Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why I’m working for £9.20 an hour

138 replies

Dragula333 · 22/10/2021 22:00

Care work, it’s chronically poorly paid but I know there are still care companies paying £10/11 an hour.

I have a degree and a Master’s, not that it makes me any better but I just feel I should and could be on a higher wage. It’s an important and very rewarding job, and I do like it but I’m starting to feel like a fool.

So many places pay better, Aldi, Amazon etc.
Would you accept this wage ?

OP posts:
BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 23/10/2021 08:01

@Pythonista

Why not move to a better paying job then?
This.

I don't really understand.

MissyB1 · 23/10/2021 08:00

@eekbumbler

To me, someone of a certain age with a degree and a masters = has never done a days work in their life. The eternal student.

Graduates are 10 a penny, companies want people with experience.

And although you say you are well suited to the work, clearly you aren't as it is a vocation.

It’s not a bloody “vocation” it’s a job!! A job that should be much more highly valued by society than it is. People who insinuate that if caters, nurses etc.. are unhappy with their wages then they shouldn’t be in the job, are a massive part of the problem.
trappedsincesundaymorn · 23/10/2021 07:48

I have just resigned from my job as an Outreach support worker for vulnerable deaf adults. I was a keyworker for 5 people. The job involved driving around 400 miles a week as the company was the only service available in the whole of the region. I worked 1 day in the office which was the only time I had to update reports, deal with social workers, etc. I also worked every other weekend and every Bank Holiday. For all that stress and responsibility I was paid £8.91 an hour. When I handed in my notice the manager took me aside and asked if I would stay if I was paid more. I said I would so they offered me £9.00 an increase of 9p. Next week I start work in a factory watching a machine. It's going to be boring but for that boring job, with no responsibility I am going to be paid £10.61 an hour.
I loved my job and felt incredibly guilty about leaving those people that needed support, but just loving the job is not enough. I need to pay bills, I need to eat and I need some sort of social life. My contracted hours were 40 a week but most weeks I would be working between 45 -50 with no pay for the hours over, we could take TOIL but being so short staffed it was impossible to do that as there was no cover available.
Until the social care sector is seen by the "powers that be" as a job and not just something that people (mainly women), do because they "enjoy helping others" then it will never change. People want carers to be paid more and treated better, but you have have to look at the reaction to the NI increases to see that when it comes down to it they don't want it that much.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 23/10/2021 06:44

I earn £9.50 an hour. I'm not educated past GCSE level and my job is a piece of piss and very flexible. I'm happy with that wage considering the nature of the job and my lack of qualifications.

Carers are chronically underpaid, I think £9.20ph for that type of work is shocking.

GlamorousHeifer · 23/10/2021 05:35

I've been working in care for the last few months (tbf it was only ever going to be something to keep the bills paid until I found something else I wanted to do)
For minimum wage I deal with medication (ordering and giving it), finances, cooking, cleaning (a lot of cleaning!) and if that wasn't enough we are mentally and physically abused by the people we care for on a daily basis. When I hear people talking about what a rewarding job it is I shrivel inside, I don't consider a job where I am barely paid enough to keep my family fed rewarding.
The other problem with care work is that it is almost expected that you are prepared to give your life up to be available for work (you need to have epically strong boundaries not to do this as the guilt trips management pull are unbelievable) so for example I was asked to go into work, I told management I couldn't as I was out that day with family, it was actually suggested that I call everyone and rearrange my plans for a more suitable date! It was already suitable as it was my scheduled day off but that is the mentality.
Anyway, I could go on (and on) about the ridiculous state of social care but as of next month I will be leaving and starting my role as a Sales Executive, I won't lie, I'm not going to miss anything about this job.

cafenoirbiscuit · 23/10/2021 03:58

I’ve sent you a PM

Nat6999 · 23/10/2021 03:57

Have you thought about being a personal assistant for a disabled adult or child? The job entails more than the stuff you do as a carer, you would help with everything including enabling the client to have a social life, taking them to appointments, helping with shopping cleaning & cooking, you become a friend as well.

eekbumbler · 23/10/2021 03:30

To me, someone of a certain age with a degree and a masters = has never done a days work in their life. The eternal student.

Graduates are 10 a penny, companies want people with experience.

And although you say you are well suited to the work, clearly you aren't as it is a vocation.

malificent7 · 23/10/2021 02:43

Carer here...temporary before I stsrt my nhs role. Mind you, I calculated that from my graduate starting salary and it's £14 ph for a highly technical role yet caring role. ( radiography)which i trained 3 years for.
Im getting 10.50 for caring through an agency op.

The best paid jobs are banking, drug dealing and arms dealing!

NCForthisxox · 23/10/2021 02:23

I did agency care I've worked all over I'm now a student nurse . I think private care homes, working with the elderly is the worst money for the hardest amount of work. Your staffing ratios are painfully low , if you can look for an agency you can do a 1:1 shift in a nursing for around £13 per hour. Learning disability supported living is also much better you will be paid the same less likely to put your back out and you get to go on fun trips out.
Even forensic mental health is much easier physically than an elderly care home it's all down to the low staffing look at specialist units for work.

Lockdownbear · 23/10/2021 02:02

@Bellyups

A little off-subject, but it’s so worrying that Carers earn so little for such an important job
Yes, and it's a good reason why Care Homes should be public not private sector. The money for Care should be spent on the people.
Bellyups · 23/10/2021 01:50

A little off-subject, but it’s so worrying that Carers earn so little for such an important job

blueberrymuffin88 · 23/10/2021 01:50

''You do realise that it's perfectly normal for people with masters degrees to be in badly paid jobs? I work in a shop for £9.50 per hour, and every member of staff under 50 has a postgraduate degree apart from the summer temps who are students''

THIS!! I'm so shocked at the number of people saying 'well just look for a better paying job'. That's all very well, but someone has to care for our elderly and disabled while we all work 40+ hours a week to contribute to the holy GDP. Would you rather those people be educated, dedicated and well paid or overworked, underpaid, under-appreciated and desperate to find other work?
Can't help but think the reason behind the shocking pay is because it's 'women's work'

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 23/10/2021 01:09

Bold fail :(

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 23/10/2021 01:09

*In my experience, people only accept low wages if:

  • They cannot get any higher wage elsewhere; and/or
  • The job they are doing feels like a calling, and it's incredibly rewarding.*
Your experience is limited. There are many reasons why a perfectly capable employee is restricted in hours, travel or accessibility. Many companies don't want to make accommodation for extra needs. And some are prejudiced against protected characteristics but disguise it.
Lalliella · 23/10/2021 01:04

I totally admire you to be doing a job as a carer. It’s such an important job and so valuable to society. I think it’s absolutely shocking how badly paid it is. What use do highly paid jobs such as investment brokers and bankers have to society really? This country values money too much and not the things that truly matter.

me4real · 23/10/2021 01:01

@Dragula333 Could you go into some involvement with SEN? I know someone who did it and you can still get a good salary but without some of the unpleasantness of teaching.

I'm sure there's something well paid you could get of some kind with your degree etc.

me4real · 23/10/2021 00:57

There's an interesting debate to be had about what constitutes "responsibility" though. Someone gets paid thousands and thousands of pounds for the "responsibility" of managing finance, but the "responsibility" for a dementia patient's whole life is not considered worth much in monetary terms. Indicative of society's values.....

@MeanderingGently It's more that more people are capable of the actions of basic care work (in theory!) than are capable of being a financial manager. So people doing the role of care workers are relatively easily replaced, and people in the jobs tend to have few alternatives, so they can be paid little and still have to stick around.

me4real · 23/10/2021 00:53

when I say minimum wage I mean what the govt call the 'living wage' of course. That was agency work. They really took the piss with the hours they wanted me to work, too. This was less than a decade ago so I imagine it's much the same, except we weren't paid for travel between calls then- I know there was discssion about fixing that.

MeanderingGently · 23/10/2021 00:53

I agree that care workers are poorly paid, and for what they do, they should be paid more and be appreciated more.

Having said that, many people earn very little in jobs which are very hard work. But of course you could earn more in a different job. Having a Masters or other qualifications doesn't guarantee you extra money; however, it does provide you with choice....the choice to go elsewhere else or do something different, a choice which those without qualifications don't have.

I also have good qualifications. In the past I have held highly paid positions, sometimes in management. But now I earn £9 per hour in a job which is quite physical in nature but which holds little responsibility. Yes, I could earn more but the point is that I have chosen not to. At my time of life, I no longer want the positions or responsibility I took on when I was younger, I just want to go to work, do the job and then go home. That's the trade off for the low pay.

There's an interesting debate to be had about what constitutes "responsibility" though. Someone gets paid thousands and thousands of pounds for the "responsibility" of managing finance, but the "responsibility" for a dementia patient's whole life is not considered worth much in monetary terms. Indicative of society's values.....

YourWinter · 23/10/2021 00:39

When I did care work 30 years ago, agency staff earned a much higher hourly rate than the staff employed by the care home. I switched to agency and enjoyed going to lots of different settings, including NHS hospital wards. I suppose you don't build up the same relationships with those you're caring for, nor the teams you're working with, unless you get regular placements in the same setting. Even bank staff at the local hospital get a higher rate than you're getting and again, my friend who does bank loves experiencing so many different areas of the hospital.

I earn £9.63 per hour working PT in a supermarket, with pension scheme, staff discount and other benefits. I really enjoy it and may well continue on reduced hours when I reach pension age next year.

me4real · 23/10/2021 00:21

I was on minimum wage when I did care work OP, as are many. (I have a 1st from a good university- it's not relevant if you're wiping arses really.)

A lot of people are leaving the sector as it's a lot of stressful and grim work for little pay.

It's your duty to make your life the best it can be, so if you want a different life, try it.

As companies realise some carers have other options, the wage may go up. But there are probably actually plenty of women with few options that they can exploit.

RicherThanYew · 23/10/2021 00:20

I don't know about the amounts paid to care homes nationally but I work for a care company in South Wales and our carers earn 8.91 per hour because the council pay us 12.15 per hour for Direct Payments and we have to fund their training, uniform, sick pay, mat leave and annual leave plus insurance. I'm not happy with how little we pay them (I earn the same) but until a higher value is placed on care work by society, I can't see it changing.

like7 · 23/10/2021 00:19

Relative moved from hospitality to home carer4 months ago as wanted to feel was doing a more worthwhile job - so tough. Always rushing in car to keep to times and so many road works. (in London) Paid 30p/mile petrol but hardly covers extra car insurance needed. etc. Now found out will be doing usual shifts Saturday (7am - 10pm) and Sunday (7am- 4pm) on Christmas Day and Boxing day and will get usual £9.50/hr. Would have got £15/hr if worked the Bank Holidays Monday 27th and Tuesday 28th but they are their days off -. It's been the final straw missing nearly all of Christmas and feels so unappreciated by employwr and planning to give notice in to finish on Christmas Eve. Going to apply for supermarket work instead as far less stressful and better pay. Such a shame.

Vivana · 23/10/2021 00:13

A company I worked for thought it was fine paying £8.91 pH for night shifts. That was a 10 bed home with 2 members of staff on at night supporting adults with learning difficulties. I soon left and found much better paid job