Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

what you think of halloween?

344 replies

adam7485 · 24/10/2021 18:40

. ok. halloween can be a fantastic time for all people kids and everyone, but am i the only person to think it brings the worst out of people? 2019 before covid i got a taxi to a local pub who were having a halloween party and we almost had a nasty accident as some kids threw something in front of the car. how we didn't have an accident was probably more luck than judgement. to think that a good celebration and fun has become tainted by the actions of a certain group of people?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 12:21

For the rest of the year we teach kids it's wrong to accept sweets from strangers!

A huge part of Halloween is divergence from the norm and overthrowing of the 'rules'. It's actually baked into many of our historic festivals, suggesting a human fascination with the idea that we play out in specified circumstances.

Ajl46 · 26/10/2021 12:19

@TheKeatingFive

the latter is all about "be good or Santa will know & you won't get any presents!"

Well that's a threat too. A slightly different kind, but still a threat.

It's a threat parents choose to use to encourage good behaviour in their own children. Not a threat to strangers to extort sweets/money from them.
For the rest of the year we teach kids it's wrong to accept sweets from strangers!
TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 12:18

Why not rename it to something less intimidating to the recipient?

I'm personally not able to instigate a widespread national shift in this regard, apologies.

Eventually language will adapt I'm sure.

Ajl46 · 26/10/2021 12:17

@TheKeatingFive

So what does trick or treating mean? In particular, what do children understand by the "trick" part? What is the consequence if a stranger refuses to give a treat when asked?

My children and their friends say the words, but have absolutely no understanding of any 'consequences'. If someone doesn't answer their door or doesn't give them anything, they'd simply leave.

Like I say, do discuss your concerns around 'extortion' from the under 10s with the police of you'd like to.

So trick or treating is encouraging kids to use words in a way they don't understand? That's not helpful to them either.
Why not rename it to something less intimidating to the recipient?
QueenofKattegat · 26/10/2021 12:14

Love Halloween. Always have. Go to a big party and ride a giant pumpkin every year and can't wait for this years' seeing as we have missed it with covid. MN is ridiculous about Halloween. Begging/Americanised/Plastic bollocks.

TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 12:13

the latter is all about "be good or Santa will know & you won't get any presents!"

Well that's a threat too. A slightly different kind, but still a threat.

TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 12:13

So what does trick or treating mean? In particular, what do children understand by the "trick" part? What is the consequence if a stranger refuses to give a treat when asked?

My children and their friends say the words, but have absolutely no understanding of any 'consequences'. If someone doesn't answer their door or doesn't give them anything, they'd simply leave.

Like I say, do discuss your concerns around 'extortion' from the under 10s with the police of you'd like to.

Ajl46 · 26/10/2021 12:06

Trick or treating has a starkly different moral message to Christmas. The former relies on a threat to get something you want, the latter is all about "be good or Santa will know & you won't get any presents!"
Very inconsistent.

Ajl46 · 26/10/2021 12:04

@TheKeatingFive

That is exactly what trick or treating means- give me a treat or I will do something nasty to you. A very weird moral message to be encouraging.

Notwithstanding the capacity for any practice to be abused by wannabe trouble makers, we are predominately talking about under 10s who wouldn't have the first clue how to do something 'nasty' to you. If you called the police to report 'extortion' how do you think they'd respond to that?

So what does trick or treating mean? In particular, what do children understand by the "trick" part? What is the consequence if a stranger refuses to give a treat when asked?
TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 11:37

That is exactly what trick or treating means- give me a treat or I will do something nasty to you. A very weird moral message to be encouraging.

Notwithstanding the capacity for any practice to be abused by wannabe trouble makers, we are predominately talking about under 10s who wouldn't have the first clue how to do something 'nasty' to you. If you called the police to report 'extortion' how do you think they'd respond to that?

Hemingwayscats · 26/10/2021 11:17

I’ve never personally experienced this at all. It’s just a fun family occasion where I live, many people decorate their houses (some go all out!) and children get dressed up and have fun.

Ajl46 · 26/10/2021 11:13

@Sparklingbrook the definition of extortion is "the practice of obtaining something, especially money, through force or threats." That is exactly what trick or treating means- give me a treat or I will do something nasty to you. A very weird moral message to be encouraging.

Popcornriver · 26/10/2021 10:56

I like it. Kids like it. We fill a huge bowl with sweets and chocolate, stick a pumpkin outside, watch some scary films, do a couple of Halloween activities, maybe some baking and crafting. I don't consider any of the kids coming to our house as 'begging' for treats since the pumpkin outside shows we're inviting them to come show off their costumes and get some sweets. I also won't apologise for allowing my child to choose a costume each year if there's no available hand me down from my eldest. Same goes with a Christmas jumper. Some might see them as wasteful but I can guarantee we have much less clothing waste as a household than those buying new clothes every other week and wearing them once or twice.

Muim · 26/10/2021 10:48

@SeasonalNamechange You need to chill out a bit love.

It's hardly begging, get a grip

lazylinguist · 26/10/2021 10:45

I'm not that fussed about Halloween (in spite of the fact that it's my birthday!), but I can't say I've ever in all my 50 years seen it bring out the worst in people tbh. The worst I've seen was someone's tree getting strewn with toilet paper about 35 years ago. People who are antisocial arseholes will always find an excuse to behave badly, Halloween or no Halloween.

Sparklingbrook · 26/10/2021 10:36

@TheKeatingFive

I loved toffee apples when I was a child. Mine aren't keen on them, which is a shame!
I quite like a chocolate covered apple now. My two never liked toffee apples either. Sad
TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 10:25

I loved toffee apples when I was a child. Mine aren't keen on them, which is a shame!

TheKeatingFive · 26/10/2021 10:25

But I doubt the plastic ghosts hanging from their tree and plastic caution tape covering their garden will be reused as they look already to be falling apart in the weather . I could be wrong.

Well we have certainly reused plastic caution tape over the years. It's hardier than it looks.

But if that's all you're talking about, it's hardly major environmental impact compared to everything else we do in this world, now is it? Binning a few bits of tape/cut outs? I expect most of us do far worse than that on weekly basis.

Sparklingbrook · 26/10/2021 10:19

When I was a kid we didn't even have toffee apples until Bonfire Night, Halloween was not even mentioned. Shock

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 26/10/2021 09:55

More commercialised tat. It's ridiculous the way people go overboard with it. When I was a kid we made some toffee apples and did a bit of apple bobbing in the washing up bowl!

Sparklingbrook · 26/10/2021 09:50

Sorry, I forgot to add 'commercialised' to the list. Grin

GladAllOver · 26/10/2021 09:40

Christmas and Easter will be the next targets

The other two festivals that have been commercialised way out of their original meaning? Yes.

Sparklingbrook · 26/10/2021 09:32

Yes every year on MN when Halloween gets a mention-

Begging
Plastic tat
America to blame
horror at the thought of a few sweets on one night-the sugar!

We now have these to add to the list

Extortion
Worries about food waste

What next?

FourTeaFallOut · 26/10/2021 09:29

No. We don't bin Halloween things either. It just goes back up in to the loft for the next year (the same as every one else). Nor do we have Christmas themes and fling out 'old colours' and replace with new. I mean, even if you didn't have an eco bone in your body, who has the energy for replacing all this stuff each year?

Explosivefarts · 26/10/2021 09:26

@Sparklingbrook excellent point . But I doubt the plastic ghosts hanging from their tree and plastic caution tape covering their garden will be reused as they look already to be falling apart in the weather . I could be wrong.