Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that refusing to do an handover so you can be called back as a consultant is a dick move?

155 replies

AFewScrewsLucy · 24/10/2021 20:45

Colleague handed in notice. And has outright refused to do a handover of knowledge, because they wants company to keep them on with a retainer and consultancy fees. so when a particular procedure happens, the company would have to being them back and pay them to do the work? They are leaving to start their new business in consultancy for this procedure.There is a member of staff that will be taking the role on and the procedure is quite specific to the company.
Is this person a dick, or that's just how business works etc.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 24/10/2021 22:28

I can see how companies find themselves in this position. They implement a system but then leave development to an in-house person. At the time it suits the company as this type of development is highly bespoke and also very cheap. The in-house developer gets minimal reward for their work as the company downplays its value basically because it was free to them.

Now the company is stuck. I am in STB ex-employee's position except that I don't have anyone to handover to. My employers are having to offer far more than I was paid even to get any interest from candidates.

AFewScrewsLucy · 24/10/2021 22:28

@User527294627

I don’t think your colleague is an asshole for not sharing a process they’ve developed themselves, for free. If the company needs this knowledge they have to pay for it. Or they have to trust that you can work it out, which at the moment they clearly don’t. Maybe you will get the opportunity to prove to them that you can once your colleague has left.
They haven't done it "for free" they're paid to do the job in which they developed the procedure on company time, on company resources after being sent in a training course the company paid for... What part of that is them doing it "for free?" Confused
OP posts:
Windinmyhair · 24/10/2021 22:26

@Hont1986 fantastic!

Windinmyhair · 24/10/2021 22:25

Given the employee is still on company time, presumably they are in breach of contract by not doing as requested.

If I was the manager, I'd look to arrange training for you from the development company.

I would also be looking at their contract for any non compete clauses which companies sometimes have, look at taking them to court for breach of contract, or start a disciplinary process (which would then affect references that would be given. References might not be the most important, but the person might need them in the early days of their business).

Hont1986 · 24/10/2021 22:19

Get IT to install a secret keylogger/screen recorder on their system. Then get this person to run their report without having to teach anyone. Now you've got a video of their process.

PackedintheUK · 24/10/2021 22:15

@User527294627

I don’t think your colleague is an asshole for not sharing a process they’ve developed themselves, for free. If the company needs this knowledge they have to pay for it. Or they have to trust that you can work it out, which at the moment they clearly don’t. Maybe you will get the opportunity to prove to them that you can once your colleague has left.
They haven't done it for free, it's what they were employed to do. Any work you create while working for an employer belongs to the employer.

Where the company went wrong was not ensuring they knew what the work was.

User527294627 · 24/10/2021 22:12

I don’t think your colleague is an asshole for not sharing a process they’ve developed themselves, for free. If the company needs this knowledge they have to pay for it. Or they have to trust that you can work it out, which at the moment they clearly don’t. Maybe you will get the opportunity to prove to them that you can once your colleague has left.

PackedintheUK · 24/10/2021 22:11

The comapny have messed up and are going to have to employ someone to unravel this. It absolutely must not be the "consultant".

userwhatever01 · 24/10/2021 22:10

It won’t be that hard, the leaver is a massive dick.

Strange how they have been allowed to do this but seriously if they are walking a round saying ‘it’s so tricky’ then it really won’t be

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/10/2021 22:07

This person is waltzing about telling anyone who'll listen how they've got company over a barrel etc.

Yes, and if the company are foolish enough to use them as a "consultant" they'll also be risking corporate confidentiality. Not usually a problem with most consultants, but almost certainly unwise with someone like this

FWIW I agree they should have had more than one person fully up to speed, but if they're allowing themselves to be "frightened" over this it sounds as if they haven't the sense

Hunderland · 24/10/2021 22:07

Someone I know did this and their work refused to take them on as a consultant.

cuttlefishgame · 24/10/2021 22:06

If this person's expert knowledge about the role has been acquired in whole or in part whilst they have been working for the company and is specific to the job being performed, then the employer actually has something called intellectual property rights over that expertise.

Glittertwins · 24/10/2021 22:06

In answer to the OP's question about how to get someone to document processes, it should be built into performance planning and development goals.
My quarterly reviews require processes to be documented.
I also have a fairly unique set of skills which for some reason people are reticent about wanting to learn so when I'm away, there are problems but they are not down to me failing to train or document the processes. They are all there on an accessible forum and links sent out so I have not hidden them. Training has been done but people try to take the easy route of getting me to do it for them instead of trying to be self sufficient.

JudgeJ · 24/10/2021 22:05

@KeyErro

Company may have taken their eye off the ball but I would not hire this person as a consultant
I hope that the new company being set up to blackmail his former employer is an utter flop, he deserves it.
Fetarabbit · 24/10/2021 22:03

Ah fair enough, you're not being petty and explains why as it'll directly affect you. Although you shouldn't have to be, I'd be proactive in collating and presenting 'evidence' to management that you can do the work, even if you need x training to do so- it'd be cheaper and better for them in the long run so wouldn't worry about putting in what development you need.

Hodgehog · 24/10/2021 22:03

Can sue*

Hodgehog · 24/10/2021 22:03

In this case as it’s too late for that - as the company will own the procedure so the

fashionSOS · 24/10/2021 22:02

It's still not 100% clear to me whether the employee is in the wrong, but after your comments on salaries, I suspect they're leaving because they feel poorly treated. Which probably explains the attitude.

You don't need to write a clause into someone's contract about a full handover; it's assumed in the standard 'and any other reasonable duties' clause.

If this is a reasonable request - it might or might not be, depending on the specifics - the practical way to enforce this is by suing the employee. It's not common in my experience, but it does happen when you part ways on such bad terms and one party reckons they can win.

noodlezoodle · 24/10/2021 21:59

Yes the company should have had some contingency plans, but the employee is also being a colossal dick.

It would be pretty unusual if your employment contracts don't have a clause saying that work developed in work time is the company's IPR, so the employee doesn't 'own' this knowledge. If they refuse to train someone or document the process in the remaining 2 weeks, I would fire them, refuse them a reference, and put them on the 'do not rehire' list.

I would let the team that thinks they can figure this out do so, and I would never, ever hire the employee as a consultant. And when inevitably asked by prospective clients about the employee, I would tell them exactly what happened.

I'm a consultant and the vast majority of my contracts come from word of mouth and repeat business. My customers rely not just on my expertise but on my integrity and credibility. Don't fancy the employee's chances of starting a successful business if this is the way they start out!

Hodgehog · 24/10/2021 21:59

In which case surely there should have been shadowing/training either at the time or as soon as it went into use incase this person left/was off sick/on holiday when it’s use was required.

Refusal to do this = disciplinary.

Lostmarbles2021 · 24/10/2021 21:58

If they do ‘win’ and they do come back as a consultant to train you and colleagues make sure you grill them and drill down so they share enough information - they can’t be trusted.

sussexman · 24/10/2021 21:57

@AFewScrewsLucy you seem to have asked several times "how can they practically arrange for handover" - clearly the answer is that they can't. However, the company on the basis of what you've said absolutely can refuse to endorse the new business, will likely own the IP in the "procedure" anyway ( www.willans.co.uk/knowledge/does-my-employer-own-my-intellectual-property/) because it was developed in the course of business and funded by the company, and a smart co would have this in terms of employment anyway.

The short management answer to "can you physically make me do this" is obviously "no", The likely real answer is "Of course not, we will instruct lawyers that you are in breach of contract, sue for loss of intellectual property rights and terminate you with cause, if we find you have consulted with BigCompetitorCorp then we will enjoin them in the cases, or you can tell Sheila here how it works."

SeasonFinale · 24/10/2021 21:55

So who trained the person who is leaving? That person or provider can train you too.

Travis1 · 24/10/2021 21:55

*database company to come it

Travis1 · 24/10/2021 21:54

I think if I was management I’d ask them to leave with immediate effect and I’d pay for the database company to company before using the ex employee as a ‘consultant’ but then I’m a petty bitch 🤷🏻‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread