Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted dying

190 replies

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2021 08:09

I have nursed terminally ill relative, it was a case where Im sure that they would have chosen to use he assisted measures and would have more comfortable for them. It would have certainly distressed me, but I would have been keen to follow their wishes

They were diagnosed with a terminal illness that had a 4 months average life sentence and they died 11 weeks after the fatal diagnosis and refused palliative care to give them a few more weeks

I do believe in some cases to be able to have assisted dying, with possibly intervention of a court to ensure the person wishing to dye isn't being pressured by anyone - would indeed be kinder.

Death even a good loving death can be traumatic and cruel by the nature of dying, whereas a controlled process would be kinder in the actual process of dying.

Someone rasping for 3 or 4 days for breath is not a pleasant for anyone (I had a friend that this happened to but actually he went on for 5 days)

With strict control to ensure their isn't pressure or guilt to die surely this is not unreasonable to ask? I do mean literally with a few weeks to dye and allowing the person to choose when they are ready - if ever

OP posts:
RAFHercules · 23/10/2021 10:17

The Netherlands is not the only model of euthanasia/assisted dying and its not one I would like to see the UK follow. I am uneasy with the way ICU doctors can euthanise without patient consent and very uneasy that they allow euthanasia for children with disabilities.
However, I fully, 100% would support a model similar to Canada's or California's which has appropriate safeguards.
The views of the religious should not over ride those of everyone else, if they don't like euthanasia, they don't have to partake in it.
It's not about cost cutting, it's about ending suffering.

pointythings · 23/10/2021 10:15

PlanDeRaccordement I understand your concerns about mental illness and euthanasia, but answer me this: how long do you think a person with severe mental illness and a wish to die should be made to suffer? A year? Five years? Ten? Or do you think they should never be allowed to say 'this is enough' and be made to live, just so that your concerns can be allayed? Because that is what your position would condemn people to. And I see it as incredibly patronising to say that people who have a mental illness must inevitably not be capable of deciding whether or not they want to live. Some will be, some will not be.

Stickytreacle · 23/10/2021 10:11

We all go on about a woman's choice to choose to abortion, yet we get terrified that a choice of continuing with someone's decision to end their life.
I think the decision should be a basic human right, who is anyone other than yourself able to decide you have to live and suffer? Unless you are in that individuals shoes, you have no understanding of what they are going through or can tolerate.
If someone is terminally ill then they shouldn't be forced to continue if they choose not to. I
I'd far rather have a controlled, pain free death than allow nature to take its course. Life at any cost is inhumane, for both animals and humans.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/10/2021 10:06

Severe MH issues is a slow death for many people, they never recover.
While this is true, currently doctors have no way to tell which people will recover and which will commit suicide. They just cannot know. Assisted dying puts too much power in the hands of doctors. Patients who are mentally ill, with no hope and a death wish who have tried multiple treatments and multiple suicide attempts can still recover. There is never objectively no hope. And assisted dying just has doctors collude with the patient’s illness when they are at their most vulnerable.

dinosaurblues · 23/10/2021 10:05

My FIL was diagnosed with terminal cancer. At first he had a quality of life, but within 6 months he was in unbearable pain and begged to die. It was so hard supporting him. He was in a hospital ward with others, massively swollen, leaking various fluids and in agony. It wasn't fair on him or the others.

He was finally moved to a hospice thanks to MacMillan. Watching him die was awful. There was no way he was ever going to become well again. No one should ever have to go through what he did.

GreenClock · 23/10/2021 09:59

Herja- he sounds like a wonderful man. I’m so sorry for what he’s going through.

It’s time we treated human beings with the same humanity and compassion that has been reserved for domestic pets until now.

It’s annoying that the bishops voted against. I accept freedom to practise religion but IMO legal decisions should be secular and rational.

EmeraldShamrock · 23/10/2021 09:54

Noa's case was very sad and similar to anorexia the trauma was too strong to overcome.
Severe MH issues is a slow death for many people, they never recover.
Noa would have committed to dying with or without help.
If I was completely incapacitated and needed help with toileting, feeding, dressing, even moving I'd want to die too.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/10/2021 09:53

[quote MatildaIThink]@PlanDeRaccordement
She was not euthanized, she starved herself to death.[/quote]
Seems there are conflicting news reports on her death. Not sure which news outlet is telling the truth.

DockOTheBay · 23/10/2021 09:52

Religion does not make a lot of sense at the best of times, it is not rational
Good point

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/10/2021 09:51

[quote MatildaIThink]@PlanDeRaccordement
She was not euthanized, she starved herself to death.[/quote]
No, Noa did not starve to death. She was euthanised at an end of life clinic in the Netherlands, age 17 for being a suicidal rape victim. Which is very common after rape to feel suicidal.
www.foxnews.com/world/dutch-rape-victim-euthanasia-eating

MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 09:50

@DockOTheBay
That wouldn't make a lot of sense, if it was from that religious belief then people wouldn't allow medical intervention to keep them alive which in many cases is all that's keeping them going by the end.
Religion does not make a lot of sense at the best of times, it is not rational.

MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 09:48

@PlanDeRaccordement
She was not euthanized, she starved herself to death.

MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 09:47

@garlicandsapphires

I think it’s inevitable. Does anyone remember the teenager with persistent depression who chose to die? In Holland I think.
Do you mean this case, where she was denied assisted dying, so starved herself to death?

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-48541233

EmeraldShamrock · 23/10/2021 09:46

I support it 100% and have helped campaign share and spread information on the dying with dignity campaign bill in Ireland, it is much further along than anyone expected.
There is a dying with dignity UK petition campaign, every signature helps.

PlanDeRaccordement · 23/10/2021 09:45

@garlicandsapphires

I think it’s inevitable. Does anyone remember the teenager with persistent depression who chose to die? In Holland I think.
Do you mean Noa? She was a 17yr old who had been molested and raped and was then euthanised. I personally agree with Dr Hurds analysis of this as an abuse of assisted dying. Especially, as I am a survivor of rape and I know that what she was feeling was real desire to die at the them but with therapy for sexual trauma, can go on to live a good life. drhurd.com/2019/06/05/assisted-suicide-depression-mental-illness-terminal/
DockOTheBay · 23/10/2021 09:42

@thewhatsit

I find it odd and barbaric that we don’t have the right to end our own lives in a dignified manner. I suppose it comes from old religious ideas that all life belongs to god and he chooses when you are born and when you die etc… ?
That wouldn't make a lot of sense, if it was from that religious belief then people wouldn't allow medical intervention to keep them alive which in many cases is all that's keeping them going by the end.
garlicandsapphires · 23/10/2021 09:40

I think it’s inevitable.
Does anyone remember the teenager with persistent depression who chose to die? In Holland I think.

MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 09:39

@vdbfamily

Porcupine, if you compare the number of abortions in the year it was legalised to how many take place now you may see evidence of a slippery slope.
All that means is that fewer unwanted pregnancies will becoming to term, where as when introduced many women were more scared of the social stigma of having an abortion.

It has not been a "slippery slope" because we have not stated killing babies, or even extended the window for abortions.

daisyjgrey · 23/10/2021 09:37

@vdbfamily

Porcupine, if you compare the number of abortions in the year it was legalised to how many take place now you may see evidence of a slippery slope.

What?!

vdbfamily · 23/10/2021 09:36

Porcupine, if you compare the number of abortions in the year it was legalised to how many take place now you may see evidence of a slippery slope.

NoSquirrels · 23/10/2021 09:35

I’ve been there as my 90+ year old grandmother lay dying, and my 70-year-old mother. One in a care home, one in a hospice.

My grandmother lay dying for weeks. As I understand it, the doctors obviously did what they thought was best but in fact they managed to prolong her end of life at the moment there was no benefit to anyone. It was pretty horrific - my dad was traumatised by watching his mother die. I only did relief shifts when it was too much for him, or my mum or other gran (they were close) to sit, and eventually his elder brother arrived too and shared the vigil. But it was weeks. There was no benefit to it, only trauma, really.

My mother was in hospice for a brief spell and died there after deteriorating rapidly. They kept us informed at every stage - they recommended when we should be moving to increase dosages of different drugs and what that would mean - that she’d no longer be responsive, that her breathing would slow. It was respectful and we felt confident in them.

Due to my mum watching her beloved husband struggle with the effects of watching his mother die, she was desperate not to have him sit vigil with her when her time came. She wanted to protect him from that. But in the end he was there holding her when she died, and I think the ‘management’ of her death, for want of a better phrase, allowed that for him and it was important and healing.

My dad remains terrified of becoming a burden or incapacitated and living when he should be dead. He says he’d kill himself. I don’t think he would, and that’s where this conflict is - when is it OK to choose, can it really be OK, and should anyone else choose for you?

My grandmother wouldn’t have chosen to end her own life, she was religious, so it wouldn’t have helped her. Would her sons have chosen the burden to help her if they knew she might not have agreed?

I don’t know the answers. Except funding for hospice care. A good death should be as important as prolonging life in so many cases.

Buddywoo · 23/10/2021 09:31

In the 1980's my father had an assisted death. He had a very caring GP who spent a lot of time with him. He was being nursed at home and in the final days with terminal cancer when he developed a lot of pain. We called the GP and she came and gave him a dose of morphine, enough to take the pain away but not to send him to sleep.
She discussed things with him and it was agreed that she would come back in 2 hrs and give him enough morphine so that he wouldn't wake up again. This is exactly what happened, he was pain free and we could all say our goodbyes.
It was what he wanted and saved him another few days of agony.

daisyjgrey · 23/10/2021 09:27

@AuntieMarys

It doesn't go far enough for me. I want to be able to decide when I wish to die, and not linger in pain, undignified and useless.

I'm with you. I am fully prepared to end it myself if I get a horrific diagnosis and the option to go abroad/do it 'above board' in the UK isn't there.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 23/10/2021 09:24

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Dontgetyerknicksinatwist do you really think care isnt rationed now?[/quote]
No I agree that it is already being rationed - but this will be seen as a another way to ease the burden on the NHS. I sincerely wish that wasn’t the case.

Herja · 23/10/2021 09:23

Thank you NoSquirrels, that's very kind.