Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why I’m working for £9.20 an hour

138 replies

Dragula333 · 22/10/2021 22:00

Care work, it’s chronically poorly paid but I know there are still care companies paying £10/11 an hour.

I have a degree and a Master’s, not that it makes me any better but I just feel I should and could be on a higher wage. It’s an important and very rewarding job, and I do like it but I’m starting to feel like a fool.

So many places pay better, Aldi, Amazon etc.
Would you accept this wage ?

OP posts:
Chakraleaf · 23/10/2021 10:48

People saying to get another job. I have applied for loads!

Thehop · 23/10/2021 10:42

I have a relevant degree and 20 years experience. Have just left a private nursery where I was room manager on minimum wage plus 5p an hour.

Some jobs will never pay a salary that reflects the value of what you do sadly.

carehomeowner · 23/10/2021 10:40

@hikingforscenery

Carers pay is between 9.30 and 12.50 per hour dependent on experience and level of responsibility. In addition I pay pension, holidays etc

Residents pay on average £4.76 per hour for residential dementia care

maternitycoat · 23/10/2021 10:20

Yes move on. The ball is in your court

Employers need to increase wages in this market. You have your pick of jobs right now

OtterAndDog · 23/10/2021 09:46

You've applied for a low paid job that your over qualified for but are then are confused when you get a low paid job that you're over qualified for?

supermoonrising · 23/10/2021 09:25

Lots of teachers are doing 60-70 hours a week. When you add up the hours, even taking into account the long holidays, it still only amounts to pay of £11-12 an hour.

The brutal truth is that, when you factor in the crazily priced tiny homes and bad weather, the UK just doesn’t provide that high a quality of life for the majority of people who live there.

puddlebubble · 23/10/2021 09:20

so is your masters a teaching masters? I hear so many teachers say I have a degree and a masters. The teaching licence isn't really a masters, it's a diploma. Much the same as nursing, it really isn't a degree. It's 2 years and then some work experience which anyone with a normal degree is expected to get AFTER their 4 years of unpaid study. Doesn't really matter you are doing shit jobs and not getting into your field, Believe in yourself more. Y

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 09:16

A degree is no guarantee of a good income - and not everyone is suited to working in the field they got their education in either. I think the whole "everyone can go to university" mantra has actually caused a lot of problems - just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

I went to a top RG university and walk dogs for a living. I previously worked in retail and worked my way up into management. My degree was a total waste of time and money but I was pressured into doing it because of my good grades.

Of course the caring profession should be much better paid but it's so underfunded that I can't see it happening any time soon.

Porcupineintherough · 23/10/2021 09:05

Yes we tried direct employment (which would of course have meant that the carer was paid much more) but couldn't find anyone suitable who could do the hours we needed.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/10/2021 08:59

@Tenfifteen

Slightly odd question but is their a world where carers are directly employed by families/elderly people? I’ve experience of LA carers for elderly relatives but they change all the time and there were a fair few who just wanted any job rather than having a calling or feeling satisfied by the work - and it showed.

If I could have peace of mind about who is taking care of my loved ones then I’d pay someone directly to do that and more than £9.20. Is there a reason why people can’t do that eg do you need to be registered/ regulated etc?

Yes, we did exactly this. I've posted upthread about it but key to finding the right people quickly was local recommendations. It was vastly better experience each time and we were able to set hour visits at the same time each day, rather than the sketchy 20-30min dash offered by agencies where even that is in a "window" of over 3 hrs.
Tumbleweed101 · 23/10/2021 08:58

So many front line jobs that involve caring for people seem to be poorly paid. Such a shame as this shows, as a society, how little value we place on others.

MyMabel · 23/10/2021 08:57

I left dental nursing when I just couldn’t get above £9.50 an hour after working for nearly 7 years.

I now work at as tech support company that needed no qualifications, just experience with IT/Excel for £7k more a year.

Honestly thought it was so important to get a high degree of education but after my personal experience and thinking about my DD’s future; I won’t be disappointed if she doesn’t go to uni or get HE because the likelihood is she’ll be just fine without it.

I’m really disappointed that I wasted those years of my life so stressed and worn down just trying to get a degree for it to come down to the fact it just doesn’t pay well where I live and I don’t want to make a substantial move to a big city.

HikingforScenery · 23/10/2021 08:49

@carehomeowner

I have NC. I own a care home. I want to start my confirming that Carers are massively underpaid. However, to assume that it’s all the fault of the care home owners is not true. I own a care home because I love what I do…. Or did before the pandemic. I also cover shifts - night shifts, cleaning, cooking. What ever needs to be done.

What the Local Authority pays me per week for some residents only covers 60percent of my salary bill for all staff. The weekly rates have been increased just 2% over a 5 year period.
I would love to be able to pay more but I can’t. I pay above minimum wage and have no zero hour contracts. But I can’t compete with what some supermarkets pay.

If I am full I make a profit. If I am not full I make a loss. Small privately owned care homes are generally not some money making cash cow. Small care home owners generally work really really hard for minimal profit. They do it, like carers, because they love what they do.

Don’t tar all care home owners with the same brush, we don’t all make massive profits, I work every single day, I’ve never ever worked as hard as I do right now. Like my staff I will be working this weekend, I will be in on Christmas Day. I don’t believe that I can own a business and lead a team if I have not actually done every single job that carers are expected to to.

Local authorities need to have the budgets to be be able to pay for the true cost of care. Then carers can be paid what they deserve. Massive social care reform is required. That costs money and taxes need to be raised (not national insurance) but the majority of the public don’t actually want to pay more and just believe that the cost of care is too high. I can promise you it is not.

Apologies I won’t reply now as I am off to bed…. As I will be caring in the morning.

How much do you pay your carers per hour and how much do you receive per resident per hour, on average if you don’t mind me asking
BubblesThaDragoon · 23/10/2021 08:47

Ahh this post breaks my heart. I used to do LD support work and I absolutely loved it - so so rewarding. However I had to leave as I couldn’t manage on the money (exactly as you all point out) - I’m now earning substantially more in a boring boring job in the Civil Service.

maggienolia · 23/10/2021 08:41

Look around for different care agencies.
I work in care and get £10/HR weekdays and £11.50/HR weekends. Double time on bank holidays and Xmas.
We also get our travel time paid and mileage. We are also paid for COVID testing and having the jabs.
No half hour calls - minimum call time is an hour, so less clock watching.

And no uniform, don't miss the polyester tunics at all!

Carers can pretty well pick and choose at the moment. It will only get worse for the agencies taking LA contracts unfortunately.

mummytothree87 · 23/10/2021 08:35

I work nights as a senior and get over £12 an hour. The next step up for me is a manager role and then that's salaried but works out around 14/15 an hour. It's a lot of stress and work though as we are ridiculously low on staff at the moment and we're having to do the job of 2 people as well as our own bits. I'm currently looking at other jobs including cleaning as its about the same wage for the same if not better pay

Pinkandpink · 23/10/2021 08:34

Briony123

I don't know anyone with a degree who ever applied for jobs as carers or supermarket staff (shelf-stacking, I mean. Obviously the CTO of Tesco has a degree).
Why would you do that?
If you have opportunities and want to care, then a medical or nursing degree would be the obvious choice.

Really? I work in retail in a large warehouse. There are lots of individuals with degrees who work there. Obviously we have students at the weekends but will leave after uni, but there are also the ones who for one reason or another have degrees and are happy working there.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 23/10/2021 08:31

It’s your choice to not use the degrees and work in the area you studied for. You then can’t moan when you have accepted a job and it’s terms when that was a choice you made.

Maverickess · 23/10/2021 08:30

@eekbumbler

To me, someone of a certain age with a degree and a masters = has never done a days work in their life. The eternal student.

Graduates are 10 a penny, companies want people with experience.

And although you say you are well suited to the work, clearly you aren't as it is a vocation.

'Vocation' - word used to excuse poor pay, conditions and treatment of people who do jobs that are essential to society.
trappedsincesundaymorn · 23/10/2021 08:26

And although you say you are well suited to the work, clearly you aren't as it is a vocation

And therein lies the problem. It being a "vocation" does not justify the poor pay. It doesn't matter how well suited anybody is, if they aren't earning enough to pay the bills they will leave. calling it a "vocation" rather than a job (which ultimately that's what it is), just excuses all the crap that care workers have to put up with.

Orla1970 · 23/10/2021 08:19

Hi OP. When you posted recently about salary and rent you got loads of great advice. Have you taken any of than on? As previously said care workers salaries vary massively from organisation to organisation and whether you are in independent of public sector and depending what part of the country you are in. Look into what your local authority and NHS are paying. Every area across the UK are recruiting for carers so plenty of choice and higher salaries and better t&cs to be had. You chose to opt out of an education role where you would earn a much higher salary and your degree and masters would be used. Last post you got lots of good options where you could combine a caring role with education.

milkysmum · 23/10/2021 08:11

I'm a nurse in a residential rehabilitation and treatment trauma informed service for women who have experienced significant childhood trauma and present with severe self harming and suicidal behaviours.
Our support workers deliver lots of the interventions for the these women, are highly trained ( all hold level 3, 4 or 5 diplomas in care ) and many with psychology and health or social care related degrees.
Work frequently involves managing serious suicide attempts on shift, and completing all the requirements of admin afterwards ( care plans , risk assessments and plans etc.)
Support workers are paid £9.50 an hour.

Briony123 · 23/10/2021 08:10

I don't know anyone with a degree who ever applied for jobs as carers or supermarket staff (shelf-stacking, I mean. Obviously the CTO of Tesco has a degree).
Why would you do that?
If you have opportunities and want to care, then a medical or nursing degree would be the obvious choice.

AppleButter · 23/10/2021 08:09

Please change jobs if you can. Someone is profiting off your work (if it is private care not the NHS).

Tenfifteen · 23/10/2021 08:04

Slightly odd question but is their a world where carers are directly employed by families/elderly people? I’ve experience of LA carers for elderly relatives but they change all the time and there were a fair few who just wanted any job rather than having a calling or feeling satisfied by the work - and it showed.

If I could have peace of mind about who is taking care of my loved ones then I’d pay someone directly to do that and more than £9.20. Is there a reason why people can’t do that eg do you need to be registered/ regulated etc?