Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think only the computer literate can now go on a foreign holiday

307 replies

rookiemere · 24/10/2021 18:46

We're just back from Tenerife and had a wonderful time, but oh my goodness the online forms to fill in were not easy for either Spain or UK, nor was the Randox registration for our PCR tests on return ( in Scotland).

I consider myself to be reasonably computer literate, but I was very grateful for some prompts I found on a Facebook help group. It took me an hour for each passenger locator for, and another hour roughly for three PCR tests ( plus an additional half hour to drive to a drop box as apparently they don't accept Royal Mail boxes anymore).

I get why the documentation is needed, so I'm not against that per se, but the fact it must be done on a device means that some people may not have that and are now forced to buy a smart phone which seems unfair.

You also need to be pretty literate to interpret the questions, so again could be tricky for some.

So my AIBU is, is it right that the form can only be completed online ?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 27/10/2021 18:59

[quote julieca]@Franklin12 I am in my fifties. Computers were not around when I started work. At university, we still handed in handwritten essays. At work, I wrote letters by hand that I gave to the secretary to type up. I didn't use a computer until I was well into my twenties (28 I think?). And then it was a basic computer. I worked with managers whose secretaries still printed off their emails 15 years ago. Some of those men were close to retirement.
People seem to think computers have been ubiquitous for a long time, they really have not.
Of course there have been people using computers at work longer than me, but my workplace was not unusual.[/quote]
I'm in my 50's too and started working in 1982. We had a few computers back then in our office (for VAT returns and payroll) as did quite a few of our clients. I moved to another firm in 1986 and we all had our own computers on our desks. By the late 1980's nearly all of our larger clients were using computers for their book-keeping/payroll etc as were a fair number of smaller clients. I moved into industry in 1992 and we were using internal "email" for all internal memos/communications etc rather than hand or type written memos/notes.

DriftingBlue · 27/10/2021 18:57

I’m 48. We had Computers classes in school when I was 14. I used a computer at work starting when I was 18. By the time I was 20, we only had a handful of typewriters left in the building for filling out the occasional form and that was at a university department park with a bare bones budget.

I think this bothers me so much because I’m not ok with my generation being written off as technologically incompetent.

LittleBearPad · 27/10/2021 18:51

@retroginglass

Computers have changed a lot over the years and unless you have kept up with doing anything more than the basics I completely agree with the OP. My DH works in IT but says he can't do a Tesco online shop - go figure!
Are you sure this isn’t convenient incompetence?
julieca · 27/10/2021 18:44

@Franklin12 I am in my fifties. Computers were not around when I started work. At university, we still handed in handwritten essays. At work, I wrote letters by hand that I gave to the secretary to type up. I didn't use a computer until I was well into my twenties (28 I think?). And then it was a basic computer. I worked with managers whose secretaries still printed off their emails 15 years ago. Some of those men were close to retirement.
People seem to think computers have been ubiquitous for a long time, they really have not.
Of course there have been people using computers at work longer than me, but my workplace was not unusual.

Franklin12 · 27/10/2021 18:11

You also just need to know the minimum, how to log on, how to load a document. How to do a spell check. How to print. Some people just put their heads in the sand and decide they won’t even try.

My DM refuses to use anything bar a mobile and she doesn’t know how to text. However she has me to help so she has decided to just not even try. Having said that she is late 80’s but she has always been like this. Doesn’t drive and never saw the need but always expects someone to pick her up (in their car!).

Franklin12 · 27/10/2021 18:07

Computers have been around for years. Maybe not when a 80 year old started work but perhaps when they were 60. My DH refused to have a mobile, computer etc and got himself in a horrible mess with his finances. He is now in a care home and I do it all for him and I am no spring chicken myself!

julieca · 27/10/2021 17:01

@RantyAunty lots of people in their 70s and 80s go on holiday abroad.
I don't know how you can be old and have worked with computers all your working life unless you were in a small group of people working with computers when they were cutting edge.
I mean the ZX81 was launched in 1981. An incredibly basic home computer that used a cassette tape. Computers in the workplace at that point were specialist and took up whole rooms.

BarbaraofSeville · 27/10/2021 16:33

@Caffeinefirst

Franklin12

Lots of people try but still struggle. My mum gets very upset and frustrated about not being able to do things herself online. She can manage emails, what’s app and online banking but struggles with stuff like uploading documents, sorting out printing issues.

I think it’s very bad how everything is going online without a thought to the very large number of people who will struggle without family support to help. And as I’ve learnt with my mum you have to be close by to offer tech support. Trying to help her over the phone is a nightmare!

My MIL had no online access at all; no computer, tablet or smart phone. There is so much she cannot access easily eg like cheaper energy deals.

But most people are able to learn and will find it easier with practice, plus things like uploading documents is very very easy on a tablet or smartphone.

Neither of my parents used computers at work but both learned the basics in their 60s/70s, with help from their children and grandchildren.

Yes, its a steep learning curve and no not everything works as well as it should, but most of this is not as impossible to access as many are making out.

rookiemere · 27/10/2021 16:29

I agree @RantyAunty that people should try to acquire basic IT skills where they can, but having been through the passenger locator form process for both Spain and back to the UK, being able to do some rudimentary navigation round the internet is not going to cut the mustard.

OP posts:
mycatisannoying · 27/10/2021 16:29

@DriftingBlue

I can maybe buy into people in their 80s possibly not being computer literate, but everyone below that, including people in their 70s have used computers actively for a long time now.
Really??
mycatisannoying · 27/10/2021 16:28

I agree with you, OP. YANBU.

RantyAunty · 27/10/2021 16:27

What age groups are you talking about who can take overseas holidays and not use a computer well?

I'm an old bag. My entire career has been with computers.

I find filling out forms tedious. I do nearly everything online. I don't want to print anything or post anything or go somewhere to get something certified.

But that's just me, because I've been with it since near the beginning and have adapted.

I have relatives who still pay bills in person, write cheques for things.

I would say to take a course in basic skills.

Caffeinefirst · 27/10/2021 16:08

Franklin12

Lots of people try but still struggle. My mum gets very upset and frustrated about not being able to do things herself online. She can manage emails, what’s app and online banking but struggles with stuff like uploading documents, sorting out printing issues.

I think it’s very bad how everything is going online without a thought to the very large number of people who will struggle without family support to help. And as I’ve learnt with my mum you have to be close by to offer tech support. Trying to help her over the phone is a nightmare!

My MIL had no online access at all; no computer, tablet or smart phone. There is so much she cannot access easily eg like cheaper energy deals.

julieca · 27/10/2021 16:07

TBH the young people in my workplace are great at using IT to do written reports and using social media and AV apps. But most are not good at doing anything new where they have to figure out how to do things. This is the skill you need as you get older and leave the workplace.

DriftingBlue · 27/10/2021 16:02

People are claiming younger people don’t know how to use computers either? Are there really schools there where students are still researching essays using encyclopedias and writing them long-hand?

I’m in the U.S, students in my area start taking tests on computers in reception. They are completely integrated into the classroom.

julieca · 27/10/2021 15:58

@Franklin12 and what about those with a tremor, memory problems or other issues that make using IT difficult or impossible? What about the disability act? Are these people just going to be cut out of society?

retroginglass · 27/10/2021 15:57

Computers have changed a lot over the years and unless you have kept up with doing anything more than the basics I completely agree with the OP. My DH works in IT but says he can't do a Tesco online shop - go figure!

Franklin12 · 27/10/2021 15:55

I honestly think people need to at least try to use computers. Just because they cannot be bothered, dont want to try, would rather do it the old fashioned way doesnt mean those ways carry on.

Banks are shutting because they are expensive to run on the high street yet people want to do it the way they have always done it and that just isnt feasible now.

Some old people are even proud they dont have a phone, computer etc but they I expect increasingly find that they are shut out of some things. If someone can say drive a car with all that that entails then surely they can gain some IT skills.

julieca · 27/10/2021 15:43

@user1497207191 you dont need to access your payslip generally. And doing timesheets online takes very basic IT knowledge. It is very different from being IT literate.

VickyEadieofThigh · 27/10/2021 15:19

@LittleBearPad

I'd imagine many elderly people would have great difficulty navigating what is required.

Comments like this are so patronising. Why the assumption that elderly people can’t use the internet. It’s been around 20 odd years.

My Dad's 88 and has never had a computer or a mobile phone of any kind.
user1497207191 · 27/10/2021 15:17

@julieca

I suspect lots of people dont realise how many jobs you can still do without a computer. Or alternatively only using one work app but nothing else e.g. amazon drivers.
You may be able to do the job without a computer, but more and more firms except you to submit your timesheets online and access your payslips online.
zingally · 27/10/2021 15:02

I think the pandemic has only accelerated the need to have a smart phone for every day life.

julieca · 27/10/2021 14:52

I suspect lots of people dont realise how many jobs you can still do without a computer. Or alternatively only using one work app but nothing else e.g. amazon drivers.

Ciaram55 · 27/10/2021 09:58

Just because computers have been around for quite a long time now, doesn't mean that adults who hadn't been taught how to use them, could use them. I'm in my sixties and basically had to teach myself. I know loads in my age group, even people in their 50s who can't.

Unless you make the decision to learn about computers or if you aren't in a job that required you to learn, then it isn't a given that everyone under 70 should be able to.

rookiemere · 27/10/2021 09:15

Yes that's a good point @Caffeinefirst . I like to be organised and get admin tasks out of the way, but there's no way to do any of this stuff in advance, so you can't avoid taking time out of your holiday to do it.

I'm thinking about going abroad for a long weekend later this year and find myself gravitating towards Spain as at least I've successfully completed the plf once so know what to expect.

OP posts: