Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A traditional Roast On A Sunday

264 replies

Middicat · 24/10/2021 20:21

I cannot lie I love love love a traditional roast on a Sunday I look forward to it all day. My husband on the other hand is saying it is not the 1950s anymore and it is old hat to want this and he reckons very few people actually have a roast at home on a Sunday each week.

Am I being unreasonable to have this one meal I really enjoy each week. Am I alone?

I would say that his argument also involves the fact that as we have young children he usually ends up cooking most of it and he says it is not worth all the effort!!!! I disagree - would also like to add we usually have what he likes on any given day of the rest of the week.

OP posts:
621CustardCream438 · 24/10/2021 22:37

How is a roast dinner a faff?!

Well, it requires someone in the house for several hours for a start (no I am not leaving an oven on in an empty house). It requires peeling and chopping potatoes, carrots, parsnips and green veg, preparing stuffing ingredients or Yorkshire pudding mix, preparing the joint or chicken and taking stuff in and out the oven every once in a while. Preheating yorkshire tin then filling it. Juggling things on shelves to cook evenly. Parboiling and then fluffing then roasting potatoes in a preheated tray. Then making gravy, draining everything, carving the meat and serving all the different elements while trying to keep everything hot and then tackling a small mountain of clearing up - board, knives, roasting tin and rack, tray for potatoes, pans for veg, tins for yorkshires, pan for gravy….

Making a curry involves cutting up a couple of chicken breasts and some veg, adding some spices and a couple of tins, stirring occasionally and then it’s done. And adding water to rice and boiling on a hob for a few minutes. Drain rice, dump rice on one side of the plate, tip curry on the other. At the end I have a board, knife, wok, spatula and a saucepan and sieve for the rice to wash up, that’s it. And from start to finish is maybe forty minutes not three hours.

5foot5 · 24/10/2021 22:37

We have one most Sundays, but we have it in the evening not at lunch time because we usually go out for a long walk somewhere during the day.

DH usually cooks it. I would happily but he insists that he enjoys doing it and it is a really straightforward meal to cook.

LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 22:37

It’s the cauliflower cheese, roast spuds, carrots, peas, parsnips, stuffing, Yorkshire Puds, that take the fucking time.

I don’t bother with cauliflower cheese as I’m the only one who like it. The rest doesn’t take much time. It takes some time cooking but roasties just do their thing. Parsnips the same. The rest is the last 20 mins.

Dindundundundeeer · 24/10/2021 22:36

@RiverSkater

I love it Buy ready made everything, Yorkshire puss, roast potatoes, gravy and microwave bags of veg so it's less cooking.
Can’t say puss is my thing, but feels pretty accurate Grin
MoreStuffingMatron · 24/10/2021 22:34

Yes I love a roast and made one today.

Roast beef and trimmings - lovely but horrendous fuss. Par boiled the potatoes roasted the next day, prepped the mash, puréed the turnip, prepared the broccoli, green beans, carrot, cabbage and sprouts. Made the gravy. Did the Yorkshires …..

Then the washing up ..,,

Dindundundundeeer · 24/10/2021 22:33

@Babdoc

How is a roast “a faff”? Am I missing something here? I just stick it in the oven and leave it to roast itself. Are other people standing there stirring it?! Grin When the family are up for Easter, we stick a whole leg of lamb in the oven after church and go out for a walk round the loch while it cooks. Christmas ditto, but with a turkey. It is way simpler than grinding ten different spices and chopping meat and veg for a curry, then standing there frying it and making a fiddly sauce etc. Or making pastry for a pie. It’s probably the least faffy meal I ever make!
But JUST a toasted joint is pretty joyless. It’s the cauliflower cheese, roast spuds, carrots, peas, parsnips, stuffing, Yorkshire Puds, that take the fucking time Hmm
Hmmmm2018 · 24/10/2021 22:28

In response to LittleBearPad lasagne is absolutely a faff to make that is why it used to be our Sunday treat as I actually had enough time to do it, always takes far longer than I remember, a roast is much more straightforward.

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 24/10/2021 22:24

I love a roast dinner and we have one most weeks throughout autumn/winter/spring and maybe every 3 or 4 weeks in the summer.

Tonight’s dinner was roast pork belly. Had with boiled potatoes and gravy, sage and onion stuffing, roast carrots and parsnips with garlic, thyme and lemon, Savoy cabbage fried in butter with garlic, plus apple sauce. Delicious!! Everything made from scratch except the stuffing as we prefer the bog standard dry mix in a box. We have enough leftover to have a hash for breakfast using the potatoes, then we will have pork, stuffing and apple sauce sandwiches for lunch.

Your DH is definitely being unreasonable (although to be fair I do think you probably ought to cook it 50% of the time. Don’t see why you having young children means you can’t cook while he looks after them).

Stompythedinosaur · 24/10/2021 22:21

Having a roast is fine, but not if you get him to make it!

plominoagain · 24/10/2021 22:18

If I’m off, I’ll cook one . I find it very relaxing to do - and because DH thinks it’s more difficult and time consuming than it really is, it means I get to sit at my kitchen table peeling veg whilst watching a Poirot , with cups of tea at my elbow , while DH goes outside and does fencing or hedge trimming or chopping wood, without asking for me to give him a hand , and asks DS instead ( it’s not hard labour ) . Then when it’s eaten I get all the plaudits and no washing up. Winner !

Labloverrr · 24/10/2021 22:18

He can look after the kids then!

reluctantbrit · 24/10/2021 22:15

I like one. But I don’t like that I am basically stuck at home for it. I never found a restaurant doing one I enjoy so either I cook it myself or we do not have it.

Each week would mean we aren’t able to go out and I refuse to be that restricted, we do one when we are in and fancy one, maybe once a month on average.

IamMummyhearmeROAR · 24/10/2021 22:15

We have a roast dinner every Sunday without fail

Stovetopespresso · 24/10/2021 22:12

why is a Sunday roast such a vibey politically charged meal? it obviously touches some nerves! I think it's to do with people thinking it's out of the 1950s, who shd cook it etc. I think its about how we relate to traditions, the "family", what a Sunday is...its a weird space for sure.

RiverSkater · 24/10/2021 22:10

I love it
Buy ready made everything, Yorkshire puss, roast potatoes, gravy and microwave bags of veg so it's less cooking.

CorvusPurpureus · 24/10/2021 22:09

Unless it's an occasion, I tend to knock it out roasting tin style these days.

Chicken thighs & parboiled potatoes roasting in the tin. With stuffing balls added later.

Big pile of steamed carrots, broccoli & peas.

Gravy made from veg stock ( freezer full of it).

It's probably one of the easiest meals I'd cook all week.

We don't tend to eat much red meat, but when I do cook beef it's easier still - it just goes in the oven...? People can eat the rarer bits or the well done ends.

Ok, I'll grant you there's a knack to decent yorkies, but if that's too much faff they're easily bought frozen.

It is definitely not my favourite cuisine, but I would argue that it is easy if you start with a decent bird/joint.

No faffing about because you can't find the fenugreek or the pomegranate seeds or whatever - you just take good quality meat, shove it in the oven, & dosh up vegetables alongside, job done.

I'd definitely find it more trouble to cook a good curry or lasagne from scratch!

jamandmarmalade · 24/10/2021 22:04

I'm with your Dh. Why spend the majority of the one proper free day just revolving around one meal. Especially if he spends his time doing it? Fine if you want to cook it but not him. Week day meals are not comparable to the time and expense of a Sunday roast.

Could you compromise and go out for a Sunday dinner? Let the pub do all the work then you get your Sunday dinner and he doesn't have to eat the same meal as you.

Maybe once a month?

Longdistance · 24/10/2021 22:00

I love a roast. Dh on the other hand likes to think outside the box —twit— and orders pasta and such shit on a Sunday.
Sunday is for roasts only as far as I’m concerned. It’s beaten in me with my dm declaring Italy as rubbish as they don’t eat roasts on a Sunday 😂

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/10/2021 21:58

We like them, have one most weeks - not at lunchtime, though, alway evening meal. But not so much in summer..

I don’t find them much more of a faff than other meals - more mess and washing up, though. Not that it bothers me. I cook, dh clears up the kitchen - I’m a messy cook - and loads the dishwasher. And unloads it in the morning. 🙂

Chocolatewheatos · 24/10/2021 21:57

I love a roast but I've never cooked one every week and wouldn't expect DH to. I haven't had one since DS was born and I need one badly!

longtompot · 24/10/2021 21:55

I cook a roast on a Sunday 9 times out of 10. We all love them, well, my ds not so much but he has left home now.

TellySavalashairbrush · 24/10/2021 21:53

The cook should have the ultimate decision in what to cook. I’d eat anything if someone else was cooking for me. That said, I don’t get how cooking a roast is a faff. One of the easiest things to cook IMO.

LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 21:52

@Hmmmm2018

Over lockdown we started having a weekly Sunday roast having not ever really done it as an adult and a few weeks ago I suggested we could try something different next Sunday, the answer was a resounding no. The whole family are loving a good old Sunday roast now and I suspect a mutiny will occur if I try and slip in a lasagne.
Tbf a lasagne is at least as much faff. I made Nigellas lasagne of love that was a pita. My normal one isn’t but still more faff than a roast.
bogeythefungusman · 24/10/2021 21:52

We've just finished our Sunday roast. Outstanding yorkies. It was delicious and enough for another meal. Don't do it every week, depends what we're up to, but it's been a dreich old day and pottering about in the kitchen for an hour has been lovely.

ouchmyfeet · 24/10/2021 21:50

@BabbleBee

I love a roast but it is a faff to cook it.
This. We don't have them very often because they are a faff. If you want it, you cook it.