Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this isn't very nice but I can't help it ...

308 replies

retroginglass · 22/10/2021 17:39

I live very near my mum. I go and see her on a Saturday and phone ever day. Without doubt she will moan about not sleeping a wink (almost every night - she is a medical marvel), not feeling well or something. It is constant. She is now nearly 80 but this has been going on for as long as I can remember. I am so tired of listening to the constant moaning. My grown up children all visit her all the time so she is not lonely. They also phone her nearly every day. If we go out for lunch she will invariably moan about the place, the noise or something. Her latest gripe is politics and honestly the ranting and raving is getting me down. If I say I'm feeling under the weather she is ten times worse. I know she is attention seeking and my kids can just about bear it she is driving me mad. Any advice?

OP posts:
JudyGemstone · 23/10/2021 11:11

“My MIL is like this. She complained about her previous neighbours, then about her new neighbours when she moved, and always about her friends. I’ve noticed she often complains to us instead of setting healthy boundaries with her friends and neighbours and telling them when they’re taking the piss.”

My mum is like this, moans to me that my brother and SiL ask her to have their kids all the time but won’t say no to them. I told her that it was up to her to communicate to them if it was too much for her.

Funnily enough I’ve just remembered that she was very clear to me about not having mine once a week when they were little!

Purplecatshopaholic · 23/10/2021 11:09

She is, as you already know, attention seeking. And sorry, but you are pandering to it. Don’t visit so often. Defo don’t phone so often. Every day? Bloody hell op, why? Just don’t. She’s not going to change now..

UpintNorth · 23/10/2021 11:04

I don’t necessarily think it’s an age thing either. My lovely Mum always saw the best in people and the world and very very rarely commented or moaned, even during her cancer treatment before she died aged 71.

And yet I know other people in their 40s,50s,60s who I mentally call the “Daily Mail” gang who seem to have very little positive in their lives. I often can’t help thinking - if they just spent a little time thinking about how much they have compared to others (or perhaps even volunteering with those who have had worse life opportunities) then their attitude might balance out a bit!

Good advice upthread..good luck OP Smile

flowersmakeitbetter · 23/10/2021 10:54

Same here.

My Mum has always been like this but has got even worse as she's got older (in her 80s now).

Other than a few health issues, she really has nothing to moan about. It's so tiring. She moans constantly that she is lonely but she is surrounded by people. We have suggested a gazillion things to keep her occupied but everything is dismissed.

Like others have said it's pure attention seeking. She has always been unable to set boundaries or find solutions and would rather moan about people and situations. Trouble is, this tactic has the opposite effect as I am at the stage now where I just don't want to spend time with her.

She has little to no interest in me yet I am expected to do all the running.

No suggestions but solidarity!

DFOD · 23/10/2021 10:45

I wonder if it’s the power dynamics in the relationship - has anyone ever given feedback / taken a parent to task?

Maybe it’s just that that would be an unusual thing to do at any age and it feels disrespectful?

What’s a real shame is that if people just grit teeth and withdraw the relationship just slowly dies a death of dread.

Also interested in where the emotional vomiting is on one sibling but able to be bright a breezy to other friends and family - that’s been my personal experience and it feels very exploitative.

Has anyone any words that have worked to steer the relationship back into a more comfortable / tolerable place?

My other observation in my family is that these were miserable bitter jealous people when fit and healthy and as others have said this has just intensified as their lives have become smaller.

How does a miserable person take on feedback?

secretbookcase · 23/10/2021 10:33

@MrsLargeEmbodied

the majority of the old people i cared for in their own homes were cheerful
My dad was adorable with his carer. He could then vent about them, about us, about my mum for hours. Family get a different mood from carers.
theluckiest · 23/10/2021 10:29

Yup. My DM is exactly the same. I recall, as a child, hating having to visit my DGM as she just moaned constantly. My mum has now turned into DGM. It's like being in a room with a Dementor.

A lot of the points on here ring true:

  • she's always been negative but this has snowballed since she developed more health conditions as she's aged
  • she can find the negative in anything
  • her world has diminished (partly due to COVID) which has also increased the moaning

DH and I have a wonderful tactic to combat this. We try to flip her negative comments into positive ones.

For example, DM 'Oh, the weather was terrible on holiday. There was nothing to do. Was boring.'

DH - 'Yes, but the scenery was glorious!!'

I often zone out TBH. I've no idea how my DDad copes with it as he's a generally positive person.

The saddest thing is that my DC no longer want to visit their GM as they just get moaned at. And DM can't see this. It's even more of a shame as they're the only grandchildren she'll ever have

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 23/10/2021 10:27

I honestly think that some old people get into a habit of endless moaning, perhaps without even realising they’re doing it.

My DM wasn’t even really old - maybe late 70s - when she got into a habit of saying endlessly, ‘The sooner I go, the better.’ She’d never really been happy since my DF died, but even so….

She said it once on a lovely sunny day when I was driving us both to Bath - which she’d wanted to visit - for a 3 night mini break!

For once I did say something! ‘It’s a lovely sunny day, we’re off on a little holiday - can you please think of something cheerful to say instead?’
But TBH it had become such a habit, I don’t think she even realised she was doing it.

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 23/10/2021 10:21

my mum is the same and it started as soon as we left home - its for attention . She's only just retired so we notice it more as she has more time to contact us and I know she is bored. She doesn't eat or sleep either lol ( according to her ) and the list goes on . She has a negative comment to make about every thing and every body . I've learned to tune out - I just change the subject or if I can be bothered I'd challenge her ' why are you saying nasty things about John next door , he was amazing when you got locked out ' etc etc

Strugglingtodomybest · 23/10/2021 10:12

Also does anyone else experience the desperation of (usually) dms to tell you the whole life story of Beryl’s cousin’s next-door-neighbour’s third cousin, whilst showing zero interest in you? I could have said, “Dm, Elon Musk has chosen me to go into space,” and dm would reply, “Hmmmmm, Joan’s great nephew is doing a space project at school. Apparently his Mars poster yada yada yada….”

Oh yes, big time!

MrsLargeEmbodied · 23/10/2021 10:12

the majority of the old people i cared for in their own homes were cheerful

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/10/2021 10:03

She probably needs more interactions than just family.

Get in touch with Age UK locally and find out what clubs and befriending services they have locally.

Being phoned and visited by family is not enough to stop a person being lonely or enough to keep them active mentally and physically.

schoolsoutforever · 23/10/2021 10:00

I have a colleague like this. It’s very draining. If anyone has a solution I’d love to have one. It’s isn’t really age with this person I don’t think. I suspect it’s just a personality type. I want to be supportive but it’s constant negativity - health, politics, the state of the country the list goes on.

lottiegarbanzo · 23/10/2021 10:00

DD works in a hospital, she says sadly many older people become bitter and nasty in old age, for no obvious reason.

Maybe because they no longer feel the need or pressure to keep up appearances and pretend they're happy when they're not?

Maybe they're finally giving voice to that 'inner voice' that says 'what the fuck are you doing?' and 'will you just shut the fuck up!'* quite frequently, instead of supressing it for the sake of propriety, smooth relationships and other people's feelings?

*(Well mine does and I slightly dread the nasty horror that I may turn into with age, increased frustration and diminished impulse control. Menopause is bringing me close to spitting curses and obscenities inappropriately, daily, already! And, isn't this cathartic, sweary behaviour exactly what all those 'mummy drinks wine' blogs are about? What do you do when your fingers are no longer able to contain the sweary blogging for you?).

Maybe when your main companions, day to day, are people you don't love, care about, or want to develop long term relationships with and some of them are medical and care home staff who do painful things to you and often do take an unacceptably long time to attend to your needs, you feel quite justified in letting out how you actually feel about the situation?

None of that is the slightest bit difficult to think of, or imagine feeling. Where is the natural empathy and common sense of anyone who cannot easily imagine that?

chaosrabbitland · 23/10/2021 09:56

my mums been through stages of this , its just constant and sometimes i think the moaning is this way because its easier for them to bang on about a situation rather than change it , i could never say anything to mine when she was bad with it though , tried once and it led to a blinding row , shes 84 now and more chilled out in her old age thank goodness , i do sometimes think if they werent carrying on about something they would be six foot under

MaryBoBary · 23/10/2021 09:51

My mother in law does this. We ignore the messages that are just full of "woe is me" now because it's so depressing. She's got lots of local family and FIL so it's not like we are the only ones she has to speak to so we aren't putting up with it any more!

Lunaduckdrop · 23/10/2021 09:42

I remember my granny being like this with my mum. Poor mum got all the negativity, moaning, details of ailments and off-loading. When I went to see granny, however, she was all sweetness and light, interested in what I'd been doing and grateful for me visiting. From what you say it sounds like your situation could be similar!

mytortoiseisill · 23/10/2021 09:37

Same here but unfortunately mine uses it as a control thing too.
She went “wrong” quite young and is no good with people over the age of 10....

Labyrinth86 · 23/10/2021 09:36

@50ShadesOfCatholic

She isn't going to change. I would just reduce my contact with her. Frankly I couldn't bear any contact but if there are things you like about her perhaps you could stay in touch but see less of her. Therws something about a lot of women of that age. My theory is that they didn't have much voice or respect as young women and were conditioned to do what was expected rather than make active choices. And they have coped by whining rather than taking control of their lives.
If it was a sister, I might agree because there would be time for her to change. As it's an 80 year old woman, I think a reduction in contact by phone but still visiting and trying to explain might be best. I lost my grandma when she had just turned 84. It happened very suddenly - she became ill for 3 months, doc said it was UTI but she had had bladder cancer for years based on size of tumour they found in hospital. She was very moany too and said a lot of the same things when I saw her - quiz shows were fixed, she hates this presenter or that presenter, etc. However, I loved her dearly and I regret not seeing her more - I was doing an intense 3 year doctorate training to be a psychologist and I was often working or sleeping. When she became ill, I put her first and finished my course months after my cohort for that reason but I still feel I should have seen her more.

My point is no one knows how long anyone has left and cutting her out completely might be something you really regret when she's no longer here. I often think this about my parents when they are doing my head in - one day I'll be wishing that my dad was giving me a lecture or my mum was telling me all about 10 different people from work that I have never met. I would reduce contact by phone though - every day seems a lot. Maybe you and your children could each csll on different days during the week so she has contact but it's less intense on you all.

DottyHarmer · 23/10/2021 09:34

Of course there are cheerful old people and moany old people, but most moany ones are suffering from “age” problems: poor health, isolation and, very importantly, little to look forward to.

Imagine if you knew you would never have another companion (your Dh having gone), possibly never another holiday, never live anywhere else, never go for a country walk…. Boy, I’m depressing myself now!

Londoncatshed · 23/10/2021 09:30

Do you think your personality is accentuated as you become older? I have found that elderly relatives become more entrenched in their personality as they age. So both an age thing and a personality thing.

Feel for you OP.

Feedingthebirds1 · 23/10/2021 09:27

I dont like the calls never to discuss age. People do change as they get older, those of us who have cared for elderly parents know this far too well. And life gets harder as we get older and some people will moan more. And some wont. But to say oh we cant discuss this as its ageism is taking away the fact people can change as they age.

For some people the complaining and misery does come on with age. As you get older your world shrinks because of health issues, you see your friends dying and can't escape thoughts of your own mortality. You have fewer opportunities to do the good things and the things that irritate you become bigger in your mind because you don't have as many good things to offset the irritation.

But that's only some older people. Some PPs are saying, in a very black and white way, 'it's an age thing'. It's not by any means all old people who complain constantly, just as some of those who do complain and moan constantly have done it all their lives.

What those people who say quit the ageism are asking for is that individual differences are recognised, rather than writing it off to a simple and inevitable consequence of ageing.

LizzieSiddal · 23/10/2021 09:21

One thing I do is call them when I am doing something so I only half hear it and I am not spending 45 just listening e.g. round Tesco, walking the dog, waiting outside the school for my DC so that the time is not dead.

This is what I do. I used to really resent phong my relative, I now do something like cleaning, walking etc so I’m not sat still, seething.

SunShinesBrightly · 23/10/2021 09:17

@Bobbie1976

I think you should enjoy your mum while you have her. I lost my Mum before Christmas at only 69. I'd give anything for her to have lived to some of the ages mentioned here.
I am sorry to hear that you have lost your Mum. 69 is a very young age.

There are many people looking after or looking out for people who are very difficult to be around. Emotionally draining and in some cases, downright unpleasant.

It sounds like your Mum wasn’t that kind of person.

I feel for the OP. A constant barrage of negativity is hard to handle when you are doing your best.

purplesky18 · 23/10/2021 09:14

I feel the same about my mum which is a shame as we are very close. It got to the point where she was moaning about some form of ailment every second I’m around, it was starting to annoy me as I feel guilty for asking her to watch the kids if I need something urgent etc etc just normal grandparent stuff. I wouldn’t mind but she’s only 60! I gave birth and she didn’t contact me for two days because she had a bad uti, well I had forceps, a catheter for a week, a uti, a episiotomy and a brand new baby but apparently she was in more pain because she had it longer! 🙄 I’ve moved away from her now and tried to build my own life, it’s definitely helped.