Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend forward facing her 9 month old

264 replies

JimHairy · 23/10/2021 09:01

My friend has a 9 month old DS who she has started front facing in the car. She has a Cosatto rotating car seat and her reasoning is that her son sometimes gets upset when rear facing and is a lot happier when facing forward. This is true, but from being in the car with him previously he’s not that bad in rear facing, just gets a bit frustrated and wriggly but he does settle after about 10 minutes.

She’s a great parent and also has a 7 year old. I’m a FTM so I feel really awkward giving her advice but it’s really really worrying me that her DS is unsafe in the car. This is compounded by a local incident that happened a few years ago where a child died in a head on collision due to an improperly fitted car seat. This is always in my mind.

So far, I’ve sent her the government advice sheet about car seat safety that says to rear face as long as possible and at least until 15 months but she just said that her car seat says it’s ok forward facing babies from 9 months. I didn’t argue, just said I’d seen that it wasn’t advised to forward face so early.

I feel I’ve done what I can by sending her the information and she’s now making an informed decision to forward face, even though it’s clearly very wrong. The other problem (although less so) is that she keeps telling me I should forward face my DS who’s the same age because he hates the car. I’ve said I’d rather he was safe and temporarily unhappy, but she argues that it’s cruel to make him so unhappy even for short periods and the chances of an accident are really low. I won’t be forward facing my DS and he’ll be rear facing as long as possible.

WWYD? Do I keep sending her info or just leave it now?

OP posts:
Glitterybug · 23/10/2021 11:57

It's none of your bloody business. Why do people feel the need to police other people's choices?

You're not much of a friend are you. Massively overstepping the line to send her material to read. Butt out and stop trying to "educate her" when she's made the best choice for her family.

DeclineandFall · 23/10/2021 11:56

I found lots of people thought front facing their kid in a car seat was some sort of developmental milestone, like weaning, walking etc that should happen asap.
I RF DS until he was 4 and got lots of comments about him being uncomfortable, being bored, getting sick etc. He is a tall child.
My answer was always that it was demonstrably far safer and that car accidents were something that most people have no control over and therefore I had to do what I thought was safest. They just wanted to justify their own decisions by criticising mine. There are some occasions where it's not practical but that doesn't make it any safer.
This thread backs that up really. You can't win this argument OP so you're just going to have to let it go and tell her its not up for discussion if she starts.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/10/2021 11:55

Isn’t it usually by weight rather than age? Our grandson’s seats are.

SunnyMustard · 23/10/2021 11:53

Maybe a car mirror would be an option though for keeping rear facing seats longer and keep the kid happy? If you have a constantly screaming baby this is also dangerous to driving. Might distract the parent in a crucial situation.

SunnyMustard · 23/10/2021 11:51

You know, after reading some of your follow up comments I feel that you and your friend have a very frank and healthy friendship and feel comfortable enough to comment on differences in choices/parenting styles. Seems like there are many cases where one of you comment but in the end you may decide to do stick to your original style. Maybe sometimes you will inspire one another to adjust your styles. Value this friendship. You care enough to comment where many people are too shy to and let their friends self destruct in various ways. However, you've now said your piece and its up to your friend.

SylvanasWindrunner · 23/10/2021 11:48

ERF seats go up to 25kg, but if you have a child right at the top of the weight centile then you won't be able to get to 8 as they'll hit the weight limit earlier. The spin/360 seats go up to 18kg.

Britax Maxway Plus or the Axkid Minikid are two of the most popular 25kg ERF seats.

Jessica60 · 23/10/2021 11:45

What car seat do you use when they get to 4? I am looking for a new car seat, have been rear facing but now getting too small

Rainbowsandstorms · 23/10/2021 11:44

You’ve done what you can. I would always share the risk with a close friend so they can make their own assessment. I remember telling a friend how children shouldn’t wear padded winter coats in car seats due to the risk of them sliding through the straps in an accident and she was really grateful as she hadn’t realised but I wouldn’t have said anything further if she’d continued to do it.
Once you’ve mentioned something to inform a friend of a risk I wouldn’t then revisit it, as ultimately it’s your friend’s risk to assess and you risk damaging your friendship. Everyone perceives risk differently. I’ve rear faced my children until they are much older but it is only a recent development in car seats so although it’s a risk it’s not a huge one.

KatieKoala · 23/10/2021 11:44

Also @PamsSpam, I know you were getting angry with me and it wasn't particularly from a supportive place that you posted, but I do feel weirdly validated by your outrage! I was outraged too, but made to feel like I was being overly critical. She's super prim and proper as well and I'm...not! So I definitely felt as if she must know the sensible thing to do.

SylvanasWindrunner · 23/10/2021 11:39

It's difficult, OP, but I think that if she cared enough about it she would do her own research. It's obviously just not important to her. Not something I understand but then she's not me.

As for the 'only on MN' thing, everyone I know who has a child DD's age (2.5) is still rear facing them. Perhaps it's just a demograph thing - we are older parents, and most of my friends are also older parents and professionals who are very big on researching purchases, so they all know how much safer it is.

KatieKoala · 23/10/2021 11:34

You know your sister in law leaves her children alone at home and goes out for the night and you haven’t said anything? To her or social services? How old are these children? Seriously, this is not the same thing and this should be dealt with?!

I know, it really was awful looking back! Bizarrely, it is not an offence to give children over 5 alcohol (or wasn't when she did it), so wouldn't get anywhere there. The going out thing was horrible. Even then, when I was quite young and didn't have dcs etc, I thought that was fucked up, but honestly everyone in the family knew about it and thought it was totally normal because she'd given the monitor to a neighbour Confused

I actually don't even let them watch my kids now we have them.

The kids are all older now. This was when I was in my early twenties, so 15ish years ago.

PamsSpam · 23/10/2021 11:26

@KatieKoala

You are lovely to care so much. Yes, she's technically breaking the law and we all know rear facing is safer. But....how involved can anyone really get in their friends' parenting decisions.

I know people cough...SIL who do things like give their small children wine to get them used to it, leave their babies at home with the baby monitor on and just give the other end to a neighbour so they can go out for dinner and so on.

Not things I would do, but not really my business.

I think I would point it out once and leave it. It is a bit tricky though, when a friend's choices with their dcs are really different to your own. But that's life really!

Sorry, what the hell @KatieKoala?

You know your sister in law leaves her children alone at home and goes out for the night and you haven’t said anything? To her or social services? How old are these children? Seriously, this is not the same thing and this should be dealt with?!

ChloeCrocodile · 23/10/2021 11:26

Honestly, OP, you’re getting a hard time on here. There is nothing at all wrong with having a friendship where you can actually be honest rather than constantly worrying if you’re going to offend. In fact, I’d say it is a good thing!

On the car seat thing - I 100% agree with the pp who said about distractions being a much bigger risk. If your friend would be worried about her baby while driving that is a distraction in itself, even if the baby isn’t crying.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 23/10/2021 11:21

@TheOrigRights

How far do you prioritise safety? You know that safest is not to have your child in the car at all. How would you feel if I approached you and suggested you didn't make that car trip to soft play or wherever, accompanied with video footage of RTAs?

She has made her informed decision and you make yours.

Except friend isn't accepting OP's decision and wants her to change hers.
AutumnLeafy · 23/10/2021 11:15

You've done what you can. If she brings it up again just say you're not discussing it anymore as you both disagree.

KatieKoala · 23/10/2021 11:14

@BertieBotts

of all the babies wo tragically die in RTAs in the UK, how many were as a direct result of them being forward facing? It isn't as if forward facing = instant death is it?

We do actually have a rough idea of this from accident studies, unfortunately. The figures show that around 75% of children who die in forward facing seats would have been able to survive had they been rear facing, as their injuries were to the neck or spinal cord with no head injury. This is consistent across various studies. In the other 25% of cases the accident was so severe/there was intrusion into the car that would have resulted in the same outcome no matter what seat was used. But fatal accidents with children in rear facing seats only tend to occur when there is some kind of impact from another passenger/luggage in the car, when there is fire or submersion in water, when the car is basically crushed, or when the seat is wrongly installed (wrong belt routing/use with airbag).

If you have 10 theoretical children in an accident severe enough to result in at least one fatality, and they are all in forward facing seats, statistically 6 of them will survive.
If they are all in rear facing seats, statistically 9 will survive.
Completely unrestrained only 2 survive - we've come a long way.

Some studies are up to 2 years and others up to 4 but the results are fairly consistent.

Forward facing is definitely not instant death and is a significant improvement over no restraint, or an ill-fitting seatbelt. Rear facing is better still. It's the car travel which is the risk though, not forward facing as such.

I don't think people should be wasting energy worrying about other people's children who are in perfectly legal and safe seats, but there is no sense in making out that rear facing doesn't make a difference because it does. It's for individual parents to make the choice for their own family though. I don't like this whole car seat police thing that gets frothed up by FB groups and the like. Make the choice for your own children and let other people make a choice for theirs unless your opinion is actually asked for (or maybe if you see something that is clearly wrong but can be easily fixed).

That's me you're quoting. As I said, mine rear faced till just shy of 4yo. Just turned ds recently and he will be 4 soon. I know it makes a difference, but the post you're quoting from was in response to another post which had questioned why we don't interfere with other parents' choices more, because "those babies are people who deserve protection" and "why do we take a 'your kid your problem' approach?", "I'd rather lose a friendship than let a baby die in a RTA" (paraphrasing a little as I'm on my phone, so not going back to quote, sorry).

I wasn't saying there is no difference between rear facing and forward facing, but I was questioning how far that person would go to protect children unrelated to her from all potential threat, since she took issue with the general consensus which is the same as yours; she's wrong, but it is not really your business.

Shmithecat2 · 23/10/2021 11:13

@toastofthetown

I don't think there's another option than to leave it. If it's an older style seat where forward facing is allowed from nine months then she's not breaking the law even if it's not the safest choice. On the same note though, she should stop commenting on your choice to keep your son rear facing. And if she keeps bringing it up then you wouldn't be wrong to tell her why you make the choice you did.

You do sound judgemental about her choices in general though (weaning, car seat, jumper). Maybe she feels that and that's why she's attacking your choices.

No, with the older reg (R44) seats, they can forward face a 9kg, not 9 months.
DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 23/10/2021 11:12

@TheOrigRights

How far do you prioritise safety? You know that safest is not to have your child in the car at all. How would you feel if I approached you and suggested you didn't make that car trip to soft play or wherever, accompanied with video footage of RTAs?

She has made her informed decision and you make yours.

Giving a friend advice or not aside it is an informed decision to keep a 9 month old rear facing as extensive impartial technical research has shown. Putting them forward facing is a combination of factors relevant to an individual’s circumstances : which are mostly not coming from an informed stance but rather preference and necessity. That is not a criticism but an observation and a there is a difference between the two scenarios.
JimHairy · 23/10/2021 11:12

@BertieBotts

of all the babies wo tragically die in RTAs in the UK, how many were as a direct result of them being forward facing? It isn't as if forward facing = instant death is it?

We do actually have a rough idea of this from accident studies, unfortunately. The figures show that around 75% of children who die in forward facing seats would have been able to survive had they been rear facing, as their injuries were to the neck or spinal cord with no head injury. This is consistent across various studies. In the other 25% of cases the accident was so severe/there was intrusion into the car that would have resulted in the same outcome no matter what seat was used. But fatal accidents with children in rear facing seats only tend to occur when there is some kind of impact from another passenger/luggage in the car, when there is fire or submersion in water, when the car is basically crushed, or when the seat is wrongly installed (wrong belt routing/use with airbag).

If you have 10 theoretical children in an accident severe enough to result in at least one fatality, and they are all in forward facing seats, statistically 6 of them will survive.
If they are all in rear facing seats, statistically 9 will survive.
Completely unrestrained only 2 survive - we've come a long way.

Some studies are up to 2 years and others up to 4 but the results are fairly consistent.

Forward facing is definitely not instant death and is a significant improvement over no restraint, or an ill-fitting seatbelt. Rear facing is better still. It's the car travel which is the risk though, not forward facing as such.

I don't think people should be wasting energy worrying about other people's children who are in perfectly legal and safe seats, but there is no sense in making out that rear facing doesn't make a difference because it does. It's for individual parents to make the choice for their own family though. I don't like this whole car seat police thing that gets frothed up by FB groups and the like. Make the choice for your own children and let other people make a choice for theirs unless your opinion is actually asked for (or maybe if you see something that is clearly wrong but can be easily fixed).

That’s brilliant information, thank you.
OP posts:
KatieKoala · 23/10/2021 11:08

@olidora63 I know! They're all older now, and lived to tell the tale. I didn't have dcs myself when she did it with hers and she's a really sensible, professional person with a very sensible job etc. As is her dh. Also I wasn't married to dh yet and was really young, so never had the confidence to say anything. But yes, now I've got dcs, I look back and think WTAF were they doing?? It wasn't decades ago either. Recent enough for it not to be the norm.

BertieBotts · 23/10/2021 11:08

of all the babies wo tragically die in RTAs in the UK, how many were as a direct result of them being forward facing? It isn't as if forward facing = instant death is it?

We do actually have a rough idea of this from accident studies, unfortunately. The figures show that around 75% of children who die in forward facing seats would have been able to survive had they been rear facing, as their injuries were to the neck or spinal cord with no head injury. This is consistent across various studies. In the other 25% of cases the accident was so severe/there was intrusion into the car that would have resulted in the same outcome no matter what seat was used. But fatal accidents with children in rear facing seats only tend to occur when there is some kind of impact from another passenger/luggage in the car, when there is fire or submersion in water, when the car is basically crushed, or when the seat is wrongly installed (wrong belt routing/use with airbag).

If you have 10 theoretical children in an accident severe enough to result in at least one fatality, and they are all in forward facing seats, statistically 6 of them will survive.
If they are all in rear facing seats, statistically 9 will survive.
Completely unrestrained only 2 survive - we've come a long way.

Some studies are up to 2 years and others up to 4 but the results are fairly consistent.

Forward facing is definitely not instant death and is a significant improvement over no restraint, or an ill-fitting seatbelt. Rear facing is better still. It's the car travel which is the risk though, not forward facing as such.

I don't think people should be wasting energy worrying about other people's children who are in perfectly legal and safe seats, but there is no sense in making out that rear facing doesn't make a difference because it does. It's for individual parents to make the choice for their own family though. I don't like this whole car seat police thing that gets frothed up by FB groups and the like. Make the choice for your own children and let other people make a choice for theirs unless your opinion is actually asked for (or maybe if you see something that is clearly wrong but can be easily fixed).

JimHairy · 23/10/2021 11:08

@DebbieHarrysCheekbones

Why are so many of you so uptight about this? All she did was give CORRECT guidelines to a friend she loves and cares for. It was well intentioned. As an another adult it is the friend’s right to do as she wishes but there doesn’t need to be any friend dumping or going off the deep end about “butting out” and launching personal attacks on the OP

I am astounded at how defensive and aggressive so many of you are in your respective choices. Bar advice giving aside most people are too busy getting on with their own Ives to hand wring over your parenting. They’ve forgotten about it while you’re stewing away planning to discard them form your life because they’ve undermined or interfered or affronted you on something like a car seat or weaning etc. Bonkers.
It is also both amusing and slightly concerning that something such as a different view of car seats would leave you wanting to jettison a friendship. This cannot be how you behave in real life? Surely Grin

Exactly this. I think I just caught a few people on a bad morning and they fancied being awful to strangers on the Internet. Very little to do with my question and a lot to do with how they were feeling when they posted.
OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 23/10/2021 11:07

How far do you prioritise safety?
You know that safest is not to have your child in the car at all.
How would you feel if I approached you and suggested you didn't make that car trip to soft play or wherever, accompanied with video footage of RTAs?

She has made her informed decision and you make yours.

Branleuse · 23/10/2021 11:07

i forward faced mine quite early as they would scream the whole time or get travel sick. I cant do rear facing when im travelling either as it makes me travel sick even as an adult.
the advice about rear facing wasnt really around with ds1 though and still not a huge thing with the other kids. People would use high backed booster seats for babys that were old enough to sit unaided when ds1 was tiny.

I wonder if you could say to her something like "I just want to check that you have seen all the stuff about rear facing vs forward facing car seats as there are safety issues about forward facing, but if youve seen all this before making your choice then I wont say anything else

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 23/10/2021 11:07

@puddlebubble

You’d end a 15 year friendship, one where you were each other’s bridesmaids, see each other a few times a week and love each other dearly because your friend sent you a link to the government website after you gave her advice to do something she didn’t agree with? After you specifically asked her what was stopping her doing that thing?

Yes, absolutely none of your business what way she places her car seat. I guarantee you there is stuff you do with your child that she internally thinks, 'what is she doing?" but doesn't say it to you and certainly doesn't email you links. Quickest way to lose a friendship, who the heck do you think you are? I'd completely dump you as a friend and wonder how I ever got to know such a person.

Did you read the part where this friend sent info about contained baby syndrome in relation to bouncers to the OP?

You come across as disproportionately intense and demanding it must be hard work being in your inner circle. Off with their head! Grin