Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send child to a secondary one hour away?

218 replies

hibbledibble · 22/10/2021 20:47

I'm thinking hard about secondary options currently. One option is about an hour away, and an amazing school. It would however involved a train ride and then a bus.

Other options are a bus ride away, and also good, but don't have the same amazing facilities or stellar results.

I'm torn regarding which school to pick as first choice.

Is an hour too much to travel?

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 12:09

@hettol

I wouldn't want an 11yo to have wait alone in a train station for that length of time.

I wouldn't want an 11 yr old or a 21 yr old waiting that long so would never live anywhere like that.

I think there is a middle ground though between trains every 20 mins & every 90 minutes.

Lots of people don't have a choice but to live rurally, though. We can't all afford to live in areas with excellent public transport links.

Which is why people have asked about the location and frequency of transport. If OP lives in London, it will be vastly different to if she lives in a village in Lincolnshire.

hettol · 23/10/2021 12:08

You said that it was fine (and normal) in London and that you don't find it tiring - people were just pointing out why it may be difficult and tiring in their area.

But it is fine & normal in London hence why I said it because lots of posters said it was out of the question.

You & another poster then replied to my posts saying not everyone lives in London. I never claimed they did but not everyone lives rurally & we don't even know where the OP lives.

hettol · 23/10/2021 12:06

I wouldn't want an 11yo to have wait alone in a train station for that length of time.

I wouldn't want an 11 yr old or a 21 yr old waiting that long so would never live anywhere like that.

I think there is a middle ground though between trains every 20 mins & every 90 minutes.

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 12:06

@hettol

You're right that OP hasn't said where she lives, though.

Thank you, so me referring to my experience in London is no less relevant to those talking about their rural experiences.

Nobody said it was irrelevant, though.

You said that it was fine (and normal) in London and that you don't find it tiring - people were just pointing out why it may be difficult and tiring in their area.

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 12:04

@hettol

Around here, if you miss the train, the next one is at least a 90 minute wait.

I would stay that statistically that would be considered not very regular. I'd be surprised if that's how frequent the OPs trains are.

I mean, that is the reality for huge parts of the country, though.

We still have no train service on Bank Holidays and on Sundays they only run every 2-3 hours, lol.

hettol · 23/10/2021 12:04

You're right that OP hasn't said where she lives, though.

Thank you, so me referring to my experience in London is no less relevant to those talking about their rural experiences.

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 12:03

[quote hettol]@icedcoffees who said it wasn't regular? Although if I missed it I would be late.

Has the OP clarified the train timetable? [/quote]
My point is that a 20 minute wait may mean you're a little late for work, but it's hardly a big deal to wait 20 minutes for a train. Whereas where I am, if you miss your train, you have to wait 90 minutes or so for the next one. I wouldn't want an 11yo to have wait alone in a train station for that length of time.

Notdoingthis · 23/10/2021 12:03

No way. They would be so tired all the time. Not worth it.

hettol · 23/10/2021 12:03

Around here, if you miss the train, the next one is at least a 90 minute wait.

I would stay that statistically that would be considered not very regular. I'd be surprised if that's how frequent the OPs trains are.

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 12:02

@hettol

But as has been said numerous times, you can't compare London to other rural areas as the transport is so different.

Where have I compared them? I simply said it's quite normal in London as many posters have said "they would never do it". They didn't say "they would never do it unless in London". Is the OP rural?

Yes, it's normal in London because the transport makes it so easy.

2-3 minute wait for a tube
20 minute wait for a train.

Those timings mean an hour commute is relatively straightforward, whereas rurally, it's much more complex and missing your connection can easily mean you're stranded and can't get anywhere. I wouldn't want my 11 year old making a journey that relied on a connection being made - what would they do if they got stuck and couldn't get to school?

You're right that OP hasn't said where she lives, though.

hettol · 23/10/2021 12:00

@icedcoffees who said it wasn't regular? Although if I missed it I would be late.

Has the OP clarified the train timetable?

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 11:59

@hettol

Again, London commutes are not really comparable to other areas of the country.

It depends, some parts of London don't have the tube. I live near the tube but always got the train to school & it was every 20 mins.

That's incredibly regular!

Around here, if you miss the train, the next one is at least a 90 minute wait.

tickledtiger · 23/10/2021 11:56

I didn’t ever resent my parents for sending me to the school I had to do a long commute to, they honestly thought it was my best shot at success and I did ok there.

I must say though, I didn’t do any extra curricular activities at all and I very rarely met up with any school friends outside of school. All due to the distance.

I wouldn’t send my own child to a school 1+ hour away unless there was something very wrong with the local option.

HairyScaryMonster · 23/10/2021 11:55

I did a train journey to school and didn't get home til after 5. It was pretty gruelling especially in the winter and the last thing you want to do after an hour's commute is get stuck into homework.

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:55

Every 20 minutes is a very regular train service

Where have I claimed it wasn't. I was just highlighting I wasn't get the tube that runs every 2-3 mins.

Has the OP said how frequent the trains are?

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:54

@Walkaround I think you are confused. I said I had a lot of energy as a teenager, I did. I don't think that was necessarily due to London tap water. Why are you talking about 2 hour journeys?

There were schools closer to me but I went to one of the top catholic ones.

Walkaround · 23/10/2021 11:53

Every 20 minutes is a very regular train service.

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:51

Again, London commutes are not really comparable to other areas of the country.

It depends, some parts of London don't have the tube. I live near the tube but always got the train to school & it was every 20 mins.

Walkaround · 23/10/2021 11:51

@hettol - would you have had the “energy” as a teenager (or 11 year old) to appreciate commuting past lots of good schools to go to a school miles from your local community when the bus and train services you relied on arrived, at best, once an hour, so that your journey home was a minimum of 2 hours if you missed a connection? Or are you limiting your comments on energy to Londoners?

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:49

But as has been said numerous times, you can't compare London to other rural areas as the transport is so different.

Where have I compared them? I simply said it's quite normal in London as many posters have said "they would never do it". They didn't say "they would never do it unless in London". Is the OP rural?

thesugarbumfairy · 23/10/2021 11:48

I think you need to do that journey and see how it feels.

My children have a commute to school (which we chose for them - rather than going to our catchment).

They get a lift to the station (7 minutes), followed by a train (15 mins) then walk 15-20 mins to school. Its fine and a lot of kids do it, but more than that I think might be excessive. My youngest started in September and was exhausted for the first couple of weeks but he doesn't bat an eyelid now. He loves the train as he gets to natter with friends.

We are in the situation where we are able to drive them to the station and pick them up - otherwise they'd also have a 25-30 minute bike ride at to get to and from the station - which some kids do - but I think mine would probably go on strike!

icedcoffees · 23/10/2021 11:46

@hettol

It takes me an hour to get to work and I'm shattered

Again 45mins - 1 hour door to door journey living & working in London is very normal.

Sometimes I think MNs is an alternate universe!

Again, London commutes are not really comparable to other areas of the country.

If you miss the tube in London, another one will be along in a second. If you miss the only bus out of the village, you can't get to school or work. The trains don't run regularly from most towns either - if you miss your connection due to a delay, you're stuffed.

sunshinesupermum · 23/10/2021 11:44

Dd2 had similar journey but made her still closest 3 friends on the school bus as there were a number of them who all went to the same school. The day was long admittedly and i dropped her off and picked her up from bus stop which meant leaving home at 7.00amand getting back at 5.00pm. She is 36 now!

hettol · 23/10/2021 11:41

It takes me an hour to get to work and I'm shattered

Again 45mins - 1 hour door to door journey living & working in London is very normal.

Sometimes I think MNs is an alternate universe!

StormzyinaTCup · 23/10/2021 11:41

@KitchenKrisis

I always think about emergencies, needing to collect them for appt or getting them home quickly etc.
This also a big consideration, especially if you find your DC needs 2/3 years of orthodontic work!!