Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To offer him a banana?

117 replies

larrythelizard · 24/10/2021 19:04

DS is 2 and 4 months.

Historically food and eating has been a battle but more recently he's been better and he's eaten what he's been given for meals (obviously he eats everything at nursery)

We're careful with timing and quantity of snacks (most of the time offering fruit/breadsticks etc).

Tonight he has decided against his dinner and would not try and mouthful of it. It was a creamy chicken thing with mash and grated cheese.

DH was adamant that DS wasn't to eat anything else however after 90 mins of ignoring the fuss he was making/cajoling him/trying the naughty step, DS has still refused to even try it (i offered a 'special spoon' to try and offer him a way to climb down from his protest without feeling he was giving in etc)

I've just offered him some milk and a banana as a compromise before bed as he's clearly hungry (I think dinner looks too saucy for him).

DH thinks I shouldn't have offered DS anything else.

WIBU to offer him a banana?

I'm all for setting boundaries but I've never made food a battle ground before and it sits uncomfortably with me.

What age do they understand consequence ie you will be hungry in the night?

OP posts:
toastofthetown · 24/10/2021 19:43

The Big Little Feelings Instagram account has great advice for fussy kids. You just put down their dinner in front of them (including any pudding if you were going to give it), make sure there's something that he will always eat on the plate (so maybe add a side of vegetables or salad he'll eat, or yogurt, or even serve the banana with the meal) and then don't say anything else. No cajoling or special spoons or punishments. You choose what he eats and when he eats it, and he chooses how much of it to eat. (Obviously this is for children who are just a bit fussy, children with sensory issues, ARFID or anything else which affects their eating will be different).

LouLou789 · 24/10/2021 19:38

(And on a practical basis, you don’t want him waking up crying at 3am because he’s so hungry. Maybe that reasoning would be a good thing to say to DH?)

SheWoreYellow · 24/10/2021 19:37

You also need to be able to take your DH to one side and say ‘we need to back down from this without losing face, how about we all have toast as pudding tonight’ or whatever.
If he’s doing something cruel you do need to undermine him, or stop him. You need to talk to him about his ideas in general too.

BigYellowHat · 24/10/2021 19:37

My mum ended up sneaking sandwiches to my niece after my sister and her husband wouldn’t give her extra food after not eating her dinner. The child is 4 FFS and was sobbing that her tummy hurt. My mum was staying the night and snuck in with the sandwiches but is concerned it happens regularly. Don’t let him go to bed hungry even if he’s being a pain.

Gatehouse77 · 24/10/2021 19:35

Additionally, I switched to offering ‘new’ foods at lunchtime knowing they would still have a meal before bed.

I agree with others that I wouldn’t sit mine for longer than it took the rest of us to finish. It’s counterproductive at that point because it simply a battle of wills at that point and not about trying a new food.

larrythelizard · 24/10/2021 19:34

I appreciate the pun @Namechanger20183110 - it is used very very rarely in this house but often that 60s or whatever gives DS a chance to calm down and then after some cuddles he will apologise for throwing something etc etc.

I didn't know that @YoBeaches so thanks - he's getting there on potty training and we only have an accident every couple of days.

Thanks for the advice @mintdream. He did go up for a bath/play upstairs after the first refusal as we thought he might just not be hungry enough yet.

DS did have banana and milk before bed.

This is the first big battle we've had over food, clearly we didn't handle it quite right - some really useful advice on this thread thanks (judgement not really helpful but expected as I posted in AIBU)

OP posts:
Blackmagicqueen · 24/10/2021 19:34

need*

Georgyporky · 24/10/2021 19:34

I was brought up to eat what I was given.
I carried on that way with my own DC.

Apart from not expecting them to eat things they very clearly disliked (parsnip is an example), we all grew up without "eating disorders".

Certainly no punishment for refusing food - their choice not to eat it & no substitution.

SheWoreYellow · 24/10/2021 19:34

We tried the following;

Always have one thing on their plate that you know they like, then they have to try the other, new, things but they don’t have to eat them.

If they are still hungry after dinner they can have fruit, yoghurt or oatcakes and cheese. Not toast because they’d rather eat that than dinner!

Usually no pudding to avoid the whole not eating dinner and then what do we do about dinner issues.

No ‘well done’ for eating or clearing plates as they leads to bad habits as adults.

All of that is pretty normal these days.

Blackmagicqueen · 24/10/2021 19:34

If my 2 year old won't eat dinner i will say 9kay youre not hungry and clear it away. i will then offer something boring later on for supper like toast and banana and milk. I would never send dcto bed hungry, they beed their calories and nutrition! It is just a phase and won't be habit forming and mine have always gone back to eating. I have found it can be molars/a cold/late snack/dislikes dinner choice etc at play that puts them off.

drpaddington · 24/10/2021 19:33

Maybe I'm soft but I don't punish for not eating. I remember being dragged in to a battle of wills when they were younger because I would worry like crazy that they weren't eating enough! But it didn't solve anything.

They are older now but one is still very fussy. We always strongly encourage them to eat whatever we've offered but if they don't like it, they don't like it. I'd never cook them a new meal- but they're old enough now to get themselves a slice of toast/ bowl of cereal/ piece of fruit.

I have some food issues myself, so I feel like I can sympathise when my own DC's don't like something. OH can get really stressed with them, so I try my best to keep things calm.

esloquehay · 24/10/2021 19:31

You and your husband spent 90 minutes trying to get your 2 year old to eat something he clearly didn't want to eat? And, you put him on the 'naughty' step?!
Are you out of your mind?!
Poor child.

greendiva · 24/10/2021 19:31

90mins! Oh dear. The best advice I have ever taken and used is, put on the child's plate a new thing or food they don't like, just leave it there, don't ask them to try it or pressure them, and repeat. Usually over time they pick up the veg and start eating it.

MistyFrequencies · 24/10/2021 19:30

This made me sad. Poor kid is tiny. Of course you don't let him go to bed hungry. He's just a baby. He won't make the link between not eating dinner= hungry in night, he will just be sad and upset and not understand why you're not fixing it for him.
If mine don't eat dinner they always can have a glass of milk, crackers or toast before bed. Don't make food a battleground.

mynameiscalypso · 24/10/2021 19:30

I have a similar aged (and difficult) toddler. Sometimes I put food down in front of him and he just says 'No' and waves goodbye to it. I ask him if he's sure. He generally says yes and I take it away. No battles, no drama. If I was planning on serving a dessert (fruit/yoghurt), he gets that and, depending on what else he's eaten that day, maybe a slice of toast. He doesn't have to try anything. The only thing I insist is that he doesn't throw the food on the floor but so long as he's polite, I shrug and that's that. I remember having so many battles over food as a child and I hated it so much. Now, I choose not to.

mintdream · 24/10/2021 19:30

Also, the advice the dietician gave us was that mealtimes should not exceed 20-30 minutes. If he hasn’t eaten then take the food away and mealtime is over.

If he’s still hungry offer something plain like toast and butter or a banana.

HoldingTheDoor · 24/10/2021 19:29

Dragging it out for 90 minutes is cruel and counter-productive. It's a great way to make him view food even more negatively.

Namechanger20183110 · 24/10/2021 19:28

@Namechanger20183110

2 is way too young for the naughty step, it's fruitless
That wasn't supposed to be a banana related pun by the way!
Namechanger20183110 · 24/10/2021 19:28

2 is way too young for the naughty step, it's fruitless

mintdream · 24/10/2021 19:27

Toddlers are notoriously fussy and it is normal, evolutionary behaviour. Turning mealtimes into a battleground and/or using the naughty step is counter productive and the latter is a wildly inappropriate use of that discipline method.

My DS(6) became fussy from 14 months and it’s been very frustrating, he’s been under a dietician for two years, and the final dietician conclusion is he’s choosing to be fussy and all you can do is keep offering a variety of foods.

So, the dietician advice was when serving a meal always include one item that he likes such as baked beans, carrots, apple, whatever. Try putting food in the middle of the table and everyone serve themselves. Offer new foods outside of mealtimes so the pressure is off if they are hungry and feel
pressure to eat. Don’t offer milk between meals as it is a food and will fill him up too much.

Have a look at the book ‘Getting the little blighters to eat’ for simple advice.

Above all, don’t make a song and dance about eating or he’ll really dig his heels in.

YoBeaches · 24/10/2021 19:26

The ability to understand consequence is linked with the developmental milestone of being ready to toilet train, so unless he's already out of nappies and mastered the potty, nothing that you are doing makes any sense to him, other than he is hungry, doesn't want what you have given him.

Your choice to send him to bed hungry, but it doesn't seem to me that that would be in his best interests. What you do now has an impact longer term.

Taoneusa · 24/10/2021 19:26

Good grief! Give him a banana!

Wow! Confused

larrythelizard · 24/10/2021 19:25

Oh I don't agree with the naughty step but don't agree with undermining DH in front of DS - we will be discussing this evening. He's absolutely not abusive but took it too far this afternoon (by too far I mean 45s on the naughty step).

The 90 mins of refusal was largely sat on my knee having a cuddle but crying and wailing anytime it was suggested he should try a mouthful.

I'll look that book up.

DS helped me cook the meal and enjoyed the whole process - I actually don't mind if he doesn't like something but think he should try a spoon/forkful and then can move on to something else.

I don't want DS to think that he can choose not to eat dinner and demand something else, that's not ok - he usually has dinner then bath then banana and milk before bed anyway so wasn't that dissimilar tonight.

OP posts:
Toktokboki · 24/10/2021 19:24

Food is a battle ground because you are doing things like using the naughty step because of it!

Kids are humans. They are like us - he may not be hungry when you are offering a meal. He may want a snack an hour later. I mean, even j do this.

GreyhoundG1rl · 24/10/2021 19:23

The naughty step for refusing dinner?? Perfect way to set up an eating disorder, besides being both cruel and stupid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread