Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend forward facing her 9 month old

264 replies

JimHairy · 23/10/2021 09:01

My friend has a 9 month old DS who she has started front facing in the car. She has a Cosatto rotating car seat and her reasoning is that her son sometimes gets upset when rear facing and is a lot happier when facing forward. This is true, but from being in the car with him previously he’s not that bad in rear facing, just gets a bit frustrated and wriggly but he does settle after about 10 minutes.

She’s a great parent and also has a 7 year old. I’m a FTM so I feel really awkward giving her advice but it’s really really worrying me that her DS is unsafe in the car. This is compounded by a local incident that happened a few years ago where a child died in a head on collision due to an improperly fitted car seat. This is always in my mind.

So far, I’ve sent her the government advice sheet about car seat safety that says to rear face as long as possible and at least until 15 months but she just said that her car seat says it’s ok forward facing babies from 9 months. I didn’t argue, just said I’d seen that it wasn’t advised to forward face so early.

I feel I’ve done what I can by sending her the information and she’s now making an informed decision to forward face, even though it’s clearly very wrong. The other problem (although less so) is that she keeps telling me I should forward face my DS who’s the same age because he hates the car. I’ve said I’d rather he was safe and temporarily unhappy, but she argues that it’s cruel to make him so unhappy even for short periods and the chances of an accident are really low. I won’t be forward facing my DS and he’ll be rear facing as long as possible.

WWYD? Do I keep sending her info or just leave it now?

OP posts:
rainbowdashsneeze · 23/10/2021 15:58

*sit

rainbowdashsneeze · 23/10/2021 15:57

@CautiousOptimist11

They have this bit in the middle called knees, that bend.

Haven't you seen the positions kids can happily sit in? They aren't adults.

Its often far more comfortable to cross their legs than to hang forward dangling in the air

You really have your children say with their knees bent on long journeys in the car? I certainly do not advocate babies sitting in a front facing car seat but a 4 year!! Sounds totally ridiculous to me having a 4 year old sat in a car with bent knees!! Mumsnet gets crazier by the day.
Graphista · 23/10/2021 15:40

I just quickly looked up the law on this. Apparently he needs to weigh at least 9kg to be forward facing, but I personally think in light of the increased knowledge and suitable car seats we have now the law needs to be updated

But unfortunately if she's within the law there's little you can do

Just because she's a second time mum doesn't mean she knows better

My dd is 20 and was forward facing from a very young age as that was what happened then, but knowledge, advice, equipment and laws change over time. By the time my siblings kids were born several years later it was all very different

CautiousOptimist11 · 23/10/2021 15:36

They have this bit in the middle called knees, that bend.

Haven't you seen the positions kids can happily sit in? They aren't adults.

Its often far more comfortable to cross their legs than to hang forward dangling in the air

rainbowdashsneeze · 23/10/2021 15:32

@Applesandpears23

I think the info on this has really changed lately. We turned my 7 year old quite early whereas my 4 year old is still rear facing. Like all things in parenting, the more you learn the better you do. However it sounds like she has dug in now so I wouldn’t send any more info and would just drop it.
What on earth do you do with your 4 year old legs?? My children was turned forward at around 1 as their legs were too long.
saraclara · 23/10/2021 15:30

One day you're going to be the MIL from hell, OP. If you're pestering a friend with unsolicited advice about her child and not taking her no for an answer, what on earth will you be like when it's your grandchild you're worrying about?

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 15:11

If we assume there's an even spread of serious injury in each group/ year.

500/15 = 33 kids/ age group and rear facing extends from 6m to 4 years = 115 severe injuries in this age group. 75% of 115 is 86 ish.

So, 86 is serious injuries could be reduced if 75% is accurate and everyone used rear facing car seats.

And I can't find any research that suggests a reduction of risk that looks anything like 75% but happy to look at any links.

Honestly, if we gave a damn about kids as a population, we should legislate to get rid of those godawful laundry pods before we hen peck parents into buying expensive rear facing car seats.

Rosesareyellow · 23/10/2021 15:05

If her friend went a step further and, for example, wasn’t even strapping her child in, would OP then be advised here to do more?

Well obviously. I’m sure she’d also do more if she was happily letting her child play with a razor but it’s irrelevant because neither of those things are comparable to using an approved car seat correctly Hmm

SproutPenguin · 23/10/2021 15:00

It’s interesting to think about drawing a line between knowing better / offering advice / “interfering”, and minding own business / protecting friendship / letting people make their own mistakes.

In this case, if (god forbid) the child got seriously hurt in an accident, would OP feel culpable? Would she actually be culpable?

If her friend went a step further and, for example, wasn’t even strapping her child in, would OP then be advised here to do more?

I generally subscribe to the minding ones own business when it comes to parenting, but there must be some things that call for action and “interference”

headintheproverbial · 23/10/2021 14:53

I agree with PP that this is all relatively new advice. My 8 year old for example was rear facing only until he moved from baby seat to toddler seat size then was front facing, so from about 9 months. It was 100% the done thing and quite hippy dippy to do rear facing after this age.

CautiousOptimist11 · 23/10/2021 14:47

I agree but you can't interfere any more, you have said your bit.

We have a friend who is the biggest worrier you can imagine, she is obsessed with not medicating with even calpol, wouldn't touch herbal teas during pregnancy, freaks if she walks past a stationary car with pram (fumes), everything consumed is organic,vaccines agonized over etc etc... and yet turned her petite 12 month old to be forward facing. Its bizarre how people cant grasp the concept of relative risk. Take calpol, maybe...I dont know, have to metabolise it with your liver. Crash FF.... internal decapitation possible. How is one a worry and the other not???!

I honestly think people don't know how much safer it is, or the chances they will be in a crash (vs other perceived very unlikely and mon catastrophic risks). There also seems to be a culture around FF as a rite of passage along with weaning, walking etc. Plus older generations cannot grasp how it isn't cruel on kids who have to bend their knees.

Our tall 4 y old is happily in rear facing. He even went FF over the summer for a couple of short journeys in a very quiet safe country abroad (weighing the risks up here) and upon return, gladly went back to RF without question.

Sleeplessem · 23/10/2021 14:39

To be honest @SickAndTiredAgain there’s a huge contradiction there legally as I’ve known kids be 9kg at 7 months and 15 months is quite arbitrary because a 15 month old boy on the 91st centile is going to be a considerable amount larger than a 15 month old girl on the 2nd. I’ve not seen a car seat with an exclusive weight measure either, perhaps that’s just infant car seats that come in a travel system? I don’t know

At mamas and papas (although don’t recommend getting a seat from there) we were told 15 months legally have to rf until. Was also the same info presented at police ran infant first aid demo at a fayre we went to- figure if the police say it then that’s what I’ll go by

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 14:31

It's far, far fewer than that, 16, 17 and 18 year olds make up the greatest number of car occupant deaths, see link above. Just 9 children between 0 and 15.

Just shy of 500 severe injuries so a bigger sample to see the benefits of rear facing.

But again, no breakdown of age groups between 0-15. Does anyone know where this information would be?

Opalfeet · 23/10/2021 14:28

Rear facing carseats do significantly decrease the risk of severe injuries, possibly not deaths

AliceinBorderland · 23/10/2021 14:27

I have this issue with my sisters children. One of them won't leave her feet on the ground. She puts them against the back of the seat in front and in some cases sits in a V shape and puts her feet almost up on the head rest.

It stresses me out when I'm in the car. I've actually said to the child (as old enough to understand) if a car crashes into the back of us it will break your legs and possibly worse.

Every few minutes she did it again. I would say, feet on the floor and she'd do it and then just do it again.

At the end of the day of her mum won't make her do it the that's her choice. I'd honestly pull the car over and refuse to move until she put her feet down. A woman suffered life changing injuries after having her feet on the dash board instead of on the floor and I'm always reminded of that.

There isn't a lot you can do.

Opalfeet · 23/10/2021 14:27

There's 1700 0-17 year olds seriously injured in car accidents a year so a conservative estimate is what about 250 under 3s. The risk is fairly low, I'm not saying there's no risk

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 14:20

Absolutely, but the question link pertains to mortality.

If everyone used rear facing car seat would we save one solitary baby from a car death a year, or would we need to wait two?

SickAndTiredAgain · 23/10/2021 14:18

@FourTeaFallOut

of all the babies wo tragically die in RTAs in the UK, how many were as a direct result of them being forward facing? It isn't as if forward facing = instant death is it?

In 2018, 9 children between 0-15 died as an 'occupant in a car crash'. I can't see how many of these children were babies/toddlers specifically but I am interested to know what the 75% reduction in morality as a result of a forward facing car seat looks like on a sample size like that?

I’m not sure about all the stats, but it’s not just fatalities. There’s a significant reduction in risk of severe injury as well.
SickAndTiredAgain · 23/10/2021 14:14

@Sleeplessem

Regardless most seats have a height and weight max on them. The cosatto one thay OPs friend has also says rf until 15 months. Just because it’s legal doesn’t make it safe, look at those seats from harmony that literally break in a 30 mph collision, they’re legal but clearly v unsafe. RF is still safer though 🤷‍♀️ A heck of a lot safer no less.

Not sure why people are going in on the OP, sometimes you just don’t know until someone tells you! I’d much rather have someone say, that car seat isn’t the best one you can get for your money for xyz, it could literally save a child’s life

I agree with you. My 2yr old rear faces and on any issue, if a friend had a genuine concern I was doing something unsafe I’d always rather they mention it to me, in case I actually didn’t know. I wouldn’t want them going on about it, but wouldn’t have any issue with a single comment, and then I’d go away and look into it if I hadn’t already.

I was just pointing out you were wrong on the law. I don’t know the reasoning behind the law, are weight based seats safer in some way, so it’s seen ok to have the law give a difference (which could be fairly large depending on the size of the child) in when a child can forward face?

LagunaBubbles · 23/10/2021 14:11

just wondered if I was being selfish to prioritise my friendship over her Ds’s safety? I’m probably over thinking!

I know you mean well and tne friendship means a lot to you but her child's safety is not you worry, it's hers. She's got all the necessary information and is making her choice.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 14:09

of all the babies wo tragically die in RTAs in the UK, how many were as a direct result of them being forward facing? It isn't as if forward facing = instant death is it?

In 2018, 9 children between 0-15 died as an 'occupant in a car crash'. I can't see how many of these children were babies/toddlers specifically but I am interested to know what the 75% reduction in morality as a result of a forward facing car seat looks like on a sample size like that?

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 23/10/2021 14:08

@Iwonder08

Wow.. You sent her the guidance as she is clearly not capable to make informed choices for her own child, is she.. I would be surprised if she still wants you to be her friend
She send her the guidance because her friend is calling OP's choice cruel.
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 23/10/2021 14:07

Really wish posters would actually read the OP and thread instead of repeating the same old mind your own business. And not one of them came back to apologise once it was made obvious to them that the friend started the judgement and conversations.

Sleeplessem · 23/10/2021 14:05

Regardless most seats have a height and weight max on them. The cosatto one thay OPs friend has also says rf until 15 months. Just because it’s legal doesn’t make it safe, look at those seats from harmony that literally break in a 30 mph collision, they’re legal but clearly v unsafe. RF is still safer though 🤷‍♀️ A heck of a lot safer no less.

Not sure why people are going in on the OP, sometimes you just don’t know until someone tells you! I’d much rather have someone say, that car seat isn’t the best one you can get for your money for xyz, it could literally save a child’s life