Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted dying

190 replies

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2021 08:09

I have nursed terminally ill relative, it was a case where Im sure that they would have chosen to use he assisted measures and would have more comfortable for them. It would have certainly distressed me, but I would have been keen to follow their wishes

They were diagnosed with a terminal illness that had a 4 months average life sentence and they died 11 weeks after the fatal diagnosis and refused palliative care to give them a few more weeks

I do believe in some cases to be able to have assisted dying, with possibly intervention of a court to ensure the person wishing to dye isn't being pressured by anyone - would indeed be kinder.

Death even a good loving death can be traumatic and cruel by the nature of dying, whereas a controlled process would be kinder in the actual process of dying.

Someone rasping for 3 or 4 days for breath is not a pleasant for anyone (I had a friend that this happened to but actually he went on for 5 days)

With strict control to ensure their isn't pressure or guilt to die surely this is not unreasonable to ask? I do mean literally with a few weeks to dye and allowing the person to choose when they are ready - if ever

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 00:22

It's not as if all lives are valued in the UK. Obviously there's the lack of simple Covid mitigations - for example unlike many other countries we don't have a mask mandate. And also austerity (which was economically a failure) is estimated to have killed approx 50-60,000. In a far less pleasant manner than an assisted suicide peaceful pill. We also have little action on the public health housing and homelessness emergency. Despite the average age of death for a homeless person being just 40 something. If we cared that much about preserving lives, we'd be tackling that.

julieca · 24/10/2021 00:22

@Tealightsandd the Liverpool Pathway was absolutely about a peaceful death. It was supposed to take the learning from the hospice movement and make it available to every patient who was terminally ill.
Great idea in practice, but in an overworked NHS within a culture that does not value elderly people, it was doomed to failure and caused a lot of suffering.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 24/10/2021 00:22

I've been an NHS professional for 40 years and I'm outraged people can't make this decision for themselves.
I've seen scores of horrible horrible deaths, I'm sick of the prolifers who go on about how we should have great end of life care instead and let them suffocate in their own saliva.
People like this have never set foot in a hospital or cared for anyone when the drugs no longer work.

KitchenKrisis · 24/10/2021 00:20

Letting old people die slowly and painfully also shows little value for their lives. The state of many care homes shows we don't know how to care as well.

I'd rather go thanks and choose for myself

julieca · 24/10/2021 00:19

@Tealightsandd Living wills sound great in theory and when I was young I would have promoted them. But my experience is people change their minds when they actually experience illness. They find there are things they still want to do, people they still want to see.
My father in his last weeks when he was feeling terrible would say he wanted to die. But then an hour later would say he wanted to live long enough to meet his grandson.

KitchenKrisis · 24/10/2021 00:18

With a legal document and mechanism now we can write, that can be followed at the right time.

KitchenKrisis · 24/10/2021 00:17

I would like to say now in a legal document when I'd like to go.
I've seen and done enough to know exactly what stages and when I'd like to go
I've also been three weeks at the bedside of someone who died and was ready to go three weeks before.

Why on earth are we forcing terminally ill people into long long painful deaths? Why!!

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 00:16

In practice some elderly patients were killed before their time. It was a national scandal.

A bit like 'living with' Covid?

julieca · 24/10/2021 00:16

Some people have talked about people terminally ill dying because food and liquid was withheld. That was the Liverpool Pathway and led to people being killed.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-23698071

When people are in the last few days of life, their body shuts down and they can no longer manage food and little liquid. So this was intended to support people in their last few days. Instead, elderly patients who were not just about to die, were put on the Liverpool Pathway, had food and liquid withheld, and were effectively killed.
I don't believe that a country that places so little value on older people can safely introduce an assisted dying scheme. If passed, I strongly suspect it will become another scandal that is exposed a few years down the line.

ToooSensitive · 24/10/2021 00:13

*As a nurse..

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 00:12

@julieca

OP sounds great in theory but in practice patients will be killed. Look at what happened with the Liverpool Pathway. It was supposed to be used on patients who had days to live and with relatives consent. In practice some elderly patients were killed before their time. It was a national scandal. This will not be any different.
Wasn't that something completely different from an explicitly stated wish for a peaceful death?

Progressive and compassionate countries (and some US states) allow assisted suicide. Denying people the option of a good death is cruel.

Dignitas is a useful guide on how to do it well with appropriate safeguards including psychological checks.

From what I've read, the so-called 'Liverpool pathway' was in fact clinician not patient decided - and it certainly wasn't a good death (unlike physician assisted suicide). The 'pathway' involved leaving patients to die a horrible neglected death.

Every adult with capacity over the age of 18 should make a Living Will (to be amended at any time throughout lifetime).

ToooSensitive · 24/10/2021 00:02

As nurse I’m following this with interest, but am very much on the fence.

As an aside, can I really kindly ask posters not to use the phrase ‘committed suicide’. It is outdated and harks back to a time when suicide was a crime - it was decriminalised here in 1961.

The Samaritans and MIND suggest phrases such as ‘ended their life’ ‘took their own life’.

Sorry to derail the thread for a moment, but it can be triggering and stigmatising for those of us bereaved by suicide.

julieca · 23/10/2021 23:48

OP sounds great in theory but in practice patients will be killed. Look at what happened with the Liverpool Pathway. It was supposed to be used on patients who had days to live and with relatives consent. In practice some elderly patients were killed before their time. It was a national scandal. This will not be any different.

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2021 23:05

TBH a good GP will prescribe JICS …just in case meds …as long as the meds are justified ie pain ,agitation then there is no reason why anyone should die in pain or distressed.

you can have them sat at the end of the bed for the best part of 4 weeks but they aren't any use without someone to ok the administration of them and that someone needs to be a doctor

OP posts:
frogsarejumpy · 23/10/2021 23:00

K123 you can make an Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment in specific circumstances

amsadandconfused · 23/10/2021 22:50

TBH a good GP will prescribe JICS …just in case meds …as long as the meds are justified ie pain ,agitation then there is no reason why anyone should die in pain or distressed.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/10/2021 22:32

It's very arrogant for healthy young or middle aged people to presume we know best about what would be In the best interests of the terminally Ill

A very valid point, though it cuts both ways. So just as it shouldn't be for the first group to insist the second go on suffering against their will, neither should they be able to decide death's "in their best interests" for less than altruistic motives

As a PP just said, you only have to read the derision for the aged on here - the last acceptable "ism", apparently - to appeciate the problems which could arise

k1233 · 23/10/2021 22:29

I think people should be allowed to make elections at any point in their life to specify in which circumstances they wish to die with assisted dying. I know my personal desires as to the minimum quality of life I am prepared to accept (I believe in quality of life over quantity) and I very strongly believe that I should be allowed stipulate this whilst I am of sound mind and can articulate the reasons I feel this way.

I do not believe imminent death should be a pre requisite. People should be allowed to make elections that suit them and not be dictated to that any life is better than dying. I don't force my views on others and resent others forcing theirs on to me.

I plan to write my wishes onto my will in the hope that they will be followed.

AntiMaskersAreTwats · 23/10/2021 21:47

@Flossieskeeper

I’m sorry you and your relative went through that experience. Out of interest- if you were the hop being asked to assist dying could you? Could you prescribe the medication knowing it will end life or administer ( possibly by injection) knowing it will end life?

And I don’t mean double jeopardy whereby you are treating pain but know the morphine will have the effect of reducing the effort of breathing.

I’m asking because to implement assisted dying will entail some degree of this. It’s not a judgement on whether assisted dying should be offered.

And yes! To answer that question, any one of my family could have injected my Nan with drugs to cause her death. We all desperately wanted her suffering to end.
AntiMaskersAreTwats · 23/10/2021 21:29

My nan was in her 90s and had a catastrophic stroke. Her brain was basically mush. They withdrew food and water from her after 2 days. We then sat with her for 4 days as that’s how long it took her to die even with no water. How is that humane?

Porcupineintherough · 23/10/2021 21:27

@BrainBleachNeeded
Of course no one is asking their elderly relatives to commit suicide. There's no option is there?

You can get paracetamol at every pharmacy. There are drops and ropes and knives and exhaust fumes everywhere. It's not lack of options that's stopping families pushing their elderly relatives to end it all, it's the fact that it's not so easy to force someone to commit suicide against their will even if you are so minded (and most of us aren't). So why would assisted suicide, with all its checks and balances, suddenly precipitate coerced suicide?

BestZebbie · 23/10/2021 21:23

Removal of fluids is horrific - my bed bound and terminally ill relative took basically the same amount of time to die from dehydration as I would have done if they had caught and strapped me down to the next door bed when visiting her!
I am not arguing that sometimes dying might become the best thing for a person - but if that is decided by the medical personnel and fluids are withdrawn to allow it to happen then it seems as if an overdose of anaesthetic at that point would get there a lot more humanely - even Jesus was offered vinegar whilst being crucified ffs! Dehydration seems an awful lot of suffering to inflict in order to maintain a very very thin veneer of weasel words that signing a no fluids order isn't taking an action that will kill, only one which will inevitably lead to death...

Totallydefeated · 23/10/2021 20:19

What changed my mind was realising how awful end of life care is - removal of fluids and dehydrating and starving a person to death is beyond comprehension. Yet it happens day in day out in our country.

Agree with this. We are already basically assisting people to die, but in a way that is protracted and prolongs the agony. The new proposals would result in far less cruelty and suffering.

Cherryana · 23/10/2021 20:10

I am someone who has changed their mind from a 'sanctity of life/too easy to manipulate' position to I think it is in 'the best interest to give individuals with capacity the choice with safeguards in place'.

What changed my mind was realising how awful end of life care is - removal of fluids and dehydrating and starving a person to death is beyond comprehension. Yet it happens day in day out in our country.

To have the option of a managed and peaceful death is within our medical capabilities and is something I would like to have the choice of.

KikoLemons · 23/10/2021 20:09

I agree with the right to die.
I am also wary of the push to get rid of people. (The hatred for MILs, Boomers, anyone over 60 as if their opinions are invalid, they have no right to a big house, a seat on a bus, to voice a comment, to use resources, to spend their own money ). So yes I'm concerned.
But if it truly is your own choice you should be given the help you need