Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 23/10/2021 20:05

In the light of this further information, I wonder if the girl may have got pregnant as a way of making academic pressure stop.

It’s hard enough for an autistic child to cope in mainstream schools. But an academic school, with no SEN support at all, would be all the more challenging. Perhaps that’s why she wet herself.

There are some circs in which tutoring for entrance exams is appropriate - but using it to scrape a ASD child into an academic school strikes me as misguided.

Btw when you say “we” got her tutoring what does that mean? Did you find the tutor or contribute financially to it?

Why are you this invested in someone else’s child? (you’ve sworn at those who suggested you’re her mum, but it makes much more sense.)

If not, have you considered she may feel she is up against a double act of pressure and expectation from you and her mum - a trio if her dad is in the picture?

Hankunamatata · 23/10/2021 19:46

I say this as a sen mum who has battled, you and the mum need to let go of battle sen mentality at the moment. This isn't about sen this is about her having a baby and you and her mother wanting her to repeat the year. Tough choices are ahead. She doesn't have the luxury of being a young 17 year old anymore, she is going to be a mum and all the baggage that comes with it. You need to find out if that if in the past the school has allowed a 6th form pupil to repeat - id say a freedom of information act would get you this request. IF the school has allowed pupils to repeat before then you have a case.

I do think you all need to draw breath. The girl could feel very different once the baby arrives, she may not want to return to education straight away. I dont think you would be doing her nay favours to make firm plans before the baby arrives.

LittleBearPad · 23/10/2021 19:34

I am so devastated that my Darling Goddaughter who has achieved so many miracles in her life, is saddled with a baby to a 'ner- do well' ex boyfriend.

I can imagine.

But I don’t think this is an educational fight.

Tequilamockinbird · 23/10/2021 19:33

I was 'saddled with a baby' at the same age, in a similar situation.

I jacked my A Levels in, had my DD, then a year later started an apprenticeship. Tax credits paid a lot of the childcare fees, and yes I was pretty skint for a few years. But then I worked hard to get on in my career, and now (23 years later) I'm in a fairly high paid job and own my own house, car etc. I only have a handful of GCSEs.

It's not the end of the world. What does your god daughter want? This isn't about her mum, or you. Ask her what she wants.

redhilary · 23/10/2021 19:27

Thus, if my friend had followed the experts and the mantra of what was the 'appropriate' educational setting for her daughter. I guess at nearly 17 she be halfway through her level 1 Math's and English courses now. However, being told that GCSE's were a mountain to far to consider.

OP posts:
redhilary · 23/10/2021 19:13

Thank you, Polar you get the dilemma. My friend and I are facing, you obviously understand Autism .My Goddaughter's mother has gone to great lengths to get her this far. First of all when my Goddaughters Autism was diagnosed at two, the 'experts' said she would never be able to write or read above the level of what would be expected of an 8 year old. My friend battling with the L.A that her daughter should be educated in Mainstream education. Goddaughter excelled once the support she needed was given this including an EHCP at Primary.

My friend was called out many times, by Teachers, Family Members and so called friends for entering her for the 11+. One of her Primary school teachers, intimating that entering her for the 11+ exam would be akin to child cruelty. (Yes we got her tutoring) so bloody what! My Goddaughter's drive and effort during her 11+ tutoring showed levels of indefatigability that I did not know any 10 year old could display. To everyone's amazement apart from me and her mother she passed her 11+. The, Local education Authority then decided because she had passed the 11+ exam an EHCP for Secondary school was no longer appropriate, despite appealing against this decision, we lost. The school realized that they needed to put something in place themselves in the first week of year 7 when Goddaughter wet herself ! It is obvious from the incidents that occurred in years 10 and 11 the provisions were not great.

This, despite written letters from the Head and SLT in year 7 stating that they will ensure that my Goddaughter receives the appropriate SEN support throughout her school career. They also stated they invisaged that Goddaughter would be supported appropriately until the year 13 (academic regulations permitting for Sixth Form entry).

With all that in mind I say again her achieving 4 grade 7s and 4 grade 6s @ GCSE is a fantastic achievement, not average in any terms.
(I'm in tears writing this)

I am so devastated that my Darling Goddaughter who has achieved so many miracles in her life, is saddled with a baby to a 'ner- do well' ex boyfriend. This being the same extremely pretty girl who would runaway from boys, who wanted to ask her for a date, just 2 months before lockdown in March 2020.

(Absolutely Heartbroken) To those saying I am her mother 'Piss Off'

OP posts:
BananaPB · 23/10/2021 18:44

I think that you and the mother are in denial about how hard it will be when she returns and there are so many unfamiliar things like her friends will have moved on and she'll have to make new friends, have new form tutors etc. Even if she makes it until the end of year 12, year 13 is going to be very difficult with her old friends having left and having to think about what happens next eg University. Her current friends will mean well but their lives won't be on pause while she is gone and I think that when she is forced to face that fact then it'll be difficult for her to attend school.

Grammars are for people who need little support and it is unrealistic to expect them to behave like they are a comprehensive Sixth Form or FE college.

I personally think that you can't hatch a plan about what comes next until she has the baby and things settle down for her a bit. If she's anxious about setting foot in another education setting just to look around, I'm not so sure she'll find it easy to walk into her grammar after a long break.

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 18:38

[quote FrippEnos]**@redhilary

IMO you should ask what your god daughter wants.

So far the thread seems to be all about you and the mother want.[/quote]
OP has already commented that the girl won't even set foot in the FE college ... have you read all of her posts

FrippEnos · 23/10/2021 18:21

@redhilary

IMO you should ask what your god daughter wants.

So far the thread seems to be all about you and the mother want.

PolarCub · 23/10/2021 17:42

Do you know what I read from all of this: you are scared and worried for her.
I also get Autism - My son is Autistic (now young adult), and believe me I've been to hell and back. I also get the being immature for their age - In one hand my son is very mature for his age, but on the other he is a good couple of years younger than his age.

And I understand the young and pregnant - I was 'just' 18 when I had my son.

I understand the want/need to keep something familiar to your God-daughter, as everything is changing, and you are trying to hang on to the one familiar thing.

I can tell you from my experience as a young mother - her current friends WILL leave her, they say they won't, but they will. They and your God-daughter will have different priorities. I can also say from experience of others who stayed on at school who were pregnant/had a child - she will be known, not by her name, but as 'that girl who's got a kid', and will likely get bullied for it.

Do you have a teacher at school who YOU like/get honest response from? If so, approach them and ask for an honest conversation on how the school will accommodate your God-daughter. Do they think that the school will actually accommodate her, or are you on to a loosing battle?

Putting her pregnancy aside - If the school are not supportive, then you are on a losing battle (been there, done that!). You and her Mum have probably, like many of us with children with additional needs, spent her school life fighting for her education and extra accommodation for her needs. You need to look at the bigger picture and work out if this is the fight you need to take on. My own feeling here is that unless this is a school with a young Mum unit - then this isn't the best/supportive place for her.
If it was me, I'd be putting my energy into the transition to college. I understand that she wouldn't step foot into the college to see it - but you could do things to make the initial process easier - photos of the college, going by and just standing outside, meeting somebody from the college (probably many times!) so she has a familiar face etc etc

TatianaBis · 23/10/2021 17:37

@Funnylittlefloozie

OP, are you actually the pregnant child here, because there's something about unsettling about the way you write, and how dismissive you seem to be of the 'having a child' bit of this problem, and hyper-focused on the 'staying at familiar school' bit.

The poor girl obviously struggles badly with change. Maybe its better to get all the changes over in one go - have the baby, have a year out, then find a decent FE college to do A-levels at.

I don’t think she’s the child but I do think she’s the mum.

There is no godmother or aunt who is this involved in the decision of a friend/sibling.

I want her in a place where she is comfortable, familiar.

That’s not the words of a godmother. What OP wants is irrelevant.

NerrSnerr · 23/10/2021 17:32

Is your god daughter happy for you to be talking about this on mumsnet? It's massively identifiable with her grades, type of school etc. How would she feel if her friends or their parents found it the thread?

iolaus · 23/10/2021 17:26

Someone in the year above me repeated his lower sixth (year 12) year - not due to pregnancy

NumberTheory · 23/10/2021 17:18

@Funnylittlefloozie

OP, are you actually the pregnant child here, because there's something about unsettling about the way you write, and how dismissive you seem to be of the 'having a child' bit of this problem, and hyper-focused on the 'staying at familiar school' bit.

The poor girl obviously struggles badly with change. Maybe its better to get all the changes over in one go - have the baby, have a year out, then find a decent FE college to do A-levels at.

Jesus Christ. Of course OP is focused on other things. Apart from the fact that no one with sense would be turning to AIBU for advice on what to do about the baby, as the friend of the child’s mum it’s not OPs place to be looking for that advice. She came on for information on a more factual and peripheral issue because this isn’t her baby or her daughter’s baby. She’s looking to be proactive where she won’t be interfering. It would be inappropriate for her to tell her friend what to do on baby front unless her friend asked for advice or was struggling (which there is no indication of).
Funnylittlefloozie · 23/10/2021 17:03

OP, are you actually the pregnant child here, because there's something about unsettling about the way you write, and how dismissive you seem to be of the 'having a child' bit of this problem, and hyper-focused on the 'staying at familiar school' bit.

The poor girl obviously struggles badly with change. Maybe its better to get all the changes over in one go - have the baby, have a year out, then find a decent FE college to do A-levels at.

redhilary · 23/10/2021 16:42

Ideal situation sorry repeated it...

OP posts:
redhilary · 23/10/2021 16:41

The 'Boy' is what the term NEET was invented for. The idea situation for him would be for Goddaughter to move him with him. Thus, get a flat together use the money Goddaughter might get for her disabilities (ESA and Child benefit) for himself get pissed and high. This would be the ideal situation for him. Goddaughter would have to be marooned at the flat and unable to go out herself .This would be his dream so he could sell his weed and shag all the girls he wants to.

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 23/10/2021 16:34

I have an autistic ds.

Get her out of there. A school that is more concerned about image and grades over pastoral care is never the right place for any student but more so than one with autism who also has dyslexia.

Start now to talk to other places. What will they offer, how will they help? What childcare is available etc. find somewhere where you get the attitude of "we want friends ds here and want to help her".

Yeah - the grammar may have a duty if care etc. but if you are having to waste time fighting for that rather than supporting a vulnerable young adult then you're fighting the wrong fight.

I say that from experience

PooWillyNameChange · 23/10/2021 16:13
  • girls' grammar not girl's grrr!
PooWillyNameChange · 23/10/2021 16:11

I was pregnant at 17 at an all girl's grammar and they also tried to push me out. My mum fought for me but the support just wasn't there and I ended up leaving. I started again at a rough inner London college known for crap results but the pastoral care was amazing and I left with 4 As and got into a top 5 uni!!

Sorry can't be any help with regards to the legal ins and outs but I guess what I'm saying is it may well not be the right school for her, even if what they're doing is wrong I'd probably see if there was somewhere else that will welcome and support her not try and shove her out (whilst, presumably, the father will merrily continue his education with minimal disruption!)

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 14:54

@redhilary

Being 19 and in school Sixth Form is not an issue for an immature girl . I would actually see that as benefit. However, Posters on here seem to think everybody by the age of 18 should be living independent lives, running a household and having no influence or guidance from their parents.

I would not be bothered if Goddaughter stayed in the schools Sixth Form until 21 ! Thus, if she came out with 3 D grades at A Level no problem she can redo them later. Academic grades despite what posters think are not the be all and end all here.

When her mother took her to visit an F.E College, she refused to enter the building because of fear of the unknown.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-50139692

I am fearful this could happen to my Goddaughter just for being Autistic, different and acting in a manner which is not considered normal for a 18 year old girl. (I am going to start a thread about how some young vulnerable Autistic people in 'Care' homes are treated worse than how Wayne Cousins will spend his time in Prison). This can and does happen to academically able Autistic (whether that's below Mumsnet average ).

I want her in a place where she is comfortable, familiar. Therefore, not likely to freak out not knowing the terms of the place , the actions of individuals and the social structures around her

P.S the authorities wanted me placed in one of these type of facilities, despite having 3 B's at A Level. So don't suggest that the (Academically Average can't end up in these places).

Your argument is as follows: Goddaughter will freak out in new places. Therefore grammar school has to keep her because there is NO other option. If goddaughter goes to a new place she will freak out and end up in a psychiatric unit.

Ok... then what will happen when she goes to university?

Grammar school and its familiarity may look like a good option now but it's kicking the can down the road. Also she may be refusing because in her mind she can still go back to grammar school, back to the way things were.

It's not the grammar school that she wants. It's the way things were and all that it represents. But that doesn't exist anymore. You're not acknowledging this point despite lots of pp telling you multiple times.

It won't be easy, but choosing the 'easy' path will result in more difficulties later. That's just the way it is. Trust me I have dealt with a lot of autistic people (including autistic DP) and rational will not convince them.
Their anxiety overwhelms them so much they choose denial. However the way around it isn't to go along with what they want in the short term, because it will fall apart when the next challenge comes along.

I know PP have said the girls' opinions etc should be listened to but from this it looks like she herself hasn't accepted just how much her life has changed. And you have to help her cope with it, not deny it.

I really feel for you because it's very very hard to do, and takes various strategies, cajoling etc etc. But it's worth it in the end.

Scirocco · 23/10/2021 14:38

It's understandable that you're feeling protective of your goddaughter, but I think it's important not to catastrophise here.

Yes, there's been a bit of discussion about exam results and some differing views, but nobody is saying she can't achieve her academic hopes - just that the way she achieves them might need to be different if she is going to have parental responsibilities.

Nobody has come even close to suggesting that she should be in any form of psychiatric inpatient setting, let alone a secure one. She wouldn't come remotely close to meeting the admission requirements for a secure unit unless she were displaying really serious challenging and aggressive behaviour, which would be way more than unintentionally breaking a chair (far worse things than that happen every day in schools up and down the country, it's not a huge deal). Education and healthcare are two completely different systems so whether or not she stays at a grammar school will not influence whether she meets admission requirements for secure psychiatric inpatient care.

I don't think anyone has suggested that she should be running her own household independently at 18. But her responsibilities and lifestyle are about to change dramatically and she needs to have appropriate support in place for this. Unless she's going to have no parental responsibilities in the household and have her own mother fully raise the child, she is going to have to prioritise her child and fit her own studies and activities around them. She needs to be prepared for this.

If she's keen to stay at her current school if possible, then it's reasonable to explore whether that's feasible. But there should also be a back-up plan for if the school says it's not an option or if for whatever reason she can't go back there.

TheMadGardener · 23/10/2021 14:30

@Shadedog

What would she have done if her school didn’t have a sixth form? What is she proposing to do after A-levels? She must leave school at some point and you and her mother shouldn’t be pretending to her that she can stay until she is 25 (or even 19). Schools are for children and there are very good reasons why adults aren’t admitted as pupils. She is having an actual baby and I really don’t understand why you are ignoring this rather pertinent fact and waffling on about sixth form colleges being an equivalent to secure psychiatric units and at the same time places where everyone who attends lives alone and runs a household and for some reason doesn’t have to hand their homework in. Is she an immature kid or is she a mother? Does she want to do A-levels or does she want to refuse to go inside the college?
Quite. OP keeps saying that the girl would only feel safe at school and couldn't cope with a new place/was too scared to walk into a FE college. I don't mean this unkindly, but does OP think girl can stay at school forever? At some point she will have to leave. If she wants to do a degree (or more likely if mum wants her to) she will have to brave university. Change is unavoidable so it may be better to get settled somewhere new sooner rather than later. Did I understand correctly that druggie boyfriend wants them to set up home together? Will girl be able to cope at all with the stress of a screaming unpredictable baby? OK she can abdicate all parenting to her own mother but maybe adoption would also be a choice if she really can't cope? The baby's wellbeing must come first. Girl will soon be a legal adult. If she freaks out at the massive stress of having a baby around or doesn't like the experience of being back at school in a different year group without her friends, there'll be nothing legally to stop her from dropping out and taking off to live with druggie boyfriend. Then it'll be up to social services to make sure the baby is safe.
Shadedog · 23/10/2021 14:10

What would she have done if her school didn’t have a sixth form? What is she proposing to do after A-levels? She must leave school at some point and you and her mother shouldn’t be pretending to her that she can stay until she is 25 (or even 19). Schools are for children and there are very good reasons why adults aren’t admitted as pupils.
She is having an actual baby and I really don’t understand why you are ignoring this rather pertinent fact and waffling on about sixth form colleges being an equivalent to secure psychiatric units and at the same time places where everyone who attends lives alone and runs a household and for some reason doesn’t have to hand their homework in. Is she an immature kid or is she a mother? Does she want to do A-levels or does she want to refuse to go inside the college?

Sirzy · 23/10/2021 13:53

@LittleBearPad

Being 19 and in school Sixth Form is not an issue for an immature girl . I would actually see that as benefit. However, Posters on here seem to think everybody by the age of 18 should be living independent lives, running a household and having no influence or guidance from their parents.

She’s having a baby! You need to stop minimising that fact OP. It isn’t going to help

She can’t be an immature 19 year old in a school. That ship sailed when she decided to keep the baby.

I agree. Encouraging the immaturity is only going to make things harder for her and confuse boundaries.
Swipe left for the next trending thread