Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To offer him a banana?

117 replies

larrythelizard · 24/10/2021 19:04

DS is 2 and 4 months.

Historically food and eating has been a battle but more recently he's been better and he's eaten what he's been given for meals (obviously he eats everything at nursery)

We're careful with timing and quantity of snacks (most of the time offering fruit/breadsticks etc).

Tonight he has decided against his dinner and would not try and mouthful of it. It was a creamy chicken thing with mash and grated cheese.

DH was adamant that DS wasn't to eat anything else however after 90 mins of ignoring the fuss he was making/cajoling him/trying the naughty step, DS has still refused to even try it (i offered a 'special spoon' to try and offer him a way to climb down from his protest without feeling he was giving in etc)

I've just offered him some milk and a banana as a compromise before bed as he's clearly hungry (I think dinner looks too saucy for him).

DH thinks I shouldn't have offered DS anything else.

WIBU to offer him a banana?

I'm all for setting boundaries but I've never made food a battle ground before and it sits uncomfortably with me.

What age do they understand consequence ie you will be hungry in the night?

OP posts:
Minniem2020 · 24/10/2021 22:07

I was just saying to dp the other day that I feel sorry for kids when it comes to food. As adults we have a say in what we eat and what they might fancy having for tea that day but with kids it's just put in front of them and it's tough shit whether they fancy it or not. I'm very easy going when it comes to my dc and food, if they don't eat their meal then I will make them some toast or similar and just try that particular meal again another day. I'm certainly not going to get into a battle of trying to force a child to eat

user1471481356 · 24/10/2021 22:00

Gosh that sounds so awful :( we don’t make food a battleground either. I serve the food, always with one ‘safe’ food on the plate. It’s up to them if they eat it or not. I don’t ask, cajole, punish or anything else about food. We sit and chat at the table and then when I’m finished I ask if they’re going to eat or not and if not I take the plate away no issues. I would have given the banana too if it’s what you normally do every night.

jamandmarmalade · 24/10/2021 21:54

@larrythelizard p.s the 90mins was abuse too. He's not suddenly going to give in is he?

jamandmarmalade · 24/10/2021 21:53

Oh I don't agree with the naughty step but don't agree with undermining DH in front of DS - we will be discussing this evening. Yes you can agree on a strategy and it should not include the naughty step. That is cruel and any child cannot be reasoned with under the age of 3 years old. He's absolutely not abusive but took it too far this afternoon (by too far I mean 45s on the naughty step). Yes that is abusive. He punished his 2 year old for not eating. Had DH or you not considered DS is overtired/has a tummy ache/ear ache? Just not hungry now?

I'll look that book up. The trouble with baby books is that the baby hasn't read the book.

I think it's great that you included DS to cook the meal but if just doesn't want it then ask him what he wants to eat instead. It's his dinnertime and he is entirely dependent on you both at this age for food. He might just be too tired to eat it.

Don't make mealtimes a battlefield.

Poor child. Put hubby on the naughty step so he can reconsider his own behaviour. He is not to throw a tantrum.

Iwantamarshmallowman · 24/10/2021 21:53

Yanbu. You did the right thing.
I grew up with a very controlling parent especially where food was concerned. It was also used as punishment, it was often withdrawn for days for the most ridiculous of things. Both me and my sibling have suffered eating disorders. I have a horrible relationship with food now.
My 3 year old is a very picky eater, I would never withhold food. If the kids don't eat their dinner there is always fruit/ veg / or toast available. My first child grew out of the picky eating stage by the time she started school.

Dcrolo12345 · 24/10/2021 21:44

Poor baby this makes me sad😢 90 minutes of trying to force him to eat ?! Putting him on a naughty step?! That’s abuse, you are going to damage your poor child if you act like this, how traumatic for them. Mine refused his dinner tonight so I waited an hour and have porridge , cheese and a plum. I would NEVER refuse food if they don’t eat dinner that’s horrendous.

Hormonehelp · 24/10/2021 21:37

90 minutes is cruel and or it’s become a game. Try for 15 minutes and that’s it.

Honestly there must be more to this- surely you don’t sit for 90 minutes trying to persuade your toddler to eat a meal? It’s definitely not the right approach to establishing a positive and healthy mindset towards food.

I would honestly suggest saying it’s supper time at a slightly later time than usual, sitting down to eat and offering him food. Don’t make a fuss or anything about any food he eats, no prraize etc. If he doesn’t eat after 15 minutes then say he can get down and play but no more food. Do you all sit and eat a meal together or do you spend 90 minutes cuddling and tempting him to eat?

StaplesCorner · 24/10/2021 21:37

Judgement not really helpful? I don’t know where to begin. Your baby is TWO. FFS. Big of you to allow him a banana but hey at least your H thinks he’s a top dad …

Porcupineintherough · 24/10/2021 21:36

@PlanDeRaccordement interesting how similar circumstances shape people differently. My mum was starving as a child (not just poor but red cross feeding station starving). She eats anything and would never have dreamt of offering us a choice of options as kids. She very much saw at as important that there was food and wouldnt make you eat, but she didnt cater to fussiness at all. If you said you didnt like it she'd tell you that it tasted better than flour paste with saccharine or "what doesnt kill you fattens you". I was still a bit fussy til I saw (not experienced) proper hunger at first hand myself though. With my kids I always felt positively decadent because I let them choose 3 things they didnt have to eat.

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 24/10/2021 21:33

When my DC were little, and shall we say 'unreliable' eaters, they always had cereal or toast for supper just before bed. Enough removed from tea time that it wasn't a reward for not eating what was served but meant they weren't going to bed hungry. They grew out of it. Although DS1 16 has started again.

Flipflopblowout · 24/10/2021 21:31

I wouldn't eat that as a grown up, I have never been able to eat anything covered in sauce or gravy. He is a very young child who understands hungry and thirsty and looks to his parents to help him with this. I doubt if he understands your DH ideas on using the lack of food as a punishment or a training aid if you like

Porcupineintherough · 24/10/2021 21:28

Totally disagree that 2 is too young for the naughty step. But keep it for the really undesirable behaviour you need to stop - hiting, biting, pulling hair, throwing toy cars at the tv screen... And certainly not for refusing to eat - your job is to provide food, they decide whether they want to eat and how much.

godmum56 · 24/10/2021 21:23

@Slowfoxfast

I was brought up to eat what I was given

So were we and all of us have had an eating disorder.

I wasn't. My dad was an orphan and he was brought up in an orphanage where the rule was eat it or starve. He never forgot it and never made us eat anything and there was always something on the table that we would eat...even if it was only mashed potato and gravy. He (and my Mum) hted wasted food so their way of managing it was to give us what we would eat...not whole alternative meals but something.
PlanDeRaccordement · 24/10/2021 21:12

DH and I both grew up in homes where food was a eat it or go hungry situation. Mostly from poverty though. They didn’t have the option to offer us an alternative. We very rarely did not eat, but I did refuse a few things...eyeballs is one thing I remember because when I refused I remember my mother crying and saying I was too thin and HAD to eat.

So one of the agreements DH and I had was our DC would never go hungry not for any reason. Once they could talk, we would discuss with them what to make to eat for every meal. We didn’t mind being short order cooks. We’d make meals for them, and then something for us. We’d encourage them to try what we were eating if they were curious. As they got older, we did weekly meal plans with them being part of the choosing of meals and transitioned to one meal for whole family.

I agree food should not be a battleground, it should be enjoyable for everyone in the family. And you were right to offer an alternative as no child should go hungry or be hungry AND punished for it!

On a side note, two of my DC were diagnosed with ASD and were very fussy eaters. We always made what they wanted, but the fussiness was more about not letting certain foods touch each other...so often a meal we’d put in one bowl for us, they’d have separated out onto three small plates. But you simply adapt and move on.

The goal is a nice meal where everyone is happy, fed and talking.

Blythwind · 24/10/2021 21:07

"Getting the Little Blighters to eat" is a very short, very clear and very helpful book. I recommend both you and your husband read it and change your approach to mealtimes.

hotmeatymilk · 24/10/2021 21:07

Please don’t battle over food. My parents did and I didn’t eat for YEARS and I was fine but I have horrific memories of the fights and the misery.

Your son is little. It’s hard when they’re tired and they don’t want something – they can’t understand why this should be punished. Just give toast or a banana or yoghurt or milk. Not an alternative dinner - just easy, comforting calories. There’s a reason simple things are called nursery food. Your DH is wrong.

Goldbar · 24/10/2021 21:03

Please don't make an issue out of food! Your son is still tiny. So long as you're offering a healthy balanced diet, just leave him to decide what he wants to eat and when he is hungry.

And no, I wouldn't send a 2 year old to bed hungry. They'll just wake up and that will wake you up.

FrozenWillow · 24/10/2021 21:00

Withholding any food should not be used as a punishment. That is actually abuse and if a social worker heard about this, they would have a field day with your DH. My father did this to me and then made me eat last nights dinner for breakfast. I spewed the following morning as a result.

Try the creamy sauce chicken thing in a week and see if it changes.

2 years old is far too young for naughty step. Their level of understanding at this age is under-developed. I would not use it as a) it did not work on 2 of my 4 children as they are autistic. b) It should not used around food hassles anyway. You're trying to get the kid to eat, not scare him into not eating.

Give the kid the banana and milk and put your foot down, that we are not starving our children just because he does not like this food right now. He might like it later. I still cannot get one of mine to eat vegetables. I actually have to make it in soup and blend it for her to eat it and she's 15! My youngest loves carrots and eats them raw. Every child is different, every child has their unique preferences for food, same as adults. If it's tried 7 times and it's still the same, it's a definite "I don't like that" as opposed to being belligerent which toddlers (and teenagers) actually do.

Speak to DH about food he does not like. Ask him if he would like you to make it, put it down in front of him and get him to eat it.

TrussOnABus · 24/10/2021 20:57

How sad! I’ll never understand why people argue with their babies/toddles/children over food. As an adult, if you don’t fancy a plate of food you are given, you’re well within rights to say “no thanks” and not eat it. You also allow yourself to have an extra snack before bed if you’re hungry. You also would absolutely NOT permit your partner/parent/friend/sister to force you to eat a plate of food they’ve made you and then punish you for leaving it. So why are you forcing your kids to eat meals they clearly don’t want and go to bed hungry? It’s cruel

Slowfoxfast · 24/10/2021 20:54

I was brought up to eat what I was given

So were we and all of us have had an eating disorder.

Tirediam · 24/10/2021 20:46

Last night my son has a Jammy dodger and yogurt because he refused his lovely tea. He eats what he eats. 80% of the time he’s great and the rest, he eats a jammy dodger for tea!

amysaurus87 · 24/10/2021 20:45

My 3.5 year old is exactly the same, eats amazingly at nursery, but at home it's a different story. We even got the nursery to send us all their recipes (meals are on a 4 week seasonal rotation) and that didn't help!

One thing we've been doing that is slowly starting to help is following Love, Like, New.

So on every plate we make sure it has something we know he loves, something he likes and something new. It's hit and miss but he is getting better.

We ask that he at least tries everything on his plate, and sometimes he will refuse to eat anything (even the thing he loves) because you know 3 year olds! In this case we will offer an alternative, but only after repeatedly trying to get him to eat something off his plate!

Oinkypig · 24/10/2021 20:44

Listen to your child, he didn’t want to eat that for whatever reason so respect and hear him communicating with you. There is nothing wrong with banana and milk, I know there might be worry about wasted food but seriously have you/husband never just not wanted to eat something. Maybe remind him of random discussions- do you fancy Macaroni Cheese for tea - no don’t want that - ok let’s have sausage and mash - oh that sounds nice. Your very young child can’t articulate his likes and dislikes well yet, he might well be very hungry at nursery and be able to eat something he isn’t fond of but not able at home. Just give something he will eat.

Although I could eat toast all day every day so not sure that’s a boring food as such!

SylvanasWindrunner · 24/10/2021 20:44

I recommend having a read of the stuff on this website: www.ellynsatterinstitute.org/

SylvanasWindrunner · 24/10/2021 20:44

90 minutes?! Jesus. What a waste of everybody's time and energy.

Food is not a battleground in our house. If DD doesn't like what she's been served, we tell her to say 'no thank you' and not eat it. I do ask her to try it, but if she tries it and doesn't like it or just doesn't want to then I don't push. Some days she doesn't eat her dinner, other days she wolfs it all down and wants seconds. That's just being a toddler. If she didn't eat the meal the previous day, then I make sure to do something I know she'll most likely eat the day after, that's all.

Please don't turn mealtimes into this kind of dreaded event. It's so, so damaging for a child's relationship with food. I remember even now my uncle forcing my cousin to eat a certain amount of beans before he was allowed down from the table and us all sitting there for 30 mins while he cried and pushed beans around. Utterly pointless.

Swipe left for the next trending thread