Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who will look after us in old age?

572 replies

malificent7 · 22/10/2021 23:16

I am curently a care assitant temp until my permanent job in healthcare is sorted. It is very rewarding but hard, dirty work for little money.
They are understaffed and many are leaving due to bad pay. As we are an aging population aibu to think this is going to get worse? How can we get carers to stay,?

Disclaimer...there is no way i want dd to look after me...not fair on her...i'd rather go to a home.

OP posts:
BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 16:23

@HoldingTheDoor

I think the reality is, some people will be thinking about the monetary value they will lose is they have to pay for fees….

People can’t always proclaim they are so caring when sometimes there are ulterior motives…..

I've seen that before as a carer. Including one gentleman whose relative bought him the bare minimum of food and the very cheapest to the extent that we carers were buying him food from our own meagre salaries to supplement it and so that he could enjoy the occasional treat.(And yes there was more than sufficient money available for his needs but his relative didn't care)

Yes - I have seen it as well. Plus there have been threads on here before from posters bemoaning the cost of care draining away future inheritances. I wonder sometimes if these people simply view their aged parents as walking bank accounts rather than living breathing human beings.

Not an issue for me as my parents only have their state pensions and live in a small council house, and it's me giving them financial help with bills and so on - so there is zero inheritance coming my way!

XingMing · 25/10/2021 16:20

It is quite impossible in so many ways. DMIL is 92, and went into a care home to give my DSisIL some respite from caring and managing the carers who visited twice daily just before the first COVID lockdown. DMIL has a dementia plus several other painful chronic conditions, and she could be very difficult/demanding; she would refuse to shower, and is doubly incontinent.

And there she remains, nearly two years later. After 10 months, it was clear that DMIL was in much better health because she had company and was properly fed, clean and coaxed into taking her medication, but her savings were running out so her house was sold. It was the only sensible thing to do: we live 350 miles away, and DSisIL was being run ragged. But DSIL is depending on inheriting something from DMIL to put a roof over her own head in retirement. As she is a carer anyway, she's not going to be able to save much (unless the pay soars). We have to hope DMIL will slip away peacefully but at £50k per year and rising, there won't be much left for sister-in-law if she lives another five years.

TableFlowerss · 25/10/2021 15:47

@HoldingTheDoor

I think the reality is, some people will be thinking about the monetary value they will lose is they have to pay for fees….

People can’t always proclaim they are so caring when sometimes there are ulterior motives…..

I've seen that before as a carer. Including one gentleman whose relative bought him the bare minimum of food and the very cheapest to the extent that we carers were buying him food from our own meagre salaries to supplement it and so that he could enjoy the occasional treat.(And yes there was more than sufficient money available for his needs but his relative didn't care)

I can very much believe it. I know a daughter of a very elderly woman who lived about 2.5 hours away and her 88 year old mother was constantly ringing the next door neighbour to help get her up, dressed, toilet etc…

The daughter was just ‘She’ll be fine…’ and social services were no help as ultimately the neighbour (my family member) was helping so much.

That daughter has a lot to answer for. I believe she was thinking about the inheritance she would lose on care fees. Disgusting

Vbree · 25/10/2021 15:43

I'd rather die than go into a home or be a burden on my children.

HoldingTheDoor · 25/10/2021 15:43

I think the reality is, some people will be thinking about the monetary value they will lose is they have to pay for fees….

People can’t always proclaim they are so caring when sometimes there are ulterior motives…..

I've seen that before as a carer. Including one gentleman whose relative bought him the bare minimum of food and the very cheapest to the extent that we carers were buying him food from our own meagre salaries to supplement it and so that he could enjoy the occasional treat.(And yes there was more than sufficient money available for his needs but his relative didn't care)

TableFlowerss · 25/10/2021 15:39

@eeyore228

My cousins DM was diagnosed with dementia. Their family made an arrangement whereby no care homes would be used and her children would care for her. Her kids don't even live in the same country!! What they actually meant was to leave the neighbours to deal with any problems, because they promised her they wouldn't use a care home. Totally unsafe and unfair on everyone involved. People need to be a bit more sensible about their options
It’s often made out that families that care for their parents are doing purely from an altruistic perspective and that anyone that wouldn’t be able to do is, is done cold hearted.

I think the reality is, some people will be thinking about the monetary value they will lose is they have to pay for fees….

People can’t always proclaim they are so caring when sometimes there are ulterior motives…..

bestcattoyintheworld · 25/10/2021 15:35

The Daily Mail are totally hysterical about ageing and death related matters. They campaigned successfully to do away with The Liverpool Care Pathway, being totally unable to differentiate between its utilisation within care homes vs NHS hospitals - which is where the problems lay. I never saw it misused within care home settings and I was involved in countless pathway cases where people died peacefully and with no pain or distress.

Now, GPs are too unwilling to prescribe decent doses of morphine so palliative patients are dying in severe pain and distress. The Daily Mail have now got it in for midazolam (a sedative used in palliative care, which relaxes and relieves distress and agitation).

I would imagine their core readership is of an older demographic, so they should be careful what they wish for. Compulsory forced life for everyone, no matter how awful and degraded your existence is.

The Daily Mail is the Dunning Kruger phenomenon in the form of a rag newspaper. Fuck all of them.

BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 15:25

@eeyore228

My cousins DM was diagnosed with dementia. Their family made an arrangement whereby no care homes would be used and her children would care for her. Her kids don't even live in the same country!! What they actually meant was to leave the neighbours to deal with any problems, because they promised her they wouldn't use a care home. Totally unsafe and unfair on everyone involved. People need to be a bit more sensible about their options
Bloody hell! What on earth happened? Poor woman, not safe at all.
eeyore228 · 25/10/2021 15:02

My cousins DM was diagnosed with dementia. Their family made an arrangement whereby no care homes would be used and her children would care for her. Her kids don't even live in the same country!! What they actually meant was to leave the neighbours to deal with any problems, because they promised her they wouldn't use a care home. Totally unsafe and unfair on everyone involved. People need to be a bit more sensible about their options

Namenic · 25/10/2021 14:54

I’ve seen lots of different cases of different care needs and different approaches to it. It was part of my job, so I do speak from experience. Different cultures tended to have different behaviours as a whole, but there were British people who also came and visited frequently, did a lot of care/helping too.

It also depends on the elderly person. Some will refuse and then it is v difficult to help and can be more difficult for those closest. But there were problems even for people who needed relatively minor care as they were far away from relatives.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 25/10/2021 14:22

Quite.

BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 13:47

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Scary thread. Seems like euthanasia will become compulsory in our time.

Where did this come from?

It's only a few posters on MN talking about it, and no one has ever mentioned anything compulsory?

Why are are creating drama where there is one?

The cynic in me says it's so that whichever news site picks the thread up, can publish a shrieking headline which says that Mumsnet users support compulsory euthanasia of the elderly because they cannot be bothered to care for their relatives...
ChardonnaysPetDragon · 25/10/2021 13:34

none

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 25/10/2021 13:34

Scary thread. Seems like euthanasia will become compulsory in our time.

Where did this come from?

It's only a few posters on MN talking about it, and no one has ever mentioned anything compulsory?

Why are are creating drama where there is one?

BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 13:27

My sister, who lived a 6 hour drive away and so visited far less often, was able to be much tougher than I was - it was a case of, ‘Come on, you need a shower - you smell!’ (She did.)
There would be tears and tantrums, but they were soon forgotten (one advantage of dementia!) and I’m sure she must have felt better afterwards.

This is a small advantage that I have - because I am only there every other week, rather than every day. I can use a mixture of cajoling and firmness ('sorry Mum but you are starting to smell so you need to wash! Let's use the nice shampoo I bought you'). Without fail she always says she feels better afterwards - it's just getting her in there that can be a battle!

CatsArePeople · 25/10/2021 13:26

Scary thread. Seems like euthanasia will become compulsory in our time.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/10/2021 13:21

Maverickess, I think the care home staff’s uniforms may have had something to do with it - made them resemble nurses. Plus, while DM was still at home, although her dementia was pretty bad before she moved to the care home, she still knew very well who we all were, and presumably didn’t like her children bossing her about (as she evidently saw it.)

My sister, who lived a 6 hour drive away and so visited far less often, was able to be much tougher than I was - it was a case of, ‘Come on, you need a shower - you smell!’ (She did.)
There would be tears and tantrums, but they were soon forgotten (one advantage of dementia!) and I’m sure she must have felt better afterwards.

BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 13:08

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER yes, there is a real art and skill to caring for people with dementia - and particularly providing them with personal care.

BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 13:06

@winnieanddaisy

I'm a retired nurse .My DM and DF cared for my DGM in their home for the last 3 months of her her life . DF died suddenly but my DD and I nursed my mother in her home through her cancer . I also cared for her 2nd DH at home through cancer . I'm certain that my DD will care for me as and when I need it . In my family this is what we do . May I also say the the district nurses were fabulous in all these situations and will provide everything you need to care for your loved ones .
Good for you - and I mean that genuinely.

Your point about district nurses is completely inaccurate though. I suspect what you mean is that in your experience and with your relatives' needs the district nurses were able to provide support.

I can tell you from MY experience that our district nurse - who is lovely, professional, supportive and caring, does NOT provide everything that we need to care for my DM. That's not her fault - it's because my DM's care needs far exceed what can be provided by a district nurse, and my DM is by no means the only person in that position. I find it a little strange that someone with nursing experience wouldn't realise that...

OverTheRubicon · 25/10/2021 13:01

@winnieanddaisy

I'm a retired nurse .My DM and DF cared for my DGM in their home for the last 3 months of her her life . DF died suddenly but my DD and I nursed my mother in her home through her cancer . I also cared for her 2nd DH at home through cancer . I'm certain that my DD will care for me as and when I need it . In my family this is what we do . May I also say the the district nurses were fabulous in all these situations and will provide everything you need to care for your loved ones .
How on earth can district nurses provide 'everything you need to care for your loved ones' when that can include 2 person hoists, dealing with severe depression or dementia, or a loved one who needs help with every meal and every toilet trip when you also have a job, young kids, and the pittance that is carer allowance would leave you in poverty?

District nurses can be wonderful but they are also vastly overstretched, they are not care support.

winnieanddaisy · 25/10/2021 12:27

I'm a retired nurse .My DM and DF cared for my DGM in their home for the last 3 months of her her life . DF died suddenly but my DD and I nursed my mother in her home through her cancer . I also cared for her 2nd DH at home through cancer .
I'm certain that my DD will care for me as and when I need it . In my family this is what we do .
May I also say the the district nurses were fabulous in all these situations and will provide everything you need to care for your loved ones .

RosesAndHellebores · 25/10/2021 12:15

Going against the grain here. There is no way I shall look after my mother. For 61 years I have done nothing to please her and if she had some capacity and mobility that would not change and our relationship would become entirely vitriolic.

When/If she is no longer able to look after herself she will go into a care home or have round the clock carers. Money is not an issue. My grannie looked after her mother, my mother looked after hers - solely. G grannie and grannie did an enormous amount for their daughters and loved them unconditionally. My mother never did.

Maverickess · 25/10/2021 11:52

[quote BackBackBack]@Maverickess I don't either. I tend to find that people with no experience of the social care system for the elderly are the ones who expect miracles ("when X needs care we'll get the professionals in"). Only to have a rude awakening when the time comes, about the cost and limitations attached to the care system! I really wish that people could spend a week working alongside these carers and see the reality of the system.

I'm not defending it - and people should be cared for properly and appropriately. But if the system isn't funded, and the staff aren't valued and instead are constantly overworked and overstretched, then the fact is that people won't get the care that they need.

And as a previous poster said upthread, those with the financial resources to pay for good quality care will be OK - and those who don't will suffer. The irony being that care-work often only pays NMW or slightly above, so all of those doing the care work now know what lies in their future because they won't be able to afford to pay privately for quality care - which is a further lack of incentive to work as a carer![/quote]
Yes to all of this, especially your last paragraph! I worry about it, I haven't had the opportunity to buy a home or save a substantial amount to pay for my care - and then you get told it's because you can't be bothered to do better 🙈 but where are we now with a lack of carers? If nothing else it's highlighting the fact that people rely on these services to look after their loved ones so they can 'do better'.
I do feel all this talk about assisted dying, whilst it's a conversation that needs to be had, yet again avoids the issue about the realities of the social care system and how it's failing. "It won't affect me because I'll take myself off to dignitas" doesn't address the issues present, and it doesn't get the care to those who need it now.
I think part of this current crisis is that carers have started to refuse to take the blame any more for the whole system, they're worn out and rather than digging deeper when demanded to (because there's nothing left) to bail the system out yet again, they're leaving because they have a choice at the moment, and that's causing this crisis we're facing around social care or rather lack of it.

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

As I said, it's probably easier in a care home setting to persuade compliance, and there's the institution feel alongside that too, uniforms, equipment etc that possibly leans expectations on people because they're in an environment they're not in control of. But, we're supposed to be moving away from that style of care, and giving choices and observing rights. I have good relationships with many that I work with, I can gain compliance where others can't in some cases, but I do feel at times they're doing it because they see me as an 'authority' which doesn't seem quite right, and not in line with the person centred care I'm trained to deliver, but, I'll take it because it means the person gets the care they need with minimal issues for everyone!

Conversely, it also assumes that people want to be independent, which often isn't the case. I get told a fair amount that I should be doing whatever I'm asked of by someone because they pay - even when they're capable of doing something themselves, there's a real 'customer service' vibe emerging in care, and that's at odds with promoting independence and the levels of staff available to provide care. You or I may think that you wouldn't be dependent on someone if you didn't have to be, but the reality sometimes is that if they're paying for their care, they want their monies worth.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/10/2021 11:18

@BackBackBack, I have to say that my DM’s (dementia only) care home was amazing at getting personal care done. While she was still at home it was a nightmare trying to get her to have a shower and wash her hair - usually I just gave up, to avoid the tears and tantrums. Her hair would smell, that horrible, unwashed smell, and she frequently wore grubby or plain dirty clothes and would get cross and grumpy if asked to change. She had formerly been very fastidious, but that’s dementia for you.

Once in the care home she was always nicely dressed, with nice clean hair. All the residents were the same. How they managed it I have no idea! It was an Abbeyfield home, in case anyone would like to know, and although by no means the most expensive, it was extremely good.,

BackBackBack · 25/10/2021 10:51

@Maverickess I don't either. I tend to find that people with no experience of the social care system for the elderly are the ones who expect miracles ("when X needs care we'll get the professionals in"). Only to have a rude awakening when the time comes, about the cost and limitations attached to the care system! I really wish that people could spend a week working alongside these carers and see the reality of the system.

I'm not defending it - and people should be cared for properly and appropriately. But if the system isn't funded, and the staff aren't valued and instead are constantly overworked and overstretched, then the fact is that people won't get the care that they need.

And as a previous poster said upthread, those with the financial resources to pay for good quality care will be OK - and those who don't will suffer. The irony being that care-work often only pays NMW or slightly above, so all of those doing the care work now know what lies in their future because they won't be able to afford to pay privately for quality care - which is a further lack of incentive to work as a carer!

Swipe left for the next trending thread