Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend forward facing her 9 month old

264 replies

JimHairy · 23/10/2021 09:01

My friend has a 9 month old DS who she has started front facing in the car. She has a Cosatto rotating car seat and her reasoning is that her son sometimes gets upset when rear facing and is a lot happier when facing forward. This is true, but from being in the car with him previously he’s not that bad in rear facing, just gets a bit frustrated and wriggly but he does settle after about 10 minutes.

She’s a great parent and also has a 7 year old. I’m a FTM so I feel really awkward giving her advice but it’s really really worrying me that her DS is unsafe in the car. This is compounded by a local incident that happened a few years ago where a child died in a head on collision due to an improperly fitted car seat. This is always in my mind.

So far, I’ve sent her the government advice sheet about car seat safety that says to rear face as long as possible and at least until 15 months but she just said that her car seat says it’s ok forward facing babies from 9 months. I didn’t argue, just said I’d seen that it wasn’t advised to forward face so early.

I feel I’ve done what I can by sending her the information and she’s now making an informed decision to forward face, even though it’s clearly very wrong. The other problem (although less so) is that she keeps telling me I should forward face my DS who’s the same age because he hates the car. I’ve said I’d rather he was safe and temporarily unhappy, but she argues that it’s cruel to make him so unhappy even for short periods and the chances of an accident are really low. I won’t be forward facing my DS and he’ll be rear facing as long as possible.

WWYD? Do I keep sending her info or just leave it now?

OP posts:
HalzTangz · 23/10/2021 18:13

Government advice, is just that advice, not law or regulation. As long as her seat is properly fitted and secured (which I'm sure it is) then the decision is hers to make

MindatWork · 23/10/2021 18:10

Ffs I’m Hmm at the number of posters who’ve not read the op properly.

OP hasn’t ‘interfered’ with her friend. Her friend is the one who was just about her choice to rf, told her it was cruel and that she should turn her child round. That’s why she sent the guidance, to explain why she made the choice she did.

OP for what’s it’s worth I think you’re getting a really hard time here. I have a similar close friendship where we do lots of things differently with our dc (born 2 months apart) but we never have fallings out over it.

PamsSpam · 23/10/2021 18:10

@KatieKoala

Also *@PamsSpam*, I know you were getting angry with me and it wasn't particularly from a supportive place that you posted, but I do feel weirdly validated by your outrage! I was outraged too, but made to feel like I was being overly critical. She's super prim and proper as well and I'm...not! So I definitely felt as if she must know the sensible thing to do.
Apologies @KatieKoala, I should have been so aggressive, I think I was just shocked and the way I read it was that it was happening now and you were just not dealing with it! But I apologies sincerely, just can’t believe people would leave their little ones home alone…or give them alcohol at 5! X
user1000000000009 · 23/10/2021 18:06

My dd went forward facing before 9 months. Severe reflux and motion sickness meant a car journey was impossible.

I'm sure plenty of people judged me but they didn't have dd in their car and constantly cleaning up vomit every school run/trip to the shops/days out.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 18:04

well yes in real terms someone else then pointed out that only 9 children died in RTCs in one year in the UK

Hate to be pedantic, but it was 9 children fatalities were children were within the car. There are far more children in the 0-15 age group killed in RTC, just mostly as pedestrians or cyclists.

BertieBotts · 23/10/2021 18:04

I'm too tired to look up/link all the studies now but ANEC TRAF 2008 is one of them which is really easy to find and read through, though does contain graphic descriptions of accident deaths.

BertieBotts · 23/10/2021 18:00

@KatieKoala I wasn't having a go as such, it was just your question stood out to me as I thought it was an interesting one to answer.

People often seem to think RF vs FF is just a theory or that it makes a tiny difference, well yes in real terms someone else then pointed out that only 9 children died in RTCs in one year in the UK (this is brilliant BTW - what if we could make it 0?) - without knowing more info about how many of those children were in seats etc you can't say what the impact would be if everyone rear faced longer, but certainly we have fewer child passenger deaths nowadays than we did during the times it was normal to have children in the back seat two to a seatbelt (and yes, I remember doing this!) or with no seat belt at all. So car seats do make a difference and rear facing for longer is one change that's happened in recent years.

Shmithecat2 · 23/10/2021 17:48

@Frederica852

Theres no way you'd fit this in a Polo and get someone in the front seat

Again, depends on the seat, and how much leg room is required in the front seat. But you certainly could fit a Britax MaxWay in the back of a Polo. As I've said already, they take up less front to back space than most infant carriers.

Fetarabbit · 23/10/2021 17:41

The child may be settled when you are also in the car, but when alone with just the driver could well be distressed- being distracted by a screaming child whilst driving is dangerous. I agree that rear facing is definitely preferable, but if a driver feels more comfortable and like they're going to be less distracted by forward facing then that's safer than heightened risk of a crash. Really drilling down into it some cars are pretty terrible safety wise, do people go round reeling off the safety reports? Once people are made aware of the research its up to them to make a decision really.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 17:39

I feel like I'm being deliberately contrary now, sorry I've got nothing against rear facing car seats. I just don't think they are a bar to judge standards of parenting.

There are so many things that pose a risk to babies and children and I'm not entirely sure if these car seats make a such a huge material every day difference to risk that it's worth chastising parents who don't fork out for this bit of kit.

TellerTuesday · 23/10/2021 17:37

The thing is OP the guidance on everything to do with babies changes all the time.

Your friends first child is the same age as my daughter, my BF has a 4 month old as well as an older child the same age as DD who has just turned 8. The things that have changed and are advised even in that time is just crazy.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/10/2021 17:33

It's very unsafe and should be illegal, but it's ultimately her choice.

Driving is very unsafe, not least for pedestrians. But ultimately, it's our choice.

RacketeerRalph · 23/10/2021 17:22

I agree with you. It's very unsafe and should be illegal, but it's ultimately her choice. Well done for pointing it out though.

Legal and safe aren't the same thing. And studies are clear that even factoring in additional upset and the distraction it causes, RF is STILL safer.

saraclara · 23/10/2021 17:17

A child unhappy being rear faced is likely to distract the driver and potentially cause an accident, IMO that outweighs the small (albeit heightened) risk of a child being in a FF seat

This is what I was about to post. Distraction is a killer when driving. The child is much more at risk from a driver who is distracted by their crying, than by being in a FF seat.

cadburyegg · 23/10/2021 17:11

YABU and i say this as someone who very much believes in ERF seats, i rear faced my children until they were 3.5. The judgement about forward facing really grates on me. I remember buying a FF harnessed seat for my mum's car for my eldest who was well over 4 at this point, he was still under 15kg so couldn't just use the seatbelt. Someone on a judgey car seat group on facebook told me I was putting him in danger. Hmm

A child unhappy being rear faced is likely to distract the driver and potentially cause an accident, IMO that outweighs the small (albeit heightened) risk of a child being in a FF seat

SickAndTiredAgain · 23/10/2021 17:05

Theres no way you'd fit this in a Polo and get someone in the front seat

I’m not sure the relative sizes of these cars but yeah we have an extended rear facing seat in an Aygo, and it just about fits with DH able to sit in the front passenger seat. But he isn’t very tall. If he was 6 foot then I don’t think it would work.

Frederica852 · 23/10/2021 16:59

[quote Shmithecat2]@Frederica852

That is certainly a valid concern, however, most 25kg erf seats are actually more compact than a normal infant carrier. It's obviously car and seat combo specific, but pretty common.[/quote]
Theres no way you'd fit this in a Polo and get someone in the front seat

Shmithecat2 · 23/10/2021 16:57

@Frederica852

That is certainly a valid concern, however, most 25kg erf seats are actually more compact than a normal infant carrier. It's obviously car and seat combo specific, but pretty common.

Frederica852 · 23/10/2021 16:54

[quote Shmithecat2]@rainbowdashsneeze

Legs can go wherever they want to put them[/quote]
This would never fit in my car. The seat we've got is a real squeeze 😳

Bexxe · 23/10/2021 16:54

Sorry OP but could never figure out people who force their opinions on people (same goes for your friend really)

You both have different views of what’s best for your children, let her crack on. What difference does it make to you? Concentrate on your kids and let her raise her children how she wants

Shmithecat2 · 23/10/2021 16:27

If you're capable of processing basic physics principles, rear facing will ALWAYS be safer, even for adults. If you want to turn your baby forward as soon as you legally possibly can, just ask yourself 'why' first.

I'm no ERF evangelist - I turned my ds FF at about 2.6y. Not ideal, but with the car we had and the country we lived in at the time, it was the best we could do. Legal does not always equal safest. But at the same time, it's not great to try and criticise another parents perfectly legal choices.

The law needs to be made MUCH stricter imo.

Shmithecat2 · 23/10/2021 16:18

@Sleeplessem

To be honest *@SickAndTiredAgain* there’s a huge contradiction there legally as I’ve known kids be 9kg at 7 months and 15 months is quite arbitrary because a 15 month old boy on the 91st centile is going to be a considerable amount larger than a 15 month old girl on the 2nd. I’ve not seen a car seat with an exclusive weight measure either, perhaps that’s just infant car seats that come in a travel system? I don’t know

At mamas and papas (although don’t recommend getting a seat from there) we were told 15 months legally have to rf until. Was also the same info presented at police ran infant first aid demo at a fayre we went to- figure if the police say it then that’s what I’ll go by

The law regarding car seats depends on what seat you're using - R44 (weight based) or R129 (Isize, height based). The 15mo legal minimum is true for isize, but 9kg is legal for R44. R44 seats will be phased out in time, but forward facing in an R44 seat at 9kg is perfectly legal. Fucking dreadful, but legal.
Friend forward facing her 9 month old
Friend forward facing her 9 month old
Shmithecat2 · 23/10/2021 16:11

@rainbowdashsneeze

Legs can go wherever they want to put them

Treaclepie19 · 23/10/2021 16:07

@JimHairy just since I saw you mention a high centile, my ds rear faced until almost 5 in an axkid minikid and he's way off the chart for height and up until recently weight as well.

Sleeplessem · 23/10/2021 16:05

No @rainbowdashsneeze you can’t dismiss car seat safety facts as mumsnet crazy. Their legs bend and it’s safer for them, it really is that simple