Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted dying

190 replies

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2021 08:09

I have nursed terminally ill relative, it was a case where Im sure that they would have chosen to use he assisted measures and would have more comfortable for them. It would have certainly distressed me, but I would have been keen to follow their wishes

They were diagnosed with a terminal illness that had a 4 months average life sentence and they died 11 weeks after the fatal diagnosis and refused palliative care to give them a few more weeks

I do believe in some cases to be able to have assisted dying, with possibly intervention of a court to ensure the person wishing to dye isn't being pressured by anyone - would indeed be kinder.

Death even a good loving death can be traumatic and cruel by the nature of dying, whereas a controlled process would be kinder in the actual process of dying.

Someone rasping for 3 or 4 days for breath is not a pleasant for anyone (I had a friend that this happened to but actually he went on for 5 days)

With strict control to ensure their isn't pressure or guilt to die surely this is not unreasonable to ask? I do mean literally with a few weeks to dye and allowing the person to choose when they are ready - if ever

OP posts:
ChorizoJacketPotato · 23/10/2021 08:53

If you wouldn’t let your dog suffer and you’re of sound mind, you should be allowed to choose.

EmmetEmma · 23/10/2021 08:52

Dementia is the one that worries me so much.

I’m all for assisted dying. I would want it for myself and don’t really understand the slippery slope argument.

But dementia - which in no way would be covered by this assisted dying act, is the thing I dread. I rarely see dementia patients who aren’t distressed to some extent. I can’t think how you could offer euthanasia to them - but if I get it I hope to god I die quickly. I also don’t understand why so many of them seem to be so aggressively treated for infections - and some don’t even have DNACPR orders

Herja · 23/10/2021 08:50

I would be all for it.

My grandad is suffering with cancer currently. He has lived a long life and has spent almost 60 years taking on a primary care role for diferent people in the family. He is terrified. He cared for his brother, before his death by the same cancer, 40years ago now. He watched the excruciating pain his brother was in. He cared for his mother in her end stages and was horrified by it. She begged to die for several months before.

Now he is facing the same and it scares him so much, the thought of his final weeks. It breaks my fucking heart that this wonderful man, a man who gave up his retirement to care for me and love me when there was no one else to do it, who has moved the street himeless into his home, who has put himself last in every circumstance to care for others, faces a death that he has had literal nightmares about for decades. It causes me actual, physical pain to think of it.

With his favourite dog, he slept with him on the floor, in his final weeks. Cradled him when he siezed and fed him by hand, carried him to the garden to toilet. When it was time, he carried him for 3 miles to the vet and held him as he died. I can't do that for my rescuer; for my one defender; the only adult who has ever really loved me. I can't do what he did for a beloved dog and it makes me rage with a fury I cannot put into words.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 23/10/2021 08:48

@nameyouwhat

The bill in parliament at the moment needs two drs a judge, person needs to be of sound mind and with less than 6 months. yes I can accept that

however when we begin to talk about it as a way to solve the care crisis...that is very worrying and not a road to go down. The choice is based on individual. .not the needs of society.

The timing is a bit coincidental though isn’t it? Suddenly the government is finally waking up to the care crisis and now there is a bill in parliament for assisted dying…
BFCfairy · 23/10/2021 08:46

Yanbu I know my parents who are fit and well have firm plans for many events living wills Dnr etc and also this. Maybe that's why I also have an attitude to this that depending on what I faced would consider it.

Sounds very hard op for you.

Andante57 · 23/10/2021 08:44

Having watched my mum slowly die of dementia, for me I would like to be supported to die at the point I am struggling to recognise my own children and my care is nothing but a burden to them

I agree and as euthanasia isn’t possible here I would like to go to Dignitas. However I don’t think they will take anyone if there is any hint of dementia in case he/she might have been pressurised by the children.

DaisyWaldron · 23/10/2021 08:43

I'm very much in favour of it being an option, alongside excellent hospice care and social support/pain relief for those who want to die naturally. I think of three different deaths from cancer: my friend, who was in such pain in her last couple of weeks in spite of great support from the local hospice; the family friend who was terminally ill who had to listen to the agonised cries of a fellow patient on his ward and knowing that this was his future discharged himself, checked into a hotel and killed himself, dying alone and devastating his family; and my grandmother who chose assisted suicide in Switzerland and died around 6 weeks sooner than she otherwise would have, without pain, surrounded by people who loved her and who came to spend her last day appreciating her to the full and making her feel loved and special and supporting each other. I would choose the death my grandmother had every time.

ginnybag · 23/10/2021 08:43

I am in support of it, and have campaigned for it.

I've watched too many people linger in conditions I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy. Seen too many people where there is no hope, facing days and weeks (and months) of slow, often painful, often embarrassing decline, as their body shuts down. All of them were mentally sound until close to the end and hated it.

Two of them eventually died alone, because the process was so protracted and uncertain. One was 91, with an untreatable condition - they absolutely should have had the right to say, 'well, it can't be fixed, I'm old, it's my time, so let's pick a day, say goodbye properly, see my priest, and then I'll just go to sleep.'

Instead, they had weeks in an unfamiliar hospital miles from family, miles from their congregation and clergy they'd known for decades, who struggled to get there, and died alone.

In contrast, my BIL died a few months ago. He wasn't elderly, but he had a progressively disabling disease. He was at the point of it really starting to impact his day to day life - needing help to wash, dress, eat and toilet, no longer safe to drive, struggling to walk... and aware of all of it. He contracted pneumonia and couldn't shake it. The decision not to re-ventilate when he couldn't manage without it and let him go was, honestly, the kindest thing that could have happened. He died in the space of a couple of hours, loved ones with him, in no pain or distress.

PurpleHydrangea1 · 23/10/2021 08:41

Yes, I am in favour of assisted dying with safeguarding measures in place.
If a person is suffering but of sound.mind, the choice should be theirs.
There should be dignity in death.

SantaMonicaPier · 23/10/2021 08:41

I absolutely agree. Having lost several loved ones to cancer it was absolutely horrific and not something I think people should have to go through if there is a more human option.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 23/10/2021 08:40

To add to my comment above - we also have the green moment, shortage of housing, care funding crisis - will people be bumped off early in ordered to help the above?

Rainbowheart1 · 23/10/2021 08:40

How do we know it’s not the same as drowning quickly, being unable to breath? Surly that must be horrible!

RicherThanYew · 23/10/2021 08:39

@nameyouwhat Hear hear. The other thread is horrifying.

AuntieMarys · 23/10/2021 08:38

It doesn't go far enough for me. I want to be able to decide when I wish to die, and not linger in pain, undignified and useless.

Frogsonglue · 23/10/2021 08:37

Yes, 100% agree. My dad lived for six days without fluids, it was the most horrific week of our lives. My mum and I both have PTSD. To see his suffering protracted like that was a form of torture for all three of us. He would not have chosen that had a swifter end been an option.

FluffyBooBoo · 23/10/2021 08:37

I suppose it comes from old religious ideas that all life belongs to god and he chooses when you are born and when you die etc… ?

I would say that's definitely part of it. My grandmother died a long, slow, painful death due to bowel cancer. But she was of the attitude that this was what god had chosen for her, so this was her lot to endure.

GoodnightGrandma · 23/10/2021 08:36

Currently have a neighbour who was given six months to live, we are around five months now and the deterioration in the last week has been heartbreaking.
The pain and constant vomiting is distressing for her. I’m sure she’d press a button if she could.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 23/10/2021 08:35

I do think in an ideal world that people should be given the choice to state when they want to go and cannot tolerate pain and discomfort anymore but the fact is that if it does people will get to a certain age where they start to feel guilty about their own existence.

It won’t be practical for every case to be scrutinised by a court. There will be relatives who will coerce family members into it so that they don’t have to look after them anymore/ get some inheritance early.

You only have to look at comments on threads like this one and read posts such as “I won’t allow myself to be a burden on my children when I’m old”.

Older people are becoming more marginalised in society. I hear the phrase “Ok Boomer” banded about a lot. I don’t trust society not to abuse AD and use it in circumstances where it shouldn’t be.

mogsrus · 23/10/2021 08:35

1000% behind this,it's my decision,I would never want to burden anyone,it's not fair,it will hurt as it always does to the remaining loved
ones,but I will rest in piece,& you will realise it was the best decision.

Bohemond · 23/10/2021 08:35

I think we keep people alive for far too long as it is. As a society we cannot afford life at all costs. There needs to be more debate on this and it needs to go further than a decision at 6 months for a terminally ill person.

MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 08:35

@BrainBleachNeeded

It’s a slippery slope and it makes me uncomfortable.
Why is it a slippery slope, is is not in countries where it is offered?

Also why should you finding it uncomfortable mean it is banned? There are things we all find uncomfortable but I am not of the view that because I find something uncomfortable it should be banned.

MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 08:32

I watched my dad suffocate to death over a week whilst fully conscious and on 100% oxygen whilst the end of his lung disease killed him, it was horrific. He knew that point was coming for a long time as it got progressively worse over years, I know he would have taken assisted dying before that final point and he should have had that right.

Flossieskeeper · 23/10/2021 08:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Getawaywithit · 23/10/2021 08:31

I have always said that at 50 when most of us have had experience of illness and death in parents, friends, colleagues and have the mental capacity enough to know what we would like to happen to us, we should be able to make a living will and set out requirements within whatever parameters are set on law. Having watched my mum slowly die of dementia, for me I would like to be supported to die at the point I am struggling to recognise my own children and my care is nothing but a burden to them. Equally, people could set out that they want every possible intervention regardless of the diagnosis or something in between. The way we treat people on their twilight years is barbaric with sub-standard care and a prolong life at all cost approach. We really do need to look at how people can be supported to make their own decisions.

Alaimo · 23/10/2021 08:31

@ivykaty44

With proper safeguarding

Indeed

I wouldn't want a Dutch system, where death is offered with many diseases near the end of life - I would be against it being "offered" but something a patient should ask, enquire for if they so felt.

Where have you heard that? Because the Dutch law is very clear that euthanasia can only be performed at the patient's request, and even then it's by no means guaranteed it will be approved. I have two family member in the Netherlands who suffered from cancer and who had both requested assisted dying. Both their applications were turned down (for different reasons). One of the two couldn't take it any longer and ended up committing suicide. The idea that the Netherlands is encouraging people to be euthanised certainly does not chime with my experience.