Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 18:46

I've remembered both your old user names and your endless, ENDLESS weird obsession over grammar schools and exam results. It's literally all you ever post about. I remember you from about six or seven years ago.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 28/10/2021 18:44

@YouJustFoldItIn

It's not the done thing to out someone's previous user name on a thread.
Ok. But you did rather make it a 'thing' by flagging it up! Anyway, as you were...
redhilary · 28/10/2021 18:36

What are you going on about ?

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 28/10/2021 17:37

@youjustfolditin

Would you possibly elaborate or PM me?

YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 17:37

It's not the done thing to out someone's previous user name on a thread.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 28/10/2021 17:35

@YouJustFoldItIn

And grammar schools and the 11 plus in general, for that matter. It really is a complete obsession with you, isn't it?
Come on you can't leave us on that cliffhanger! Have we been wasting our time trying to offer constructive advice?
Howshouldibehave · 28/10/2021 17:26

@YouJustFoldItIn

Oh my god. The penny has just dropped as to who you are.

Now I understand the obsession and complete over-investment in this girl and her A levels.

?
YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 17:25

And grammar schools and the 11 plus in general, for that matter. It really is a complete obsession with you, isn't it?

YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 17:21

Oh my god. The penny has just dropped as to who you are.

Now I understand the obsession and complete over-investment in this girl and her A levels.

Whinge · 28/10/2021 16:23

OP your last post just shows you're too over-invested in this girl's life, not to mention weirdly obsessed with her grades and education. Confused Step back, let her live her own life even if it means making mistakes and stop interfering.

As for the work disciplinary, do you have any boundaries at all? Shock Stop discussing other people's private matters on a public forum.

redhilary · 28/10/2021 16:19

Results. * Fuck I nearly posted a whole thread without missing or incorrect words...

OP posts:
redhilary · 28/10/2021 16:18

I know the GCSE came out on August 12th before anyone calls me out for posting June. something else about the company and June on my mind that's why I posted June ...

OP posts:
redhilary · 28/10/2021 16:13

Are you Autistic Youjustfolditin and trying to pretend in life that you are just the same as everyone else, thus live by the same rules, act the same way and are quite normal really ! In which case you are headed for one great fall, with your appraisal of life. It might not come this year or next year because you might be flying, at the moment but it will happen.

If you are not Autistic you are very ignorant, just using buzz words, you have read about without knowing what they mean or actually what Sensory Overload is or its effects.

Secondly Goddaughter scored 367 on the Kent 11+ test with scores of (122) Math's (122) English and 123 (NVR). Traditionally the required score for passing the Kent 11+ is around 360 with no one component scoring less than 120. Does that mean she scraped a pass ! However, if she did scrape a pass according to you, she most certainly was not a 'lucky loser' in gaining entry to her schools Sixth Form.

The, ''Grammar" school does not require a pupil to attain a single grade 7 to be admitted in to its Sixth Form . Goddaughter attained 4 grade 7's (though we have to question the validity of her grades, due to Covid and the formulas used to calculate the results) DD's Grammar school must be producing very 'lackluster' grades for a Selective educational facility. This, because her 4 Grade 7 GCSE's are only marginally below the average number of grade 7's that were attained/given (like sweeties) to their year 11 Cohort in 2021 (with the supposedly inflated and inaccurate grade inflation given this June to pupils results).

If you want to get in to who is a '14' GCSE grade 9 'Super Selective' type and its "Bullshit", well DD2 scored 420 on the Kent test and was distraught , because she lost 3 points on her English component. She felt it was not fair because her friend who is not of the same ability in Math's gained a full house of 423. DD2 could have gone to any Grammar school in Kent or to any of the four Independent Schools, that offered her a 100% full Academic Scholarship . In the end she chose the same 'bog standard' Grammar that her elder sister attends. DD1 scored 385 on the Kent test (Super selective, probably not though I could not care less)

This brings me on to say given Goddaughters Autism and SEN issues, 4 Grade 7's are equal to her elder sisters , results or whatever my DD1 gets and even if DD2 achieves '14' grade 9's.

Finally, I am currently writing a work disciplinary report about a 19 year old employed Autistic 'lad/man, that swore at a customer, last Saturday. The customer probably not older than 20 himself, was pulling faces and mocking my employee for the fact that he was obviously Autistic due to his mannerisms. The "bully" was poking fun at the poor teenager with his mate giggling . This because he was brushing the floor with a brush, so he must be a S* because normal people don't have/do such lowly jobs. This, lad is likely to be fired because the two "twats" have reported him with his name badge on to Customer relations, who have informed the Area manager (who should be me, but is not because my promotions lets say have been hindered due to my Autism).
This lad is unlikely, to find a job anytime soon or later, he only got a job when he walked in, because I was prepared to find something for him to do, he has been with the store 3 weeks !

Show some bloody sympathy and understanding towards Autistic people.

Finally I believe if her Grandmother, Mother, Me ,Husband and my Mother step up to the mark for Goddaughter and her baby, she will at least equal my 3 B grades @ A level.

OP posts:
TheMadGardener · 28/10/2021 15:09

OP, you still haven't responded to posters' concerns about the care of the baby and the amount of support that GD will need with parenting. You have also now revealed that GD had screaming rows with her DM such that she ended up living with you, and that her DM has a history of drink problems as well as the screaming rows. These are the people who are planning to care for the new baby? Can you not see why many posters are more concerned about the welfare of the baby rather than the amount of A levels its mother may or may not achieve? If I was the GD's older sister or another relative/friend I'd be standing by to alert social services if I didn't think the people involved were not putting the baby's welfare first. You're all running round complaining about the school but who is ensuring the long-term safety of the baby?

YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 13:16

It takes years of coping strategies for High Functioning Autistic people to feel comfortable, building their wall. These walls can/will collapse if one brick is removed from them.

Being immature young and Autistic with things out of your control, is like being hit constantly in the head with a hammer.

This being because her Autism meant it was impossible for her to endure with the twice daily arguments between her mother and father

When her mother took her to visit an F.E College, she refused to enter the building because of fear of the unknown.

None of this bodes well for impending stresses of motherhood does it?

So she can't cope with changing to a FE college, but you think she can cope with a new baby while doing 3 A levels which sound a bit of a push for her in normal circumstances. Can you even hear what it is you are saying?

YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 12:43

I know this is wishful thinking on my part and that I can not be held responsible for the actions of a 16 year old girl. But I think we would now be discussing what Degree she wants to do, not which Pram to buy.

I agree with you 100% but unfortunately that decision has already been made and neither you nor I can change it. She's made the decision to have a baby. It doesn't sound as though she is was terribly academically motivated even before she was pregnant, and neither your nor her mother's ambitions for her is going to change that.

YouJustFoldItIn · 28/10/2021 12:35

Autism in its self is not an excuse for violent behaviour. However, if you understood what it is like being a young immature Autistic person under intense pressure, you might be more sympathetic. (if you had a constant pain in your head you might kick a chair yourself).

And how will her reactions to 'constant pain in her head' and to 'intense pressure' look when this immature autistic person struggles with the considerable challenges of a new baby? Her rigid routine and inability to cope with change? Screwed. Her need to protect herself from sensory overload? Screwed. Her inability to control her meltdowns when things get a bit much? That baby will be the one to pay the price for that, in terms of its emotional development at the very least. Sorry but it will. Let's just say it.

If her autism is going to be used as justification for why she has underachieved at school and failed to cope with the rules imposed on her then we have to face up the fact that she is going to need huge amounts of support to parent effectively, or even adequately.

Fuck - we all struggle with our first baby. But if she can't cope with the relatively minor stresses of a classroom environment without resorting to swearing and shouting at people and breaking furniture then what hope has she got of coping well with a baby, never mind a baby and A levels?

I know it's tempting to accuse the school of wanting to offload her so they don't see their results dip. Selective schools do have a habit of that. And I understand her mother's desire to insist that the school should not be allowed to sweep 'inconvenient' students under the carpet to make themselves look better.

But quite honestly, it doesn't sound like it's the right environment for her, and it hasn't been for a while. Perhaps the reason she is pregnant in the first place was a subconscious way of trying to deal with that.

Her results are lacklustre to say the least, for someone who got into (maybe just scraped into?) a selective school. And with those results it's debatable whether she'd cope with the rigours of A levels even with the required application and without the baby. Whether she possesses the intellect to cope with them is almost beside the point. It's only part of what's required to do well.

You have to ask if it isn't fairer and more appropriate all-round to just pull her out and let her have some space this year to cope with becoming a mother. God knows that will be hard enough.

Banging on the desk demanding that the school fulfils its obligations to her as 'a vulnerable young person with disabilities' is all very well, but it might not be in the girl's best interests to be there. Her mother needs to put her academic ambitions for her DD to one side and see the bigger picture.

redhilary · 28/10/2021 10:18

No the tutoring was done at my home and obviously I comforted, encouraged her and took the brunt of her persistent tantrums. Autistic 9/10 year olds when told they have an hour of tutoring today can become quite difficult and forceful in their opinions.

Goddaughter always tells me things before he mother, hence I was the first person she told what had happened and that she was pregnant.

Posters say why do you feel responsible or at fault, for Goddaughter's upcoming pregnancy. Giving my history with her, I believe I should have got her to get some clothes, get her in the car and bring her home with me during the lockdown . This, when it was obvious what was going to happen between her and the boy. Especially, I should have collected her when she was having blazing arguments with her mother about sneaking out . Goddaughter's mother was telling her to go and live anyway with me when angry which. I think Goddaughter might have liked to live with me then, as it would have given the opportunity to remove herself from her obsession of the 'boy' .

I know this is wishful thinking on my part and that I can not be held responsible for the actions of a 16 year old girl. But I think we would now be discussing what Degree she wants to do, not which Pram to buy.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 28/10/2021 09:31

@redhilary

Thanks Darbs.

P.s it was me who got Goddaughter through the 11+ tutoring and exam that's why I am so loathed to give up her grammar school place...

What do you mean by this-did you tutor her in English yourself?
redhilary · 28/10/2021 09:12

No she has got an after school detention next Tuesday not a lunchtime one. It is not because she finds the homework difficult, it is just act of defiance from her. Apparently she is finding year 9 Math's so boring. According to her there is no point doing stuff she has known how to do since she was 8 (she is classed as gifted and talented in Math's and Science ) DD2 is outstandingly good at Math's and Science for her age. The school expect her to get a Grade 9 GCSE mark for Math's when she takes it next year in year 10 . Thus, often naughtily DD1who struggles relatively with Math's has let's DD1 do her Math's homework for her.

The teachers are not stupid though thus on occasions have made DD1 do her homework again over lunchtime. One time DD1 s Math's teacher marked DD1s homework by saying 'excellent' work DD2 . 'DD1 Lunchtime detention'.

It is amusing at times having a very gifted child, but she can be a 'brat' at times. DD2 has been known to answer back Science teachers in Primary/Secondary School when she thinks they have given a wrong explanation.

There I am now talking about my DD's ...

OP posts:
Appuskidu · 28/10/2021 08:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Sirzy · 28/10/2021 07:25

Maybe stop being so focused on other families and concentrate on yours?

And maybe realise that micromanaging things doesn’t work! Seems you need to be in control of everything which doesn’t help anyone learn independence

HoppingPavlova · 28/10/2021 03:00

Tbh I wouldn’t blame your daughters. If you have been carrying on at home as you have been on this thread I wouldn’t wonder the wheels have fallen off a little for them. I can’t imagine it would be a great environment to be in. Maybe look to address this as priority rather than checking their work and blaming the school for not notifying you of one lunchtime detention.

I honestly can’t see the big deal with the homework detention anyway. That’s how kids learn. Your DD is in Year 9. Are you going to be checking work etc at uni? It’s the transition to independence and has to start somewhere and there will be some slip-ups but this is normal. It’s far more effective for a kid to be motivated to want to do homework because of the consequences of detentions rather than being treated as a young child being stood over and having work checked off by a parent. It’s only by getting the detentions that they can understand they don’t want to keep getting them and this causes an intrinsic change in their motivation to do the work. It’s a very safe way to let a kid fail in order to learn. It’s with these little ticket items you get these opportunities as opposed to big ticket items where it’s not a safe way to let a kid fail in order to learn such as drugs, pregnancy etc.

DumplingsAndStew · 28/10/2021 01:54

Well isn't she lucky then, to get a 'first offence' consequence for something she's done 3 times.

Maybe pay more attention to your own daughters, rather than your goddaughter.

redhilary · 27/10/2021 23:27

DD2 was given a lunchtime detention..

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread