Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Difficult uncle situation

39 replies

Jane032 · 25/10/2021 05:16

I have a toddler who is much loved by my DH and myself and the grandparents. My husband's brother has autism and lives in assisted accommodation. He has trouble regulating his emotions and sometimes has aggressive outburst and once was even in court for threatening a staff member (where he lives) with a knife. My DH previously described him as a "creepy uncle" of the family and his cousin mentioned that his teenage daughters feel uncomfortable around him. I mentioned to my DH previously that I would not feel comfortable with his parents babysitting alone if his brother was around. Although they are lovely people they are in their 70s and 80s and they could not protect our DC if the uncle had an aggressive outburst. My DH agreed and said we'll just tell them that.
However last weekend we were visiting the grandparents and MIL mentioned that the uncle (DH's brother) is staying with them next week as some work is being done on his accommodation and whether it is okay they bring him to come babysitting (the babysitting has been scheduled for a couple of weeks, it is not a regular occurrence). I sad "I'm not so sure about it" and looked at my DH hopping he'll explain, but he just said "yes, that should be fine". I was really upset about this and when we were alone reminded him about our previous agreement (he said he forgot) and he said that he'll talk to MIL. After talking to her he said she was very disappointed and DH was very sad and told me he feels torn and like he's betraying his mum and brother. I obviously don't want him to be sad, but what should I do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AspCommie · 25/10/2021 16:30

I think your DH would be betraying your child if he allowed them to be in a situation where they may not be safe.

His DB and DM feelings are not the priority here.

Skeumorph · 25/10/2021 16:24

He felt he was 'betraying' his mum and brother... but was happy to call him the 'creepy uncle' behind their backs?

No, he isn't 'torn' or feeling terrible... he's just a coward who won't support you if it means an awkward conversation. He clearly has little loyalty to his brother when it comes to making him the butt of a cheap joke, so you can ignore that.

He's just a coward.

I would bypass him, talk to MIL yourself, and tell your shitty DH that the next time he suddenly has an attack of 'loyalty' when it comes to awkward conversations, you'll tell MIL that he refers to his brother as the creepy uncle so he clearly doesn't think the way he claims to.

ANameChangeAgain · 25/10/2021 16:18

You have made the right decision. I wouldn't villainise your DH as some would suggest, as I think families in this situation don't necessarily see their family member in the same way that outsiders do, they can often underestimate what they are capable of. The important thing is that you made a stand and your DH backed you up. Of course he's going to be upset, he has had to face the fact that his brother is a threat to your children, which is a pretty tough pill to swallow.

AnneLovesGilbert · 25/10/2021 09:10

How difficult for you. The only thing that matters is the safety of your child. Everyone else’s feelings are just that and not your problem.

You’ve done the right thing. You now know you can’t trust your husband or his parents and that’s awful.

dottiedodah · 25/10/2021 09:06

It's a shame your dh is upset. However your dd comes first here.he would be even more upset if dd came to any harm at the hands of her uncle. I would cancel your plans and rearrange at a time uncle isn't there.the Young nieces are not comfortable around him.that should tell dh all he needs to know!

EnjoyingTheSilence · 25/10/2021 09:04

Ask you dh and his mum how sad they’d feel if anything happened to you child? They’re both being ridiculous, this is for your bil benefit as well, it’s not fair putting him in a situation he might not be able to cope with.

Rainbowheart1 · 25/10/2021 09:00

He would be more sad if an accident happened involving the baby.

Rangoon · 25/10/2021 08:58

I long for the days of real men. You know the sort who knew that the father's duty was to protect their children - they were out there fighting the sabre tooth tiger at the cave entrance instead of engaging in existential angst. Instead your husband is being all sad because you quite reasonably don't believe that your small child should be left with somebody violent and unpredictable while only being protected by two elderly frail people. What a wet idiot your husband is and your in-laws aren't much better. I mean it's not like your husband and his family have had a sudden ephiphany about his brother - they have long known that he is dangerous and unpredictable. Yes I can see your MIL doesn't like to think of one of her sons as being too dangerous to trust with children but she should be thinking of protecting her grandson before all.

BowledOverly · 25/10/2021 08:58

Your DH needs to stop feeling sad about protecting his child. Sometimes being a parent means making the hard choices and he should feel proud he’s done that.

IntermittentParps · 25/10/2021 08:55

Your husband is pathetic. He 'forgot' your previous agreement? How convenient. He's very sad? What is he, three? 'he feels torn and like he's betraying his mum and brother.' Drama llama.
He'll just have to get over it/himself.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 25/10/2021 08:20

Your DH will just have to come to terms with it
I had to stop my elderly inlaws looking after my youngest cos I judged it wasn't safe. That caused awkwardness and upset but it was still the right thing to do.

Hoppinggreen · 25/10/2021 08:17

Well firstly your H didn’t “forget” did he? As someone else said he threw you under the bus.
As for feeling sad well he will just have to suck it up, protecting yourself child is more important

NewlyGranny · 25/10/2021 08:05

Nothing. You do nothing. The agreement was made and DH didn't forget, he caved because he was too uncomfortable saying no to his DPs.

He has to fix this, not you. The no has to come from him; this is his family and it's his child he's protecting.

All you need to do is tell him no, the risk to your child's safety is not to be taken and having got you all into the situation, he is the one who must get you out!

smoko · 25/10/2021 08:03

Wow your husband's really thrown you under the bus there.

Do you honestly believe he forgot this conversation & agreement?

How is he not betraying his daughter by wanting to let her hang out with "creepy uncle" when he previoustly agreed that wouldn't be happening? (his own words!)

I honestly could not be with someone who was so fickle & weak, moping around they'd "betrayed" their family while throwing partner & child under the bus. What a weak hypocrite.

If I were you would be calling MIL & setting her straight that your partner privately has called his brother "creepy uncle" & told you your neices are uncomfortable around him.

He will be putting all this on you during his conversation with his mummy & this will in turn unfairly create an atmophere centred around you when you're around your IL's.

Holly60 · 25/10/2021 07:51

@Jane032

Thank you, we did cancel babysitting. The problem is that my husband is upset and feels like he's betraying his mum and his brother. I think this is very much a safety issue, but he (my husband) is still very sad about it.
I wonder if your husband has acknowledged that he has a right to feel sad and to mourn what he doesn’t have.

To acknowledge that he has probably felt sad his entire life, and that this is totally reasonable.

He is mourning the sibling relationship he would have wished for, and now it is for the relationship he wishes his brother could have with his children. Also recognising his mum has probably always been sad about what his brother has missed out on, and this is just another thing to mourn. That he can’t be an involved uncle.

BUT none of this is your DHs fault. He is a victim of circumstance the same as everyone in the family. He cannot fix his brother so his mum is not sad. He cannot put his child in a potentially dangerous situation. He has to simply work through his grief and sadness the same as his mum will have to. With you there for support.

And then perhaps work out a way, another time, for his brother to have a relationship with your DC, in a way that is safe.

Muttly · 25/10/2021 07:47

Tough situation. I have a son with ASD and he has some school friends with some very challenging behaviours so I do understand your MIL’s disappointment. But disappointment or not, she is still wrong in her expectation that your DD will be put in a vulnerable situation to ease her emotions. Your DH needs to start understanding that it is ok for his mother to be upset when she has unrealistic expectations around his daughter’s safety. It won’t be the last time.

rwalker · 25/10/2021 07:39

It's a complete no win situation sad but it is what it is. move on

Beautiful3 · 25/10/2021 07:29

Your husband is out of order, he should be supporting you. He didn't forget, he just didn't want to.be the bad guy, saying it.

Beautiful3 · 25/10/2021 07:28

I'm sorry but surely your main priority as a parent is the safety of your child? Not, never hurting people's feelings! If his outbursts can be violent then hell no!

CiaoEB · 25/10/2021 07:18

Your child’s safety is a priority beyond anyone’s hurt feelings. I really like the PPs post about saying how you’re really sorry too but reinforce your boundaries. No one gets to guilt you into compromising your child’s safety, especially after the incident with the knife and other children feeling uncomfortable around him.

TasteTheMeatNotTheHeat · 25/10/2021 07:10

My brother is austistic and it does unfortunately result in some very challenging behaviour. I love him very much but I would never leave him alone with my pets or my children. It's sad but as PP have said, your child's safety comes first.

Your DH is probably just feeling this way because his Mum is upset.

IWantT0BreakFree · 25/10/2021 07:08

Your husband has properly fucked this up. You had a very sensible agreement in place but at the first sign of the issue raising its head, he's chucked you under the bus and made you the bad guy. Instead of doing the right thing and prioritising the safety of his DC, he's made it look like he's totally happy for his brother to babysit and it's just you that has the problem. As well as the obvious risk of this causing friction between you and your in-laws, the fact that they think your husband approves of his brother having this kind of contact with the DC which will reinforce to them the illusion that it's perfectly safe and not a problem. What a spineless, disloyal arsehole. I'd be fuming.

Your DH may well feel conflicted, sad, disappointed, uncomfortable, and I imagine a million other things. That's the nature of these kind of issues in a family. Of course it's sad. Of course everyone wishes it were different. But he's a father FGS! He has to put his own emotions aside and act in the safety of his children. He shouldn't need reminding of this, but I would be reminding him very sharply. What a knob.

Whydidimarryhim · 25/10/2021 06:55

Pay for a babysitter going forward as next time they may not tell you he’s around.
Your husband is going to have to get over it - he can feel the emotions and let them pass. He will be ok.

StoppinBy · 25/10/2021 06:54

Tell him to look at it this way

Can I deal with upsetting my Mum/feeling like I am betraying my brother in order to keep my child out of harms way?

Can I live with my child being injured or hurt because I didn't want to hurt my Mum/feel like I betrayed my brother?

I know what I would choose.

clockledd · 25/10/2021 06:52

We had a very very similar situation. In the end I told the grandparents that I was sorry, we love uncle X, but we had to prioritise the safety of our DC. They knew themselves that they couldn't do anything if he became violent. Firstly you need to speak to your DH, you'll need a united front on this. I have to be honest, we did upset a couple of family members with our decision but mostly people understood.

Swipe left for the next trending thread