Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think only the computer literate can now go on a foreign holiday

307 replies

rookiemere · 24/10/2021 18:46

We're just back from Tenerife and had a wonderful time, but oh my goodness the online forms to fill in were not easy for either Spain or UK, nor was the Randox registration for our PCR tests on return ( in Scotland).

I consider myself to be reasonably computer literate, but I was very grateful for some prompts I found on a Facebook help group. It took me an hour for each passenger locator for, and another hour roughly for three PCR tests ( plus an additional half hour to drive to a drop box as apparently they don't accept Royal Mail boxes anymore).

I get why the documentation is needed, so I'm not against that per se, but the fact it must be done on a device means that some people may not have that and are now forced to buy a smart phone which seems unfair.

You also need to be pretty literate to interpret the questions, so again could be tricky for some.

So my AIBU is, is it right that the form can only be completed online ?

OP posts:
Franklin12 · 28/10/2021 15:13

So having observed other people at airports around Europe over the summer could I give a couple of examples of what I saw.

People trying to blag it. The women in front of me with her two kids had done the NHS tests before her flight. She clearly thought they would let her through anyway. She said her friend had said it was fine....She started kicking off and had her poor kids with her as well. Eventually she claimed she was going to a funeral.

People filling in PLF's at the airport having not even thought about ordering a Day 2 test. Very luckily there was a TUI rep who pulled them to one side but they were shouting at her and I felt really sorry for her.

Its a nightmare. Some countries require LFT test, some PCR, some need to supervised, some not.

My only real tip is when you have booked your holiday just check, put a note up on Trip Advisor Forum under the relevant destination with any questions. Although I wouldnt take what they said as gospel its a start and its amazing how many people still think you can use a NHS test.

Why would the 400 odd private providers be in business if you could do that!!

Print out whatever you can in advance. Dont leave it until the last minute.

I agree with a PP - try a simple App. Get used to it and whoever said 'the more I practise the better I get'.

I understand its really complex sometimes but you at lest have to try and get used to the new world.

The PLF is tedious. It repeats and tries to be one form for every eventuality. I never got to upload my vaccine passport. I think there might be a bug but it said that you could always show seperately so I did.

julieca · 28/10/2021 15:12

And I suspect because it is mainly old and vulnerable people transferring money over the phone, when you phone up they really quiz you now about where you got the account details, have you met this person and are you being coerced.

julieca · 28/10/2021 15:10

Yes that is awful.
I admit I don't do online banking. I did when younger, but I don't think my eyesight is good enough now to safely do it.

itsnotmeitsu · 28/10/2021 15:06

@shineynewapple21 > 'That's awful @itsnotmeitsu was it proved? Was he prosecuted? Did her family get any of the money back ?

The bank agreed that the transactions to this person should never have taken place. There were five in all, done over the phone. So the fact that my sister never owned a computer or a smartphone didn't come into that. However, the neighbour had her using his laptop to place online orders and I know he stole much more money than was taken by the bank transfers, but that can't be proven. My sister had no idea about passwords or anything like that. She had some mental health problems and was on benefits - she didn't have the resources or the ability to be computer literate.

The bank immediately repaid the money into a probate account, so her daughter got that part of the inheritance back. However, the police have now dropped the case because they say the bank won't hand over the recordings of the phone calls about transferring the money, and without that there's no evidence. So the bank have paid out £45,000 and he's got away with £45,000 of someone else's money, because they won't hand over the evidence required to take it to court. Thanks for asking about it x. I suppose my point in mentioning this was that no, not everybody is able to be computer-literate because they're dinosaurs, stubborn, etc, and this is still very raw to me. It may be a massive convenience for those who currently can't do it, to get computer-savvy. But this option isn't open to everyone; it certainly wasn't for my sister. Not that she'd had a holiday since the 80s, so no technology involved then.

How many people who have never been onboard with technology (and there's no comparison between using computers today and using them in the 80s and 90s) and now find they have to use this technology are putting themselves in a vulnerable position? Even the most technology-savvy are able to be scammed. God knows how many criminals and how much money is being stolen due to this push for everything to be done via a machine rather than human beings having personal interaction.

julieca · 28/10/2021 15:02

I think the apps make it more difficult although I do agree with what you are saying. But also taking your example, applying for an ESTA is a piece of piss. Whereas there are lots of people on this thread who are computer literate saying they struggled with the apps.

Badbadbunny · 28/10/2021 15:00

@julieca

I keep reading about people being turned away from flights for not meeting rules. Enough to know that some people are struggling to understand and follow through with them.
But is that due to the app or do some people struggle with rules/paperwork anyway? I'm sure that people used to be turned away back in the times of pen and paper before apps. Certainly if you try to fly to the US without the ESTA you'd be turned away at the departure gate!
julieca · 28/10/2021 14:57

I keep reading about people being turned away from flights for not meeting rules. Enough to know that some people are struggling to understand and follow through with them.

BunNcheese · 28/10/2021 14:51

I don't think it's a case of being computer literate.

It's just a tedious process and having to get the timings right for the testing and reading the rules and regs were the worst part when I flew in summer this year.

Badbadbunny · 28/10/2021 14:48

My point is that people are acting as if it's a complete surprise that computers/apps/smartphones have suddenly appeared. In reality, we've had "tech" for 30/40 years and use/scope has been steadily increasing throughout that time. It's been blindingly obvious that the use of "tech" will increase and eventually take over all "manual" operations.

I think there is a minority of luddites who are just in denial about "tech" and are assuming they don't have to use it, and that there'll always be alternatives or someone else to do it for them, not because they're incapable, but because they just can't be bothered.

I have some sympathy for those, say, 80 and above, who were retired/winding down by the time computers/smart phones became commonplace, but anyone younger has had ample time to become IT literature when they were young enough to be able to learn the basics. And let's face it, it's only basic use that is needed - no one is expecting a 60 year old to learn to program, they're just expected to be able to navigate an app.

julieca · 28/10/2021 14:38

@Badbadbunny Between 1985 and 1990 Amstrad sold 3 million computers. By 1990 computers had become a bit more common. But 3 million computers in total over five years is not a lot. No most people did not have a personal computer. It was from 1990 that computers began to take off. Late eighties computers began to become more common in the workplace, especially for secretaries. 1990s/early 2000 is when lots of secretary jobs were got rid off and other staff expected to take on those roles with their own computers. Look at footage of people trading in the stock exchange in the 80s. They were still doing it on the floor rather than at computers.

By the way worldwide in 2019 23.2 million personal household robots were sold. Do you know many people who have a personal robot at home?

Badbadbunny · 28/10/2021 14:27

@Franklin12

Some of it is laziness I think. If they just dont bother then it will all go back to the old ways that they know and love. That and giving it to someone else to do (i.e me!!).

The PLF has brought to the forefront that you MUST embrace some things. Not be a wizzy expert but just know enough to get by. You cannot expect everything to remain the same just because you cannot be bothered. My DM and DF have me - some people dont have anyone.

I agree that for a lot of people it's just laziness and "can't be bothered" rather than them genuinely being unable to cope with new tech.

It's no surprise people struggle when they make no effort to learn new things and then find themselves forced to use it at a stressful time. Yes, being forced to use an app for PLF forms when you've never used an app previously will be hard and stressful. But there is no reason why people couldn't dip their toe in the water and start using apps for other things beforehand to get their smart phone connecting to the internet, get accustomed to the app store, etc. If you've used a few simple apps, (such as weather, online shopping, new, etc), then you've gained a lot of experience and skills for more complicated apps.

Badbadbunny · 28/10/2021 14:23

@julieca

No I have never heard of the Wang computer. But talking about using what was very specialist equipment then is pretty meaningless in terms of the average person. I mean I suspect in years to come we will have personal robots that we will have to programme. If someone in years to come said that people have been using personal robots since 2015 that would be true. But virtually no one has a personal robot now. And even though they are widespread in some industries like car manufacturing, very few people use robots at work. It is a specialised piece of kit, rather than something nearly everyone has.
But there weren't just "very specialist equipment". The Amstrad PCW was launched as far back as 1985 and cost just 25% of PCs at the time, so was a very affordable home and small office computer.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amstrad_PCW

Franklin12 · 28/10/2021 13:27

Julie - I 100% agree with you. Horribly stressful and you drive to the airport always thinking you might have missed something. Some check in agents ask for all forms, some ask for some of them and suddenly as you walk off the plane someone is literally standing there demanding to see your locator form.

Because of the pandemic we have all had to think very carefully whether we wanted to go abroad. I made the decision that a UK holiday would not be good enough so I spent hours sorting out forms, checking and re-checking and making sure everything had been completed, ticked etc.

The result was I went twice and the second time was no easier than the first because the blooming rules had changed again!

Was it worth it in the end - ABSOLUTELY!!

Would I have rather given all the paperwork to someone else to do so I didnt need to bother if I had the option? Yep....

julieca · 28/10/2021 13:15

@Franklin12 going abroad on holiday takes work and some stress. At various points of life the stress is not worth it for some people. For some that is travelling with a baby or toddler, for others that is dealing with multiple forms and tests. It is supposed to be fun.

Franklin12 · 28/10/2021 13:13

Some of it is laziness I think. If they just dont bother then it will all go back to the old ways that they know and love. That and giving it to someone else to do (i.e me!!).

The PLF has brought to the forefront that you MUST embrace some things. Not be a wizzy expert but just know enough to get by. You cannot expect everything to remain the same just because you cannot be bothered. My DM and DF have me - some people dont have anyone.

julieca · 28/10/2021 13:06

Not laziness, just stressful.

Seahawk80 · 28/10/2021 13:05

My parents are in their 70s/ early 80s and have no problems with all the forms. In laws are 10 years younger and won't go abroad as it's "too much hassle and we can't do the paperwork ". This feels like a recurring theme, lots of things are too much hassle for them. I feel like for a lot of people it's more that they can't be bothered to read the information and take the time to understand it. Instead they blame the fact that it's all online whereas really it's just laziness.

MrsColon · 28/10/2021 13:02

Ha, my Dad's 70 this year, and is my go-to person for digital/technical computer stuff!

Even my 93-year-old Grandma has a tablet.

julieca · 28/10/2021 12:53

No I have never heard of the Wang computer.
But talking about using what was very specialist equipment then is pretty meaningless in terms of the average person.
I mean I suspect in years to come we will have personal robots that we will have to programme. If someone in years to come said that people have been using personal robots since 2015 that would be true. But virtually no one has a personal robot now. And even though they are widespread in some industries like car manufacturing, very few people use robots at work. It is a specialised piece of kit, rather than something nearly everyone has.

RantyAunty · 28/10/2021 12:40

[quote julieca]@RantyAunty did you go to a private school?
The cost of an Apple in 1978 is equivalent to $5,600 today. Few schools could afford that and certainly no state schools I knew.
And sure there were small numbers of PCs produced that used dos commands. They were very user-unfriendly and expensive. They were not widely used and most people had never used a computer as early as this.
For example, in 1983 IBM sold 750,000 computers worldwide which was seen to be an enormous success. This is nothing.
I was at university then and we were all doing handwritten essays. Computers were for those studying computer science or for data-heavy tasks in workplaces, or firms who bought cutting edge technology. It was not commonplace. And most people my age would not have used any computer until much later.
I mean my friend who works with mainframes was using computers 50 years ago, but her knowledge was so specialist she travelled the world for her kob. Not your ordinary office worker.[/quote]
Yes, I know all this. I was there. I have quite a few patents.
I never was an ordinary office worker but I've implemented countless systems over the years.

Do you remember the Wang 2200 computer?
The majority of the top US companies used Wang office equipment in the early 80s.

julieca · 28/10/2021 10:51

@Worldgonecrazy yes lots of places had mainframe computers. Very different from a desktop. My brother had a ZX spectrum, it was affordable but loaded up using a tape recorder and really had fairly low capability. My brother works in computers and is a big computer geek.
That year was about the time there was the national campaign to get a BBC computer in every state school. I think it depended on the number of pupils if you got one computer or more? But most pupils obviously got nowhere near the one or two school computers.

Abraxan · 28/10/2021 10:40

My parents are late 60s and mange to go away, all booked independently via their computers abd iPads. As does MIL who is in her 70s.

Even older people can use technology if they want to learn how to.

user1497207191 · 28/10/2021 10:38

@Worldgonecrazy

1984, my school had two or three BBC computers and one ZX.

My dad showed me the computer room at his county hospital around the same time. It had a huge mainframe and a lot of tapes.

At home we had a BBC, and a tape recorder, also around the same time.

I think saying a person needs to be IT savvy to fill in the forms is misleading. The forms are not user friendly, and that is the root of the issue. I guess zero cross-platform user testing was carried out, or if it was, it was done by someone already familiar with the forms.

Forms not being user friendly was common with paper forms too, it’s not an exclusively “computer” thing at all. Poor form design, ambiguous questions, unanswerable questions, not enough space etc has been commonplace on paper forms for decades.
KrispyKale · 28/10/2021 09:51

True, You have to be confident enough to know it's not you with the problem but the form.

Worldgonecrazy · 28/10/2021 09:43

1984, my school had two or three BBC computers and one ZX.

My dad showed me the computer room at his county hospital around the same time. It had a huge mainframe and a lot of tapes.

At home we had a BBC, and a tape recorder, also around the same time.

I think saying a person needs to be IT savvy to fill in the forms is misleading. The forms are not user friendly, and that is the root of the issue. I guess zero cross-platform user testing was carried out, or if it was, it was done by someone already familiar with the forms.