Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my nursery aged DS to be scared by Halloween at school

63 replies

pipiandbelle · 22/10/2021 07:23

Hiya. My DS primary PTA have organised a Halloween event in school today. Sort of a disco with snacks. However I’ve seen the room it’s taking place in and it has been decorated in, what I think, is quite a scary way. All the kids are going in fancy dress today too (yr 6 to nursery) and I don’t know what will be allowed (eg Scream outfits et). My DS is currently finding it hard to know what is real or not on TV (eg in a cartoon or a human in cartoon) so I’m worried he will get freaked out with the costumes (possibly) and the scary room (definitely I think). AIBU to keep him off school today so he doesn’t see this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
justmaybenot · 28/10/2021 21:28

If he has been scared of this kind of thing before then no, YANBU. My ds was terrified of masks and witches at that age and had to be talked down every time he saw one. Do what you think is best, you know your ds better than anyone.

Tumbleweed101 · 28/10/2021 21:25

We are doing a toddler Halloween party, allowing them to be introduced to Halloween celebrations in an age appropriate way. For example, this week we have been exploring pumpkins, looking at what is inside one, chosing as a group what shapes to do eyes, nose, mouth etc. It takes away some of the mystery behind what they will see so they can understand. This has all gone hand in hand with autumn, leaves changing, darker nights, harvest etc. The party with the dressing up will be seen as part of the stories we've read and songs we've been singing. Halloween isn't just about being scared, it's about the change of season and move into the colder months. None of our little ones are seeing it as scary, no more than dinosaurs and crocodiles etc are scary, anyway.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/10/2021 21:13

knittingaddict

How old is your son?

My grandson has positively reveled in Halloween since he was at nursery school. The more gruesome the better as far as he is concerned. I don't think it's done any permanent damage.“

Guess it depends what they’re accustomed to.
“Gruesome” just isn’t appropriate for most small children.

CakesOfVersailles · 28/10/2021 21:12

@MaskingForIt

I would imagine there is probably a rota where each class or at least each Key Stage uses the Hall at a time

At least? At most, surely? Aren’t Key Stages larger than individual classes or year groups?

Separated into classes or if that is not possible at least separated into key stages.

Surely that is what the commenter meant...

audweb · 28/10/2021 21:08

My daughter was really sensitive until she was about seven. Any masks would set her off (and normally she was a confident wee thing but Halloween just freaked her out). Going round shops were a nightmare in October, and the nursery were clear no masks were allowed or very scary costumes. I never kept her off but I did have a chat to them, I mean she ran away screaming when trick or treaters came near the house, she genuinely was terrified by everything at Halloween. Speak to the nursery but don’t keep them off would be my advice.

Jasmine11 · 28/10/2021 21:03

You won't know if he finds it scary if you won't let him go, if you trust the nursery with looking after your son, why won't you trust them to know what's appropriate for children of his age? For what it's worth my son has loved Halloween since he was 2 and he is a really sensitive little soul.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/10/2021 20:58

22/10/2021 07:34 MajorCarolDanvers

Schools have been organising these parties forever and have enormous experience of what works for this age group. “

Disagree. Our youngest was a littlie a long time ago but even then there were kids at the primary school school halloween party with axes in their heads and the scream faces.

It’s too much at that age. Why are some people so keen to make them grow up so fast?

MaskingForIt · 28/10/2021 20:54

@CallMeRisley
I would imagine there is probably a rota where each class or at least each Key Stage uses the Hall at a time

At least? At most, surely? Aren’t Key Stages larger than individual classes or year groups?

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 28/10/2021 20:24

Our school has a disco for KS1 and KS2 separately. The kids love it. No one needs to dress like Freddie Kruger and if they did, l'm sure they would be asked to tone it down.

CottonSock · 28/10/2021 20:15

Some of the outfits parents have been sharing (showing off) on Facebook have been scary and realistic (and imo ridiculous for young kids) . My daughter would not have liked it. I'm glad our school doesn't do the dressing up.

Spainintherain · 28/10/2021 20:11

I too have noticed Halloween decorations getting scarier. I took my young children to a soft play which had an axe wielding zombie silhouette. I find it strange that a school would even talk about Halloween which is likely to be scary to many children

BogRollBOGOF · 22/10/2021 09:52

DS (10) hates Halloween and that distortion of reality/ fantasy and things not looking as they should (he has ASD)
I've never pushed him to dress up, and don't push him to extra things like the PTA disco (of the good old days). I don't expect to change anyone else's behaviour though. Halloween will be there every year and part of life is adapting to cope around difficult things. He knows it will pass and is only an issue for about 10 days.

They're watching a film this afternoon as the end of term reward. I've given my permission but let the teacher know that he struggles with mild peril (he's much better with actual catastrophe!) and can he do some doodling as a coping strategy if he needs to.

It's a difficult week with the end of term anyway and that means a bit more patience and quiet time at home in a safe space.

I can't protect him from all the parts of life that he finds difficult and it wouldn't be doing him any favours either, but I do respect his needs.

JurgensCakeBaby · 22/10/2021 09:38

I was surprised that DS' nursery have been taking about Halloween and ghosts etc. DS loves spiders hubby's them in the garden will happily pick one up in the house to take it outside, now he's saying they are scary and ghosts are scary and getting up in the middle of the night saying there is a ghost in his room. He's not quite three yet. I'm not impressed tbh

Georgewontsleepnow · 22/10/2021 09:38

My children would be kept at home if there was a day like this. They are not anxious, snowflakes not over-protected from the world. We don't celebrate Halloween and I wouldn't appreciate being pressured into it being forced upon us.

3scape · 22/10/2021 09:36

You know what bothers your child. I tried pre warning my daughter's nursery about how scared she was of people in Santa costumes. They thought I was being a bit precious. Until she took off out of her classroom like a deer, scaled the fence to the next year group and hid in a playhouse until he was gone. They'll expect some to get overwhelmed but the lure of sweets can be compelling for some.

HiJenny35 · 22/10/2021 09:36

I'd keep him off, you know your child, some are ready and love scary things, my eldest was fine my youngest would have nightmares for weeks after. As for the "you need to expose your child to these things" don't be ridiculous, no 3 year old needs to be exposed to pretend blood, monsters, ghosts and very realistic and scary costumes, we wouldn't allow it on TV at this age or take them to a show that wasn't age appropriate so no because it's Halloween doesn't make it OK.
As for teachers know, they really don't, teacher of nearly 20 years and I've repeatedly seen children scared by things teachers thought would be ok but have misjudged the immaturity of the child, very easily done when you have a few in the class who are so much more grown up. He doesn't have to be in nursery at this age so a day off makes no difference at all. Stay home, do a mini disco, introduce a few lightly scary masks over Halloween to introduce the idea of it all being pretend. He'll be fine by next year but if he's not ready this year that's fine.

Porcupineintherough · 22/10/2021 09:31

It's totally fine to shield small children from all sorts of disturbing and frightening things, even if they will have to learn to deal with them eventually. In some circles it's even considered good parenting. Hmm

horseymum · 22/10/2021 09:23

Children have a right to feel safe at school and not scared.

appleturnovers · 22/10/2021 09:22

Personally I think Halloween costumes and decorations have gotten way scarier over the last 10-15 years. Some of the stuff is really realistic and gruesome, especially the zombie stuff. When I was a student I had to basically stay in my room the whole week of Halloween because some of the super-realistic zombie costumes and props were seriously triggering of a horrific incident in my life that I have no desire to be reminded of.

So yeah, if that's the sort of thing you're talking about then I agree. The older children should be able to have their fun, but I think at least the younger children and older children should be separated generally on that day, even if you can't 100% shield little children from anything scary.

horseymum · 22/10/2021 09:22

I'm not convinced we should hold schools up as always knowing what is appropriate, teachers make mistakes like anyone else. Their opinion on age appropriate is not always the same as yours. You know your child better. This is not teacher bashing by any stretch, just that you are your child's main influence and should be confident in that role. ( I used to be a teacher so know how hard it is) We have had several instances of inappropriate material in English, to the extent that my child is now totally switched off from the subject and we have lost faith in the department. It's not always as simple as changing school if you don't trust some of the staff, you have to engage with staff and explain the reasons.

Lindy2 · 22/10/2021 09:03
  • too
Lindy2 · 22/10/2021 09:03

I'd let him go but ask that the staff keep an eye on him. I'm sure he won't be the only little one a bit unsure of spooky stuff but I'd expect the school to have done this before and know how to make it fun and not to over the top scary.

As a PP said there does seem to be a shift away from thè more traditional cobwebs and bat decorations towards much more scary zombies and horror film characters (that I would hope most Primary school children wouldn't even know).

I'm on a large Facebook group where some mums have shared photos of their kids in Halloween make up and although the make up skills are very high quality the actual looks they have gone for are quite horrifying. Much to much for young kids and I can't believe driven by the actual children.

We're at a C of E school though so October is more about Harvest Festivals rather than Halloween which suits me just fine. I'm not sure Halloween should be a school thing at all really regardless of the type of school.

JudgeRindersMinder · 22/10/2021 08:48

I totally understand and respect people who don’t want to do hallowe’en for reasons of faith, but absolutely not for reasons/excuses of might be scared!
With kindness, get over yourself, and realise that you’ll look back and laugh at this in years to come!

girlmom21 · 22/10/2021 08:45

The school will know what's appropriate. If you don't trust their judgment, maybe he's at the wrong school.

kitcat15 · 22/10/2021 08:45

YABVU if you keep him off..... bet he has a great day

Swipe left for the next trending thread