Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my daughters school is misusing isolation

52 replies

GrabbyAbbie · 23/10/2021 10:26

My daughter is in year 9 at my local secondary school. She is generally a well behaved teenager, she has her moments but don't they all!, but generally keeps her head down and doesn't engage in negative behaviour.

However despite being a child who doesn't get in much trouble she has been put in isolation 3 times!

Once for drinking out of a water fountain - she apparently broke covid procedure ( this resulted in a full day of isolation) when I complained and said there were no cups or a warning on the fountain they said tough basically.
I accept she maybe should have been punished but maybe a warning of even a detention could have been used not isolation.

The other two times she was placed in isolation for a uniform issue and couldn't come out of isolation until I brought the correct uniform ( I work part time so if I hadn't have managed to bring the uniform in she would have been in isolation a full day)
The first time was a genuine mistake she thought she had to go in her pe kit in face she was told to by a teacher who got it wrong and the second time her shoes were broke so she had to wear trainers.
I get she should have had some sort of sanction but when I was at school isolations were for severe disruptive or aggressive behaviour and not for minor offences.
My friends son had been bullied for weeks violently and the culprit wasn't given a lesser punishment than my child.
Should I just suck it up? Am
I being a precious parent? Or is the school misusing isolation?

OP posts:
LolaButt · 23/10/2021 10:53

Isolation to me says to a child - your behaviour is so egregious you shouldn’t be around other people.

Of course schools abuse it. Because it’s easier to dump the child in the proverbial bin for the day and criminalise them, rather than deal with the actual issue.

I think it’s appalling that as adults we allow schools to use this technique so easily. What is it teaching a child who incorrectly used a water fountain? Nothing. Instead they could have asked her to spend half hour of her break printing up some signs for the fountains.

Makes me mad.

Periperry · 23/10/2021 10:35

This all seem quite harsh - isolation is used for disruptive behaviour at my kids’ school. Although they are insanely strict on uniform, I think they use DT’s for incorrect uniform.

Swipe left for the next trending thread