Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this isn't very nice but I can't help it ...

308 replies

retroginglass · 22/10/2021 17:39

I live very near my mum. I go and see her on a Saturday and phone ever day. Without doubt she will moan about not sleeping a wink (almost every night - she is a medical marvel), not feeling well or something. It is constant. She is now nearly 80 but this has been going on for as long as I can remember. I am so tired of listening to the constant moaning. My grown up children all visit her all the time so she is not lonely. They also phone her nearly every day. If we go out for lunch she will invariably moan about the place, the noise or something. Her latest gripe is politics and honestly the ranting and raving is getting me down. If I say I'm feeling under the weather she is ten times worse. I know she is attention seeking and my kids can just about bear it she is driving me mad. Any advice?

OP posts:
Psychofortruth · 25/10/2021 09:31

I love my mum dearly, but honestly only talk to her once a week, sometimes more. I have a very busy lifestyle and sometimes it just works that way.

But never the less she is my mum. She can be moany, not so much about aches but more people and general things. That is just her, many things I detest many thing I love. But the best thing I find is when she goes into one of those moods, kinda take a smile and wave take omg she never, and what did you do. At the end of the call if there is anything important hold onto it the rest let go!

GirlWithAGuitar · 25/10/2021 09:00

It may seem patronising to say suck it up coz they won't be around forever but in actual fact its the truth. You only get one mum (unless you're very lucky and have 2) so even if our mums, dad's or whatever moan its normal and we all do it x

No. We don’t all do it. Not every second of every phone call or visit. And if you do, you need to stop and think how you are making others feel. My friend felt suicidal at her mums behaviour. And what made it worse, she’d bump into her mums friends and they’d all be talking about what great company she was, and how she cheered up so and so at church etc.
These mums so often seem to save it up their children. Or even just one child. My brother got none of it. He got a mum who asked him questions about his life and engaged with him. I put her on speaker talking to me a few times and he didn’t recognise this moaning misery on the phone.
So anyone that tells me I should have just sucked it up can just fuck off.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 25/10/2021 08:45

I think it is worth remembering that people who complain are really sad and unhappy.

I suppose you could blame them for not doing more to help themselves, or for feeling helpless about their situation, but I've always thought people reach a point where they probably think that they've tried every pain medication but their back still hurts, and they've tried every trick to overcome insomnia and none of them really worked either, and they know they should join some groups to make friends but it's just too scary.

Fundamentally, she's sad and the things that are hurting her - whether we get it or not - are all consuming and at the forefront of her mind at all times. She knows no one cares about these things, not really, but desperately wants someone to genuinely hear her and realise what she's coping with, just like her husband used to, or her good friends before they moved away.

I often think people living alone and unhappy could do with a good therapist for a weekly moan to people paid to care.

Unfortunately you can't simply list all of the things she has that others don't have, all the things she should be grateful for, because sadness doesn't work like that.

And you shouldn't wonder why she can turn on the charm for people outside the family, because we are all at our worst with the people we trust aren't, when we can be ourselves without the public mask - it's why children are sometimes angels at school but awful at home.

Just grin and bear it. Only give as much of yourself as you can. Remember that she loves you and doesn't want to be a burden, and will be gone soon enough. When you are her age you might understand her better.

Claraoclara · 25/10/2021 07:48

You’re not going to change her now. She’s very lucky that people talk to her at all. I would try and zone out and just placate her. Make a joke of it to yourself and try not to take it to heart . My mum is the same but she has bi polar and if I challenge her she tries to hurt herself (or worse) so I just put up with it. Since I’ve become a mum I just have her lower on my list of priorities which has helped a lot. I would just switch off and try and enjoy yourself in-between visits. Look after yourself. She is.

Fluffykins2020 · 25/10/2021 07:36

It may seem patronising to say suck it up coz they won't be around forever but in actual fact its the truth. You only get one mum (unless you're very lucky and have 2) so even if our mums, dad's or whatever moan its normal and we all do it x

fourminutestosavetheworld · 25/10/2021 07:15

I think about 90% of posters have said 'oh yes my mum is like this too.' Therefore, the odds are that - for whatever reasons - most of us will edge into this too at some point. Then we will at least have the answers about why they do it, because we will be doing it ourselves!

IMO this is common as people get older - and I don't think it's ageism to say that, and I know anecdotally that it doesn't happen for everyone of course - because often people are dealing with physical pain, insomnia, loneliness (even with a daily phone call, they are mostly alone), and the knowledge that their lives are receding behind them.

I guess we think we know what it will be like, but we don't. A bit like the arseholes who criticise your parenting until they have children themselves and realise how hard it is.

I think she will not change now and telling her she's miserable is unlikely to yield positive results, so managing your response to it is probably the best way to deal with it - calling while doing something else, changing the subject, jollying her along, humour.

speakout · 25/10/2021 06:15

I think the growth of popular psychology has seen new generations of people questioning our thinking and communication styles, how we realate to others, how we raise our children.
This highlights the negative communication methods that other use- we can cast an objective ear over what people are saying and how people talk.
My mother is a half empty glass peson, ful of criticism and negative words- she walk like that when I was a child and she was in her 30s.
So a day to day narrative may have been " sit here and have your hair brushed, it is ugly like rats' tails" instead of " let me do your hair, it looks so shiny and soft after a brush".
Many of us realise the benefit of positive parenting, and it works in other relationships too- we are far more likely to get a child or employee to comply when we use encouraging words with an expection of a desired outcome.
A child is far more likely to help in a supermarket if he is given the opportunity to feel responsible and organised rather than if he is being bribed or threatened to comply.

Seeing the positive in things extends far more than language.
I live with my mother in an idyllic spot, surrounded by woodland and wildlife. It is a genuine treat every morning to throw open the curtains to see the weather, the ever changng scene. Bright skies, mist, rain, changing colours.
Every morning without fail my mother has a moan about the weather.
"Too hot," too cold" " I hate the mist" "Can't stand the wind" " not rain again"- she has no idea of the shrapnel and shards she is spraying around- without even thinking. I have thick armour now. She berates her friends to me, pastors at her church, shop keepers and bus drivers.
The sad thing is she doesnlt even knw she is doing it.

smoko · 25/10/2021 04:26

The posters saying we should be grateful as one day the parent will be dead are missing the point. These people likely had more dynamic relationships with their mothers, had mums who, while complaining about health mixed this in with their genuine care & concern for their kids.

I'm sure will mourn the grandmother figure & all the missed wonderful conversations we could have had when she wasn't dominating conversations about her various ailments. But it's a bit patronising & arrogant to assume that everyone should put up with being spoken at constantly with no opportunity for a 2 way conversation.

Also as someone else said, it becomes a case of crying wolf - so when they do actually take seriously ill you've lost the capacity for compassion & may also not take these health issues seriously, as according to them they've been on their death bed your whole life anyway!

GirlWithAGuitar · 25/10/2021 02:08

Some of the posts here saying just put up with it because one they they’ll be dead are quite patronising and minimising.

I have no contact with my parents as they were abusive, but before I cut them off the whinging really affected my mental health. I have a friend who was at complete breaking point because of her demanding mother and her constant misery. My friend has wanted to die herself at times, it’s been that bad. So no, you don’t just have to love them and listen and put up with them whilst your own mental health deteriorates just because they’ll die one day or because someone else is sad that they don’t have their mum anymore. Fuck that.

Lentil63 · 25/10/2021 01:28

If you want advice here is mine:
There are no words for how much I miss my mum (and dad). Was she wonderful? No. Did she have faults (many) yes.
Would I give a small fortune to speak to her again and tell her how much I love her? Oh yes!
People can be aggravating, old people especially so. They are precious and it’s awful when they’re gone

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 25/10/2021 01:02

My 38 year old sister is like that OP. Always moaning and I find myself trying to avoid calling her. We live in different countries and after every call, where she talks 90% of the time I'm exhausted. She talks over you, doesn't listen, complains then same again next time.

TheCuntessOfMiddlesex · 24/10/2021 23:46

@50ShadesOfCatholic

My mother was like this. Yes I was sad when she died but I have no regrets about taking space from her in order to cope with her negativity.

That a person dies eventually (we all do) does not mean you need to sacrifice your mental health by drowning in their depressing personality. It's possible to love them and also keep yourself well.

Spot on
TasteTheMeatNotTheHeat · 24/10/2021 23:36

@50ShadesOfCatholic

My mother was like this. Yes I was sad when she died but I have no regrets about taking space from her in order to cope with her negativity.

That a person dies eventually (we all do) does not mean you need to sacrifice your mental health by drowning in their depressing personality. It's possible to love them and also keep yourself well.

Very sensible post.
50ShadesOfCatholic · 24/10/2021 23:20

My mother was like this. Yes I was sad when she died but I have no regrets about taking space from her in order to cope with her negativity.

That a person dies eventually (we all do) does not mean you need to sacrifice your mental health by drowning in their depressing personality. It's possible to love them and also keep yourself well.

GinPin2 · 24/10/2021 23:19

I am so sorry @rosedrop, @Nicolew1188 and @trixie1970 for the loss of your mums Sad
You are right, we must love our mums just the way they are.
Just this last week my mum has been feeling nauseous on waking up every day. I just hope it is an old (92) age thing.

trixie1970 · 24/10/2021 23:07

I've got some advice OP.

Accept your mum for who she is. Always make a fuss of her, do nice things with her and for her. Laugh with her, make her feel loved and listen to her "moan" without moaning back.

I'd give my right arm to be able to hear my mum's voice again but very sadly, she passed away last Friday. Suddenly and alone. It hurts so badly to have lost her 😢💔

Just love her, OP, because one day, she won't be there anymore xx

bembridge11 · 24/10/2021 23:05

Wow. This post has made me feel so much better about my mum! I thought I was alone in experiencing this and feeling so worm down by it!
Emotional vomiting- such a good phrase!
Thanks all

Nicolew1188 · 24/10/2021 22:41

Make the most of your mums.
Moaning or not. You never know when you are going to lose them.
Mine passed away two weeks ago.
I miss her so much. The pain of losing her is almost physical.

EvaAesthetica · 24/10/2021 22:23

Boundaries! It’s not easy, but if you want to stop her behaviour affecting yours and your family’s life, you will have to set boundaries. Be clear what sort of behaviour you will accept and what you won’t.
Be frank and tell her how her behaviour is affecting you and your family’s life.
Speak with her at a time when you are happy and calm, and set at least one hour uninterrupted time to discuss the matter with her. Be firm but kind and loving. It’s not about telling her how to do things, but about what you are expecting and are prepared to accept as a reasonable behaviour. Ask her what she feels she gains from her complaining to you, and whether you can both think of a way she can find solution to each of her frustrations once a week when you meet.
Of course, some people just moan and complain about everything and anytime (having a problem for every solution!🤣), but even if she is that way inclined, she has to understand that this is affecting your life and that is not right.
Just like when managing children and training them for adult life, do not let her push the boundaries.
Best of luck. xx

rosedrop · 24/10/2021 22:14

My mum was the same. I used to just turn off when she started. Trouble is she had her usual moan and groan on the Thursday over the phone and I told her don't worry I am sure you will feel better tomorrow. Next day she was in hospital and at the end of the week dead. I still feel awful about how I spoke to her but was the case of crying wolf. I am now starting to get to the aches and pain age but I don't tell my DC if I feel a bit down or Mrs so and so down the road is winding me up. I had one grumpy gran and one who was always happy and smiling and when I depart from this place I want to be remembered as the smiling one.

GinPin2 · 24/10/2021 22:13

My mum is just the same. I have the landline on speakerphone and just get on with jobs for 59 mins, 59 seconds. First thing every morning so I am on autopilot really. She is nearly 92. Avid gardener so of course she never gets enough rain ! Etc, etc. Why are other people also getting winter fuel allowance when it should be just her as she is on pension credit, ( I dare not tell her that my husband has just got £200 winter fuel allowance along with his state pension and bus pass !!! ) All these people coming into the country and taking our resources, etc. And so it goes on.
Yet, she can be really kind and knits for all her 12 great grandchildren. She just sounds so different on the phone to real life!
The problem is that our landline is broken, won't be fixed for a week and my mobile ( £5 ) cannot do speakerphone !!!!

Mollymoostoo · 24/10/2021 21:48

@Wingedharpy

I think they call this emotional vomiting OP. When you see or speak to her, she offloads all her angst and worries on to you. You leave, worn out and exhausted, she feels loads better for having offloaded. You could try the " get your happy head out Mother 'cos you're depressing me" approach or, reduce contact to save your sanity. Good luck.
This is brilliant. I know I do this and this thread has helped me see the impact it can have. My Polish friend says no-one asks how you are in Poland as a niceity like we do here. They only ask if they genuinely want to know.
ImInStealthMode · 24/10/2021 21:35

My Nan was the exact same as this, and my Mum just would take it all from her, and then whinge to me about it to me afterwards, so I got double helpings of moaning! Everything was about her, no matter anyone else's troubles she was worse off, looked down her nose at people, judgemental and negative about everything.

I just started being firm, like with a toddler. 'If you haven't got anything nice to say then please don't say anything because I don't want to hear it' and so on. If she criticised someone's weight/clothes/appearance I'd remind her that she wasn't exactly Cindy Crawford herself Hmm

I'd leave the room / house / table if necessary. I don't know if it really had much impact on her but it was certainly better for me to distance myself from it.

Ddot · 24/10/2021 21:31

Pain not paint

Ddot · 24/10/2021 21:30

Typical visit, can you (move heavy item of furniture) no sorry mam I have bad back remember, response well I will have to do it myself then. I would then move it hurt myself throw up be in paint for days.
Now
mam, can u,
Me, NO!
Mam, oh well I do myself,
Me CRACK ON then!