study costs. Plus remember as a condition of visas sometimes you have to go to less desirable parts of a country. (My friend wanted to go to Australia to teach but you had to go to Darwin for the first 2 years!)

shylatte · 25/10/2021 20:48

My best friend is a GP and moved to Perth. They love it and say they will never come back to live in UK. Their 3 dc seem to have a much more independent life, cycle to school alone and have a great outdoor sport schedule. The work/life balance is so much better than the UK.

Cameleongirl · 25/10/2021 19:19

@Onesailwait

Please come to BC specifically Vancouver island. I've been on waitlists for 8yrs trying to get a family Dr. Tried to get into a walk in clinic today. All at capacity by 9am.
That's awful, @Onesailwait, but it doesn't surprise me. DH has a Canadian friend who's had significant health problems in recent years (we're in the US). He has said bluntly that he thinks he'd be dead if he still lived in Canada, because he wouldn't have been seen/treated quickly enough (he's recovering from cancer). I know that's just an anecdote, but it sounds as if the Canadian system is really over-stretched. Sad
MamsellMarie · 25/10/2021 19:08

I'm in Scotland and still no one gets to see their GP face to face. Everything's behind - scans, ultrasounds etc Not sure whereabouts they other poster was.

Mooda · 25/10/2021 18:51

Good friend is in Australia now - GP. They went when kids were 8 and 6. He was also offered a role in NZ. Their preference was Canada but there was a reason they couldn't get a visa, not sure of the ins an outs. Professionally he is so much happier there although they do miss friends and family and covid has exacerbated that. But there is no way he could return to the NHS at the moment, his mental health was shot here, and that was pre covid. Good luck OP.

mustlovegin · 25/10/2021 18:43

Oh, and we did clap in this house OP Smile Flowers

Ozanj · 25/10/2021 18:08

@orangeautumnleaves

And like a pp has already mentioned we have no problem touting health care professionals from countries that have a dire need for them such as The Philippines and India, but our own get guilted into leaving by some of these attitudes here. You cannot have it both ways!
Yes. It used to be the case that Indian students who were studying an MBBS on government scholarships would get approached by agencies while studying so their first role was in the NHS & they never actually got to work in India.
Awalkintime · 25/10/2021 17:57

@HyacynthBucket

While I sympathise hugely with anyone in today's NHS, the government did pay for most of your medical training? It takes an average of £220,000 to train a doctor in the UK. I expect to get shot down for this, but unless you are willing to pay back a substantial proportion of that from future earnings made elsewhere, it might be best to stay in the UK. It is being widely recognised that the NHS has reached rock bottom, so maybe the only way is up? if you can stick it out. Is there any chance of moving to a different NHS Trust area that might be better run?
How about people who trained here are allowed to live where they want because we treat them like shit. Yes it costs us money but if we treated them with decency we would get that back.

However, we also gain when Drs from abroad come to work here - we gain by not having had to pay for them to train.

Swings and roundabouts. It's never been an issue before covid and then all of a sudden people think Drs owe them money. They do not, they have given service, were treated like shite and decided to leave before it killed them.

TheKeatingFive · 25/10/2021 17:28

I know a number of people who went to Australia. They all came back after a few years though, so make of that what you will.

Onesailwait · 25/10/2021 17:25

Please come to BC specifically Vancouver island. I've been on waitlists for 8yrs trying to get a family Dr. Tried to get into a walk in clinic today. All at capacity by 9am.

showerswithsunshine · 25/10/2021 17:18

@godmum56

I trained as an Occupational Therapist some 40 years ago. No there was never any contract but the moral expectation from the college was that on qualification we would work for the same number years within the NHS that our training had taken. I belive that in the armed services, there actually is a contract, for people who do an army funded degree, that they will work in the army for a set number of years once they graduate.
You surely know that doctors graduate with a huge amount of debt and that their degree is at least 2 (now often 3) years longer than the average degree. 6 years of degree + 6 years of obligatory work is a long time to be unhappy. Anyway, most doctors pretty much are already obliged to work in the NHS for a significant amount of time. Moving abroad is not an option for many people and working privately is not possible until GP / consultant level.

I'm not sure I want a health system that is staffed by people who are miserable and would far rather be somewhere else. Is it that difficult to look after our healthcare professionals?

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/10/2021 17:16

@HyacynthBucket

While I sympathise hugely with anyone in today's NHS, the government did pay for most of your medical training? It takes an average of £220,000 to train a doctor in the UK. I expect to get shot down for this, but unless you are willing to pay back a substantial proportion of that from future earnings made elsewhere, it might be best to stay in the UK. It is being widely recognised that the NHS has reached rock bottom, so maybe the only way is up? if you can stick it out. Is there any chance of moving to a different NHS Trust area that might be better run?
I'm willing to bet the UK has poached more doctors from much poorer countries that can ill afford to lose them. So it all comes out in the wash. Certainly not one of my doctors in the UK had a UK accent. And most of the hospital staff were European, African, Caribbean.

OP do what's right for you. I'd keep an eye on the rules for medics because post-covid, I bet many countries will sorely need you.

orangeautumnleaves · 25/10/2021 17:14

And like a pp has already mentioned we have no problem touting health care professionals from countries that have a dire need for them such as The Philippines and India, but our own get guilted into leaving by some of these attitudes here. You cannot have it both ways!

PooWillyNameChange · 25/10/2021 17:14

I was at a friend's on Friday night. Her husband is a GP and says we are losing people left right and centre to Australia. Apparently in some specialities they can make up to 10k for a private shift!!!

Hillary17 · 25/10/2021 17:10

Dubai. Easy.

mbosnz · 25/10/2021 17:07

Yeah, let's guilt-trip them into staying. Rather than actually properly staffing well maintained hospitals and providing half way decent working conditions and pay that keeps up with both the rising cost of living and how many hours they are actually working, rather than contracted to work.

orangeautumnleaves · 25/10/2021 17:04

@godmum56

I trained as an Occupational Therapist some 40 years ago. No there was never any contract but the moral expectation from the college was that on qualification we would work for the same number years within the NHS that our training had taken. I belive that in the armed services, there actually is a contract, for people who do an army funded degree, that they will work in the army for a set number of years once they graduate.
Yes but then you didn't pay fees. Now Drs pay tuition fees like anyone else and usual graduate with a debt of circa £80K. I qualified in 1999 and graduated with a debt of £7k!!
godmum56 · 25/10/2021 16:55

I trained as an Occupational Therapist some 40 years ago. No there was never any contract but the moral expectation from the college was that on qualification we would work for the same number years within the NHS that our training had taken.
I belive that in the armed services, there actually is a contract, for people who do an army funded degree, that they will work in the army for a set number of years once they graduate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread