Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 22:18

@redhilary

When the baby is asleep ! I am guessing the baby is likely to be asleep for about 14-15 hours a day....

Goddaughters school day 9-6 including coming home time is 9 hours . I work on that one but there is potential for collective study together for the girls.

You said that goddaughter will be at school 8-6 and so will be apart from her baby all of that time.

I would imagine from 6-8pm at least, she will be feeding, bathing and enjoying being with her tiny baby who she won’t have seen for ten hours. If she is then studying with your daughters after that in the evening, she is going to burnout very quickly.

Nobody is really considering the baby here.

redhilary · 29/10/2021 22:09

When the baby is asleep ! I am guessing the baby is likely to be asleep for about 14-15 hours a day....

Goddaughters school day 9-6 including coming home time is 9 hours . I work on that one but there is potential for collective study together for the girls.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 21:56

Because the posters are so ardent in their hatred of Grammar schools, they look for any inch they can to call or intimate that they are evil

I went to a grammar school, my parents went to a grammar school, my DH went to a grammar school and our children all went/go to a grammar school. I have nothing against them at all and had a wonderful education. It’s your attitude to this baby that I can’t get over.

Goddaughter needs to do more than 8 Hours a week study for three A levels...

Right, ok. I ask again. When in the week will your goddaughter be studying with your daughters?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/10/2021 21:44

Because the posters are so ardent in their hatred of Grammar schools, they look for any inch they can to call or intimate that they are evil.

I went to a grammar school. I had a great experience in mine and benefitted hugely from it long term, it offered me opportunities for which I am especially grateful for as a council estate kid with experience in the foster system.

I still think, as I've said, that your behaviour is undermining your friend, is not allowing her to step up and is unfair on your daughters.

It's nothing to do with grammar vs non grammar, you've entirely constructed that argument as you seem to think people are as fixated on it as you?

It's not about grammar vs non grammar, it's about overstepping boundaries, about causing irreparable damage to her and her mothers already tricky relationship and about not putting your daughters' needs at the centre of this.

Stop thinking everything is about people's feelings about grammar school - it isn't!

redhilary · 29/10/2021 21:38

Goddaughter needs to do more than 8 Hours a week study for three A levels...

OP posts:
redhilary · 29/10/2021 21:37

Stickyblue. Your post is an inspiration and very well done your sister as well.

Because the posters are so ardent in their hatred of Grammar schools, they look for any inch they can to call or intimate that they are evil. I had years of this mentality growing up, with my 'militant' NUT School school teacher mother. To her Grammar schools and in particular the 11+ was up their with the wrongs of Capital Punishment, so I understand the methods employed. First these types lie to you stating that the Grammar won't have you because your grades are not good enough. Secondly, then when that's proved wrong look to say they are ill -equipped to deal with anything, but a butter would not melt in the mouth pupil from a middle class home. Then you hear the moral argument, that Grammar schools inherently discriminate against , slow developers, those from economically deprived families E.T.C

However, my mothers message got through to my younger brother, thus when he took the 11+ answered not one question on any of the tests. However, he did leave a Precis at 10 years and 3 months about the wrongs of the 11+:: "The 11+ is morally and categorically a defunct outdated selection tool, which seeks to keep the middle classes in a perception of superiority against the working class. Their stupidity and visions of grand academic excellence for their offspring, mean they are themselves the real subordinate class , to those of the Public School Educated upper class". Well coached mother.. 'The Modern Education' did not stop him getting a P.H.D in Chemical Engineering though. My mother today is ashamed and mortified she held the views against selection in education but mostly that she brainwashed a little boy who wanted to please his mum.

Stickyblue I know my Goddaughter is tentatively thinking towards Social Work as a career, she believes her trials, tribulations and educational difficulties mean she could relate to people similarly in socially difficult circumstances.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 21:26

Goddaughter, believes studying with my two DDs will enable her focus on study to be enhanced hugely

But god daughter will be at her school from 8-6 every day! When exactly will she be studying with your daughters?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/10/2021 21:01

@Sirzy

Your poor daughters.

Just because you are over invested in your goddaughters life doesn’t mean they have to have be.

You really do need to take this on board OP. It's not fair on them at all. The fact your 16 year old god daughter has said she wants a particular living arrangement doesn't mean it's best for her or for your daughters. Stop discussing this with her. Discuss it with her mother. HER mother. You are not her mum and you are undermining your friend hugely, while also placing pressure on your own daughters not just to be comfortable with the amount of time and energy you're spending on this issue but also now expecting them to be ok with her / her baby moving in and even bloody coaching her through exams because they are good at the subjects too.

The truth is, none of you including your god daughter, know how she will feel when her baby arrives. There are so many factors at play here and you're doing everyone a disservice by acting as the gatekeeper to your god daughters future and the active parent when you aren't her parent at all.

Support your friend to support her daughter, so she can in turn support her new baby when that baby arrives. Whatever that looks like, you're piling pressure on everyone involved to make massive decisions that centre your disproportionate need to not see your god daughter's grammar school education / academic ability go to waste (as you see it) rather than centring your two daughters, your god daughter as a new mum (soon) or your friend as an existing mum (currently being undermined).

Sirzy · 29/10/2021 20:47

Your poor daughters.

Just because you are over invested in your goddaughters life doesn’t mean they have to have be.

Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 20:42

Living in her own granny flat will also give her the privacy to have whichever boys round, whenever she fancies!

Good luck with this one, OP-I think you’re early going to need it.

Stickyblue1987 · 29/10/2021 19:44

Op I haven't read full thread but my dsis had an unplanned pregnancy at 16, did GCSE's pregnant and gave birth just before 17th birthday. No father involved (he ran!). Luckily my dsis and I have great supportive parents. She took off the rest of year, was at a grammar school but decided not to return there (her choice to not return for 6th form but they would happily have had her back). She lived at my parents home who helped in that she didn't pay any board costs but just paid for her own bits and baby.

She went to college and baby went into childcare (paid for with tax credits etc). She got what she needed for uni, then met her now dh who is fab. She worked for a few years and then got married had her second dc. Applied for social work degree and is now qualified a few years and is already a senior. She's 30 with a great career, 13 yr old and a 7 year old. Is onto her second house and has her whole life in front of her. I'm so proud of her! It is doable to study and achieve your dreams but without that family support she would have been screwed. I work with young people and see how difficult it is without academic ambitions and family support (financial and practical). I wish your goddaughter all the luck 🍀

LittleBearPad · 29/10/2021 19:30

Goddaughter, believes studying with my two DDs will enable her focus on study to be enhanced hugely

Of course she does

Whatever!

redhilary · 29/10/2021 19:23

According to Goddaughter she does not want spend 7 days a week with her mother. She knows she has to start rebuilding the relationship which is at currently rock bottom and believes 7 days is far to long a time to begin the mending of wombs. She would likely crack under the pressure of seven days of co- parenting a young baby where tensions still linger. Also, she does not want to live full time with her mother if she continues in education, regardless of whether it is at the school or elsewhere.

Goddaughter, believes studying with my two DDs will enable her focus on study to be enhanced hugely. DD1 will also (unless the sky falls in) be starting her A level study at the same time in September with probably the same chosen subjects of English/Chemistry and History. This has to be a benefit and a shoulder to cry on, if Goddaughter is struggling or does not understand a particular A level topic.

This being one of the reasons why I was looking at the possibility of Goddaughter joining DD1/2 school , if her school had not made any potential offers towards a restart to year 12.

We are very lucky to have a two Bedroom 'Granny' flat with a Kitchen/Dining and Living room in our garden. The girls my two of the Brady Bunch ( I call the four of them that, because over the years they have all been so close and are 'sisters' if not blood one's) want to decamp and live in the Granny flat.

However, what an opportunity for Goddaughter to have Supervised Freedom, living between the Granny Flat/ Main House and her mothers home.

The 8am- 6 Pm suggestion that her mother cares for the baby is based on the fact, that her school Library is open to 5.30 PM Monday-Thursday. this would allow for her to work independently on her studies for two hours after school. I or husband can then pick her up at 5.30 PM . Alternatively she could get the 5.30 bus home which takes about 15 minutes from her school ( which is closer to my home than my 2DDs one is) if she wants her own independence and time.

The Granny Flat offers her a great opportunity to grow up, take some responsibility of being a mother Thus, also giving her breathing space which should enable her to build the broken bridges with her own mother. The, other advantage of living in the Granny flat being that she has me, husband and two 'sisters' at the other end of the garden if parental/moral support is needed in caring for her child.

Finally, my best friend will be a brilliant surrogate mother, to her Daughters young child. The tension and difficulties between mother and her nearly 16 and 3/4 year old daughter, have no bearing on the quality of care my friend will ensure her Daughter's child will receive.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 18:52

I actually really hope the school take advice and involve social services for support when their pregnant student moves out of home and in with someone else.

LittleBearPad · 29/10/2021 17:52

Also OP how disruptive to your daughters will a tiny baby crying through the night be? Let alone you and your husband!

Enough surely.

YouJustFoldItIn · 29/10/2021 17:48

She proposes on weekdays that I drop the baby off at her mothers at 8AM and then take her to school for 8.40 AM . Then at about 6PM on weekdays her mother will bring the baby back to my house to reunite mother and child

But why? If she is uncomfortable with living in her own family home then why would she be happy for her mother to have caring responsibilities 5 days a week during term time from 8 until 6? That makes no sense. Why not just live at home with her mother?

Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 17:31

Especially, I should have collected her when she was having blazing arguments with her mother about sneaking out . Goddaughter's mother was telling her to go and live anyway with me when angry

And you all think this woman should be the one to raise this baby from 8-6 every day?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/10/2021 16:33

Can you also see how your behaviour is undermining her mum rather than giving her space to step up? You could support her mum in doing that but instead you're taking over by undermining her and discussing her daughters future with her daughter in a way that excludes her mum to a large extent. It is an incredibly complex dynamic that I don't think you're navigating in a way that is most productive or realistic for anyone involved, even if your intentions are good.

redhilary · 29/10/2021 13:39

I am taking on board that I perhaps can be overinvested in keeping rigid structures in place. I thank posters for allowing me to consider that I should accept I can't control everything my kids or Goddaughter wrongly undertake .

I am also aware that my rigid way of thinking needs to change, as my children get older . They will inevitably, stray from any over arching pathway I might be trying to plot. Who knows the brightest of the 4 'Brady' Bunch kids DD2, might decide not got to University @18 and instead become a full time 'Insulate Britain' protester. I would have to accept as a mother, it was her choice to glue herself to the road. No matter how much I would be upset or disappointed, that she prefers to be glued to the road then be studying .

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/10/2021 13:10

@redhilary you seem more interested in being defensive than against taking on board some things you might not have considered or might have struggled to understand when it comes to nuanced dynamics.

I personally wrote what I hoped was a thoughtful and sensitive to you post trying to unravel a bit of it but it feels like you are more keen to engage with people you think are attacking you instead of really listening and maybe rethinking your approach a bit. It's a shame as I think it comes from a good place. But I regret taking time over it if it's been wasted and you don't really want people's thoughts after all?

redhilary · 29/10/2021 12:51

Whatever I say will get me condemned by one poster or another but here goes. Goddaughter wants to live with her baby and my family Monday-Friday if she decides to continue in education in the near future. What she wants to happen, if she is still in her current place of education and restarts year 12 in September is to live with her mother over the Weekend but with my family over the school week.

She proposes on weekdays that I drop the baby off at her mothers at 8AM and then take her to school for 8.40 AM . Then at about 6PM on weekdays her mother will bring the baby back to my house to reunite mother and child Thus, the only time Goddaughter will be separated from her baby is when she is at school, which is only about 15 minutes drive from the school if she needs to bond with her child. ( if the child was in a Creche in a F.E College would not mean she would have any more contact with her child than this anyway)

This is not my idea but Goddaughters mother and Goddaughter wants to at least see if this can work.

Fold, I am flattered you would get up at 5 am and write 300- 400 words about the further adventures of redhilary.

OP posts:
inferiorCatSlave · 29/10/2021 12:06

Your role should be to speak to your friend, her mother, and give her guidance if you feel she needs it (which you clearly do) rather than undermine her by having these conversations with her daughter who is a child. Especially if it's her mum who is apparently going to be raising her child for the most part!

I've read the thread and it does seem OP undermines this mother as both DDs complain to her about lax parenting.

I would be fuming if I found out that a family friend or family member was undermining my relationship with my children this way.

Then as Viviennemary say why if the parenting is so bad is this new baby being handed over to her.

None of this makes any sense - the 16 year can clearly go on - if she wants- to get A-levels and later a degree - many women in this situation go on and do so - but the OPs obsession that the only way is her way staying on at this school is bloody odd as is the complete failure to realse there will be a baby to consider that will mean massive changes.

Viviennemary · 29/10/2021 11:35

If she doesn't approve of her mother's lax parenting methods then why is the baby to be handed over to this woman to be brought up. The whole thing is totally illogical. Never mind if the child goes off the rails it can be handed back to you to sort out.

TirednWorried · 29/10/2021 11:11

She is fed up of having limited rules and in how her mother does not discipline her for her stupid actions. In such as she would like the some of the discipline and rules I impart on my DD's, such as strict minimum number of hours of homework each night over six days and 9.30/10.30/12.30 bedtime curfews I insist on for DD2 and DD1on Weekdays/Friday/Saturday respectively.

Said no 16 year old ever

Howshouldibehave · 29/10/2021 08:48

@YouJustFoldItIn

Red I think you have always had a real bee in your bonnet about never fulfilling your potential as a young student because of undiagnosed autism and other conditions. You like to lay blame for that at everyone you can.

As a result you've spent your life since having children obsessing over making sure your they achieve and are supported (or controlled?) to achieve, coached to go get into to the best schools you can find in your area without needing to pay (although you've suggested in the past that your siblings are terrible people for not offering to pay for your own DC to have a private education, even when you were not working and neither was their father, or he was earning very poorly if I recall.)

Perhaps because you are autistic your particular pet topic/obsession is grammar school education compared to non-grammar or 'modern school' education, as you like to call it, and you can compare and quote at random the results scores of grammar schools and other high performing schools up and down the country, even in areas where you don't live. If that's your 'thing' then by all means enjoy it.

But this girl who may or may not be your goddaughter (or perhaps your niece?) is not your toy or a chess piece to be used in your personal vendetta against a system you feel let you down. You can't live vicariously through her, trying to right the educational wrongs as you see them, that were done to you.

She isn't you. Doggedly pushing her to where you would have liked to be at her age is not going to change the way you feel about yourself. She may say she welcomes this intervention but I think she is just playing to her audience because she enjoys the attention she's getting from you.

Besides, this is about so much more than making sure she's supported in education with her autism and dyslexia. She is about to have a baby and you seem alarmingly unaware of the full impact that is going to have on the day to day life of an autistic 17 year old. You seem to think this baby is nothing more than a fly in the ointment, and as opposed to the main thing^ that everything else should be centred around from now on.

If she's asking to live with you now it's not because she 'wants' the very strict boundaries you would put in place, and you are pretty soon going to find that out the hard way.

She wants to live with you because she's an immature, pregnant, rebellious teen with some behavioural issues who objects to her mother's efforts to control her, however half hearted those efforts may seem to you. It's extremely arrogant and deluded to assume that the only reason she's pregnant and not engaging properly in education is because you haven't been allowed to take the reins and manage her life for her, and if you had it would all have been different.

Running to you now is nothing more than a way of sticking it to her mother. Can't you see that? If she says she is relishing the idea of monitored minimum homework hours and an evening curfew she's just playing you. Even if she thinks she wants that, she's being incredibly naive. She has a baby to put first for a start. Who is going to look after this baby while you are busy coaching her and helicoptering over her several hours a day? And you think you are going to draft in your mother and your husband with this project too, when this girl has two parents of her own?

You are so alarmingly lacking in understanding of what is the right thing to do here, it's unbelievable.

If you really want to help, then your focus should be on helping her not screw up this child she's bringing into the world. God knows that sounds like enough of a challenge to keep the lot of you busy.

Some really excellent advice here.

Keeping the baby at the centre of all of the decisions to stop them getting screwed up is key here. Not pretending it doesn’t exist so that this pregnant teen can get equivalent A levels to the OP which is about as relevant to anything as a chocolate teapot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread