Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think only the computer literate can now go on a foreign holiday

307 replies

rookiemere · 24/10/2021 18:46

We're just back from Tenerife and had a wonderful time, but oh my goodness the online forms to fill in were not easy for either Spain or UK, nor was the Randox registration for our PCR tests on return ( in Scotland).

I consider myself to be reasonably computer literate, but I was very grateful for some prompts I found on a Facebook help group. It took me an hour for each passenger locator for, and another hour roughly for three PCR tests ( plus an additional half hour to drive to a drop box as apparently they don't accept Royal Mail boxes anymore).

I get why the documentation is needed, so I'm not against that per se, but the fact it must be done on a device means that some people may not have that and are now forced to buy a smart phone which seems unfair.

You also need to be pretty literate to interpret the questions, so again could be tricky for some.

So my AIBU is, is it right that the form can only be completed online ?

OP posts:
Deliaskis · 25/10/2021 10:51

I agree the system seems to be quite impenetrable for some. My parents are going away in a couple of weeks and Mum has been nearly in tears trying to sort it. They do use computers for some parts of their lives, but have been retired for well over a decade and are a long way from our 'digital native' experience for those younger than about 50.

They are generally smart people, and pick up things and use them regularly, e.g. the online booking system for their golf club, or the askmyGP system. But those are systems they have learnt and use regularly. They're still not comfortable with online banking or supermarket shopping. And this week the COVID online admin that they are still only part way through is close to beating them. Those who are starting from a lower baseline would have no chance.

So yes I agree, international travel is now going to have a series of additional barriers for those who struggle with online forms, either due to capability/capacity or simply access to tech.

Topseyt · 25/10/2021 10:41

@Elieza

My 80 year old mother couldn’t fill in a form online as she doesn’t have a computer. Or indeed a mobile phone. So it may be a stereotype which is offensive to some and inaccurate to others but it’s true of her. She’s fab incidentally. Courageous, clever and funny. Just not into IT. Likes to speak to a human being.
Same for my mother. She is 86. She has a small interest in some technology and uses an Alexa as she finds it much easier than the controls of a traditional radio or CD player for her arthritic fingers.

She doesn't actually have a smartphone or computer though. Just a barely used iPad which she relies on my sister or I to help with and hardly touches herself. She'd recoil in horror at the idea of online forms.

I agree with OP's sentiments. I thought this while filling out Passenger Locator Forms during a recent holiday in Malta. The whole system assumes that everyone has access to and is able to use a computer or smartphone. There are a (dwindling, I should think) percentage of people for whom that is not the case. That doesn't mean they are stupid or that they should be discriminated against. A paper based system is still needed as a backup at times.

StupidPhones · 25/10/2021 10:25

I namechanged because I spent an hour grappling with the Scottish NHS passport app.last night. I'm not particularly stupid, honest!

TempsPerdu · 25/10/2021 10:21

It's not an age thing. It's an exposure thing

Yes agree, and also (principally IMO) general education levels. That’s what I was getting at with my post upthread: it’s not my parents’ age that’s preventing them from accessing tech, it’s that their overall education level is deficient. Both left school at 15 with no qualifications, and they lack the transferable skills that are necessary to grasp new and unfamiliar concepts. Plus they haven’t been exposed enough in the workplace to make basic IT skills become natural and intuitive.

user1497207191 · 25/10/2021 10:15

@Sonex It's not an age thing. It's an exposure thing.

I fully agree. But given that, people should start getting used to apps etc as it's the future and no one is going to put the genie back in the bottle. The use of apps etc will continue to increase. People need to start using the simple apps, simply to get used to them, and then they'll be in a better position to do the more complicated things.

My MIL (in her 80s) needed a consultation with a hospital specialist in the height of covid, so it was an online one with webcam. My MIL barely used the phone and basically just sent the odd text and had never used any apps. The hospital administrator/secretary talked her through how to set up the app, texted the link etc., and got it up and running before passing her over to the specialist - took about 5 minutes of the secretary guiding her through it. We were quite impressed really but clearly the secretary was doing a lot of it as she was very clear and confident in her instructions.

Sonex · 25/10/2021 10:03

It's not an age thing. It's an exposure thing. The friends I was helping get away are in their forties. One is a scaffolder, the other works in a supermarket. They don't really use computers in their day to day lives. They only have smartphones and only really use them for social media. They aren't widely travelled, having come from economically disadvantaged backgrounds (one grew up in foster care), so were stumped by a test booking site, for example, that wouldn't take their phone numbers. It was a site that operates internationally and hence wanted phone numbers in 00447 format, not 07XXXX which is what they know their phone numbers to be, they had no idea about the international format. There are lots of people like this. It was a real eye opener to me about the technological/educational divide that exists in the UK.

Saoirse82 · 25/10/2021 09:52

@DriftingBlue

I can maybe buy into people in their 80s possibly not being computer literate, but everyone below that, including people in their 70s have used computers actively for a long time now.
Yes, but using computers for certain aspects of work that you were confident about 10 or 15 years ago isn't the same as filling in those types of forms which can be stressful and you're more likely to get flustered. So for instance my mum is 75, she was an accountant and retired 10 years ago, would have used a computer daily in her job and she often uses a tablet and emails etc now, I know she would find these forms difficult and it would totally put her off going away as she's not confident on the computer and would definitely get stressed and flustered. My dad uses the computer more than I would but I think even he'd struggle too. My MIL is 53 and she couldn't even turn on a computer or a tablet, she even struggles with the basics of a mobile phone so it's not necessarily an age thing either.
stargirl1701 · 25/10/2021 09:23

I have found the intuitive aspect of Apple really helps with my PILs. They had very little tech but we bought them an iPad when DD1 was born so we could FaceTime. Over the last 10 years, they both came to find it so useful they bought another so they could have one each. They passed an old one onto my DC this month as they upgraded to the latest model this month.

They are also in their mid 70s.

They have the money to purchase the latest tech and they now need it to live their lives. I'm not saying they use it the way my DC do but they would not be without iPads now. I can't see this changing.

rookiemere · 25/10/2021 09:11

That's nice @stargirl1701 .

My DPs are in their 80s - granted they are too frail to travel now anyway- my DF was an early adopter of all technology but around his late 70s his ability to navigate the changes declined. At that age they were still travelling abroad, but wouldn't have if they would have been required to navigate through online plfs.

OP posts:
stargirl1701 · 25/10/2021 09:05

My 75 year old Dad is currently in Spain. He did everything from his new iPhone 13.

Aposterhasnoname · 25/10/2021 08:56

@OverByYer

I’m going away next week and I’m finding all the forms and tests overwhelming. I went to a gig last night , in Wales where we have to have Covid passports 🙄. Poor young guy didn’t have a smart phone and got turned away. Felt so sorry for him. He had his vaccinations card but that wasn’t good enough apparently. What difference does it make?
I don’t believe for a single minute that a “young” guy, with the means to go to a gig doesn’t have a smart phone. You can buy fake vaccine cards for around a tenner, and I’ll bet the house thats what he had done.
R0tational · 25/10/2021 08:54

@rookiemere
You have a completely valid point - digital exclusion is real and a problem. Older people and poorer groups are more affected. Havent RTFT as don't want to waste time reading about people's 103 yr old coding grannies.

Dee1975 · 25/10/2021 08:50

@rookiemere I tried photo and screen shot of my pass - neither worked! I wonder if there has been a bug in the system where it that bit doesn't work maybe?! 🤷‍♀️

Shocked no one checked when we landed though - there wasn’t any health checks at my local airport. (Unlike Spain that had a whole team checking all the docs. Doing random temp checks etc …!!!)

thewhatsit · 25/10/2021 08:42

I’m definitely computer literate but I’ll be honest, the changing rules, different requirements and norms over masks and fossil distancing between countries and the chance for any bit of it to go wrong makes the idea of travel very daunting right now.
It’s probably not as hard as I’m imagining but I’m avoiding for now. This is the longest I’ve ever not been abroad in my life by far but I think it will be a while longer. I guess that is kind of the point though isn’t it? They’re not banning it, they’re making it difficult.

Badbadbunny · 25/10/2021 08:36

@ApolloandDaphne

The digital divide still very much exists in the UK. Not just the elderly but those with disabilities, those living in poverty and those in rural areas with poor access to the network. They are plenty of people who are not able to access things via the Internet not just holidays. Things like benefits, jobs etc are hard to access without Internet access.
Yes, living rurally, I appreciate that, but as each day passes, there are more and more options to get connected, virtually every cafe/coffee shop has free wifi, as do libraries, and even places like shopping centres, hospitals, etc have free visitor wifi.
Badbadbunny · 25/10/2021 08:34

@rookiemere They should just get themselves the right phones - which are expensive

I've just spent 2 minutes googling and found a PAYG smartphone for under £50. That's not expensive at all. Yes, a tint minority may not have £50 to spare, but then they wouldn't be able to afford the flights, passports, taxis, etc to travel abroad anyway.

ApolloandDaphne · 25/10/2021 07:56

The digital divide still very much exists in the UK. Not just the elderly but those with disabilities, those living in poverty and those in rural areas with poor access to the network. They are plenty of people who are not able to access things via the Internet not just holidays. Things like benefits, jobs etc are hard to access without Internet access.

HijHij · 25/10/2021 07:46

I'd imagine many elderly people would have great difficulty navigating what is required.

Oh my goodness... Would you like to pat me on the head too?

I'm 'old'(*) and I'm blind and I can use computers and phones better than my personal assistants (who come to help me with other stuff, like going out) can!
I have been een helping young sighted neighbours sort out their online shopping, covid vaccine appointments etc.

I'm disappointed that you forgot to say "awww bless" too.

(*) old = over 60,completely grey hair and used the 1st ever word processor in Yorkshire in 1981 (it was about 8'x6'x6')

InvincibleInvisibility · 25/10/2021 07:36

I agree with PP about for other things but PLF etc are temporary for the pandemic so wont exclude permanently

Campervan69 · 25/10/2021 07:27

Maybe you won't get the agreement on here, it bring an online forum so the people on here will be comfortable with tech.

But I totally agree OP. I seem to be the go to in my family for navigating all these things on behalf of elderly family members. Not just holiday stuff but recently had to complete a really complicated blue badge renewal for a friend of my mum's in his 90s who was completely in a panic about the whole thing. There was no other way to apply for it.

ConfusedBear · 25/10/2021 07:26

It is more complicated than it needs to be. Even a list of what information you need to input would be useful! We also had to submit new forms once at the airport because we couldn't check in until we had a plf and then we were given seat numbers which meant we needed new plfs.

I found it stressful. I'm not sure how computer literate I am, however I am posting on Mumsnet and I do work with computers everyday. I can think of lots of people I know who would either be unable to complete the form or who it would take ages for.

Porcupineintherough · 25/10/2021 07:26

There comes a point at which technology becomes mainstream, we have reached that point with computers and the internet I think. If you are in your late 60s and cant navigate a computer that means you have been refusing to get onboard with them for nigh on 35 years, for the internet 25.

It's not so much that it doesnt matter of people get left behind, more that there comes a point where it becomes inevitable. There have been - and still are - many, many cheap or free opportunities to learn how to navigate this not so new world - my 80 year old mum had just gone on an introduction to smart phones course run by the local council when COVID hit and has had to learn to shop online and use zoom over the last 18 months.

The world moves on. You either run to keep up or get left behind. That's not new.

Worldgonecrazy · 25/10/2021 07:26

Just to add, as it seems a common problem, also unable to upload qr code for vaccinations so that was another waste of time. Obviously this is a common issue.

Worldgonecrazy · 25/10/2021 07:25

Yanbu

I am very computer literate, and have spent all my working life since 1990 on computers, have the latest smart phone etc.

The Greek plf was a lot easier this year,, the Greek government obviously responded to the clarity issues last year. But the British plf has become more complicated and the randox submission forms were also a faff to complete on a smart phone.

My dad, also computer literate (taught himself computer programming in the 90s) would struggle as he is beginning to find forms more difficult to understand.

The Greek plf form took me about 5 minutes, brutish PLF form about 25 minutes, randox forms about 30 minutes total.

And no one checked on arrival back in the U.K. so just a complete waste of tine

rookiemere · 25/10/2021 07:22

@Dee1975 the Scottish form is the same as the English one, I just thought our vaccine details might be in a different format. I was determined to get the details uploaded so most of the time was taking photos of the QR code and trying to get it on the form. Maybe I'm just particularly slow though, but I did find some of the questions tricky to answer correctly.

OP posts: