Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why I’m working for £9.20 an hour

138 replies

Dragula333 · 22/10/2021 22:00

Care work, it’s chronically poorly paid but I know there are still care companies paying £10/11 an hour.

I have a degree and a Master’s, not that it makes me any better but I just feel I should and could be on a higher wage. It’s an important and very rewarding job, and I do like it but I’m starting to feel like a fool.

So many places pay better, Aldi, Amazon etc.
Would you accept this wage ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
me4real · 26/10/2021 16:58

@Elleherd Try and get the direct payments if you haven't already, and/or employ an individual. Then advertise locally for a self-employed carer. They will have the time to do the actual hours- and will have to or they'll lose their own income as you could get someone else.

There are plenty of self-employed carers (I've been one) who will value the work and be able to take more time/effort over it.

me4real · 26/10/2021 16:52

Yes of course, I never insinuated that it was abnormal , just that I am capable of earning more

The whole think comes across a bit badly to me OP and that you think you're far above the millions of people on minimum/low wage jobs etc.

If you are then get another job suited to your lofty superior status. As you're worth so much more than millions of others it should be easy.

WhenwillSleephappen · 25/10/2021 08:02

Depends if it brings you satisfaction, enjoyment and it’s affordable for you to live on?

I gave up a better paid, but demanding career to do a less well paid, but less demanding job. I love it! Although I’ve only being doing it a few months, so I can’t guarantee it’ll be forever. Luckily we can afford the reduction of income and it’s making home life better

Elleherd · 25/10/2021 07:17

I feel I now understand why everyone want's to only talk to NOK about arrangements and not the person on the receiving end, even if they're being billed.

Dragula yes it's underpaid and under valued work. The people doing it are underpaid and undervalued, as are the people on the receiving end of it.
I may be wrong but I think while care recipients have no value other than as cash cows, it's unlikely those brought in to provide services to them, will have any either.

Elleherd · 25/10/2021 07:07

I've just canceled my home 'care package' because my underpaid, badly treated, 'carers' are passing on what's done to them, to me, and I'm just being taken advantage off by exploited people and expected to be complicit in the whole charade.

When I canceled no one asked why or any questions, and there was no surprise. (It was treated like canceling a milk delivery.)

The lack of language is a real issue, but there's no (apparent) desire to change it.

The main activity and what takes by far the longest time, is sitting and writing about what they've supposedly just done to assist. Most of it makes little sense, but things like 'help with wash', 'breakfast', and 'dinner', appear daily, but none of it's happened ever, and attempts to get those things actually happening didn't go well.

The call is for an hour, (twice a day) Generally they're in and out in between minimum 7 and max 20 mins. No one's ever stayed 30 mins.

I feel really sorry for them, because they're clearly exploited, but I'm also being exploited and my quality of life has gone down, not been maintained, or gone up.

Boopeedoop · 24/10/2021 23:32

@Porcupineintherough

No I dont think I would, that's horrifically bad. Sad Do you happen to know what your clients pay per hour? We pay £19/hr to the agency for my dad, I'd hope to God the carer sees a good chunk of that.
They won't see the majority, sorry to say.
Rivermonsters · 24/10/2021 21:29

Glad I’m not going uni after reading this

AngelDelight28 · 24/10/2021 20:02

@julieca It was just an example of the type of jobs where the pay is decent and it doesn't require going back to uni to retrain. OP could transfer to retail, starting as an assistant and working her way up to management. I know of several people who have switched from care work to retail and the pay is generally better. Of course retail might not interest the OP but was just a thought.

Flowerpowwer6 · 23/10/2021 23:56

You can apply with the NHS bank OP. Are you able to do nights and weekends? They pay a lot better.

amsadandconfused · 23/10/2021 23:54

@goose1964

Carers are totally underpaid, unfortunately a lot of owners see homes as a way to print money, look at the high spec cars they drive , where they holiday. My daughter works in care and when I saw her with my mother in law , dementia and limited mobility, I was so impressed how she managed to help her without her noticing she was being helped. She gets paid more than minimum wage, not by much, and she's starting her level 3 NVQ to work as a,senior carer.
Agree..it is absolutely shocking..care workers are lining someone’s bank account and the residents are cash cows …I feel so strongly about this ! Am a RN working in what was a lovely care home but has now been reduced to a grovel. The residents are being neglected and the carers are treated like trash !
FinallyHere · 23/10/2021 21:29

Nope.

HTH.

Stickyblue1987 · 23/10/2021 17:44

@Dancerinthedark01

*Stickyblue1987 what qualifications do you need to be a teacher or teaching assistant in special needs schools?

I want to do this and have similar qualifications to OP - but was under the impression that you needed to do a specialist training course. Is that true?*

To teach you would need a teaching degree (although some academy schools don't require this). The op says education degree but not sure if this equates to QTS? When I did my teacher training I specialised in SEN in my last year. I would not have needed additional training to work in special schools.

For TA jobs there's no specified qualifications, though experience in working with children would usually be needed.

Sloth66 · 23/10/2021 15:35

Care homes are essentially businesses, run for profit. I went for an interview at one, looked up the company and the owner was reported as living in an 8 million pound house 10 years ago. Low wages have paid for that.

Zotter · 23/10/2021 14:26

@Tenfifteen

Slightly odd question but is their a world where carers are directly employed by families/elderly people? I’ve experience of LA carers for elderly relatives but they change all the time and there were a fair few who just wanted any job rather than having a calling or feeling satisfied by the work - and it showed.

If I could have peace of mind about who is taking care of my loved ones then I’d pay someone directly to do that and more than £9.20. Is there a reason why people can’t do that eg do you need to be registered/ regulated etc?

I employ someone directly through the council’s direct payments scheme which I financially contribute to. They helped me with recruitment. One carer has been with me for 14 years. Suits me much more than agency.
Hmumoftw0 · 23/10/2021 14:19

I haven't got a comment to make on the wage sorry but just want to say if you like your job and care well for these people then carry on but find a company that pays better! Sadly their are a lot of horrible carers out their and people like yourself are rare :(

Zotter · 23/10/2021 14:16

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Zotter I will ask her but I expect you are right. Sad We did try and employ someone direct at first but couldn't find anyone suitable. He only needs 5x 1 hour a week at this point which I guess isnt a very attractive package of work.[/quote]
@Porcupineintherough, understand about the hours and difficulty ,finding someone suitable.

julieca · 23/10/2021 13:53

@AngelDelight28 most of your post is great advice. But why would OP get a job as a store manager at ALDI. She has no understanding of retail or management. Running a supermarket is a skilled job, hence the pay level.

AngelDelight28 · 23/10/2021 12:43

@eekbumbler "Vocation" is a term bandied about to exploit people's goodwill and get them to accept poor wages and conditions. There's no such thing as a vocation, there are jobs - for which people should be paid a living wage. They may enjoy their jobs, find them rewarding and enjoy helping people (so, a vocation) but that doesn't change their need to eat and pay bills.

Also, a degree and Masters involve a huge amount of work, how bizarre to claim someone who has these qualifications hasn't done a day's work Confused My Masters was a lot harder than the actual job it trained me for, which after a couple of years I could do with my eyes closed.

To answer the OP...no, I wouldn't work in care for £9.20 an hour unless I was desperate and had no other options. I think I remember one of your other threads about a similar thing...you said you struggled with the behaviour management of teaching, if I remember right. I don't know how long ago you graduated but could you apply for generic graduate schemes, the ones where they accept any degree? They usually lead to some sort of management position and are well paid. There's good money to be made in sales too, if you've got the personality for it. Retail too...the Aldi near me was advertising for store managers, £35k salary.

Insert321Data123 · 23/10/2021 12:34

This is what I've learnt over the years

Nobody is going to wave a magic wand & find you a perfect job that you will enjoy & with a great salary

It is therefore up to you, to market yourself & look for better opportunities

If you have no dependants, can you work any hours & move location eg abroad ?

I know some people who teach part time & do a totally unrelated second job

Do you have any friends or family, who can introduce you into the company that they work for ? Some companies offer a "refer a friend scheme"

Some people would suggest speaking to a career coach to help you think "outside the box"

secretbookcase · 23/10/2021 11:50

Set up a care agency. Pay the carers £13ph so you get to poach and keep the best ones.

AppleButter · 23/10/2021 11:38

Can you go to a care agency and allocated to where you are needed most? Or go self-employed but you would have extra admin and have to get your own insurance.

Maverickess · 23/10/2021 11:36

@carehomeowner

I have NC. I own a care home. I want to start my confirming that Carers are massively underpaid. However, to assume that it’s all the fault of the care home owners is not true. I own a care home because I love what I do…. Or did before the pandemic. I also cover shifts - night shifts, cleaning, cooking. What ever needs to be done.

What the Local Authority pays me per week for some residents only covers 60percent of my salary bill for all staff. The weekly rates have been increased just 2% over a 5 year period.
I would love to be able to pay more but I can’t. I pay above minimum wage and have no zero hour contracts. But I can’t compete with what some supermarkets pay.

If I am full I make a profit. If I am not full I make a loss. Small privately owned care homes are generally not some money making cash cow. Small care home owners generally work really really hard for minimal profit. They do it, like carers, because they love what they do.

Don’t tar all care home owners with the same brush, we don’t all make massive profits, I work every single day, I’ve never ever worked as hard as I do right now. Like my staff I will be working this weekend, I will be in on Christmas Day. I don’t believe that I can own a business and lead a team if I have not actually done every single job that carers are expected to to.

Local authorities need to have the budgets to be be able to pay for the true cost of care. Then carers can be paid what they deserve. Massive social care reform is required. That costs money and taxes need to be raised (not national insurance) but the majority of the public don’t actually want to pay more and just believe that the cost of care is too high. I can promise you it is not.

Apologies I won’t reply now as I am off to bed…. As I will be caring in the morning.

I've worked in small, private homes (do now) and for large, corporate style companies. Without fail, smaller and private homes have kept their staff better and provide much better actual care, though the building is often cobbled together, decor is dated and you do have to make do and mend a lot of the time. The pay and conditions are rubbish, but the actual physical support to staff is better. The larger corporate places are lovely, pretty and shiny, but they're ruthless in running the place at a profit. I saw more humanity in hospitality than I did working for large corporate homes. They are the ones dragging money out of care.
bellabasset · 23/10/2021 11:20

£20 an hour isn't a huge amount to pay for a carer. Whilst your pay is £9:20 an hour you have to factor in what you actually cost your employer. First of all you have an entitlement to 5.6 weeks holiday, the company has to pay NIC, pension contributions and fund SSP for staff. There is or should be staff training, admin and overheads.

You can and should check the CQC report on the service you work for to see the rating it has. CQC said yesterday that the shortage of care workers is a tsunami. My main criticism of the current system is that whilst the government imposes laws they don't allow for the correct funding to be put in place. In an area sadly lacking in hospital space our local hospital in Cornwall was shown on the news this morning as having 217 people medically fit to leave the hospital but there was no home care available for them. In Cornwall the high cost of housing is also a significant factor in lack of care staff.

This failure to provide adequate pay is a short sighted policy as it's massively impacting on the NHS services for everyone. Care is a profession so should be paid accordingly.

crimsonlake · 23/10/2021 10:57

Care work is very physical, not to mention the personal care they do, pay should reflect this.
You are not wrong to be unhappy with the hourly rate, but you are wrong to stick with it. Get applying for other jobs.

shinynewapple21 · 23/10/2021 10:50

@carehomeowner yes I think there is a lot of misunderstanding about running of a care home, about overheads and local authority funding .

Swipe left for the next trending thread