Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why I’m working for £9.20 an hour

138 replies

Dragula333 · 22/10/2021 22:00

Care work, it’s chronically poorly paid but I know there are still care companies paying £10/11 an hour.

I have a degree and a Master’s, not that it makes me any better but I just feel I should and could be on a higher wage. It’s an important and very rewarding job, and I do like it but I’m starting to feel like a fool.

So many places pay better, Aldi, Amazon etc.
Would you accept this wage ?

OP posts:
Thehogfatherstolemycurry · 23/10/2021 00:09

Depends on what you're getting out of the job that isn't monetary.
I work in a preschool for £9.20 an hour. It's exhausting both physically and mentally. I often do my paperwork eg planning and observations at home unpaid. I'm perminantly knackered tbh.
I have a level 3 qualification as an early years educator plus a degree in social policy and education. I could earn much more I guess and lord knows my husband and even my boss repeatedly tell me I am wasted there and could do so much better however I love my job. I love each and every child in my care. I love watching them develop, I get so much from it. Also I work termtime and have been able to spend every holiday with my own children which is worth more to me than money.
I guess you have to weigh up what else the job gives you apart from a wage. If its not worth it for you then it's time to look for something else.

Merryoldgoat · 23/10/2021 00:08

@Glenthebattleostrich

It's more than i earn as a childminder!
That’s disingenuous. You can have more than 1 child, pick your hours and plan your day as you please.

My CM had 3 children full time and therefore got £19.50 per hour.

carehomeowner · 23/10/2021 00:07

I have NC. I own a care home. I want to start my confirming that Carers are massively underpaid. However, to assume that it’s all the fault of the care home owners is not true. I own a care home because I love what I do…. Or did before the pandemic. I also cover shifts - night shifts, cleaning, cooking. What ever needs to be done.

What the Local Authority pays me per week for some residents only covers 60percent of my salary bill for all staff. The weekly rates have been increased just 2% over a 5 year period.
I would love to be able to pay more but I can’t. I pay above minimum wage and have no zero hour contracts. But I can’t compete with what some supermarkets pay.

If I am full I make a profit. If I am not full I make a loss. Small privately owned care homes are generally not some money making cash cow. Small care home owners generally work really really hard for minimal profit. They do it, like carers, because they love what they do.

Don’t tar all care home owners with the same brush, we don’t all make massive profits, I work every single day, I’ve never ever worked as hard as I do right now. Like my staff I will be working this weekend, I will be in on Christmas Day. I don’t believe that I can own a business and lead a team if I have not actually done every single job that carers are expected to to.

Local authorities need to have the budgets to be be able to pay for the true cost of care. Then carers can be paid what they deserve. Massive social care reform is required. That costs money and taxes need to be raised (not national insurance) but the majority of the public don’t actually want to pay more and just believe that the cost of care is too high. I can promise you it is not.

Apologies I won’t reply now as I am off to bed…. As I will be caring in the morning.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/10/2021 00:06

Have you considered working as an independent/private carer?

Having navigated the hell that is agency managed "care" in recent years more than once I found that the agency provision was charged out at 20-25ukp per hour, visits were rarely the same carer for more than a few days running making any kind of client relationship impossible, visits were carved into minimal length and in 3hr windows and the carers were run ragged.

I thought going privately would cost more but was desperate for better care options after a week of "breakfast" and "lunch" visits being combined into one visit (so effectively only one meal as well).

We found private carers who worked independently and had all the DBS checks/insurance you would expect. They both charged £14 per hour which was the standard rate in the area for independents. I was astonished as we were expecting to pay more. Both were adamant that for the type of care needed this was the rate and was near double what they had been paid in the agency sector. Both had left agency work for exactly the reasons you described - too much work, too fragmented, difficulty getting to know clients. As independents they could ensure they saw the same clients at the same time every day, build a relationship, manage their own workload and have much more job satisfaction. It was also more money (even with the business overheads) but that wasn't the key reason for going independent.

wallysally · 23/10/2021 00:05

@Sequin4Bag567 Yy my dh has no degree and earns approx 80k a year. Plus bonus, health insurance and 2-3% raise each year!

shinynewapple21 · 22/10/2021 23:57

It all depends on how much you need the money really .

I would rather earn £9 an hour where I got job satisfaction than £10 per hour where I didn't . But I'm not struggling financially .

I would think that there are other options open to you with your qualifications though .

mrsfollowill · 22/10/2021 23:56

I'm very deflated reading this thread- I'm a team leader working for the local council. My hourly rate works out at £12.00 an hour. My direct reports earn £9.63 an hour- I have 8 staff but am often responsible for 25 in total. When I started this job it was relatively well paid - £16K early 90's. It's a joke now really. We work in finance- get abuse and threats daily- talked 2 customers down from suicide in the past few weeks as well as dealing with the staff 'issues' - I have 2 members of staff who have awful mental health problems (not work related but dreadful personal issues) . I cannot stand how devalued some jobs have become- Have nurses/careworkers in the family and it is utterly shocking how low wages are. Close family member has spent last 30 yrs working at secure mental health facility- full of 'mad not bad' prisoners and been injured many times. Awful situation and I hope to god wages increase soon for everyone in public service /care jobs.

Willow231 · 22/10/2021 23:54

Op I understand how you feel. I work in a nursery and I don't even earn £9 an hour. I love my job and my kiddies but it can be tough going sometimes and I feel I put in so much heart and effort for so little pay, long hours and shit holidays. It's disheartening as our role is essential and important.

BungleandGeorge · 22/10/2021 23:54

A staff nurse is only on £13-16 an hour so realistically you’re unlikely to be paid much more than you are currently. Your masters degree is irrelevant to your current job so as people have suggested if you want better pay I’d try and look for something which will use both skills such as special schools (maybe a residential one?). Or possibly look at agency work or being self employed as a home carer.

RubyJam · 22/10/2021 23:41

@Fairyliz

But surely you knew the wage when you applied? Why did you not apply for graduate jobs?
This Why go on about having a degree if you haven’t used it ?

Caring is an amazing rewarding job if your heart is in it

atee · 22/10/2021 23:40

@Porcupineintherough

No I dont think I would, that's horrifically bad. Sad Do you happen to know what your clients pay per hour? We pay £19/hr to the agency for my dad, I'd hope to God the carer sees a good chunk of that.
" I'd hope to God the carer sees a good chunk of that."

Under 50% for sure. I think the average for care workers in the UK is about £9 per hour. So a few are paid more, most are paid much less, £8.50 ish I imagine.

I know a few carehome owners locally.

New cars for all the family every year.

Minimum of 6 weeks (paid of course) overseas each year.

Max of a couple of hours of "work" each week.

Restaurant or high end take out daily, and for lunch usually.

The nurses and customers are being ripped off in almost all cases I have seen or heard of.

The assited living flats places are better value, but only for mobile and non-dementia people sadly.

Nat6999 · 22/10/2021 23:37

I think carers should be paid at least £20 an hour knowing some of the things they have to do & the fact that home carers only get paid the time they are in a client's home, not the time travelling between carers. Anyone who doesn't think they should be paid £20 an hour should try doing the job for a year, they will soon change their minds. Carers keep ill, disabled & elderly people out of hospital & care homes & must save the NHS & Social Care service millions each year & should be treated as a valuable commodity.

Porcupineintherough · 22/10/2021 23:36

@Zotter I will ask her but I expect you are right. Sad We did try and employ someone direct at first but couldn't find anyone suitable. He only needs 5x 1 hour a week at this point which I guess isnt a very attractive package of work.

ShaneTheThird · 22/10/2021 23:33

I'm on £8.91 an hour in retail. When I was a carer years ago I was on £6 an hour it's a disgrace.

NowEvenBetter · 22/10/2021 23:32

There’s no need for anyone today to be sad about shit pay. Quit. Labourers have their pick of jobs at the minute, employers exploiting us for poverty wages deserve to be discarded and ridiculed.

Zotter · 22/10/2021 23:28

We pay £19/hr to the agency for my dad, I'd hope to God the carer sees a good chunk of that.

Probably not. An agency charges me £17 an hour, the carer gets £9 an hour. I asked a carer. I only use the agency for holiday cover. Think staff are exploited.

sweetkitty · 22/10/2021 23:27

It’s disgusting how little we value care work in this country, people who care for our young, elderly and vulnerable seem to get paid very little. The classroom assistants in our school are very poorly paid (special needs) it’s a demanding job and they would get more in Tesco they stay because of the term time hours and because they love the children.

Dancerinthedark01 · 22/10/2021 23:24

Have you considered working in special needs schools? Where I am there has been an appeal for any teachers to come forward to support these schools due to massive staff shortages.

@Stickyblue1987 what qualifications do you need to be a teacher or teaching assistant in special needs schools?

I want to do this and have similar qualifications to OP - but was under the impression that you needed to do a specialist training course. Is that true?

Babyroobs · 22/10/2021 23:19

Gosh that sounds difficult. My dd has just landed a job cleaning at her school and is going to be paid £9.20 per hor. She turned 16 in June. My wages don't work out to much more then this though and the job is emotionally draining dealing with one terminally ill person atter another.

TatianaBis · 22/10/2021 23:18

How old are you and what is your previous work history? Given your qualifications why are you looking at minimum wage jobs?

Care work is one of the very hardest jobs in the world and one of the least well paid.

Chakraleaf · 22/10/2021 23:17

I get min wage when I am with the agency and then they charge the clients about 30ph and I get a tiny wage :(

fashionSOS · 22/10/2021 23:16

In my experience, people only accept low wages if:

  • They cannot get any higher wage elsewhere; and/or
  • The job they are doing feels like a calling, and it's incredibly rewarding.

They earn more than you, but for example, junior doctors aren't paid nearly as much as the general public thinks they are, and they have horrific conditions. They only accept them because medicine feels like a calling - they could get paid more to do other jobs, but they feel drawn to the role.

The question therefore is, how much do you love what you do? Enough to put up with this wage?

And if you don't love it enough... can you get a better job? Have you looked?

NowEvenBetter · 22/10/2021 23:14

Even when I had a job that I hated and was applying for loads of others, I wouldn’t ever consider applying for a carer job, or go back to hospitality. Such shit industries need to value their workers, until they choose to do that, they don’t deserve our labour.
(Got a WFH job £11ph, paid time off, pension, bonuses.)

Cheeseontoastwithchopsauce · 22/10/2021 23:14

My DD is a Deputy Manager for a care company, she's been in Care for 10 years, she's on a salary and has just done 4 17hour days on the trot she's demoting herself on Monday and is going over to Bank Staff plus looking to join the NHS to work in a Surgery/Clinic/Hospital where there's more structure. Those that own Care Homes/Companies are just lining their pockets on the backs of the Carers that are slogging their guts out for mininum wage.

Wbeezer · 22/10/2021 23:14

Yes I have a Masters and work for £9.50/hour but it's a much easier job than caring.