Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never use eBay again

90 replies

Pencilandpaper · 22/10/2021 21:55

Used to use eBay loads but haven’t sold anything for over a couple of years. I have a sofa I need to sell due to moving house, it’s branded and in excellent condition so fairly high value. I listed it very clearly as collection in person with my town.

Anyway, item ends and the winning bidder immediately messages me telling me wrap the sofa “like a newborn baby” Hmm I messaged back stating that I hadn’t included packing materials cost, so no it won’t be packaged. She then tells me it will be collected by courier on one of two days! So I reply again, saying as stated it was collection in person and I’m not sending a high value item unwrapped with a courier, nor am I staying in for two days waiting for it to be collected.

Since then I have had no end of grief trying to sort. She messaged me constantly, being very rude. I reported her but have heard nothing on my report. Whenever I try to get hold of someone at eBay, their website is like a maze - eventually you stumble on a live chat who may or may not be able to help. I tried to refund the buyer but it kept saying there was an issue with my account. Finally got through to an agent who managed to refund for me so i thought all resolved..only to find today I have been stung with final value selling fees and negative feedback from the buyer.

Aibu that eBay is such a stressful experience. I’m closing my account!

OP posts:
dottypencilcase · 23/10/2021 09:47

In the case mentioned above, I asked eBay why the buyer was entitled to a refund when they'd come and inspected the item and had taken it away. Surely if it had been damaged, they'd have refused to collect it. Any damage caused afterwards was therefore done once the table had been taken away. I was told they were entitled to a refund because they'd collected in person and they had 'sellers rights to return' but had the table been collected via courier, eBay would have rejected their claim and told them to claim compensation via the courier company. I was told the complete opposite in another case which makes it clear they don't have a clue what they're talking about.

As for negative feedback- I was left negative feedback when someone wanted to return an item and I refused, they then cut the leg off the trousers abs tried to claim they'd arrived like that! The damage increased with each message basically. eBay told me it was against their rules to leave negative feedback so they'd be removing it. Maybe they make up the rules on a call-by-call basis.

MattDamon · 23/10/2021 09:44

I would never sell anything high value on Ebay anymore. Too many chancers/scammers, plus the fees are insane.

I recently sold a laptop on Gumtree. It took 5 weeks of reposting the advert to find a serious buyer, but it was worth it. I met them at a neutral location, they examined it in person and paid cash. Anything happens after that point, not my problem.

HelplessAndLost · 23/10/2021 09:42

If the buyer arranges the courier then they are responsible for the item aren’t they?
I bought an item from a Mumsnetter and she told me to arrange the courier. I did and the item disappeared never to be seen again but the seller couldn’t be held accountable as I’d organised the courier so lost my money for that and the money for the item. Definitely won’t make that mistake again.
Very cheeky of them to presume you’re prepared to wait in for the courier though.

MandalaYogaTapestry · 23/10/2021 09:41

@dottypencilcase

I totally understand OP. I sold a beautiful, high-dining table a few months ago with a partial glass top. It went for pennies vs what I'd paid for it but I needed a more child-friendly table that wouldn't make me wince each time the DC went near it. Anyway, buyer came to collect it in a caravan (!) after examining it like they were a forensic expert. All good. Until i got an alert the next day saying they'd opened a case against me because of chips to the glass, missing xyz, scratches to the base, etc. There was no way I was accepting that table back in the condition they'd described because the table had been in near mint condition. Ebay the bastards decided in the buyers favour (they had PayPal buyer protection and eBay buyer guarantee or whatever it's called) so I was without a dining table and the paltry amount I got for it was taken away from me too! Never again!
This is disgraceful, sorry you went through it. So the buyer paid by PayPal and collected in person? Didn't ebay make them return the item to you before issuing a refund?
severusvape · 23/10/2021 09:33

I refuse courier collection and have now stated when I sell as it seems many don’t understand.

Very rude not to ask the person before buying, expecting them to package the item and wait in for the courier. Also the buyer many say the damage will be their responsibility but EBay will go in their favour and refund them.

YoungGiftedPlump · 23/10/2021 09:29

Some couriers arrive and wrap which is fine

I did once a sofa. I bought a giant roll of thick plastic used in buildings for about £8. The buyer paid

KingsleyShacklebolt · 23/10/2021 09:21

Gumtree is much better for things you want to sell locally. I've stopped using Ebay as a seller too, far too many cheeky fuckers out there.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 23/10/2021 09:07

@OooohAhhhh

Btw If it's collection you should never accept payment via eBay as it leaves a trail and you are leaving yourself wide open for a buyer to claim "Item never received" as you wouldn't have any proof of postage, because it was collection. For collection stuff you should do cash on collection only, or bank transfer. I love eBay, had my fair share of problem buyers, but haven't we all? Speak to eBay, they will refund your fees. Block her, & re list as cash on collection. Or sell via marketplace etc.
They have tried to get around this issue by now having a collection code which the buyer brings up in their phone and you scan on yours so that there is proof on eBay that they came and collected.
Shade17 · 23/10/2021 08:56

Yes, you can. People can and do. They pay by PayPal, collect the item, and then claim that the item never arrived.

That’s not how it works now.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 23/10/2021 08:33

Collection in person is because you don't want to wrap whatever it is, fanny about printing labels etc. I wouldn't be impressed with someone who tried to use a courier after buying. I can't think of many that would accept an unwrapped, unlabelled item!

KhaleesiOfChaos · 23/10/2021 08:18

I haven't used eBay since Facebook marketplace was launched. No fees, much less hassle and items are generally sold and collected within 24/48 hours. Usually always locally too.

NautaOcts · 23/10/2021 08:05

@Time40

You can't claim non arrival of collection only item

Yes, you can. People can and do. They pay by PayPal, collect the item, and then claim that the item never arrived. Ebay don't care - they always favour the buyer, and will refund. It's a known scam. I always used to put "cash on collection only" on my collect-in-person listings, but several years ago Ebay made it impossible to remove the PayPal payment option. If the PayPal option is there, people will pay by PayPal whatever the listing says.

I think there’s a new thing with a QR code or code to enter or something that verifies the item was collected.
NautaOcts · 23/10/2021 08:04

Agree that if it says collection in person and I want to use a courier (due to location or size of item) then I ask prior to bidding if they’re prepared to work with a courier.
Many will because it opens up the pool of buyers - not many people have the transport at hand for something like a sofa.

But I wouldn’t expect them to wrap a sofa - what on earth would you wrap it in? A decent courier has blankets and stuff they can put over but a sofa should be fine I would’ve thought. In fact I’ve got a lovely £150 sofa I got this way.

Piglet89 · 23/10/2021 07:56

EBay’s website is a fucking crime against organisation. Impossible to find shit on there.

THisbackwithavengeance · 23/10/2021 07:51

I have sold on ebay since the 90s on and off and have had my fair share of chancers.

My most recent was a job lot of 5 pairs of trousers. Nothing special, just Next, Dorothy Perkins etc. Couldn't be bothered to list individually just wanted rid. Sold for a tenner, so bargain right? Buyer then opened a case to say that they were in bad condition so to shut her up, I gave her half her money back. By this time I have lost money so I am pissed off but hey ho...

I then checked her account a few days later. She has individually listed all my trousers as being in VGC. Now she is entitled to relist, I have no issue with that, it's the bare faced lie to ebay to get her refund.

She is now a saved seller and one day, I may or may not fuck her over.

Sally090807 · 23/10/2021 07:50

The whole thing is a total nightmare. I sold some expensive shoes that belonged to my daughter, I sent them via Hermes and paid extra for guaranteed delivery. They were picked up from my local store but never made it to the main sorting hub. Hermes offered me £20 and I’ve had to refund the buyer £130 and my daughters £180 shoes have been “lost”.

Redrosesandsunsets · 23/10/2021 07:20

I once sold a big lot of expensive school uniform on there and someone bought it and paid by PayPal. They wanted to come and collect it so they came by train to pick up package (so I had no proof of package once picked up, after they had left).
They went home and pulled the money back from PayPal!!! They got my items and didn’t pay.
I learned you have to show proof the item was picked up or sent by post (normally by post so a postal receipt counts). So without me taking a photo of this man on my doorstep physically picking up the package I had no proof of this. I tried to track said man down. He closed his account and eBay were hopeless and didn’t care. Neither did PayPal. Never again. Expensive lesson learned. Some people are so brazen. He was an old man. Said it was for his granddaughter. All BS. He scams people for a living.

knittingaddict · 23/10/2021 07:12

@StepAwayFromGoogling

I'd assume 'collecting in person' means a courier could collect on your behalf.
Have you ever used Ebay? That's a really bad idea for the seller and not something that ebay would support. It is up to the seller to arrange delivery IF THEY WISH TO. There are all sorts of scams involving buyers arranging their own couriers as the seller has to prove delivery in the event of a dispute.

Personally I would stick it on gumtree and expect to almost give it away. Second hand sofas don't really seem to sell well for some reason.

RedHelenB · 23/10/2021 07:07

A couple of times ds wanted to sell old electronic games. They were a fair price but each time sonething was " wrong ". He did get the games back but it was a lot of hassle and ended up costing me money with postage and returns. Won't use it again to buy or sell.

Pencilandpaper · 23/10/2021 07:00

@Bogeyes

They are trying to scam you. Mark the item as unpaid and report them.
I did, this was a couple of weeks ago and have t heard anything about me reporting them - however they reported me and I then got my account suspended! Really unfair. They also could leave me negative feedback which they did yesterday and I can’t leave them any, only positive
OP posts:
Pencilandpaper · 23/10/2021 06:58

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

I wouldn't see any issue with using a courier either - if the courier were the same sex (even then he could claim to be her DH) and in an unmarked vehicle, you wouldn't even necessarily know that it wasn't the buyer - but they need to agree a reasonable time slot and take responsibility for authorising the courier to check the item on their behalf: any breakages or 'not as described' later are entirely between the buyer and courier.

As it's being collected in person, though, rather than sent through the post (with proof of posting), I would also insist that the courier pay cash on collection - non-negotiable.

I don't think I'd object to helping out with some cardboard, plastic dust sheet or other similar cheap protection, but the 'like a newborn baby' demand is extremely strange.

You would always know it’s a courier, they would tell you or it would be obvious when speaking to them. Agree with the points you have made but even if they agree to take responsibility, I don’t think that would mean anything if something did happen to the item/the buyer claimed it was damaged before but you become the one “posting” it
OP posts:
Chunkymenrock · 23/10/2021 06:04

Use gumtree. Much better for local items.

ElftonWednesday · 23/10/2021 05:02

I wouldn't bother with Facebook marketplace either for collection only. You just get loads of timewasters who are too far away and don't turn up, or ask you to post a large, free item. I only ever use local groups, most people on there are friends of friends so there is a little less anonymity, which can help.

Bogeyes · 23/10/2021 04:50

They are trying to scam you. Mark the item as unpaid and report them.

IndecentCakes · 23/10/2021 02:17

I refused a courier collection. It was a pram, I'm not wrapping a pram!