Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another selfish, selfish man furious that no one was paying attention to him

220 replies

Notusuallyshocked · 22/10/2021 01:01

This just makes me so angry...

www.suffolknews.co.uk/ipswich/news/man-who-shot-wife-and-left-her-to-die-as-he-ate-breakfast-is-9222020/

He shot his wife and left their children to find her body because she 'wasn't paying enough attention to him or his needs'.

As the judge said, 'she was carrying the entire burden of running that house whilst you took to bed.'

An 8 year minimum sentence doesn't seem long enough. Another example of undervaluing women's lives.

OP posts:
Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 12:42

Didn't the judge specifically link the killing to the wider issue of male violence against women? So it's wrong to say it's not about men. It is. Men kill and abuse women in vastly greater numbers than women kill and abuse men.

OP posts:
KayKayWat · 24/10/2021 12:37

I think it's a bit repulsive that the same old posters are trying to take a story about a tragedy caused by severe mental illness and shoehorn it into another diatribe about men.

HarrietsChariot · 24/10/2021 11:50

He was mentally ill. Courts treat people with mental health problems differently to healthy people if they did not have full mental capacity to understand their actions and have control over them.

It's an unfortunate case, and I agree there is an argument that mental health shouldn't be taken into account for people who kill and that we should have the death penalty for people like this, as the law stands the sentence is pretty harsh if anything.

thedancingbear · 24/10/2021 11:42

Except this isn’t what fucking happened, is it?

Talk about trying to shift the narrative. Talk about pushing an MRA agenda

Absolutely disgusting

2Two · 24/10/2021 11:01

Life should equal life. End of.
Manslaughter should only be for genuine accidents

Suppose, @MumofBreck, someone you love gets into a massively abusive relationship so that they are totally ground down and become seriously mentally ill. Eventually they snap and kill the abuser. Should that person be convicted of murder and spend the rest of their life in prison?

x2boys · 24/10/2021 10:53

There was a case near me last year ,a women randomly stabbed a little girl to death on a park ,she was also mentally ill she also got a life sentence with a minimum of 8 years ,to serve in one of the special hospitals like this man I suspect she will be in hospital for far longer,the point people are missing is that mental health services have been stripped bare for many years.

MrsClatterbuck · 24/10/2021 10:45

We have a case here in Ni where a man locked his wife in the car and then set it alight. She was rescued from the car but died a day or two later. Can't get my head around it tbh

MumofBreck · 24/10/2021 10:45

Life should equal life. End of.
Would anyone want this monster back on the streets on or off medicine? How can he be trusted as he doesn’t value life. Manslaughter should only be for genuine accidents. Sentencing is ridiculous here.
If he ever gets out he won’t be safe for public consumption. I don’t care where but he has proven that he needs to be locked up to keep others safe.

Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 10:42

It has nothing to do with the victim's identity.

Their respective levels of culpability were poles apart, as was the extent to which they demonstrated remorse after the killings.

OP posts:
x2boys · 24/10/2021 10:36

Why isn't it comparable ,they were both psychotic at the time of killing ,both had become ill during lockdown
Or do you not think the killing of a disabled child mattered as much
My child has similar disabilities,so I'm very aware of how hard lock down was

2Two · 24/10/2021 10:32

But the psychiatric report found no evidence that he was legally insane at the time or incapable of having the intention to kill his wife

Someone must have accepted that he had no genuine intention to kill his wife (other than a a delusion-caused intention) otherwise they wouldn't have accepted the diminished responsibility plea. The elements of that are:

He was suffering from an abnormality of mental functioning;
From a recognised medical condition;
Which substantially impaired his ability to understand his conduct, form a rational judgment or exercise self-control.

If you don't understand your conduct and can't form a rational judgment, you can't frame a genuine, sane intention to kill. Plus, as has been pointed out, no-one gets committed to a mental hospital indefinitely without being seriously ill.

Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 10:31

Yep I mentioned this up thread apparently it wasn't comparable according to the op ,which are found quite sickening as the parent of a severely disabled child

But it wasn't comparable. That doesn't mean the killing of that little boy wasn't dreadful. Just that you can't draw parallels between it and the present case. The circumstances of the two killings and the mitigating/aggravating factors were entirely different...hence the different sentences.

OP posts:
KayKayWat · 24/10/2021 10:27

Guarantee if it had been a woman who killed her husband people would've been sympathetic, probably insinuating that he was abusive or it was down to the mental load of doing the housework.

2Two · 24/10/2021 10:26

@TeachesOfPeaches

He got a life sentence of 16 years with minimum 8 to be served
As I've said above, this cannot be true. A life sentence is a life sentence, it isn't determinate. You can have a life sentence with a recommendation that parole can't be considered before a minimum period has been served, but you can't then have a second date that brings the life sentence to an end. There is no mention of 16 years in other reports and it appears to be a mistake in the report linked to in this thread.
x2boys · 24/10/2021 10:23

[quote KayKayWat]Interesting comparison to read the below thread about a mother murdering her son in a similar state of dimished responsibility.

It's titled 'Poor Poor Woman' and there is much sympathy for her despite her son apparently 'howling like a dog in distress' as she suffocated him.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4147066-Poor-poor-woman[/quote]
Yep I mentioned this up thread apparently it wasn't comparable according to the op ,which are found quite sickening as the parent of a severely disabled child

x2boys · 24/10/2021 10:21

@Notusuallyshocked

This is the nature of psychosis,many people with psychosis lack the capacity to understand that they are lll and they need to take medication ,some people have g to be forced to take medication in injectable forms using mental health law

This man was not psychotic all the time. That would have made him insane. At most he was a depressive hypochondriac who was alleged to have killed his wife during a psychotic episode. Even if you accept the medical evidence that he lacked capacity at the time of the killing (which the judge seemed sceptical about), he had capacity the rest of the time.

The verdict was diminished responsibility. It wasn't not guilty by reason of insanity.

Ime Judges tend not to have a good understanding of mental illness, i would have thought ,the forensic Psychiatrist ,s who have years of experience in this field will have a better understanding of this man's illness tbh
KayKayWat · 24/10/2021 10:19

Interesting comparison to read the below thread about a mother murdering her son in a similar state of dimished responsibility.

It's titled 'Poor Poor Woman' and there is much sympathy for her despite her son apparently 'howling like a dog in distress' as she suffocated him.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4147066-Poor-poor-woman

Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 10:17

This is the nature of psychosis,many people with psychosis lack the capacity to understand that they are lll and they need to take medication ,some people have g to be forced to take medication in injectable forms using mental health law

This man was not psychotic all the time. That would have made him insane. At most he was a depressive hypochondriac who was alleged to have killed his wife during a psychotic episode. Even if you accept the medical evidence that he lacked capacity at the time of the killing (which the judge seemed sceptical about), he had capacity the rest of the time.

The verdict was diminished responsibility. It wasn't not guilty by reason of insanity.

OP posts:
Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 10:12

I do have a question though, assuming this man recovers and is released in 8 years will he be allowed to take full custody of those boys? That's would be awful if so.

I don't think that would ever happen. Decisions as to who looks after the boys will be made based on their best interests and I can't see it ever being in their best interests to be brought up by their mother's killer. Especially given the evidence suggests he is an entirely unfit person to have charge of two children. The boys were lucky to survive imo. This case bears chilling similarities to other family destruction cases where men snap and kill their entire families.

OP posts:
KayKayWat · 24/10/2021 10:11

I don't care about this man. The fact he still refuses to engage with mental health support even after killing his wife as eliminated any sympathy or understanding I might have had.

Yes, it's almost as if he's not thinking right isn't it?

x2boys · 24/10/2021 10:11

@startrek90

I don't care about this man. The fact he still refuses to engage with mental health support even after killing his wife as eliminated any sympathy or understanding I might have had.

The people I feel sorry for are his wife who lost her life and her two sons who found her body. I hope they have mental health support to come to terms with what has happened to them. I do have a question though, assuming this man recovers and is released in 8 years will he be allowed to take full custody of those boys? That's would be awful if so.

This is the nature of psychosis,many people with psychosis lack the capacity to understand that they are lll and they need to take medication ,some people have g to be forced to take medication in injectable forms using mental health law .
startrek90 · 24/10/2021 10:05

I don't care about this man. The fact he still refuses to engage with mental health support even after killing his wife as eliminated any sympathy or understanding I might have had.

The people I feel sorry for are his wife who lost her life and her two sons who found her body. I hope they have mental health support to come to terms with what has happened to them. I do have a question though, assuming this man recovers and is released in 8 years will he be allowed to take full custody of those boys? That's would be awful if so.

KayKayWat · 24/10/2021 10:03

Nobody said that mentally ill people can't have the intention to kill. It's about the reasoning. Like, you can kill somebody in self defence if you genuinely thought your life was in danger.

Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 09:49

However the root of the problem seems to have been that he had actually gone insane

No he hadn't. No evidence was found that he was insane or incapable of having an intention to kill.

OP posts:
Notusuallyshocked · 24/10/2021 09:48

Have you actually read the story?

Yes I have.

He wasn't insane. The actual finding was manslaughter due to diminished responsibility - that's diminished responsibility not no responsibility. The diminished responsibility was due to depressive hypochondria, apparently with psychotic symptoms. But the psychiatric report found no evidence that he was legally insane at the time or incapable of having the intention to kill his wife.

The judge appears to have been very unimpressed with him.

"You thought your wife, the victim of this fatal shooting, was not paying enough attention to you and your needs," said the judge.

“She was carrying the entire burden of running that house whilst you took to bed."

The judge noted that Hartshorne-Jones had refused to take his anxiety medication. He lied on his gun licence renewal forms. He had multiple contacts with health professionals on 26 days out of the 42 days before the tragedy. This was not a man who was being ignored. This was a man who failed completely and totally to take responsibility for himself and his mental state so he didn't pose a danger to those around him.

The judge viewed assessing culpability as posing a 'complex challenge'. Hartshorne-Jones made no comment in police interviews. The evidence as to diminished responsibility was accepted by prosecutors and not tried in court. In particular: Judge Levett said that none of the three psychiatrists who had assessed Hartshorne-Jones appeared to have asked him: ‘Why did you shoot your wife?’ According to the psychiatrist, Hartshorne-Jones 'maintains largely that he doesn't know what happened' and 'reserts being asked about' the killing.

This raises questions about the quality of the evidence. It also doesn't really sound like a man overcome with remorse. Instead, he sounds like a thoroughly awful and self-centred man who is still refusing to take responsibility for what he has done.

OP posts: