Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 23/10/2021 13:52

Being 19 and in school Sixth Form is not an issue for an immature girl . I would actually see that as benefit. However, Posters on here seem to think everybody by the age of 18 should be living independent lives, running a household and having no influence or guidance from their parents.

She’s having a baby! You need to stop minimising that fact OP. It isn’t going to help

She can’t be an immature 19 year old in a school. That ship sailed when she decided to keep the baby.

Sirzy · 23/10/2021 13:49

It’s a massive leap from not being allowed to stay in a setting which may well not be suitable to being a psychiatric inpatient! I’m not sure such dramatics will help anyone.

For now focus on getting her and the baby settled and happy. Everything else can wait. If she wants to be a mother to the baby then she is going to need support and to be able to focus her energy on that. She can go to college or whatever in the future when the time is right.

A levels aren’t the be all and end all

redhilary · 23/10/2021 13:46

Misprint Normal for a (17 or 18) year old girl before I get called out by some posters...

OP posts:
redhilary · 23/10/2021 13:44

Being 19 and in school Sixth Form is not an issue for an immature girl . I would actually see that as benefit. However, Posters on here seem to think everybody by the age of 18 should be living independent lives, running a household and having no influence or guidance from their parents.

I would not be bothered if Goddaughter stayed in the schools Sixth Form until 21 ! Thus, if she came out with 3 D grades at A Level no problem she can redo them later. Academic grades despite what posters think are not the be all and end all here.

When her mother took her to visit an F.E College, she refused to enter the building because of fear of the unknown.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-50139692

I am fearful this could happen to my Goddaughter just for being Autistic, different and acting in a manner which is not considered normal for a 18 year old girl. (I am going to start a thread about how some young vulnerable Autistic people in 'Care' homes are treated worse than how Wayne Cousins will spend his time in Prison). This can and does happen to academically able Autistic (whether that's below Mumsnet average ).

I want her in a place where she is comfortable, familiar. Therefore, not likely to freak out not knowing the terms of the place , the actions of individuals and the social structures around her

P.S the authorities wanted me placed in one of these type of facilities, despite having 3 B's at A Level. So don't suggest that the (Academically Average can't end up in these places).

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 13:27

@Shadedog

Being in a school sixth form when you are 19 and have a toddler and all your friends have left and you are stuck on the outside of established friendship groups with the year below sounds utterly shit.

Instead of reinforcing this 16 yos normal fear and apprehension of changing to a large 6th form with new people and new systems and no uniform and more grown up attitude to independent learning then the actual adults in her life should be showing her the positive side. She’ll have more flexibility with her timetable so it will be easier with childcare, there will be a lot more autistic and dyslexic students than in her current school and they will have better support in place, it will give her the chance to make new friends, larger cohorts after mean better support like lunchtime drop in sessions for homework help, she will likely have around 15 hours of contact time for 3 A-levels with half days and possibly even whole days off so she can manage her time around the baby better, there may be a crèche, or dedicated support for young mums.
You can’t dismiss the most appropriate educational setting for a 19yo mother (which is what she will be by the end of this) because some fictional lecturer who she doesn’t know might not tell her off for not handing her homework in. My ds goes to a massive college and all his teachers would pull him up on not submitting work. University students get pulled up in this.
This is a fabulous opportunity to make a fresh start and establish her life as a student mum. It’s not appropriate to try to shove her backwards into school as if that will turn the clock back to before covid, before boyfriend, before pregnancy.

The last sentence describes it perfectly!
TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 13:26

Also OP - if it wasn’t clear - trying to keep her mentally healthy by getting her back into grammar school is like trying to seal a leak on a ship with sticky tape. The bigger change is her having a baby. It will have larger repurcussions for a long time . You must help her deal with change now, rather than trying to keep things as familiar as possible. It’s gone, and won’t come back. Even if she does manage to pass A levels with support she will breakdown at the next stage if not primed for how monumental having a baby actually is.

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 13:22

@redhilary

What ESA group you are put in can be down to how correctly or incorrectly you fill the boxes in . There are people with Masters Degree's in the Support group.

However, I was being flippant there because that is what the ex boyfriend thinks would help them pay and to live in a flat together.

Oh Yes the ex boyfriend 10 months older than my Goddaughter, the sort every parent would walk 500 miles to make sure their daughter avoided him. Permanently expelled from school for multiple offences. These, including selling weed on school premises, swearing at teachers and smashing chairs up. I wonder where Goddaughter got her ideas for her defiant actions.

The really tragic thing about this though is this is the first boy, I think she has not only dated but actually had a grown up conversation with. Goddaughter Autism means in terms of maturity, she is more like my 13 year old DD2, than DD1 15, indeed DD1 has always protected her like a big sister despite being 13 months younger. Up to about a couple years ago if My friend and I went out together with the girls it would be DD1 trying to get my Goddaughter to leave her mother and me and do something on their own. She was/is very shy and nervous
This is why I think the thought of 3000 or so strangers in an F.E or Sixth Form College is scary for her. She feels comfortable in a environment where you might get a Detention for not handing in your Homework and wear school uniform/dress code. These are like security blankets to her, therefore understands the procedures and likes the conformity they bring. She would feel uneasy and scared in a environment such as a F.E college where a lecturer might not even tell her off for not handing in a piece of work.

The ‘security in familiarity’ ship has sailed OP. Even if she returns to the same school, with all its rules her environment has changed irrevocably. Her friends will be focused on different things. She’s not even going to be in the same class as them. She will have a baby and everybody knows. She’s not going to conform on the contrary she’ll stick out like a sore thumb, especially if teachers are going to be making lots of allowances for her.

I’m aware of how structure and rigidity is important for autistic people inclined that way but the point is it’s too late for her.

Her world has changed. Unless you’re going to give the baby up for adoption, or her mother is going to raise it independently of her, she is a mother now. And babies are unpredictable. they don’t cry, get hungry or shit themselves on a set schedule.

The point of this OP is whether a return is feasible. I think it isn’t based on what you have said. And even if she does manage to go back and complete her A-levels you will simply be pushing the consequences further down the road. What happens when she goes to university- not only completely new but a very unstructured environment?

@NumberTheory AIBU is generally vicious but this thread isn’t - pp have made valid points.

MrsAvocet · 23/10/2021 13:05

To be fair to the OP, I can see the attraction of trying to keep as much the same as possible when such huge changes are imminent. It must be tempting to focus on what you can possibly control when there is so much that you can't.
But I agree with those who are saying that it won't be the same anyway, and relationships with friends are inevitably going to change. There is no harm in exploring a return to the same school as an option, but I wouldn't assume that it's the best option and I think it is very important that the OP's god daughter is encouraged to understand that things won't be the same and to explore all the choices open to her.

TatianaBis · 23/10/2021 10:40

Being in a school sixth form when you are 19 and have a toddler and all your friends have left and you are stuck on the outside of established friendship groups with the year below sounds utterly shit.

That’s the reality. That’s a fundamental change that will make a familiar place feel alien that is not being factored in.

TatianaBis · 23/10/2021 10:38

I find the justification of fear of change for staying at a school, when the girl’s life is about to be torpedoed by one of the biggest changes of all, truly bizarre. The biggest change she has to deal with immediately is dealing with life with a baby.

That will be a massive challenge for an autistic teen baby and it may well take longer than for a NT teen.

The world will look very, very different the other side of this.

At that point, if she does go back into education, may not happen for a couple of years anyway, if ever, the place that is most appropriate is the place that is the most supportive to her needs at that time.

Shadedog · 23/10/2021 09:55

Being in a school sixth form when you are 19 and have a toddler and all your friends have left and you are stuck on the outside of established friendship groups with the year below sounds utterly shit.

Instead of reinforcing this 16 yos normal fear and apprehension of changing to a large 6th form with new people and new systems and no uniform and more grown up attitude to independent learning then the actual adults in her life should be showing her the positive side. She’ll have more flexibility with her timetable so it will be easier with childcare, there will be a lot more autistic and dyslexic students than in her current school and they will have better support in place, it will give her the chance to make new friends, larger cohorts after mean better support like lunchtime drop in sessions for homework help, she will likely have around 15 hours of contact time for 3 A-levels with half days and possibly even whole days off so she can manage her time around the baby better, there may be a crèche, or dedicated support for young mums.
You can’t dismiss the most appropriate educational setting for a 19yo mother (which is what she will be by the end of this) because some fictional lecturer who she doesn’t know might not tell her off for not handing her homework in. My ds goes to a massive college and all his teachers would pull him up on not submitting work. University students get pulled up in this.
This is a fabulous opportunity to make a fresh start and establish her life as a student mum. It’s not appropriate to try to shove her backwards into school as if that will turn the clock back to before covid, before boyfriend, before pregnancy.

LittleBearPad · 23/10/2021 09:19

@HoppingPavlova is spot on.

As for
This is terrible advice. Teens who get pregnant are better off if they stay in school and maintain friendships.

But her friendships won’t last, not properly. She’ll be with the current GCSE year as she’ll skip a year. Her current friends (who are relieved they aren’t in the same boat) will be focused on UCAS forms and looking forward to university.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 23/10/2021 09:07

"This is terrible advice. Teens who get pregnant are better off if they stay in school and maintain friendships."

IME friendships are unlikely to endure. The rest of her group will be in Year 13 and focused on university applications.

I feel that the school has probably seen this situation before and knows the % likelihood of success/failure. They are trying to give good advice - grammar school, with everyone knowing why you've repeated a year, watching your friends move on, for a child who was already struggling and is now also a mother, is not going to be the best environment.

She wants to stay in school because she doesn't like change. Take her to see the other options, with all of the support they offer, and help her to make an informed decision.

Otherwise you'll be on here in a year saying that she's missing deadlines and they're being unsupportive so she's failing, stressed and struggling. Encourage her to go somewhere where they are saying that they want her and have lots of experience in meeting similar needs, not somewhere that's begrudgingly taking her under pressure.

Suzi888 · 23/10/2021 06:54

If she wants to go back to school then let her go. If it doesn’t work out, she can resit at college later.

Suzi888 · 23/10/2021 06:50

Happened in my sixth form and I’m 43 now!

I agree with pp, wait a year and go to college.

Sirzy · 23/10/2021 06:46

This is terrible advice. Teens who get pregnant are better off if they stay in school and maintain friendships.

But rhay isn’t the plan anyway. The plan is still for her to be out of education for 9 months and then re enter with a different cohort of students so really very little will be the same as she knows school to be now.

It would be the same building but everything else would be very different. From what the OP has said I could see how this could actually make things even tougher and more confusing.

Offmyfence · 23/10/2021 06:42

@TractorAndHeadphones

PP have almost unanimously suggested that grammar school isn't the option. But the bigger issue is why is your friends so set on her daughter retaining her place - does she think that FE college is inferior?

Grammar schools are not designed for students who need extra support - quite the opposite. While FE colleges are designed for people who do. Besides the former won't help with contextual evidence. And her friends will have left, so won't be in the same year.

There's everything to be gained from going to the FE. The school isn't being U at all.

This
NumberTheory · 23/10/2021 06:04

@HoppingPavlova

She feels comfortable in a environment where you might get a Detention for not handing in your Homework and wear school uniform/dress code. These are like security blankets to her, therefore understands the procedures and likes the conformity they bring.

And she is about to have a baby. I just can’t wrap my head around you focusing on schools and A levels where the same girl you are describing with these challenges is about to have a baby. Good god! School would be the last thing on my mind in this situation. Her world, based on structure and the known in order to survive is going to implode shortly! Instead of focusing on how to concentrate on this aspect and getting her through, you keep blathering on about school and A levels and seem utterly fixated on the wrong thing. You seem more of a hinderance than help to be frank.

This is terrible advice. Teens who get pregnant are better off if they stay in school and maintain friendships.

Also, the OP being on here asking about schools is no indication that that is the main focus of how the girl is being supported.

Hankunamatata · 23/10/2021 02:03

This school seems unwilling to work with you. Look at another grammar school that will allow her to repeat

HoppingPavlova · 23/10/2021 01:40

She feels comfortable in a environment where you might get a Detention for not handing in your Homework and wear school uniform/dress code. These are like security blankets to her, therefore understands the procedures and likes the conformity they bring.

And she is about to have a baby. I just can’t wrap my head around you focusing on schools and A levels where the same girl you are describing with these challenges is about to have a baby. Good god! School would be the last thing on my mind in this situation. Her world, based on structure and the known in order to survive is going to implode shortly! Instead of focusing on how to concentrate on this aspect and getting her through, you keep blathering on about school and A levels and seem utterly fixated on the wrong thing. You seem more of a hinderance than help to be frank.

NumberTheory · 23/10/2021 01:16

School sixth forms in England are supposed to receive funding for students up to 19 yrs old. So I don't see why the suggestion isn't feasible (which was your question) if it fits around subject offerings, if she's doing subjects that may not be offered to the year below her it makes it less feasible. Unfortunately you need a bit more than 'feasible' if the school is currently reluctant.

A sit down with her teachers and her to hammer out a solid, achievable plan. Her showing commitment to it by putting in the effort before the baby is born. Maybe some check in points where the approach can be reassessed if it doesn't seem to be working.

I think you should also look into the discrimination route as well, though. It does sound like they are reluctant to have her do her A levels there because they don't think she's deserving now she's pregnant (since they took her on to sixth form with the GCSE grades she got and her discipline record before they knew she was pregnant, but now she's pregnant they're suddenly concerned she won't hack it). I think you would need proper legal advice about that though.

Have the school ever had someone carry on for a third year of sixth form? Maybe because of illness or something? If you can show precedent for this approach you might have an easier time convincing them.

I would call some of the responses you've received on here bizarre, except this is par for the course on AIBU - It seems to be a blood sport for some posters.

I can see why some people think and FE college might be best, but I can also see arguments for staying with an environment she knows. You know her far better than any of the posters on here and exploring an option, finding out if it can be done doesn't commit her to it - it just gives her options. Good luck with it.

redhilary · 23/10/2021 00:06

What ESA group you are put in can be down to how correctly or incorrectly you fill the boxes in . There are people with Masters Degree's in the Support group.

However, I was being flippant there because that is what the ex boyfriend thinks would help them pay and to live in a flat together.

Oh Yes the ex boyfriend 10 months older than my Goddaughter, the sort every parent would walk 500 miles to make sure their daughter avoided him. Permanently expelled from school for multiple offences. These, including selling weed on school premises, swearing at teachers and smashing chairs up. I wonder where Goddaughter got her ideas for her defiant actions.

The really tragic thing about this though is this is the first boy, I think she has not only dated but actually had a grown up conversation with. Goddaughter Autism means in terms of maturity, she is more like my 13 year old DD2, than DD1 15, indeed DD1 has always protected her like a big sister despite being 13 months younger. Up to about a couple years ago if My friend and I went out together with the girls it would be DD1 trying to get my Goddaughter to leave her mother and me and do something on their own. She was/is very shy and nervous
This is why I think the thought of 3000 or so strangers in an F.E or Sixth Form College is scary for her. She feels comfortable in a environment where you might get a Detention for not handing in your Homework and wear school uniform/dress code. These are like security blankets to her, therefore understands the procedures and likes the conformity they bring. She would feel uneasy and scared in a environment such as a F.E college where a lecturer might not even tell her off for not handing in a piece of work.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 22/10/2021 23:09

Has she considered adoption if she wants to continue her studies without too much interruption from a demanding newborn baby. A child which which will be her responsibility for at least the next 18 years.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 22/10/2021 23:06

Apparently, some of them are relived they are not in the same situation

I can't imagine any girl in year 12 studying for her A levels would want to be in the same situation and most, if they did find themselves pregnant, would not go ahead with the pregnancy.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 22/10/2021 23:02

@redhilary

My Goddaughter does not want to leave the school, she does not want to go a an F.E college or a Sixth Form College. But If that is deemed the way forward we will go with which ever one is the better.

I am very well aware of the potential mental issues going forward having been there myself. I am looking for different options academically and emotionally,

My Goddaughter gets Personal Independence Payment (PIP) due to her condition. Thus, for those saying forget education at least temporary, that as soon as she becomes 18. I'm sure if will put the right words in the right order , we could ensure she was placed in the ESA Support Group and a total £760 a month would come her way.

I don't want that therefore I am seeking out solutions academically at first...

You are saying that her disability impacts her to such an extent that she is incapable of doing any work whatsoever and would qualify for ESA, yet expect her to be able to cope with studying for A levels at a grammar school alongside caring for a small baby.
Swipe left for the next trending thread