Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend forward facing her 9 month old

264 replies

JimHairy · 23/10/2021 09:01

My friend has a 9 month old DS who she has started front facing in the car. She has a Cosatto rotating car seat and her reasoning is that her son sometimes gets upset when rear facing and is a lot happier when facing forward. This is true, but from being in the car with him previously he’s not that bad in rear facing, just gets a bit frustrated and wriggly but he does settle after about 10 minutes.

She’s a great parent and also has a 7 year old. I’m a FTM so I feel really awkward giving her advice but it’s really really worrying me that her DS is unsafe in the car. This is compounded by a local incident that happened a few years ago where a child died in a head on collision due to an improperly fitted car seat. This is always in my mind.

So far, I’ve sent her the government advice sheet about car seat safety that says to rear face as long as possible and at least until 15 months but she just said that her car seat says it’s ok forward facing babies from 9 months. I didn’t argue, just said I’d seen that it wasn’t advised to forward face so early.

I feel I’ve done what I can by sending her the information and she’s now making an informed decision to forward face, even though it’s clearly very wrong. The other problem (although less so) is that she keeps telling me I should forward face my DS who’s the same age because he hates the car. I’ve said I’d rather he was safe and temporarily unhappy, but she argues that it’s cruel to make him so unhappy even for short periods and the chances of an accident are really low. I won’t be forward facing my DS and he’ll be rear facing as long as possible.

WWYD? Do I keep sending her info or just leave it now?

OP posts:
Iwonder08 · 23/10/2021 13:53

Wow.. You sent her the guidance as she is clearly not capable to make informed choices for her own child, is she..
I would be surprised if she still wants you to be her friend

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 13:52

@Sleeplessem

But the law says 15 months *@Frederica852*, whilst you may not know people who erf (which is a shame) it is inherently safer, especially with high impact collision
It's only 15 months for certain types of car seat, for others it's based on weight and therefore babies can legally FF before that.
SickAndTiredAgain · 23/10/2021 13:52

@Sleeplessem

But the law says 15 months *@Frederica852*, whilst you may not know people who erf (which is a shame) it is inherently safer, especially with high impact collision
The law doesn’t say 15 months. It says 15 months for height based seats. For weight based seats they can forward face earlier (from 9kg).

www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules

Sleeplessem · 23/10/2021 13:48

But the law says 15 months @Frederica852, whilst you may not know people who erf (which is a shame) it is inherently safer, especially with high impact collision

Skysblue · 23/10/2021 13:44

Mind your own business OP. Why on earth are you sending her info?! She’s done her research, made a decision she believes is best for her child, and she doesn’t need bossy supervision from you. All you are doing is annoying her and damaging the friendship.

As a sufferer of travel sickness, travelling backwards in a car is pure hell for me, and in forty years I’ve never been in a car accident. I feel so so sorry for the travel sick toddlers whose parents force them to face backwards as long as possible. For some it is fine, for others it is hell.

Frederica852 · 23/10/2021 13:39

@WaterBottle123

Read the chapter in freakonomics about the minimal difference made by car seats vs. people's behaviour on the road and leave your poor friend alone.
This.

Mumsnet is the only place I've ever heard of people rear facing their kids beyond a year old. I changed mine at around 1 year as did everyone else I know

Onairjunkie · 23/10/2021 13:35

She used to send me car seat ratings from some German site that she used to translate in Google as she said their testing is more rigorous or something? No idea.

She also said she couldn’t believe I hadn’t sold my beloved fast car to buy something slower and family-safe and was horrified that I put my kid’s car seat in it on occasion. I pointed out that a car’s ability to go fast is entirely in the hands (or feet) of the driver. Looking back, I suspect she had some sort of postnatal anxiety but I didn’t need her projecting that onto me, especially as she wasn’t particularly kind with it.

Sleeplessem · 23/10/2021 13:34

Well I understand why you’d want to say something and keep on saying something as it could really be life and death but should you? Probably not. You’ve passed on the information you know and the evidence which is the best you can do.

Cosatto seats are all style over substance anyway and not particularly safe. Better than the harmony/ team x ones but still largely crap.

OP saw you wanted to rear face with a high centile child under 4 at least, there are some good belted erf seats on the market, check out axikid they go up to 25kg, normally quite pricey but I think I saw a good deal somewhere! There’s some good Fb groups to join thay are very knowledgeable on car seat safety.

We got a joie spin safe which will last us a while for dd and shes lower centile wise, that’s another good choice for anyone looking to erf

SickAndTiredAgain · 23/10/2021 13:33

@BigWoollyJumpers

Can I ask an honest question, as things have changed a lot since my DD's were young.

We used to have three/four DC's back for play and tea after school from about 5 or 6. They all just sat in the back of the car with seatbelts. Does this not happen any more then? How do you get multiple children back for play? You can't get three/four car seats in a standard car.

Children under 12 or under 135cm if that comes first must have a car seat. That’s the current law.

There are exceptions - if the journey is short, unexpected and necessary then that’s ok. Or where there is no room for another child seat (say you have two in the back already) then a child over three can sit in the back with just a regular seatbelt. So you could use that exception I guess, if parents are happy with it and you have two other car seats in use in the car.

rooarsome · 23/10/2021 13:30

OP, you will never change anyone's mind by telling them they have to do x y z and sending leaflets. Look at Miller and Rollnick's research. People do not respond well when told explicitly what to do or what is best.

Onairjunkie · 23/10/2021 13:30

I had a formerly good friend who used to really seem to fret about my parenting. There were so many gasps and raised eyebrows, I used to find it hilarious. She was very easy to wind up.

Anyway, before anyone imagines me letting my child hang from the guttering over a pit of broken glass, it would be over tiny things like giving him a pillow and duvet from one, giving him a metal knife and fork to eat, letting him fall over or try a big slide etc. really minor things.

Anyway, her constant judgement started to wear really thin and now I don’t see her. It was exhausting and she was so superior.

Don’t be that friend. These are not your decisions to make. And if you’re so traumatised by her having a front facing seat then do her a favour and stand back.

Bunnycat101 · 23/10/2021 13:23

DebbieHarrysCheekbones I should have said eldest hit 18kg at 3 so we then bought the 25kg seat. She was fine in it for weight but did reach a point that it became uncomfortable for her legs. I suspect my youngest will never need the bigger seat as she is tiny in comparison.

Tiredalwaystired · 23/10/2021 13:23

@BigWoollyJumpers

Can I ask an honest question, as things have changed a lot since my DD's were young.

We used to have three/four DC's back for play and tea after school from about 5 or 6. They all just sat in the back of the car with seatbelts. Does this not happen any more then? How do you get multiple children back for play? You can't get three/four car seats in a standard car.

This is why seven seater cars are now a thing.
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 23/10/2021 13:20

@Glitterybug

It's none of your bloody business. Why do people feel the need to police other people's choices?

You're not much of a friend are you. Massively overstepping the line to send her material to read. Butt out and stop trying to "educate her" when she's made the best choice for her family.

The friend keeps asking OP to change her choice and calling it cruel. How is OP the bad friend?
BigWoollyJumpers · 23/10/2021 13:16

Can I ask an honest question, as things have changed a lot since my DD's were young.

We used to have three/four DC's back for play and tea after school from about 5 or 6. They all just sat in the back of the car with seatbelts. Does this not happen any more then? How do you get multiple children back for play? You can't get three/four car seats in a standard car.

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 23/10/2021 13:03

@Bunnycat101

Car seat discussions often seem to be a bit fraught. It is quite clear that rear facing is safer but whether for cultural or just educational reasons it seems to wind people up. You don’t seem to get the same push back for cutting up grapes or other safety things. That said though, some people push it too far and see things black and white. If a child is vomiting/screaming etc when rear facing they are likely to be more of a distraction and presenting more risk.

For what it’s worth, my first rear faced until 41/2 before she outgrew her extended rear facing seat. She is on the 91st centile so will be taller than the vast majority. Youngest is much shorter and will probably manage in her 18kg seat until 4.

Weight is the most criteria for car seat having being outgrown as opposed to whether a child is short or not My almost four year old was on the 99th centile for height but much lower for weight and consequently was able to stay in his rear facing car eat (up to 18kg) for longer than my friends child who is far shorter but was 18kg some six months earlier than him and couldn’t stay rear facing in the exact same car seat
WhateverIdo · 23/10/2021 13:02

@KatieKoala

You are lovely to care so much. Yes, she's technically breaking the law and we all know rear facing is safer. But....how involved can anyone really get in their friends' parenting decisions.

I know people cough...SIL who do things like give their small children wine to get them used to it, leave their babies at home with the baby monitor on and just give the other end to a neighbour so they can go out for dinner and so on.

Not things I would do, but not really my business.

I think I would point it out once and leave it. It is a bit tricky though, when a friend's choices with their dcs are really different to your own. But that's life really!

It's not illegal if she's using an old r44 type seat that forward faces from 9kg.

Let people do what they need to do. None of your business.

mumwon · 23/10/2021 12:44

slightly off topic but relevant
rear facing seats are safer full stop - for anyone
In RAF passenger planes the seats face backwards - for precisely that reason but because civilian paying for yourself passengers don't like traveling that way (some get travel sick) or you can't see out of the window or the cost (who knows?) seats on planes, buses & cars face forward (obviously in cars doing this might be impractical structurally & convenience wise!)

berlinbabylon · 23/10/2021 12:30

When my ds was small you turned them to a forward-facing seat at around 9 months. I think the keeping them rear facing for much longer is a very new thing isn't it?

The thing that has always surprised me is the fact that so many parents allow their quite small children to sit in the front seat of the car. My mother wouldn't let me sit in the front until I was about 12, and I was the same with ds.

SylvanasWindrunner · 23/10/2021 12:25

I think it tends to annoy some people who had children before it was a 'thing' because they think there's some sort of implicit criticism of their own parenting (the same way as the 'well I put my children to sleep on their front and they were all fine' brigade and the 'my Nan smoked 40 cigarettes every day and lived to 500' crew).

I just think some people are incapable of separating 'Now we know better so we can do better' from 'You didn't do this so you're a bad parent'. Even though research is always finding out new things, some are scathing of parents acting on it because they did XYZ with their own and believe that they did the best for their child, which they probably did with the knowledge we had at the time. In 10 years, some of the stuff I do with DD will probably no longer be judged as the safest option - that's just the way it goes. But I hope I won't be defensive about it because we can only operate on the information we have at the time.

That said, I don't understand anyone who has access to that updated information and chooses not to follow it, but then perhaps some of my parenting decisions are just as inexplicable to others. Just life, innit?

Bunnycat101 · 23/10/2021 12:16

Car seat discussions often seem to be a bit fraught. It is quite clear that rear facing is safer but whether for cultural or just educational reasons it seems to wind people up. You don’t seem to get the same push back for cutting up grapes or other safety things. That said though, some people push it too far and see things black and white. If a child is vomiting/screaming etc when rear facing they are likely to be more of a distraction and presenting more risk.

For what it’s worth, my first rear faced until 41/2 before she outgrew her extended rear facing seat. She is on the 91st centile so will be taller than the vast majority. Youngest is much shorter and will probably manage in her 18kg seat until 4.

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/10/2021 12:12

@DrCoconut

I would say that in general MN is against RF. It's odd, given the studies that support it, when on other threads people are berated for giving their child a penguin bar or something because it's putting their health at risk. Virtually everyone I know now with young children RF them. DS3 was about 5 1/2 when I stopped due to him getting too heavy for his seat. There was still plenty of room in it. Interestingly I have not commented on other people's choice of car seat but I've had people comment on mine.
My experience is exactly the opposite. I know precisely one family in real-life who have ERF despite being in an ‘older, professional’ demographic (to cite a pp).
SylvanasWindrunner · 23/10/2021 12:11

I think it is just demograph. MN will just have a higher proportion of people who use the internet to research and make decisions and who look at parenting advice and websites. People who aren't interested in that stuff just won't tend to use the site. And it's the same for certain friend circles IRL too. As I said, everyone I am friends with who has young children has rear faced them well into toddlerhood, but perhaps it's the echo chamber thing because we all have similar outlooks and approaches to researching information, etc.

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 12:07

@DrCoconut

I would say that in general MN is against RF. It's odd, given the studies that support it, when on other threads people are berated for giving their child a penguin bar or something because it's putting their health at risk. Virtually everyone I know now with young children RF them. DS3 was about 5 1/2 when I stopped due to him getting too heavy for his seat. There was still plenty of room in it. Interestingly I have not commented on other people's choice of car seat but I've had people comment on mine.
I would say it's 100% the opposite.

Everyone on MN appears to rear-face their seven year olds, but in reality I don't know anyone who rear-faces beyond 6-9 months of age, let alone well into primary school.

DrCoconut · 23/10/2021 12:04

I would say that in general MN is against RF. It's odd, given the studies that support it, when on other threads people are berated for giving their child a penguin bar or something because it's putting their health at risk. Virtually everyone I know now with young children RF them. DS3 was about 5 1/2 when I stopped due to him getting too heavy for his seat. There was still plenty of room in it. Interestingly I have not commented on other people's choice of car seat but I've had people comment on mine.