Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
Softleftpowerstance · 26/10/2021 19:09

Has your GD been allowed to read this letter?

Does she feel able to meet the terms and conditions set out?

Has she been able to articulate how she wants to raise her child in the early years?

--The letter is setting her up to fail and allows you and her mother to continue to duck the actual issues. --

Howshouldibehave · 26/10/2021 18:39

@redhilary

Thank You Murdoch.

To the other posters, It seems like Murdoch knows a thing or two about how schools think. This is because this morning a letter arrived from the school at my friends house.

Firstly the letter was very polite and positive in its nature asking about elder sister and making complimentary remarks about her school achievements . (totally irrelevant but it sets up the letters positive tone)

OK. The crux of the letter, highlights the issues facing the school and indicates possible solutions to Goddaughter remaining there. Firstly how they intend supporting Goddaughter in the school setting, until she begins her Maternity leave in the middle of November. This being the Doctor's recommended time to begin her Maternity leave and is 32/33 weeks into her pregnancy.

Post pregnancy they are keen to be updated and kept informed about her progress with the baby and wellbeing. Therefore, when possible/plausible would expect Goddaughter to undertake some A level study via the means of remote learning. The school will make work available for her remotely, they will mark/grade the work give back positive and negative feedback the same way as all the other year 12 pupils. Thus, seeking to keep her readily engaged in her education during her early post pregnancy.

The school are aware that for Goddaughter, to meet her academic potential, it may be required for her to repeat year 12 at the school or through another educational provider. Thus, they are prepared to consider readmitting her to year 12 beginning in September 2022. This being provided she positively engages, firstly with her remaining time at the school pre-pregnancy and then with the work provided online. They also would expect Goddaughter to attend the current year 11' s three Sixth Form inset days in July . There are a few more terms and conditions but this is the summary .

The letter than goes on to suggest that they have possibly not supported Goddaughter's SEN needs as well as they could have, over the last two difficult school years.

Finally. they add that Goddaughter has the ability to educationally thrive at A level study and enter in to Higher Education post the completion of year 13.

Well, that was a timely letter indeed.
redhilary · 26/10/2021 18:07

Thank You Murdoch.

To the other posters, It seems like Murdoch knows a thing or two about how schools think. This is because this morning a letter arrived from the school at my friends house.

Firstly the letter was very polite and positive in its nature asking about elder sister and making complimentary remarks about her school achievements . (totally irrelevant but it sets up the letters positive tone)

OK. The crux of the letter, highlights the issues facing the school and indicates possible solutions to Goddaughter remaining there. Firstly how they intend supporting Goddaughter in the school setting, until she begins her Maternity leave in the middle of November. This being the Doctor's recommended time to begin her Maternity leave and is 32/33 weeks into her pregnancy.

Post pregnancy they are keen to be updated and kept informed about her progress with the baby and wellbeing. Therefore, when possible/plausible would expect Goddaughter to undertake some A level study via the means of remote learning. The school will make work available for her remotely, they will mark/grade the work give back positive and negative feedback the same way as all the other year 12 pupils. Thus, seeking to keep her readily engaged in her education during her early post pregnancy.

The school are aware that for Goddaughter, to meet her academic potential, it may be required for her to repeat year 12 at the school or through another educational provider. Thus, they are prepared to consider readmitting her to year 12 beginning in September 2022. This being provided she positively engages, firstly with her remaining time at the school pre-pregnancy and then with the work provided online. They also would expect Goddaughter to attend the current year 11' s three Sixth Form inset days in July . There are a few more terms and conditions but this is the summary .

The letter than goes on to suggest that they have possibly not supported Goddaughter's SEN needs as well as they could have, over the last two difficult school years.

Finally. they add that Goddaughter has the ability to educationally thrive at A level study and enter in to Higher Education post the completion of year 13.

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 26/10/2021 16:06

She will find A levels difficult, nearly every student does, but there are students who flourish post-16 when concentrating on their favourite subjects. As an ex Head of Sixth Form I can confirm that students with babies can cope back at school, and can achieve to a high standard. However, grammar schools tend to be very narrow minded about their sixth formers, choosing to focus on students who want to progress to university, particularly Oxbridge. Their attention to apprenticeship seekers can be scant, and certainly pregnant students are not their chosen cohort. If the girl is determined to return to her school, there is a good case to be made for it, and she needs to be working hard on her subjects throughout her pregnancy. If the school refuses a place, an appeal to the governors is appropriate. But she should also investigate other local schools with sixth forms to have a plan B. College may not be an appropriate venue for her, she may need the additional support a school sixth form gives.

Viviennemary · 26/10/2021 11:59

In your eyes the school doesn't seem to have handled things to your satisfaction over a number of years. Its difficult to see why you think she should remain there in spite of their apparent failings. It looks to me as if you are determined to get your own way and to browbeat the school into accepting her back. Even if its not in the girl's best interest.

Homelearningandvaddie · 26/10/2021 10:33

Op I think you need to make clear to your goddaughter that she is the one who has to take responsibility for this. She no longer has the luxury of being immature she has a child to care and provide for. You need to stop thinking about the wrong thing you are focusing all your energy on the school being crap, the lack of support for ASD, the downsides of a higher education college and the boyfriend all of that is a peripheral issue. Ultimately the school is utterly unsuitable on many levels and also clearly doesn’t want her so she can’t stay, there really is no option. Also the idea of her being away from her baby 5 days a week is for the birds. Your friend and her mother can’t simply decide they will act like the mother when the mother is GD and she needs to be the primary caregiver while the mother and grandma can help out and offer support you can’t just pretend it’s their baby. The person who has to step up is your GD for the huge life changing event that’s about to happen to her forget about the education as your main focus and enrol at a college that has the ability to support a young mum and focus on her and the baby.

Howshouldibehave · 26/10/2021 09:03

No senco has the time to come and remove a disruptive student every time they do something they shouldn't. Sounds like the girl and the school are a bad fit

I’m glad someone else said this. As a virtually full-time teaching senco, I wonder what I would be supposed to do with my own classes if I was coming in and out of them at this rate to sort out endless situations in other people’s lessons!

OP, I think you need to withdraw here and let the teen and her family sort this out-with her and the baby at the centre of any decisions made-NOT with a grammar school and A levels being the starting point! This clearly isn’t your fault, contrary to the frankly bizarre suggestion by the sister that it was. Focus on your own family and leave them to their mother.

hedgehogger1 · 25/10/2021 22:18

@redhilary

Yearssince *She is disrespectful at school-swearing and destroying furniture * She is sly...sneaking out of the house without anyone knowing in order to have sex. * She is now pregnant * She says she wants to be rat-arsed for her birthday.

Firstly these two school incidents are partly down to the poor provision of SEN support (the school needs to improve on that for any future girls who might need support )

The first incident in year 10 occurred because all the girls were talking amongst themselves about what a 'Selfish Twat' the head is. However, Autistic people have a habit of speaking their minds openly so Goddaughter shouted at the head that she was a 'Selfish Twat' instead of keeping her opinions to herself. What should have happened is the SENCO should have been called and moved Goddaughter to a room hence told her to write an instant Apology letter to the Head This would have made Goddaughter aware had done and given her the option to remedy her actions. No the school acted in a inappropriate manner firstly by instantly placing her in to isolation for the remainder of the day and registering the isolation. Then the school brought this incident up in the year 10/11 assembly by highlighting the unacceptable conduct of some girls with the head of year 11 looking directly at Goddaughter.

The second incident (the broken chair one) happened in year 11. Goddaughter was texting the 'Boy' who had been bombarding her with texts for three days about waiting outside the gates for her at 3.30 .
The school have an 'instant' 1hr after school detention policy for use of a mobile phone in class. The Math's teacher thus walks over to her, pulls the phone directly out of her hand informing her and the class of her 1hr instant detention. Guess what 'Bingo' Goddaughter gets up, kicks her chair and accidentally breaks it. This results in a three day External Exclusion.

Again what should have happened here, is that the Math's teacher should have contacted the SENCO through her phone on her desk about Goddaughters use of the mobile in the lesson. The SENCO should then have collected Goddaughter from the classroom, talked to her for a few minutes and then asked her to hand over the phone. After that the SENCO should inform her of the sanction for her actions. That being an 'instant' after school detention. This is surely the correct way to diffuse a situation with an Autistic girl. An Autistic person is likely to act differently, to how a Neuro-typical person might in instantly understanding the consequences of showing their frustration, through an inappropriate action.

Please don't be nasty and unsympathetic towards her, by trying to paint her as someone who is reaping what they sowed through her actions.

No senco has the time to come and remove a disruptive student every time they do something they shouldn't. Sounds like the girl and the school are a bad fit
Softleftpowerstance · 25/10/2021 19:32

OP your support for your GD is admirable but you have to accept there are limits to what you can do here.

Your thinking is unhelpfully black and white. It is not an either/or choice between staying at the grammar and living on benefits for ever. It is a very good thing for the young woman to get get the best qualifications that she can. But lots of posters have suggested that doing that via an unsupportive school environment might not be the best route.

Every adult involved in this young woman’s life seems intent on minimising the actual pregnancy. You may be close to your GD but you don’t appear to have had the conversations with her that she needs about whether adoption is an option and if not how she intends to raise her child. That’s fine, you don’t have to solve everything. But support that puts the GD’s needs first is the most important thing for someone to provide. I honestly think this is a situation where a social worker could help.

You come across as someone who is projecting your own experiences onto the young woman and are in essence trying to save your own past self. The sister’s blame towards you is unhinged and the mother’s fixation on the chain of underage mothers is an odd distraction. All of you have lost sight of the wood for the trees.

YearsSinceISawYou · 25/10/2021 19:12

@redhilary

In the nicest possible way, I think you have got to stop looking for reasons as to why the world is out of step and not your God-daughter.

To me, and I might have the wrong impression, you are anxious to at least find someone who can share the blame with her instead of saying to her, 'This is your fault and your alone.'

I still think all this energy being expended on whether or not she can go back is a distraction technique. It's as if you are channeling Nero and his violin while Rome burns.

It may all be academic because the way in which you describe her and the constant excusing of her bad behaviour, may very likely point to baby number two making an appearance before the first one is walking.

I would still be interested to know what your family thought of her sister blaming you for this girl's pregnancy? Were they not outraged on your behalf?

Anyway, I'm wishing you all the very best. This family do not sound like good news for you.

TheMadGardener · 25/10/2021 19:04

But OP, you're still posting reams about past events and what the school SHOULD have done. That's all in the past and can't be changed. It's only relevant in that you're saying your GD's needs have not been met by the school and they are not good at SEN provision.

And yet you and her mother are still determined that she should go back there? I don't understand why, when you obviously don't rate the school's provision for her. Will they suddenly make more allowances for her SEN when she has a baby in tow? Probably not. Will she be a calmer student when she has had all the turmoil of giving birth and dealing with an unpredictable, demanding infant? Very unlikely. Are there other educational settings more suited to her future needs? Most posters on his thread have said so.

But I'm wasting my time saying this because you will just start quoting exam stats again or telling us how the school let GD down when she was in Y7. None of which helps her with her current situation. From what you've said I doubt she really wants to take your advice. Does she even want a baby, or to go to uni? Or is she being pressured into both by the adults in her life?

redhilary · 25/10/2021 17:32

Require the same consequences to their actions . I have got to stop rushing because I keep missing words out.

OP posts:
redhilary · 25/10/2021 17:29

This is to answer the question about whether the school is meeting Goddaughter's SEN requirements.

OP posts:
redhilary · 25/10/2021 17:27

The interesting point about the school not meeting the needs is probably down to some individual teachers and the poor SLT . This is because in English Chemistry and History which happen to be the three A levels current being taken . The teachers involved in these three subjects have been teaching Goddaughter for years and so have commonly used strategies similar to what I proposed earlier. It is the lack of uniformity or guidance from the SLT team , which at times has meant Goddaughters needs have not been met. An example of her current English teacher who also taught her in year 8 being able to both comfort and discipline her at the same time. This being her first after school Detention for not doing Homework and for being cheeky in class. That is a symptom of if people are going to talk about me or mock me, let them do it on my terms . Firstly her English teacher comforted her when she was crying over the Detention before explaining calmly to her that her behaviour was not good enough and she is better than that. Thus, bringing her raging emotions right down, potentially stopping her form doing something like chair kicking incident.

This is a good management technique for dealing with 'bright' children with additional SEN needs. These kids are far from stupid and the same consequences to their actions but need slight adjustments in how the consequences are in- acted.

Do you think some of the girls might have wound up Goddaughter, to do their dirty work for them by Swearing at the Head for not allowing a Non Uniform day. In an office environment as you know there can be a patsy possibly Autistic or not the brightest. used for other peoples gains or motives. This is likely what happened with that incident.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 25/10/2021 17:10

@redhilary

There is currently a thread which is similar to this running on A.I.B.U. The fact it is about a boy starting education is not the point, because many of the facts or interventions/strategies explained or equally relevant to a Year 12 Girl Autistic Girl.
This thread is more about how a pregnant 16 year old will cope with education after she’s had a baby though.
redhilary · 25/10/2021 16:53

There is currently a thread which is similar to this running on A.I.B.U. The fact it is about a boy starting education is not the point, because many of the facts or interventions/strategies explained or equally relevant to a Year 12 Girl Autistic Girl.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 25/10/2021 16:12

You seem to think the school isn’t meeting her needs at the moment, so why would you think it would be any better adding in a newborn and putting the teen in with a younger cohort of children?!

Yes, people with degrees-autistic or not-probably have better outcomes than those without. People pregnant at 16 will probably struggle though.

Fighting to stay at this school sounds like a mistake. If she’s choosing to keep the baby, then she can make education decisions after the baby is born. It might be A levels, it might be a btec, it might be an access course. It might be none of these things and she gets a part time job around her baby. That is for her and her parents to decide.

Sirzy · 25/10/2021 14:18

It seems your quick to blame everyone else for her actions.

Autistic or not she isn’t above the school rules and that certainly doesn’t justify calling the head a selfish twat!

But if you believe the SEN support is so poor then why would you want to fight for her to stay there? Hmm

Scirocco · 25/10/2021 14:17

The two school incidents may be relevant to whether or not the school is prepared to go the extra mile for her, but they really aren't the key issues here.

And is your account of what "should have happened" actually what is documented in any formal support plan, or is it an expectation that you have personally? Without a formal agreed plan for what to do in those situations, the teachers will have (quite reasonably) followed their standard processes. If there was a plan and it wasn't followed, that's a different issue.

To be honest, if anyone had behaved like that at the school I attended, they would have been disciplined. Not necessarily removed from the school or told not to come back, but they would have received clear disciplinary action.

redhilary · 25/10/2021 14:07

Yearssince
*She is disrespectful at school-swearing and destroying furniture

  • She is sly...sneaking out of the house without anyone knowing in order to have sex.
  • She is now pregnant
  • She says she wants to be rat-arsed for her birthday.

Firstly these two school incidents are partly down to the poor provision of SEN support (the school needs to improve on that for any future girls who might need support )

The first incident in year 10 occurred because all the girls were talking amongst themselves about what a 'Selfish Twat' the head is. However, Autistic people have a habit of speaking their minds openly so Goddaughter shouted at the head that she was a 'Selfish Twat' instead of keeping her opinions to herself. What should have happened is the SENCO should have been called and moved Goddaughter to a room hence told her to write an instant Apology letter to the Head This would have made Goddaughter aware had done and given her the option to remedy her actions. No the school acted in a inappropriate manner firstly by instantly placing her in to isolation for the remainder of the day and registering the isolation. Then the school brought this incident up in the year 10/11 assembly by highlighting the unacceptable conduct of some girls with the head of year 11 looking directly at Goddaughter.

The second incident (the broken chair one) happened in year 11. Goddaughter was texting the 'Boy' who had been bombarding her with texts for three days about waiting outside the gates for her at 3.30 .
The school have an 'instant' 1hr after school detention policy for use of a mobile phone in class. The Math's teacher thus walks over to her, pulls the phone directly out of her hand informing her and the class of her 1hr instant detention. Guess what 'Bingo' Goddaughter gets up, kicks her chair and accidentally breaks it. This results in a three day External Exclusion.

Again what should have happened here, is that the Math's teacher should have contacted the SENCO through her phone on her desk about Goddaughters use of the mobile in the lesson. The SENCO should then have collected Goddaughter from the classroom, talked to her for a few minutes and then asked her to hand over the phone. After that the SENCO should inform her of the sanction for her actions. That being an 'instant' after school detention. This is surely the correct way to diffuse a situation with an Autistic girl. An Autistic person is likely to act differently, to how a Neuro-typical person might in instantly understanding the consequences of showing their frustration, through an inappropriate action.

Please don't be nasty and unsympathetic towards her, by trying to paint her as someone who is reaping what they sowed through her actions.

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 25/10/2021 13:56

Thus, Goddaughter has more chance with a Degree than without one of escaping 40 years on ESA and PIP.

Not one person has said she shouldn’t get a degree. All people are saying is that she shouldn’t be shoehorned into the path she was on as that path has now changed. She wants to stay on that path, as by doing so she can pretend everything is the same and nothing is changing. But it won’t be, and indulging this fantasy is doing her a great disservice.

There is no reason she can’t get a degree but once she chose to have a baby, the reality is that the path to get there may be a different path with a different timeframe. I would focus the energy there and supporting her with this, rather than concentrating on pretending to her that her life will be exactly the same (and even trying to facilitate this by letting her pretend she doesn’t have a baby 5 days a week), and distracting yourself with school stats.

HoppingPavlova · 25/10/2021 13:49

Dumplings yes I do know the number, which is about 8%.

Is that only covering those that are diagnosed though? Over the decades I worked with many people who would have ramped it in had they had ever been diagnosed but in my day unless you had Kanner type autism you were just classed as weird/odd/naughty/overdue for a good smack etc. Aspergers didn’t even exist as a diagnosis back in my day, that came subsequently and alas has now been cannibalised by the ASD umbrella. Lots of specialty occupations are stacked with undiagnosed people who don’t form part of official stats. That will well change as this gen comes through where many (but by no means all) are diagnosed, but I’d be careful about throwing out ‘firm stats’ of people who would fit the current dsm definition of autism in regards to participation in the workforce.

redhilary · 25/10/2021 11:37

My thread might be disjointed in nature, but this is why up-thread I pointed out ESA and £760 a month which many posters did not get. You probably know what I mean. I don't want her stuck on ESA and PIP in her mid twenties, because as you know Autistic people found it extremely difficult once on PIP and ESA to ever leave it.

The Government or more specifically Work and Pension's give absolutely Fuck all help to High Functioning Autistic adults. They want them to just disappear in a hole I think. This is another reason why unlike other people on the 'DOLE' they never chase them asking what they are doing to change their circumstances. Work and Pensions realize that getting 'proper' employment for High functioning Autistic people is walking bare foot on 1000 degree Coles.

However, what little chance Goddaughter has in an work environment , which despite the so called progressive outlook today, which actually is more discriminatory than twenty years ago. An example being an Autistic person might have a gift for something but because they can only achieve a Grade2/ 3 in GCSE Math's/ English they have no chance to show their natural ability.

Thus, Goddaughter has more chance with a Degree than without one of escaping 40 years on ESA and PIP.

OP posts:
motherofthelittlescreamingone · 25/10/2021 11:37

Maybe one further way of thinking that might appeal to your friend is to understand that:

  • grammar schools do not necessarily have better teachers, what they have is pupils who have been selected from a particular ability range. Great when you have a child who fits the profile, but can be dispiriting to struggle - and realistically it will be a bit of a struggle to do herself justice (arguably, she has been struggling for some time given her particular needs).
  • your GD may get a better contextual offer as a later applicant from a FE college than from a grammar school (even with knowledge that she is a mother). An extra year or two in education is nothing at 16-20
redhilary · 25/10/2021 11:12

Dumplings yes I do know the number, which is about 8%. Autistic people particularly High Functioning ones are probably the most discriminated group in the U.K today.

Somehow it is seen as acceptable to discriminate against Autistic people, but that if they were another group would be declared as criminal actions.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread