Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 22/10/2021 05:00

Will she definitely need to repeat? Baby is due December and she'll get 6? weeks off? Given her Mom will be massively stepping up to parent the baby would she be able to keep up with her studies sufficiently to pass whatever she needs to in y12?
Or do they want her to essentially drop out the year and come back September? I'd think if she's essentially giving up her place this year then she might be subject to readmission based on the criteria for external students which tend to be much higher. It would also mean there might not be enough space for her if everyone in the current year 11 moves up she'd essentially be pupil 31. On those basisid think they could reasonably choose to not readmit her.

Namechangedforthethousandthtim · 22/10/2021 04:48

With kindness, I agree with the PPs. Her GCSE results were poor, and she has struggled with her emotions even before the stress of being a young mother with a newborn - A levels are difficult and stressful at the best of times, let alone when you're 17 and have a newborn baby to take care of. The school are probably just being realistic about what is actually best for the girl.

Her mum might want her to stay in school, but if it's not in the best interests of the girl (and it sounds like it isn't) then she should be open to alternatives. You can't call disability discrimination every time something doesn't go her way, I'm afraid. This isn't discrimination. It's weighing up the girl's situation, her capabilities as a student, and her emotional issues in the past which indicate that her staying in this school could be extraordinarily difficult for her and lead to other serious problems, which really isn't worth the risk considering her likelihood of actually getting positive results out of being at the college.

PennyWus · 22/10/2021 04:37

FE college will be a much better environment for her.

NumberTheory · 22/10/2021 03:16

@5zeds

Why do you think you are better placed to decide how she will manage than her teachers?Confused
OP doesn't. She's asking how she can ensure the school provide the service that the girl's teachers are encouraging.

It is the school's leadership that is hinting they don't want the girl there for a third year and OP has already told us why she thinks they are doing that. You really could just rtft.

5zeds · 22/10/2021 01:34

Why do you think you are better placed to decide how she will manage than her teachers?Confused

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 22/10/2021 01:14

If I were her I'd plough on and just do them...... Which is what I did
Tiny babies are far easier, plus if she gets out of the loop by taking a break she may never get back into it.

Keep her in education and make sure she sits her Alevels as normal. Being pregnant won't stop her studying. And having a supportive mum at home means she can study at home too.

Knackeredmommy · 22/10/2021 00:52

The school will not give her the emotional support she needs. She will do much better in a nurturing sixth form or college. I'd be arranging a meeting with the local authority admissions/send department and discussing a managed move with the school.

DumplingsAndStew · 22/10/2021 00:50

I understand that F.E Colleges are more likely to be supportive to a new mother.

Then why wouldn't they been seen as the best option in those circumstances?

Surely being at a college who support her current situation would be wholly better for her than a school who they feel don't want her there?

I know what it's like to have a teenager with SN and need to fight for every last gasp of support, and i wonder if you're fighting this simply out of habit, which is understandable, but possibly not the best thing for the circumstances she is now in.

MouseholeCat · 22/10/2021 00:45

Why try to keep your child at a school they are unwanted - it won’t be a good environment for them especially at a time when they are navigating all sorts of new challenges

This is pretty much what I came here to say.

If she stays at this school, everytime she struggles and needs to pick herself up she's probably going to have senior management suggesting a "better environment" for her or questioning her ability to apply herself. That's such negative messaging to repeatedly hear about yourself.

Do I think she school is letting down a vulnerable pupil with disabilities? Absolutely. I think it's worth formally raising that with them.

But I also think it's possible to tackle the issue and ensure your goddaughter has the best possible chance at success, and that's probably through her going to an FE college where leadership actually believe in her potential and can provide supportive resources.

StaplesCorner · 22/10/2021 00:18

Please contact the following organisations to get definite legal advice:
www.ipsea.org.uk
www.sossen.org.uk

I got my DD's EHCP when she was 18 in year 13 so it can be done, I'd strongly recommend your friend applies now as the local authority will need to get an Ed psych report done. There are several brilliant facebook pages - NotFineInSchool, EHCP Professional Parents and Send Family Instincts. There's a wealth of support and information through all these charities and voluntary groups - they can help your friend get all her facts etc, I think all that's happening on this thread is people are discussing whether or not they think a pregnant teenager should return to school. You need to find out if she can, then everyone can have a think about if she should.

HoppingPavlova · 22/10/2021 00:05

It takes years of coping strategies for High Functioning Autistic people to feel comfortable, building their wall. These walls can/will collapse if one brick is removed from them.

I think you will find having a baby will blow a hole wide open in that wall. It’s obvious current school is not the place to be when that happens, it’s setting the situation up for failure all around. She needs to take some time out at this point as her wall will essentially be shattered. Taking the next year to rebuild a new one that will look completely different to her previous one and then look to continue on at that point in a supportive environment (not the current one).

minipie · 22/10/2021 00:00

In a sense it doesn’t matter if the grammar school is right or wrong. Fact is, they don’t want her. Why try to keep your child at a school they are unwanted - it won’t be a good environment for them especially at a time when they are navigating all sorts of new challenges.

Tell your friend that her dd will do her best in an environment that truly supports her, not one that has been forced to keep her through discrimination threats. And she may do better taking more time off and coming to her A levels when the baby is older, than trying to juggle it all earlier and burning out/melting down.

WyfOfBathe · 21/10/2021 23:52

I worked at a school where a couple of girls resat year 12 or 13 due to pregnancy. Others also resat for other reasons. On the face of it, I think it’s reasonable.

However, my experiences of this were at a comprehensive that prided itself on pastoral care and was used to helping pupils with difficult home situations. Not all schools are that flexible, and IME grammar schools (and high-achieving comps) do sometimes prioritise their results over their students.

Even if you did get the school to eventually agree to her repeating year 12, I’d wonder whether she might be happier somewhere she didn’t have to battle SLT? Some colleges even have on-site nurseries, and they tend to be more used to supporting students in ‘unusual’ situations. With 7s at GCSE and the right work ethic, I’d expect your goddaughter to still do well.

Even if the school end up agreeing

MrsAvocet · 21/10/2021 23:44

You sound very caring redhilary.
You are right of course that your God Daughter should not be discriminated against and I can quite understand why you and her Mum would want to fight against prejudice when you see it. But I would urge you to look at all options as that fight may not be in her best interests.
I can empathise with the dilemma though. Without going into details, I was extremely badly treated in a former workplace. I could have fought to keep my job and my union were confident I would have won, but it would have meant returning to a very toxic environment where I knew that my line manager would have just been waiting for the day that I was 5 minutes late or gave someone a funny look, and as it happened
a financially acceptable exit route presented itself. I was very torn between fighting because of the principle of the matter and leaving. In the end I did leave because I realised that I was in danger of getting embroiled in an unpleasant fight, the "prize" for which was something that wasn't really in my best interests. I'm sure my employers consider that they "won" and I am still annoyed that they got away with their behaviour but actually I'm much happier as I am now, and they still have a vacancy, so maybe I won really?
Different circumstances I know, but I think there are parallels. You could fight and win the grammar school place for your goddaughter but then that's just the start of it. If the school aren't fully supportive, as they may not be if they have been forced into it, then it could make an already difficult situation a lot worse. Going down an avenue that at first seems bad or unfair, might actually turn out better in the long run.
Obviously none of us know what your local provision is like so the suggested FE college may or may not be the answer, but do look at it, and what else there is locally. My friends who teach at our local FE college are, I believe, excellent teachers. Well they are certainly excellent human beings who have taken these kind of jobs precisely because they want to work with young people who have needs or circumstances that make mainstream schooling less suitable. I can't guarantee that all FE college staff are like that of course, but I know some are, so it is worth a look.

SRS29 · 21/10/2021 23:35

@redhilary

Thank you Hamster and Getaway. I have known her all her life and I am her God Mother. I owe it to her and her mother who without, I would never of got of the floor from the mental and physical illness I suffered from 18- 24.

I know very well what my Darling God Daughter is going through right now. I am with her all the way, I will do everything in my power for her at this time.

OP you sound a wonderfully perfect Godmother...good luck Flowers
Bunnycat101 · 21/10/2021 23:27

There is a point where you have to look at how realistic study with looking after the baby actually is. I did my dissertation with a newborn and it nearly killed me. It was one of the most hideous experiences and by the time I handed it in, I was basically hallucinating as I was so tired. I think you need to find the most supportive environment for her and that may well be the college. I found it stressful knowing my peers were doing their work without the pressures of a baby. When they moaned about how hard it was I just found them intensely irritating. Her life has changed and set her apart from her peers and that in itself can be quite a jolt.

me4real · 21/10/2021 23:24

They should make reasonable adjustments so that she can be included despite the circumstances she finds herself in.

Having said that, people think sixth form colleges will give poor results but mine was great and I did well. I think they can give more consideration to young adults as human beings than can a cold, solely academically-minded school/beurocracy.

ThisMustBeMyDream · 21/10/2021 23:21

I just wanted to add that I didn't find A Levels and a 6 month old baby hard at all.
I went to uni to study midwifery when he had just turned 2. I worked 16 hours on top.
I didn't live at home (lived in a council house). I lived with his dad. I didn't have family help.
I'm not super intelligent (I'm not stupid though!). My GCSE's were A, Bx6, C.

Even with autism and dyslexia, with the right academic support, why can't she do it? Especially with pretty reasonable results.

I went to a college, I didn't even consider going back to 6th form. But, why shouldn't she if that is what she wants?

I found being a single mum of 3, and working in a shift based career far more stressful than one little baby and A Levels. Take me back!

redhilary · 21/10/2021 23:09

Thank you Hamster and Getaway. I have known her all her life and I am her God Mother. I owe it to her and her mother who without, I would never of got of the floor from the mental and physical illness I suffered from 18- 24.

I know very well what my Darling God Daughter is going through right now. I am with her all the way, I will do everything in my power for her at this time.

OP posts:
Getawaywithit · 21/10/2021 22:59

I think she should have a look at the 3 A level equivalent BTEC courses. My dyslexic 17 year old is excelling at his and will be going to uni. It has been a revelation to him after years of struggling.

redhilary · 21/10/2021 22:58

As I have said...

OP posts:
redhilary · 21/10/2021 22:56

She is currently doing O.K academically. However, has I have said up-thread being immature young and Autistic with things out of your control, is like being hit constantly in the head with a hammer.

High Functioning Autistic Adults, Teenagers or Children are among the most misunderstood, thus discriminated people in this country.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 21/10/2021 22:51

She won’t be going back with her friends anyway, so I would start her at a sixth form college if immediate study is what she wants. Having dyslexia, autism and a newborn, she may not feel ready to go straight back into A levels anyway. I had a baby that didn’t sleep and barely knew which way was up for 18 months, there’s no way I could have sat exams then (and I’m a pretty academic ex-grammar school student with a post-grad), it just would have been too hard at that point.

upthekyber · 21/10/2021 22:49

Not really read the thread but if you don't already have an EHCp apply yourself as they go to 25. That said I know another child without an EHCp who is also doing 3 years.
My year 12 son has just started a 3 year 6th form I can assure you he is not pregnant they have done it because the LA stuffed up big time and 1 of the subjects he wanted to take where no longer available.
So yes it is possible and remember her triple whammy under the equality act of disability, sex and pregnancy discrimination.

Isausernameavailable · 21/10/2021 22:47

It would be worth looking at whether care to learn funding is still available. This pays for funding for full time child care if a school age mum continuous education .

The school should treat her like a pregnant member of staff would be treated (except pay obv) on terms of maternity leave and return.

The DDA that applies would be age and maternity rather than disability