Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted dying

190 replies

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2021 08:09

I have nursed terminally ill relative, it was a case where Im sure that they would have chosen to use he assisted measures and would have more comfortable for them. It would have certainly distressed me, but I would have been keen to follow their wishes

They were diagnosed with a terminal illness that had a 4 months average life sentence and they died 11 weeks after the fatal diagnosis and refused palliative care to give them a few more weeks

I do believe in some cases to be able to have assisted dying, with possibly intervention of a court to ensure the person wishing to dye isn't being pressured by anyone - would indeed be kinder.

Death even a good loving death can be traumatic and cruel by the nature of dying, whereas a controlled process would be kinder in the actual process of dying.

Someone rasping for 3 or 4 days for breath is not a pleasant for anyone (I had a friend that this happened to but actually he went on for 5 days)

With strict control to ensure their isn't pressure or guilt to die surely this is not unreasonable to ask? I do mean literally with a few weeks to dye and allowing the person to choose when they are ready - if ever

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SlumberMyLittleOne · 25/10/2021 02:49

@AuntieMarys

It doesn't go far enough for me. I want to be able to decide when I wish to die, and not linger in pain, undignified and useless.
I am 100% in favour, and it needs to go a lot further than what is currently being proposed.

My Mum died of cancer, in Canada, where assisted dying is legal. But when she was in her final days, in agony, and asked for help to die, it was denied. The required paperwork takes months to process and needs assessment and approval from three separate doctors.

So she couldn't die at home, in the place that she loved, with my Dad by her side, as she wanted to… she was taken to hospital and had to go completely on her own because of Covid rules. The only consolation is that at the hospital they were able to put her in an induced coma and that ended her suffering. My kind, gentle Mum, who spent her whole life caring for others, deserved a better ending than that.

2bazookas · 25/10/2021 02:06

@vdbfamily

Porcupine, if you compare the number of abortions in the year it was legalised to how many take place now you may see evidence of a slippery slope.
The slippery slope of abortion, happened secretly and out of sight before 1967, when it was still illegal. Totally unregulated, often carried out in filthy conditions by untrained people with no anaesthesia, horribly dangerous and risky.
Nobody knows how common it was then compared to now.
Hatsuma · 25/10/2021 00:52

@k1233 it’s a horrible prospect isn’t it. Watching my gran go through it, I’d say the worst bit for her was the couple of years where she swung between being ‘normal’ to not having any idea what was going on, and back again. On the lucid days she had an ok quality of life but at the same time she also knew in those times that she was losing her mind and that was terrifying for her. And when she was having bad days she’d put herself in all sorts of danger, go off wandering along main roads and not know where she was or how to get home, that kind of thing. By the time she got into a home she was pretty much completely gone and only recognised her favourite child, no one else. She then proceeded to live for another 6 years in a home in that state, with the end being especially grim. It would be hard to know when the right time to step in would be, if someone else had to make that decision for me. Arguably it was all pretty crap, but I still maintain those years before she went into the home were the most distressing for her. But how could any decide that would be the right time for her to die when she was still having good days? I don’t know how it could work in practice but I wish there was a way.

k1233 · 25/10/2021 00:39

@Hatsuma I know exactly what you're saying. Dementia runs in my family too and I would like to be able to specify NOW, whist mentally competent, that if I reach a certain level of care (that to me takes away my dignity) then I want to die. I don't want to endure years of something that I personally find demeaning. That is my choice and my level of dignity. Others don't have to agree with me and make the same choices. That's ok. As is my determination of what is right for me.

There is no getting better from dementia or a number of other diseases. Losing the ability to communicate basic needs eg pain, hunger, thirst is awful and IMO can lead to neglect (even if unintended).

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/10/2021 19:01

Andante apparently Dignitas use Pentobarbital, a barbiturate
Morphine's an opiate, and post-Shipman I expect there are far fewer prepared to help the dying in this way, though no doubt some still do it out of sheer human empathy

It's said that the line between palliative therapy and that which will actually kill the patient can be very thin, especially when someone's actively dying, so on that basis we'll probably never know how many deaths could reasonably be classed as "assisted"

Andante57 · 24/10/2021 17:04

Arguably, rather than leaving someone to slowly starve/shutdown, it is more of a kindness to give a painless overdose. More dignity, that's for sure

I agree. Why can’t the patient be given a morphine overdose or whatever the medicine is that’s given at Dignitas.

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 17:01

No food and minimal liquid when our organs start shutting down is a kindness

Arguably, rather than leaving someone to slowly starve/shutdown, it is more of a kindness to give a painless overdose. More dignity, that's for sure.

I know what I would prefer for myself and for my loved ones.

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 16:58

@Supersimkin2

Trouble is so many people have dementia by the time they die they couldn't benefit from AD. Even tho they'd certainly be in their right mind about wanting it.
That's when a Living Will comes in.

It should be something every adult with capacity over the age of 18 does. Obviously as a flexible document that can be amended whenever someone wishes.

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 16:55

Well definitely many people currently have to opt for assisted suicide too early. They have to travel to Dignitas whilst still physically able to make the journey.

Probably even worse than that, many others have to resort to DIY methods. Often less successful but more painful and distressing (for both patient and loved ones).

Btw there is a difference between euthanasia (clinician administers it) and physician assisted suicide (patient does it themselves but the doctor provides a safe effective - and pretty much painless - medication).

Whilst I personally strongly support both being an option, it's worth noting that Dignitas offers only assisted suicide, not euthanasia. And that is what is currently being debated as an option here too.

So, when people ask what if somebody changes their minds. Well then that's what they do. Change their minds.

julieca · 24/10/2021 16:35

But when would you kill yourself with dementia? My relative has dementia. Can cook, go to the local shop, socialise with family. TBH you wouldn't know as long as he stays in his routine. It only becomes obvious if he is outside his routine e.g. when admitted to the hospital.

Supersimkin2 · 24/10/2021 16:28

Trouble is so many people have dementia by the time they die they couldn't benefit from AD. Even tho they'd certainly be in their right mind about wanting it.

Mydogisagentleman · 24/10/2021 16:06

I am a firm supporter of voluntary euthanasia and have a DNAR.
When me and DH made our power of attorney, mine had to go to the court of something, possibly appeal because it was considered by whoever registers them that I had been coerced!

julieca · 24/10/2021 15:12

No food and minimal liquid when our organs start shutting down is a kindness. But under the old pathway, elderly people were being denied food and drink because the decision had been made by people without the skills to do so. It was palliative care on the very cheap.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/10/2021 12:18

I don't believe that a country that places so little value on older people can safely introduce an assisted dying scheme

Even as someone who supports the principle, that's my own worry - the key word being safely

About the Liverpool Pathway, though - someone please correct me if I'm wrong but I thought that still existed, only it's called "comfort care" now? The protocols might be different but it's certainly what happened to my FIL when they stopped trying to drag him back, and involved the withdrawal of observations, food and drink

Fortunately his last days were peaceful despite the previous medical negligence, and while no food and drink upsets our human instincts to care, we were told their withdrawal shuts down the body's capacity to feel pain and distress - though how true this is I don't know

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 00:55

When I die, I don't want it to be withdrawn treatment - left to slowly, over days, shut down. I intend to go to Dignitas, where I can under my own control take a pill that lets me fall asleep painlessly. A truly peaceful death that the 'Liverpool Pathway' most definitely isn't. Thing is, Dignitas isn't an option for many people. It's expensive, and you have to be physically well enough to travel. People have had to travel whilst they still can - meaning some die before they were ready.

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 00:43

Dignity in Dying are a good source of information/explanation on the campaign for, well, dignity in dying.

As well as the physical aspects, we shouldn't underestimate the psychological and spiritual value that having a sense of control over death can give. Control and dignity.

UndertonesOfCake · 24/10/2021 00:41

I'm not suggesting it's just instantly available as it needs to be controlled to avoid the very real threat of abuse e.g. elderly relatives "requesting" it when they're about to go into an expensive care home and such like or where there is a genuine question over mental capacity but the choice should be there.

In the end it was never necessary, but I could certainly have seen my DGF preferring death over a care home - he wouldn't have coped.

My DGM, who I had thought would cope, and even make new friends, was so miserable in her (expensive, very much the nice end of the spectrum) care home that she was upset when she moved in, looked miserable the one time I got to see her lucid a month later (I live a distance away), and died two months after she went in. I think she pretty much gave up, truth be told.

Hatsuma · 24/10/2021 00:37

It is tricky. I have an autistic 17 year old dd who often asks why I didn’t have an abortion with her, she struggles with life so much and I think there’s a good chance that if she could end it all now in a painless way she could well be tempted. That would be heartbreaking as she is amazing and I’m sure there are brighter times ahead for her, she just can’t see that now.

The worry is with older people that they may feel like they are putting their loved ones out by existing and needing help, or spending money they’d like to leave to others on care. So not really thinking about what they themselves want, but not being coerced either.

Also people with dementia - that’s a horrible way to die and there’s a trend of it in my family so it’s a personal worry for me. But of course these people can’t be deemed capable of making the decision to die. I’d hope it would be possible to make it clear in advance that if I got dementia then I’d rather not be here. But at what point would they say ok she’s mad enough to die now? Not sure how that would work but it would be a shame if dementia sufferers had to endure life to the bitter end.

Heartsandroses · 24/10/2021 00:36

My grandad died of dementia many years ago
To watch my beautiful,brave,fearless,intelligent grandad wither into a skeleton was the worst thing I will ever live through
I love him so much-he was my world,and to watch him change so much and he didn’t have a clue who I was
18 months I watched this evil illness take yet another part of him until there was nothing left
I was 14 at the time and even now at the age of 43 I wish I could have just flipped a switch and allowed him to die with dignity
It was his worst nightmare to die alone in a care home-and we (or rather the adults) put him there
I’m convinced that at the end he knew-he certainly waited for me to come and say our last goodbyes
He should have been allowed to die at home,with his loved ones by his side-18 months before he did actually die

julieca · 24/10/2021 00:31

@ThinWomansBrain the medical teams would listen to your father each time treatment was given. My father had a DNR, but each time he was asked if he wanted antibiotics or other treatment, he always said yes. It is not up to relatives, but the patient. And consent does have to be sought.

Pazuzu · 24/10/2021 00:30

It amazes me that we allow animals far more dignity in death than humans.

Losing all mental faculties or suffer horrendous pain? Why is it OK for our species alone?

I'm not suggesting it's just instantly available as it needs to be controlled to avoid the very real threat of abuse e.g. elderly relatives "requesting" it when they're about to go into an expensive care home and such like or where there is a genuine question over mental capacity but the choice should be there.

The penalties for abuse would also need to be high.

julieca · 24/10/2021 00:29

@Tealightsandd

The Liverpool Pathway was not about peaceful death. Starving to death is not peaceful. Nor was/is it peaceful in the sense of emotionally or spiritually peaceful.
It was supposed to be about a peaceful death. Withholding food is only supposed to happen at the end when eating can cause pain because the organs are already shutting down. In practice that is not what happened. Patients were starved. Death isn't always peaceful emotionally.
ThinWomansBrain · 24/10/2021 00:26

My father spent the last year of his life in and out of hospital; a fall, but with history of a couple of strokes, heart attacks, diabetes...
His quality of life in that last year was negligible, he had no dignity.
I was asked about DNR when he went into hospital fifteen months before his death, and responded that yes, he would much prefer that - but the many medical teams never took any bloody notice.
I am angry on his behalf - and the NHS resources wasted in keeping him alive - for what? He was never going to "get better" even though their was no single terminal disease.

The right to commit suicide and availability to request euthenasia should both be every much a right as a womans' right to an abortion.

Tealightsandd · 24/10/2021 00:25

The Liverpool Pathway was not about peaceful death. Starving to death is not peaceful. Nor was/is it peaceful in the sense of emotionally or spiritually peaceful.

julieca · 24/10/2021 00:25

@Tealightsandd I agree with all of that. The action during the pandemic showed that we can end street homelessness.