Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted dying

190 replies

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2021 08:09

I have nursed terminally ill relative, it was a case where Im sure that they would have chosen to use he assisted measures and would have more comfortable for them. It would have certainly distressed me, but I would have been keen to follow their wishes

They were diagnosed with a terminal illness that had a 4 months average life sentence and they died 11 weeks after the fatal diagnosis and refused palliative care to give them a few more weeks

I do believe in some cases to be able to have assisted dying, with possibly intervention of a court to ensure the person wishing to dye isn't being pressured by anyone - would indeed be kinder.

Death even a good loving death can be traumatic and cruel by the nature of dying, whereas a controlled process would be kinder in the actual process of dying.

Someone rasping for 3 or 4 days for breath is not a pleasant for anyone (I had a friend that this happened to but actually he went on for 5 days)

With strict control to ensure their isn't pressure or guilt to die surely this is not unreasonable to ask? I do mean literally with a few weeks to dye and allowing the person to choose when they are ready - if ever

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 23/10/2021 12:51

@BrainBleachNeeded

I wish people would stop with their anecdotes. I bet everyone has experienced death with a parent or loved one here. Doesn’t make you a better person for wanting to help them die so they don’t suffer, compared to someone who has lived through and cared for them until the end.
I don't think anyone is suggesting that.

The difference is one side believes it should be the choice of the person dying, where as the other side wishes to deny choice.

Sn0tnose · 23/10/2021 12:50

I’m all for people choosing assisted dying where it’s the right decision for them.

But I don’t have enough confidence in our safeguarding procedures to believe it would be anything other than a slippery slope to ‘dealing’ with ill people who have become an expensive inconvenience and don’t have family members to protect them.

nomoneytreehere · 23/10/2021 12:40

@PlanDeRaccordement I have a similar experience to you. I agree wholeheartedly with you. My father was asked to sign a dnr as he arrived at hospital with oxygen levels of 80%. I do not believe he had capacity to do that. He was then not treated appropriately either. My mother died of dementia. She fought for 2 years and did not want to die. Life is precious. I do not agree with assisted dying but I do think much more can be done to make people comfortable. My mum died within 24 hours of the administration of end of life drugs so I do think there is a bit of helping them on their way that goes on too (but she was clearly near the end).

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 23/10/2021 12:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FluffyBooBoo · 23/10/2021 12:32

Doesn’t make you a better person for wanting to help them die so they don’t suffer, compared to someone who has lived through and cared for them until the end

Had anyone suggested that to be the case?

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 23/10/2021 12:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

schoolsoutforever · 23/10/2021 12:09

Completely agree. Watching my dad in his final few days, I know he would have opted for this. It was horrendous, as I’m sure it is for others. I can’t see why we couldn’t find a way.

Ozanj · 23/10/2021 12:09

@pointythings

RAFHercules can you link me to the sections of Dutch euthanasia law that say ICU doctors can euthanise without patient consent and that euthanasia is legal for disabled children? I'm Dutch and I've read up on various websites, including the Dutch government's own pages on the subject, and I can't find it.

Where children are concerned all I can find is that parental consent is needed between ages 12 and 16 and that between ages 16 and 18, discussion with the parents must take place, but they are not the decision makers.

A lot of people have fallen for the misrepresentation in the media around Noa’s death & think doctors intervened to help her die.
BrainBleachNeeded · 23/10/2021 12:00

I wish people would stop with their anecdotes. I bet everyone has experienced death with a parent or loved one here. Doesn’t make you a better person for wanting to help them die so they don’t suffer, compared to someone who has lived through and cared for them until the end.

BrainBleachNeeded · 23/10/2021 11:57

@Gatehouse77 what do you mean arm themselves with information? I have all the information I need, with the fact I knew my own parents wouldn’t have wanted assisted death and that I wouldn’t want it either. Neither would my husband. There’s another thread talking about dementia patients; and I’m not even touching that because I looked after a parent with dementia, and although it almost broke me, there is no way I would have ever opted to do this for my parent.

It is a slippery slope, because once something like this becomes accepted, there will most definitely be vulnerable ill old people who may feel guilty and opt for this, even though they don’t want to die. Why should people have to kill themselves to help alleviate a political problem such as care crisis or housing crisis?

starrynight21 · 23/10/2021 11:07

Thankfully, where I live ( Australia) it was passed with very little dissent about a month ago. Having seen my sister and my best friend die horribly from cancer, I'm all for having the option of a dignified and pain-free ending.

pointythings · 23/10/2021 10:59

RAFHercules can you link me to the sections of Dutch euthanasia law that say ICU doctors can euthanise without patient consent and that euthanasia is legal for disabled children? I'm Dutch and I've read up on various websites, including the Dutch government's own pages on the subject, and I can't find it.

Where children are concerned all I can find is that parental consent is needed between ages 12 and 16 and that between ages 16 and 18, discussion with the parents must take place, but they are not the decision makers.

Gatehouse77 · 23/10/2021 10:57

I am very pro assisted dying having watched my bed bound mother take 8 weeks to, effectively, starve and dehydrate herself to death.

She had a rare neurological condition which was only ever going to get worse. She had no 'quality' of life for the 2-3 years before her death and would have gladly taken the option to die. And none of us, her children (DF not in the picture) or grandchildren, would have denied her. It infuriated me that people bandy the phrase 'quality of life' around as though simple being alive is 'quality'. Those last few years, my mother simply existed.

However, even under the current guidelines in those countries (and states) that do have assisted dying she would not have met the criteria because her condition wasn't 'terminal'.

I heard a fantastic talk given by Rabbi Jonathan Romain and his position as a religious leader who agrees with assisted dying and has contributed to a book ( Assisted Dying – Rabbinic Responses, Movement for Reform Judaism (2014)[23] ISBN 978-0947884246) which was a fascinating read.

I do wish people would arm themselves with information before the 'slippery slope' comments.

Susiesue61 · 23/10/2021 10:52

Can I just clarify as someone who works in a hospice, we don't give drugs that make anyone die more quickly.

RAFHercules · 23/10/2021 10:49

Flossieskeeper
I would suspect some of the 50% of doctors who wouldn't prescribe are bound by their own religious rules.

Glitterybug · 23/10/2021 10:47

Often there's a religious element to the counter argument. God gives life and only God can take it away. But what's the point in having free will if a human being can't exercise it to choose when to die?

UndertonesOfCake · 23/10/2021 10:45

My DF fears the indignities, pain and suffering of old age so much that he has been telling me, for many years, that he intends to kill himself before he gets to that stage. I don't believe he's mentally ill - it's a totally rational decision for a very independent man who has seen the brutal realities of what old age did to his parents and others.

If he knew he would have the option to die at a time of his choosing, then he would be spared the dilemma of knowing he has to kill himself while he is still physically capable of doing so, but before he actually wants to go. The option of assisted suicide would probably allow him to carry on living longer.

Will he actually go through with it? I have no way of knowing. But I'm not looking forward to being the one who finds his body.

When watching my DGM die - it took about 10 days though for the first few we thought she would recover - in about the latter half I would have personally administered the euthanasia drugs. She was not deriving any benefit from living, nor was there any prospect of her deriving benefit ever again, and at that point it would have been better for her to go.

daisyjgrey · 23/10/2021 10:43

I personally agree with Dr Hurds analysis of this as an abuse of assisted dying. Especially, as I am a survivor of rape and I know that what she was feeling was real desire to die at the them but with therapy for sexual trauma, can go on to live a good life.

YOU can. Maybe she couldn't. You don't get to say what she should or shouldn't be able to live through.

RAFHercules · 23/10/2021 10:42

thereisonlyoneofme
I'm so sorry to hear of your illness.
No one should be forced to undertake such an ardous journey, often opting to go to Switzerland earlier than they would choose, for fear of not being allowed to travel at all if they are too ill.
It is disgraceful.

Porcupineintherough · 23/10/2021 10:37

The concerns about mental health and assisted suicide are largely moot as most people with mental health issues dont require assistance to end their lives.

The value in assisted dying is the choice it provides to those physically incapacitated by illness.

Flossieskeeper · 23/10/2021 10:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

lemmein · 23/10/2021 10:34

100% agree with assisted dying - for any reason, including MH. I also have no issue with it in the context of relieving a struggling NHS.

I've worked in nursing homes for those with severe dementia - it's fucking terrifying. There was an elderly woman who walked the corridors all day, every day crying because she couldn't find her baby - I can't imagine the constant trauma that poor woman must have felt. It still upsets me, all these years later - she could well be walking those corridors still today.

It must have cost millions to keep that home going - to warehouse those poor people in a living hell. Yet we have those desperately needing vital healthcare being told there's no funds available - it just doesn't make sense to me.

Healthcare is fraught with difficult ethical decisions and as unpalatable as it may be, every day decisions are made on peoples care based on costs. I don't think it's unethical to consider the costs in these circumstances too.

But, costs aside, if I could have helped that woman escape the constant torture and exhaustion of searching for a baby that doesn't exist I would have, in a heartbeat.

thereisonlyoneofme · 23/10/2021 10:32

I actively researched Dignitas and would choose this for myself, BUT it is a long and arduous process re paperwork etc, you have to have various consultations and paperwork from your doc , then you have to get there. It apparently can take about 6 months for the whole process to be agreed, so a lot of people dont have that much time. For myself I would have no one to accompany me there. Im very much afraid of my end as I have terminal cancer. This Bill will not get
anywhere i n this country Im afraid. Its another instance of the nanny state knowing whats best for us Sad

RAFHercules · 23/10/2021 10:29

Flossiskeeper In a recent (Sept 2021) BMA survey of 29,000 members, It seems that 50% of doctors would be willing to prescribe medication to hasten death.

Careerchangetime · 23/10/2021 10:25

www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-48541233.amp

The 17 year old had an eating disorder and starved herself to death. She wasn’t euthanised.