Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another selfish, selfish man furious that no one was paying attention to him

220 replies

Notusuallyshocked · 22/10/2021 01:01

This just makes me so angry...

www.suffolknews.co.uk/ipswich/news/man-who-shot-wife-and-left-her-to-die-as-he-ate-breakfast-is-9222020/

He shot his wife and left their children to find her body because she 'wasn't paying enough attention to him or his needs'.

As the judge said, 'she was carrying the entire burden of running that house whilst you took to bed.'

An 8 year minimum sentence doesn't seem long enough. Another example of undervaluing women's lives.

OP posts:
50ShadesOfCatholic · 22/10/2021 08:24

@Naunet
You think? Do you follow sentencing? I do and 16years is indeed a lengthy sentence.

Notusuallyshocked · 22/10/2021 08:23

It's very lucky that he didn't harm the children.

OP posts:
Notusuallyshocked · 22/10/2021 08:23

8 years is not long enough.

It makes me so sad. That wonderful, brave woman doing everything at home and for her children Sad. And now they've lost the parent who was capable of putting them first. I don't care if he was ill, he was also a selfish, selfish man.

OP posts:
Naunet · 22/10/2021 07:59

@50ShadesOfCatholic

I don't disagree that his actions were outrageous and that he sounds like a dreadful person, but a 16 year sentence is lengthy. Eight years is the minimum to be served, he might well be kept longer.
16 years is lengthy?! For killing someone in cold blood with 2 children in the house? Lying for a gun licence too. Yeah, I think not. 50 years would be lengthy.
Naunet · 22/10/2021 07:58

That’s two men who have shot women this year that I’m aware, who lied to get a gun licence. Clearly the licensing checks aren’t working.

nettie434 · 22/10/2021 07:46

The judge's comments as reported here are telling. What I also took from the article is that the husband had contacts with mental health professionals in 26 days out of the 42 days preceding him shooting his wife but he refused to take the anti anxiety medication he had been prescribed. I wonder the the procedures are for informing the authorities if you have a mental health problem and hold a gun licence? This is not an example of someone whose mental health worsened but who slipped through the system.

I feel very sorry for the poor children. They have lost their mother and are now effectively parentless.

DorsVenabili · 22/10/2021 05:18

nicegerbil it's the diminished responsibility that i was focusing on
Murder is committed when a person of sound mind unlawfully kills another person
The defense of diminished responsibility reduces the murder conviction by removing malice aforethought. For example, if the offender has an abnormality of mental functioning caused by a recognised medical condition, diminished responsibility may be pleaded successfully. It will, however, be necessary to obtain and serve complex medical evidence as to the state of mind of the accused, at the time of the offence and leading up to it.

The terminology does matter- it's why it is (or should be) manslaughter if a woman kills a man after prolonged abuse rather than murder - & impacts the sentence

50ShadesOfCatholic · 22/10/2021 05:05

I don't disagree that his actions were outrageous and that he sounds like a dreadful person, but a 16 year sentence is lengthy. Eight years is the minimum to be served, he might well be kept longer.

NiceGerbil · 22/10/2021 03:10

'Hartshorne-Jones denied murder at an earlier hearing. The charge was dropped as prosecutors accepted his plea of manslaughter due to diminished responsibility.'

He was charged with murder. Changed to manslaughter as would mean guilty plea.

Max sentence same I believe.? I think anyway.

So they prosecuted for manslaughter.

I'm sure you're aware that people tend to say murder in RL in a general 'he killed her' way rather than talking legalese?

Eg. Legal. Found guilty of causing or inciting a child under the age of 13 to engage in sexual.
Public- he sexually abused her.

No?

He shot his wife twice while she was in bed. Two children in the house. Then he went and had his breakfast.

And you feel the need to quibble over the use of the word murder?

alexdgr8 · 22/10/2021 02:57

it was not murder.
he pleaded guilty to manslaughter by reason of psychosis.

DorsVenabili · 22/10/2021 02:46

He;s been remanded in a psychiatric hospital and the prosecution accepted his plea of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility- so appears to be pretty severe ( this was in the link given by the OP)
Judge also said "the case brought a sharp focus on an array of topical issues including violence against women and the impact the pandemic has had on people's mental health." ITV

Obviously it could be an elaborate defense/excuse - i think thats what the victim's family think- but based on the evidence that we can see its hard to say.
I'm not saying any of this to diminish the horror of what he did or of women who are killed by their abuser/through domestic abuse

NiceGerbil · 22/10/2021 02:15

Judge comments don't seem impressed. Reasons for murder MH not mentioned.

Do you have the full judges comments?

NiceGerbil · 22/10/2021 02:14

Can you provide different info to show who said what about his MH please?

Loads of people have MH issues from mild to severe.

They don't go around killing people.

To have it as defence/ mitigation it needs to be full on psychosis as in no idea what doing. Hallucinating. Really far gone.

Got a link?

SammyScrounge · 22/10/2021 02:12

He was given a life sentence of 16 years with a minimum of 8 years to be served in a psychiatric hospital.

DorsVenabili · 22/10/2021 02:09

I'm not sure its as clear cut as selfish man kills wife- he clearly has/had a psychiatric issue - and thats not just what the defence said
I do think one issue is why should someone with mental health issues be able to get a gun licence-and whilst i can see that he lied surely you shouldn't be able to lie- there should be some sort of central check/need to get a medical sign off etc

StrangerYears · 22/10/2021 02:01

Judge Levett 'highlighted that since Mrs Hartshorne-Jones’ death 120 women had been killed, with seven women a month killed by current or former partners."

that is shocking. If it was a defined group , (eg teens, pub fights)
other than abusive partners, killing at this rate, there would be uproar. But for murdered women it is just a small article in a local paper.

NiceGerbil · 22/10/2021 01:37

In that article what sticks out for me.

Is that the judge's comments- surely the major item when it comes to the case- were right at the end.

And those comments were strong and clear.

Yet at the top it's loads of - MH worsening, scared of COVID, she dropped tissues, murder dropped to manslaughter etc.

Many people don't get to the end.

And even if you do, the scene has been set/ you have been presented with the stuff at the start that could well make the judge comments less powerful iyswim.

It's back to front.

I assume at least some of the top bits were from defence - who didn't win.

Why this common thing to do stuff like this in the press?

I read s thing about reporting VAWG a while back. Which said it was really unhelpful that so often media present the defence arguments during the trial uncritically.

Eg murdered women had a secret lover!!!

Later. Well no. That was an excuse made by the murderer.

Notusuallyshocked · 22/10/2021 01:20

Thank you for the link @Etinoxaurus. I will ask for the sentence to be reviewed (as I hope the family are doing). 8 years is not long enough. A lifetime wouldn't make up for what this arrogant, self-centred man has done.

Yes, he apparently had anxiety/hypochondria, but he lied on his shotgun licence renewal application and failed to take his anxiety medication.

Those poor children Sad. He probably made their home hellish in the lead up to the killing too.

OP posts:
Etinoxaurus · 22/10/2021 01:13

28 days for anyone to appeal
mailto:[email protected]
You need to give his name, the date and the sentence.
Sad poor woman.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 22/10/2021 01:10

Imagine the carnage if 50 year old women started shooting people who weren't paying attention to them.