Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
redhilary · 21/10/2021 22:47

I find it quite amusing on here about the huge numbers of posters children who get 10 grade 9s at GCSE. I will be very happy if DD1 year 11 achieves 5 grade 7's and 4 grade 6's in June. These grades are realistic targets for her they are more than enough to be on the right path for successful A Level study,

OP posts:
Stickystick · 21/10/2021 22:47

I feel like we don’t know all the facts here.

We know she got OK-ish (not stellar) GCSEs. We know she had trouble during her GCSEs (and there were probably additional incidents as well as the ones she got excluded for, because exclusion at a grammar is usually a last resort).

What has not been said by OP is how well she has been coping
academically with A level work so far. A levels are a big step up from GCSEs. Even without her disabilities and imminent teenage motherhood, I don’t think it’s U for a school to say, you are already struggling here, there is a limit to how many more adjustments/allowances we can reasonably make, and we think you would be better off somewhere that can better meet your needs.

plopplopplop · 21/10/2021 22:47

Oh and I meant to say, I was so surprised by how the standard of teaching at the local college was the same as at the extremely competitive sixth form. The only difference was the actual students. I did just as well in my A levels at the college as I would have done if id have stayed on at the first school (AAB).

plopplopplop · 21/10/2021 22:43

Hi OP, I was in a very similar situation.

I fell pregnant during Y12 and my sixth form originally allowed me to take a year out and come back to complete Y13. When I did go back, I was made to feel like a leper and the school made it clear that I wasn't welcome.

My mum, like your friend, wanted me to do whatever I could to stay on at the sixth form but in the end I told them where to stick their school and enrolled at the local college.

It was the best thing I could have done. I made a new start and didn't tell anyone that I had a baby at home. I was living on my own in a tiny flat with my baby and it was hard but not impossible. I also had more free periods so didn't have to go in all day every day and so this was better for childcare. I completed my A Levels a year after my peers and then went on to university.

The last thing the girl needs is to be made to feel unwelcome and unsupported. Whether the school are right or wrong, they are going to make her time there difficult if she stays, and that's the last thing she needs.

TatianaBis · 21/10/2021 22:40

This seems to be so much more about your friend being desperate for her DD to continue at her grammar as if nothing had happened.

What has happened means that the grammar school is not not the most appropriate and supportive place for her DD to be. Why does your friend want her DD to be somewhere that doesn’t want her?

You say: My friend is also desperate that her daughter achieves her academic aims.

Why? And why do they need to be achieved right now? She just seems to be in denial.

The most important thing right now for a child with additional needs and a baby on the way is for her to get through the birth and adapt to her new life. That would be hard enough for a NT child let alone an autistic one.

DD has plenty of time to resume her education at an FE college when she has adjusted to her new circumstances.

Hamsteronrollerblades · 21/10/2021 22:38

Derbee two incidents over two years of GCSE are not a violent history. How the school handled them does speak volumes about its lack of understanding - great that they provided a time out card after a meltdown and exclusion. If only the SENCO had managed that first…

Hamsteronrollerblades · 21/10/2021 22:36

Our local FE is appalling for A Levels so the grammar would be way better. Many FE colleges are much more about GCSE resists and vocational with poorly taught and rated A-level provision. Too many on Mumsnet will have you believe that unless students have a clean sweep of 8s and 9s then they are not serious A-level material. Happily this isn’t true.

She may benefit from the familiar setting and staff. If there is a local sixth form college that may be another good choice but local and personal variables here are huge. No one can advise without knowing the specifics of local provision.

Fundamentally she wants to stay, has the support of subject teachers and should not be encouraged to leave because of the misogynistic values of SMT who are worried about the school’s reputation and view pregnancy as a social contagion.

If this was a woman asking about work she would be told to lean in if that was her instinct. I have seen plenty of teens make a marvellous job of A-levels and babies and of course many who don’t but do not allow anyone else to set that bar low for her.

Derbee · 21/10/2021 22:32

Explaining her violent behaviour away because of autism and lockdowns etc doesn’t wash. Her external stress factors are likely to be even greater next year, with a young baby.

Arguing with the school for arguments sake isn’t necessarily going to end up with the best outcome for your friends DD.

Rather than trying to work out how everything can stay the same despite a baby, it might be more helpful to work out where she will be able to access the most support to help her achieve her potential. As PPs have said, that’s more likely to be at college

redhilary · 21/10/2021 22:29

Seasonfinale. What Grammar schools are you talking about Henrietta Barnett...

My DD's perfectly academic grammar school requires an average of 5.5 or 44 points over 8 subjects = 4 6s and 4 grade 5 for 6th form entry !

OP posts:
redhilary · 21/10/2021 22:25

Firstly its not my daughter so the choice is down to my friend and her daughter. Secondly I am not anti F.E College at all, I understand that F.E Colleges are more likely to be supportive to a new mother.

Autism in its self is not an excuse for violent behaviour. However, if you understood what it is like being a young immature Autistic person under intense pressure, you might be more sympathetic. (if you had a constant pain in your head you might kick a chair yourself).

This being a major reason why a significant number of young offenders are diagnosed or are un diagnosed Autistic.

It takes years of coping strategies for High Functioning Autistic people to feel comfortable, building their wall. These walls can/will collapse if one brick is removed from them.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 21/10/2021 22:22

I don't think re-admission to school to repeat a year is usual in those circumstances. FE college is the usual route. It might be to do with funding.

RaoulDufysCat · 21/10/2021 22:21

I am sorry for your friend's daughter and for your friend. This sounds really tough. But I honestly think it may be better to take a year or two out and look later at doing A Levels and going on to further study. Doing A Levels with a baby in tow would be challenging for someone without any additional needs. And I think your friend's daughter's grades are not so good that they suggest that she would breeze A Levels. This might be due to her additional needs but for her sake I think doing all this at once may be too much for her. I would suggest she takes a year out, gets good childcare in place and goes back, maybe to a sixth form college, once things have settled a bit.

YearsSinceISawYou · 21/10/2021 22:19

Given her GCSE grades, did the girl's mum put pressure on the school, in order to allow her to go forward?

Swearing and braking chairs doesn't sound "happy and contented" and if she resits, she won't be in the same class as her friends. You also say her friends look her as some kind of 'awful warning', glad they're not in her position. It doesn't sound great.

What are the girl's thoughts because it sounds as if mum is the one pushing for her to stay at school, when an FE college might be more appropriate...many of them have creches for a start.

caketiger · 21/10/2021 22:14

Honestly that kind of environment is just about results I went to one, a local college would be much more suitable to support her transition to adulthood.

SeasonFinale · 21/10/2021 22:06

It is quite unusual for a grammar school to take someone into 6th form with only four 7s and the remainder at a lower grade. So they were willing to give her the benefit ofnthe doubt and take her in. However her pregnancy now suggests to them that she is either going to be unwilling or unable to keep up with the pace a grammar would be teaching at even if they were to allow her to repeat a year.

borntobequiet · 21/10/2021 21:55

She’ll get way more support in FE.

TheMadGardener · 21/10/2021 21:48

Seems like 99% of us are suggesting that grammar school may not be the best fit for this girl, but OP doesn't want to hear this.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/10/2021 21:40

PP have almost unanimously suggested that grammar school isn't the option. But the bigger issue is why is your friends so set on her daughter retaining her place - does she think that FE college is inferior?

Grammar schools are not designed for students who need extra support - quite the opposite. While FE colleges are designed for people who do. Besides the former won't help with contextual evidence. And her friends will have left, so won't be in the same year.

There's everything to be gained from going to the FE. The school isn't being U at all.

HappyDays101010 · 21/10/2021 21:40

So she isn’t applying herself academically, and this is about what the mum wants rather than what’s best for the daughter?

Also, ‘cos COVID’ really isn’t a very good reason for the violence.

Knickerthief1 · 21/10/2021 21:35

I'm sorry OP but it sounds like your friend is desperately clinging on to her hopes and dreams for her daughter. I think she needs to take a step back and see how things play out, otherwise she is putting too much pressure on her daughter. Academics can come later and aren't the be all and end all now. My daughter is autistic and pressure of any kind never ends well.

XelaM · 21/10/2021 21:33

I went to a gymnasium (similar to grammar school) in Germany and a classmate got pregnant in our last year. She had good childcare arrangements as her parents cared for the baby whilst she was at school and she actually finished with good grades despite a newborn

SammyScrounge · 21/10/2021 21:33

@redhilary

Sorry the exclusions were in year 10 and in year 11 . The first one was an internal exclusion for 1 day for Swearing at the Head teacher . The external 3 day one was for an incident last year. She got very stressed due to the lockdown thus kicked and broke chair in class ! These are both symptoms of Autism especially the broken chair incident. She is very sorry for both incidents . She did not mean to break the chair. The school have now given her a "card" to use as a firebreak when she is anxious to leave the classroom.
Autism should never be used as an excuse for violent outbursts
Seashor · 21/10/2021 21:32

She is using her disability as an excuse. Why should other students and teachers have to put up with her breaking chairs! It’s absolutely outrageous. I’m pleased that the school are taking a stand. What about everyone else’s rights!

ThinWomansBrain · 21/10/2021 21:31

contented and generally happy at the Grammar school
the stress of looking after a baby AND studying a levels could change that - she might start swearing at the headteacher of breaking up the furniture.
A fresh start at a sixth form or FE college might be a better option.

Scirocco · 21/10/2021 21:26

She may get on better as a new young mum at an FE college, where there's likely to be more flexibility re: childcare and accommodating the difficulties faced by parents of young children.

Grammar schools are often quite academically intensive, which might not be what she needs when she's adapting to parenthood on top of studies and life. To be honest, while she's done well to get some GCSEs, with those grades she would likely be under a lot of pressure and have to work very hard at her studies to keep up with the expectations of most grammar schools' A-level courses. Putting her in that environment could risk setting her up to fail, while a more flexible school/college might be better for her development and help her remain confident in her abilities.

It's not unreasonable to explore the option of repeating a year, but she may want to consider alternatives as well. Where she gets her A-levels really won't matter that much in the longer-term, but the experiences she has in the next few years may well leave lasting impressions on her self-esteem.