Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To offer him a banana?

117 replies

larrythelizard · 24/10/2021 19:04

DS is 2 and 4 months.

Historically food and eating has been a battle but more recently he's been better and he's eaten what he's been given for meals (obviously he eats everything at nursery)

We're careful with timing and quantity of snacks (most of the time offering fruit/breadsticks etc).

Tonight he has decided against his dinner and would not try and mouthful of it. It was a creamy chicken thing with mash and grated cheese.

DH was adamant that DS wasn't to eat anything else however after 90 mins of ignoring the fuss he was making/cajoling him/trying the naughty step, DS has still refused to even try it (i offered a 'special spoon' to try and offer him a way to climb down from his protest without feeling he was giving in etc)

I've just offered him some milk and a banana as a compromise before bed as he's clearly hungry (I think dinner looks too saucy for him).

DH thinks I shouldn't have offered DS anything else.

WIBU to offer him a banana?

I'm all for setting boundaries but I've never made food a battle ground before and it sits uncomfortably with me.

What age do they understand consequence ie you will be hungry in the night?

OP posts:
LemonWeb · 24/10/2021 20:43

By the time I’d got to DC3 i realised the futility of toddler food battles.

“I not eat dat” just didn’t get a reaction, and we calmly took away uneaten food after the rest of us had finished eating and replaced it with a slice of plain toast.

saraclara · 24/10/2021 20:42

@ShirleyPhallus

You put him on the naughty step for not trying his dinner?

I honestly cannot believe be some of the stuff I read on here. I hope this is fake.

Me too. And 90 minutes? Seriously? He's TWO!

You need to advocate for your DC because your DH is being massively unreasonable, and your DC will end up with massive food hangups at this rate.

Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 24/10/2021 20:42

Your husband sounds like an abusive twat and all this I don’t want to disagree with him in front of our DS is controlling bullshit.

Poor baby

godmum56 · 24/10/2021 20:38

Tell your husband that the victorians are calling and want their attitude to feeding children back.

Lucycantdance · 24/10/2021 20:38

Not RTWT but you both need to chill.

Look up “you don’t have to eat it” by Ellin Satter (sp?) - it changed things massively when my PFB was 2 and refused to eat anything, this is an article about it:

www.huffpost.com/entry/6-words-that-will-end-picky-eating_b_7139710?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAABeEqxfMiZNw9So2_TrzEU-wo1RG7CwftSmAtm7Wygc6PDRTyOo6SqVrOEz7GOAHUqhVyxmIpNAHltBwihetoYJnw2bF0oLDWiZoorUsvs3Y8Fxd1hbZ2QwK-vV_-JLGQXwbrhsp-lKdFIRpV0Xl8SxwsVGFtWFFGwxtnmipbv-w

HoneyPea · 24/10/2021 20:38

My DS is the same age. If I was offering him a new meal I would make sure there were at least 2 or 3 things on his plate he would eat. Was the sauce on the mash? I would have made sure the new food, the saucy chicken was separate from the mash (just incase he didn't like the sauce) That way he would be likely to start eating the mash and then accidentally try the chicken and maybe like it! We also sometimes turn it into a game by pretending we are going to eat his dinner, load up a spoon and tell him not to eat our spoonful while we do something else and 9 times out of 10 he will eat it while we "aren't looking" 😉
As for your AIBU I would have definitely given him a banana and some milk before bed especially if that is what he usually has anyway!

FictionalCharacter · 24/10/2021 20:37

@nurserypolitics

Your husband is going against any advise a healthcare professional would give, and I would argue is being abusive. At a minimum that's how y ou set children up for eating disorders.

Read a book by Bee Wilson called First taste, it gives a history of how humans learn to eat, and I found it really easy navigating how to approach picky eating with a child with allergies. Our dietitian echoed the approach. At that age, you want them to try things, you DO NOT EVER want to punish eating, or not eating. You need to stand up for your son here or your DH's attitude will have long lasting effects on him.

This, absolutely.
HampshireMutha · 24/10/2021 20:35

My son is 2y 5m and doesn't have a big appetite. Meals can be hit or miss and a few times he woke up really early because he was hungry. We've been giving him tea at 5pm and supper consisting of half a banana and a piece of toast at 6.30pm nightly for 8 or 9 months. It's improved his sleep no end, and he's still trying new foods and eating food he likes without the pressure of eating loads of it. My son just has a small appetite and it suits him to eat less food more often.

Yutes · 24/10/2021 20:35

There’s a great Instagram page called Feeding Littles that looks helpful. It’s American based but the techniques still stand

Summerfun54321 · 24/10/2021 20:28

A health visitor told me on average most kids need to be offered the same new food around 7 times at different meals to get used to eating it. You’re expecting WAY too much. We have a massive array of food at our finger tips and the shear variety of foods we can offer toddlers compared to 30 years ago can be overwhelming for them. Maybe he eats better at nursery because he has more repetition of foods and zero pressure.

violetfern · 24/10/2021 20:19

My little girl has just turned 2 and used to eat anything- tonight refused to even try the pasta and sauce I’d made which she’d loved last week. Ate the tiniest bit of broccoli. She had some plain yoghurt and a banana on the side as I know she’ll
always eat some of that.

I think at this age they are notoriously fussy, and too bothered about other things than eating. It’s a battle we’ve decided just not to start. She asks for food if she’s hungry and she’ll also stop eating when she’s full- be that not finishing a treat ice cream or her porridge.

I think at this age they are just too little to properly express why they do/don’t do things. Maybe I’m just wanting an easier life, but I’m figuring there are bigger things to worry about than her refusing some foods xx

Temple29 · 24/10/2021 20:14

I agree with your approach as opposed to your DH’s approach. My DS is 2.5 and eats no dinners at all, literally nothing, only carb he eats is bread.

I serve him a small amount of what we’re having and include a favourite food, such as baked beans for us all to have. I serve fruit or yogurt as pudding alongside the main meal. Up to him how much he wants to eat and I don’t suggest he eat anything or comment when he says he’s done. Toast and milk before bed if needs be.

MyCatHatesWhiskas · 24/10/2021 20:09

90 minutes is insane! In our house, what is on offer is on offer for the amount of time the rest of us are eating and sat at the table (DC2 is about 6 months younger than your DS). Then the meal is over. That’s the window for eating, kiddo. Until supper.Wink

Toddlers are fickle. I will offer an alternative if hungry. Tonight I gave DC2 a toddler ready meal, which he confirmed he will not eat (he has always refused pre-prepared food, which feels like my parenting comeuppance as DC1 refused anything I cooked at this age Grin). So he got scrambled egg and toast as I knew I was chancing my arm with it and we were eating separately.

I will offer alternatives if they don’t like it or are being stubborn. I don’t offer alternatives if it’s a meal I know they like and normally eat (they can have supper though). Depends on the circumstances but nothing too interesting - something like Weetabix, toast, banana, etc usually.

I am probably not the best person to advise but I decided very early on that food would not be a battleground as it’s a battle you’ll lose, potentially three times a day. Much better to show zero emotional reaction if at all possible (for me this is much easier with DC2).

Ledition · 24/10/2021 20:07

God what is it with men and this shite? My father was the same and my children's father the same too. As if causing a full blown battle at the dinner table has ever solved a fussy eating situation.

Your DS is tiny. Many, many children go through a fussy period at this stage. Just keep offering him meals at set times every day including a bed time snack so if he doesn't eat his dinner at least he'll have something before bed. No fuss no drama, just if he refuses his dinner remind him there won't be anything else until before bed. If you send him to bed starving you'll only suffer the consequences when he wakes in the middle of the night/in the early hours of the morning because he's famished. Cruel and unnecessary.

tootootaataa · 24/10/2021 20:00

Do not enter into food wars.

My DC don't always want their dinner, so they can take fruit. There will be no crisps/bread etc and I am not a hotel so I don't offer a choice of meals. We save milk for after meals.
But they are always welcome to take fruit. As they have got older, they ask when dinner is and know not to take fruit in the 30 mins beforehand.

Your DS is two years old. Your DH needs a bloody good talking too.

minipie · 24/10/2021 19:59

He probably eats better at nursery because of 1) peers eating with him and 2) less tired

ExPatHereForAChat · 24/10/2021 19:58

Toddlers have hungry days and not so hungry days. 90 minutes trying to force feed? Good grief.
If my 2yo DS refuses a meal we try again 5 minutes later, if he still refuses, he's not hungry.
I might try again in an hour. If he doesn't want the meal, of course he can have a banana or porridge or whatever. It's not a battleground.

ImFree2doasiwant · 24/10/2021 19:54

With meals like this, I would give the mash with cheese, some veg they will definitely eat, abd some pieces of chicken out of the sauce. Introduce it a bit at a time

Fdksyihfd · 24/10/2021 19:52

When my DD reached 3 she understood consequences better and I could say if she didn’t eat her food there wouldn’t be anything else but before then I didn’t bother; as frustrating as it is I didn’t feel she could understand the consequences and I didn’t want her to be hungry in the night so I’d give her crackers or cereal or toast before bed.
In total honesty even at 3 once she understood consequences I probably would have still given her something before bed but it became easier to negotiate so I didn’t have to.

NotSureYesorno · 24/10/2021 19:52

I have a similar age child with autism and a food issue called arfid

He eats what he wants, when he wants. We were told look at the weekly intake not daily and trust he will fancy whatever he needs. We honestly seek to have some weeks of only chocolate then the next fruit and veg then back again alongside a few ‘safe’ foods (a type of cracker, waffles, chips, smooth yogurt of one brand only)

Beautiful3 · 24/10/2021 19:52

Your husband was wrong, you are right to offer a healthy snack before bed. 2 is far too young to punish for not eating. My brother would starve himself for long periods, when he was a toddler. It was made worse with punishments. It improved when they ignored him when he didn't eat, and offered small amounts of healthy food at other times. No junk food was ever offered as they didn't want him to think he'd get better tasting food, if he didn't eat his meals.

SpookyPumpkinPants · 24/10/2021 19:50

He's 2.4.

Just stop with all the drama. Make meals he likes and put a new thing on the side for him to try if he wants to.

Honestly, the battles you have with toddlers really isn't worth it.

They're grown before you know it & it doesn't matter if he wouldn't eat cheesy mash potato & chicken in sauce one night

He is too young to understand anything that isn't an Immediate consequence! Like not eating dinner & being hungry later.

I know it feels like 'a big deal' now but when you look back you'll realise it was not.

Naughty step for not eating dinner. No way. Deliberately hitting another child or something, maybe... but mouth eating?! Your DH needs to lose the need to exert control in this way.

BaileysforBreakfast · 24/10/2021 19:49

I'm an old lady now - almost retirement age - but I felt really triggered reading this. Food was a battleground when I was a child. We didn't have a naughty step; we were made to stand in the corner instead. We had to sit at the table indefinitely while food grew cold and tempers grew frayed. Once my mother gave me a plate of cold vegetables for breakfast because I hadn't eaten them the previous evening. Please don't do this to your child and don't underestimate the psychological impact of your actions. Punishing a refusal to eat can lead to a lifetime of disordered eating. Believe me, I know.

larrythelizard · 24/10/2021 19:46

Big discussion coming up tonight @SheWoreYellow - we're usually on the same page about discipline etc but not tonight.

Will give that a follow @toastofthetown

It was completely a battle of wills @Gatehouse77 - he would have eaten that dinner no problem at nursery - I think that's the thing that frustrates us; we know he's not a bad eater at nursery but home is a different story!

This thread has given me more confidence that my approach this evening was correct.

OP posts:
1forAll74 · 24/10/2021 19:46

Your Husband has weird ideas about feeding a child. I would tell him to shut up. You don't ever have to punish a small child, if the child refuses any food, you use common sense, and see if the child will eat something else. Lots of children have things they won't eat at given times, so you try something else as a rule. Bananas are a good standby,if they are cut into small pieces, to avoid choking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread