Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send child to a secondary one hour away?

218 replies

hibbledibble · 22/10/2021 20:47

I'm thinking hard about secondary options currently. One option is about an hour away, and an amazing school. It would however involved a train ride and then a bus.

Other options are a bus ride away, and also good, but don't have the same amazing facilities or stellar results.

I'm torn regarding which school to pick as first choice.

Is an hour too much to travel?

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 11:38

@hettol

It's quite normal when I was growing up in London to travel that for secondary.
But as has been said numerous times, you can't compare London to other rural areas as the transport is so different.

If you miss the tube in London, there's another one 2-3 minutes later. If you miss the train in NowhereTown, you may not get another one for 2-3 hours.

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:38

But I got public transport by myself. Surprised at those saying they were tired. I had so much energy as a teenager.

Same

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:38

also managed to do after school activities no problem.

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:36

In terms of friendship groups we were all fairly spread out so met up on weekends.

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:36

It's quite normal when I was growing up in London to travel that for secondary.

RealBecca · 23/10/2021 11:30

Sorry yes it is. Think how long your sons day will be. And an jour each way...well, he cpuld spend that doing homework if he went to the closer school couldnt he.

KitchenKrisis · 23/10/2021 11:28

I really wanted a school that was just a little tricky to get too, she didn't get in and I'm glad now because it was just that little bit to hard to get her there and back and getting her from my work to dentist appt etc

KitchenKrisis · 23/10/2021 11:27

I always think about emergencies, needing to collect them for appt or getting them home quickly etc.

reluctantbrit · 23/10/2021 11:26

Depends on several points:

How much homework/revision time do they expect each day? DD's school sys 1 1/2 - 2 hours in KS3 and 2-3 hours in KS4, that already eats in free time and hobbies, a long commute on top of that is difficult to manage.

How reliable is transport? How often are the trains cancelled or delayed? What is your back up plan? How often is a train in the afternoon? DD's school can issue same day detentions, what would happen if your child misses a train? Or if she attends any after school clubs/school activities, will she still be able to come home?

Hobbies - will she be able to continue with her hobbies or are they at times where she will still be travelling/just come home?

Friends - no necessarily the ones she currently has, DD lost contact with most of them as they were put in different forms but the ones she will make. Are you willing to play taxi all the time to drop her off? Is there public transport at weekends for her to go on her own?

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 11:22

@Animood

Big difference between:
  • the closest school being an hour away, so the kids have to go there and
  • there being loads of schools in the vicinity, but your stupid parents thinking you're better off being in the "good school" a sodding trek away.

I cannot stress how much I resent my parents for this. Why did they pay for the stupid far away school?

Yep, I think a lot of people are missing this point.

If everyone from villages A, B, C and D has to go to school in town E, then it's doable.

But if you live in town A and your parents decide to send you 30 miles away to town B, even though there's a perfectly decent school five minutes away, then you may end up pretty resentful and fed up after not too long.

Freeekedout · 23/10/2021 11:22

Would you be happy doing the same commute to work, then coming home and starting your homework?

If the school is so good, move closer to it but don't commit your child to seven years of long journeys.

Fallagain · 23/10/2021 11:14

Come yr 11 if they want to get good results then they should be studying for 37 hours a week (advice given in our local schools). Imagine doing a full time week with a 2 hour commute but being of an age when you need more sleep than an adult.

Animood · 23/10/2021 11:11

Big difference between:

  • the closest school being an hour away, so the kids have to go there and
  • there being loads of schools in the vicinity, but your stupid parents thinking you're better off being in the "good school" a sodding trek away.

I cannot stress how much I resent my parents for this. Why did they pay for the stupid far away school?

TheGlitterFairy · 23/10/2021 11:05

I did an hours commute to attend secondary school as it was better than a closer one. Was all fine and many children had the same commute from the various villages around

ItsAllComingBackToMe · 23/10/2021 11:02

Lots of kids travel to my sons school. Mostly with a travelling time of an hour or more.

The entire point is that this is NOT the case where the OP is so her child would be travelling to a school that is t set up for this long distance travel by himself.

This isn't a school where lots of dc travel an hour or more.

Walkaround · 23/10/2021 11:00

Oodles of available public transport every few minutes is also common in London, so a missed connection is not the same thing there as it may be in other parts of the country, where a delay in one stage of the journey might result in a doubled journey time, or even being stranded miles from home. So, it does depend partly on context. Getting a train and a bus and journeying for at least an hour each way to avoid schools acknowledged to be good seems wasted effort to me, though.

DuvetDayIsEveryDay · 23/10/2021 10:39

Lots of kids travel to my sons school. Mostly with a travelling time of an hour or more.

It's fairly common here in London.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 23/10/2021 10:26

Mine goes to school which used to be a 40 minute journey away and since we moved is now more like an hour and 20 with one long bus or two shorter buses. It's not ideal but it's worth it for him to keep his friends and relationships. I chose that one in the first place above the closer, less good school. Now we live nearer much better schools but he doesn't want to move. I guess that's because he's established though which yours is not yet

StormzyinaTCup · 23/10/2021 10:23

Have been through a similar situation with DD a couple of years ago although she is a bit older and it was the choice between two colleges, one a 5 min train ride and 10 min walk with just OK facilities versus one that involved 1 train (15 mins) and 1 bus (40 mins) but the college had great facilities. She picked the better facilities and the longer commute. It turned out to be a shocker of a journey, the train was no problem but the buses were awful, it was one bus every 20 mins and they were always running late and if they got really delayed in the rush hour they would just cancel it completely and she'd have to wait for the next one and it caused her problems with her college on occasion due to lateness. She was leaving at 7am and quite often not getting back until 7pm which was especially grim in the winter. It also prevented her from doing her out of college sporting activity which she loved and she wasn't able get a part time job like a lot of her friends. She transferred for her second year to the nearer college, resumed her sporting activity (and the social element) and now has a part time job two evenings a week and Saturdays. She is a lot less stressed and happier now.

mumda · 23/10/2021 10:21

How will he socialise with children from that school?
Will he be able to go on his own?
How tired will he be?
How long is the journey on a bad day?
How will public transport failings / bad weather affect the journey?

refusetobeasheep · 23/10/2021 09:49

Currently DD's favourite school would involve a 10 min walk to where the school bus picks up, then a 45 min ride. So she'll be only with others from that school on the coach. I had 45 min journey to secondary and always vowed not to give that to my child .... trying to steer her to a nearer school, we shall see .....

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/10/2021 09:28

@thewhatsit

I don’t think it’s far away. Mh school was about that, so was DH’s.

When we look at senior school options for DC we’ll have about 15+ schools to consider, closest I suppose 30 mins commute.

And your dc will probably go with some friends. Op hasn’t clarified if this is the case. Going alone is completely different.
Bayleaf25 · 23/10/2021 09:23

My dd would hate it, she’s now 15 and loves the flexibility of seeing friends locally whenever she wants.

She’s always involved in extra curricular activities so often stays on at school for one thing or another.

She has quite a lot of homework and revision now so I can’t imagine having to factor in a long commute.

If you live rurally and everyone has to travel I can see why you would, but otherwise I would stay local unless the schools are dreadful.

ItsAllComingBackToMe · 23/10/2021 09:05

This thread is interesting. Some children, like the ones in my village don’t have a choice (unless parents move) and cope perfectly fine.
My nephew is in this situation and my dd who is the same age walks 15 minutes to her school. She gets home at 3:40. He gets home at 4:50.

My nephew's school only set an hour of homework a day as they know their students are all on buses for two hours a day every day whereas my dd gets double that. His school also don't schedule after school matches, they are all played on Wednesday afternoons whereas all my DD's are after the school day.

Rosti1981 · 23/10/2021 08:57

I did that kind of journey for sixth form, but I think that's a different kettle of fish to asking an 11 year old to do it! I was shattered in 6th form and my parents usually took me one way, then I'd get a bus (rural variety going round every village in the area!) home... Had a friend or two on the bus with me so not too bad, or I read. When I passed my driving test it made a big difference too, obviously that isn't an option for most high schoolers!
I think the main things are the complexity of the journey though (multiple changes, walking either end), the reliability of public transport options, and whether other children would be making the same journey. That matters more than total time as time spent on a reliable train with a friend is probably quite fun/social, whereas waiting around in the cold for unreliable connections on your own is not.