Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child's gained weight with daily exercising

117 replies

Artie30 · 23/10/2021 09:46

Hello all. It seems a child's weight post can get pretty nasty but want some advice... I'll take the bit.

Ds is 10, he has asd. He's about 145cm tall. A few weeks ago he was 6.5 Stone which put him in the overweight category.

He doesn't really care about his weight so it goes over his head, which is good. I don't want him obsessing over his weight.

I've been trying to watch what he eats. Also we've bought him a new bike since his old one got too small. For the last 3-4 weeks he's been out on it daily. For an hour outside after school each day and often going on 2 mile bike rides with Dp... he's obsessed with his new bike.

I felt like he was looking like he'd slimmed down a bit, in the face too I think!

But I've weighed him today and he is 6 Stone 12.5! Nearly 7 Stone. Wtf?? Surely he can't gain half a stone in a few weeks whilst we are making an effort with his diet and exercise.

He is 10 nearly 11! He is in 11-12 clothes that fit him fine so not in clothes big for his age!

What the hell do I do now?

His diet isn't the best but not the worst either. He only drinks water, hates anything sweet, he's partial to chocolate and crisps but in moderation. He doesn't like sweets.

For breakfast it's usually 2 slices of marmite on toast, school lunches on week days and usually fish fingers for dinner (he will only eat fish fingers atm, don't hate me). He maybe had a packet of crisps in the evening but that's it. Weekends he may eat a little more but not extreme!

OP posts:
TheChiefJo · 23/10/2021 15:28

Muscle is denser and therefore, the same volume of it weighs more. FFS. That is obviously what is meant by "muscle weighs more than fat".

I love that PPs are saying a specified weight of X weighs the same as exact same specified weight of Y. No kidding.

Vieve1325 · 23/10/2021 15:20

@MushMonster

Ok, let's not complicate life. Of course a pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat. But it does not take the same space. Two people with same height. One really fit and muscly and the other one not, and do not be surprised if the fit one weighs more even looking rather thinner. That is what people means when they say muscle weighs more than fat. It saves words, time, and we have all already been to primary here.
Yessss- and that’s what’s meant by muscle is DENSER.

It is not HEAVIER. That’s just misinformation.

Strugglingtodomybest · 23/10/2021 15:16

@Artie30

Thank you. To be honest I don't make a point of weighing mine all that often! It's not a regular thing really! He hasn't grown much in height for a while so hoping he'll shoot up soon. Not sure what the average height is for his age but most of the boys un his class lot taller than him - not sure if he's short or they are really tall though!

No worries OP! I think I should have also pointed out that when they were going through this phase, I worried like hell that they were going to end up obese, so I completely get where you're coming from Smile

Also, the height thing, honestly, please don't worry. All of my sons' friends have had their growth spurts at different times and the difference in heights has been quite funny at times. Remember, some of them are almost a year apart in age, you'll really notice this in a few years time too

MushMonster · 23/10/2021 15:02

Ok, let's not complicate life.
Of course a pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat.
But it does not take the same space.
Two people with same height. One really fit and muscly and the other one not, and do not be surprised if the fit one weighs more even looking rather thinner.
That is what people means when they say muscle weighs more than fat. It saves words, time, and we have all already been to primary here.

Crystal90567 · 23/10/2021 15:00

No point arguing with pp who can't understand basic science. KS1 science at that!
Lead = heavy, like muscle
Feathers = light, like fat.
1 pound of anything weighs the same as 1 pound of anything else. But we still compare the weight mass of materials. I do wonder why? Hmm

Crystal90567 · 23/10/2021 14:56

Ffs @Dolly That is extreme.
@shouldistop To whom do you refer?

JSL52 · 23/10/2021 14:55

@merryhouse @Vieve1325 is right.
A ton of feathers weighs the same as a ton of lead.

Lostmarbles2021 · 23/10/2021 14:55

Kids often ‘go out’ before they ‘go up’. You are doing all the right things for his health and wellbeing: creating fun opportunities for activity, eating food that’s as nutritious as possible given restrictions and keeping a gentle parental eye on it without making it a big deal for him. Gold standard!

If you want him to eat more fruit and veg it can be helpful to have it easily accessible and let kids (especially those with sensory issues) just play with it and get used to it first.

Modelling a healthy relationship to food is also key and despite your own issues you are doing your best with that. There might be more scope to change there but only you will know that for sure.

I think the chances are he will shoot up soon.

JSL52 · 23/10/2021 14:53

@sueelleker

Muscle weighs more than fat, so he may be slimmer and still weigh more.
Not true. A pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat.
JSL52 · 23/10/2021 14:52

@XelaM

Muscles weigh more than fat. Maybe he's building muscles?
They don't.
shouldistop · 23/10/2021 14:52

@chesterelly what did you check? Nhs says that's 93rd centile, above 90th is overweight.

DollyDinkle · 23/10/2021 14:49

My son, at 5, was going on 12 mile bike rides. 2 miles is not enough to burn calories

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 23/10/2021 14:47

He'll shoot up and balance out. Boys especially seem to eat and eat and then grow like a weed.

lljkk · 23/10/2021 14:43

Muscle is barely heavier than fat & the amount of muscle the child could have converted from fat to muscle in 3.5 weeks just from a little cycling is miniscule, won't account for 5 lbs.

Also, ppl over-estimate how far & how much work kids do on a bike. if OP puts an activity tracker on the lad, the activity won't be that huge. 2 miles is 10 minute ride on most bikes, maybe 15-25 minutes off road &/or terrible bike.

I'm voting dodgy scales -- sorry.
It's great that the lad enjoys cycling, being outdoors & something to do with his dad. WinWin.

LetHimHaveIt · 23/10/2021 14:38

You're confusing the OP with me, I think.

My son is 14 and a half. Sorry; should've said that. He is emphatically underweight, and looks it. He's got virtually no interest in food, which doesn't help. I'm taking him to the GP when I get can an appointment in about 2024.

merryhouse · 23/10/2021 14:28

@Vieve1325

Just coming here to correct one thing - muscle does not weigh more than fat. Muscle is DENSER than fat.

1lb of muscle and 1lb of fat weigh the same.

1cm2 of muscle will be heavier than 1cm2 of fat. That's how it works.

oh ffs

1cc of muscle will be heavier than 1cc of fat. That's how it works. Yes! Muscle is heavier than fat. That's what people mean.

Would you go round telling us that lead does not weigh more than feathers?

Crystal90567 · 23/10/2021 14:08

Op you are wrong.
At age 15yo, 7stone 12 and 5'11 is very underweight 1%
At age 13yo, 7 stone 12 and 5'11 is underweight
At 11 it's just in lower end of normal bmi but 11yos dont tend to be 5'11.

Crystal90567 · 23/10/2021 14:02

7st 12 is very underweight for a 5ft11 male, but its allowable as he's a child so yet to broaden out. I'd say 7st12 is still quite a low weight for anyone 5ft 11. Must be quite skinny.
Depends on age a bit but 5'11 I'd guess 15yo?

Artie30 · 23/10/2021 13:50

@LetHimHaveIt

My 5 ft 11 son weighs 7 st 12 :( which I am worried about. Your kid sounds fine. It seems curious that you're almost drawing a veil over those posters pointing out that he's not overweight according to any known measure.
I put his weight into nhs bmi calculator and it said he is overweight so I went by that!
OP posts:
Artie30 · 23/10/2021 13:49

Quality of sleep is okay. Takes a while to go sleep but will sleep all night once asleep.

OP posts:
Artie30 · 23/10/2021 13:48

@MacMahon

I'm the first to admit that Ds'a diet is rubbish

Well, surely that's going to be the biggest health concern? A 2 mile bike ride isn't a big deal fitness-wise (I hear what you're saying re. hypermobility). There's no need for any of us to be eating crisps or chocolate every week.

What's the quality of his sleep like?

He has autism. It's not his or my fault. It's not a terrible diet, just very selective and unvaried. He doesn't eat chocolate and crisps all the time, I just said he likes them.
OP posts:
MacMahon · 23/10/2021 13:44

I'm the first to admit that Ds'a diet is rubbish

Well, surely that's going to be the biggest health concern? A 2 mile bike ride isn't a big deal fitness-wise (I hear what you're saying re. hypermobility). There's no need for any of us to be eating crisps or chocolate every week.

What's the quality of his sleep like?

Crystal90567 · 23/10/2021 13:43

These men are 16 stone + and professional sportsmen at the top of their game.

My point is you cant weigh boys by the same scales/rules, as its different for men and mums of boys should be aware of that, esp age 10 -18.

Child's gained weight with daily exercising
Vieve1325 · 23/10/2021 13:38

Just coming here to correct one thing - muscle does not weigh more than fat. Muscle is DENSER than fat.

1lb of muscle and 1lb of fat weigh the same.

1cm2 of muscle will be heavier than 1cm2 of fat. That's how it works.

Crystal90567 · 23/10/2021 13:31

The Rock weighs 20 stone.

Big muscle bound men weigh quite a lot. Its nothing like the usual weight scales youd think.

My son is 12yo old and 9stone but fit as a fiddle and a rugby player. I'll find a stock image of a catalogue model type kid like him.