Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant Year 12 the opportunity to repeat year 12 next yeara currently pregnant currently pregnant year 12

542 replies

redhilary · 21/10/2021 20:07

I have reposted this thread from chat due to limited traffic.

Is it a feasible proposal that a school might consider allowing a currently pregnant year 12 girl the opportunity to repeat Year 12 next year.

OP posts:
motherofthelittlescreamingone · 24/10/2021 22:26

But it is not relevant to what GD should do in future to dwell on what you might have done in the past. You didn't have the parental rights to wade in and GD's mother chose to ignore it, effectively - that is on her and not on you.

GD's sister might have been right in the past about what the better option for her sister was, but her sister is her own person, a person who is about to be a mother. Enough handwringing about academic achievement right now. Ensure GD has options for the future and support her to be a mother.

You can't go back, only forward.

It's hardly going to help GD to grow up if you are all handwringing about what you all should have done to control her and massively overreaching all the time. She is autistic and she might be young and naive, but she isn't incapable of being a good mother. There are lots of things she can do - maybe having a bit of space and another person to factor in might help her to find the Motivation to find her OWN path.

Head girl and Durham isn't the be all and end all, frankly.

redhilary · 24/10/2021 22:23

Modern day Catholics are selective in what they do. But ABORTION is a no no..

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 24/10/2021 22:19

I thought the Catholic rule was no sex before marriage. And divorce is a no no as well. I think you should step away and let them get on with it. Your interference is making things even more muddled and difficult. Now this schoolgirl is to be boarded at a house away from her baby all week. I still say adoption should be considered under these circumstances.

redhilary · 24/10/2021 22:13

I said it was not this supposed term 'Super Selective' not Selective. The difference is Super Selective schools select say takes the top 5% based on the number of places available on scores . Normal Grammar schools require a pupil to achieve say a score of 360 over English Math's, and Non Verbal or Verbal reasoning tests with a score of no less than 120 on any of the three 11+ tests taken. Hence non super selective grammar schools take the top 25% of the ability range.

Complicated I know but that's how the 11+ works.

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 22:11

What a mess.

But it isn’t your fault or your responsibility OP.

redhilary · 24/10/2021 22:03

Because she and the family are Catholics...

OP posts:
redhilary · 24/10/2021 22:03

Right the reason I am so invested in this 'Shit storm', is because Goddaughter's elder sister (20) the pregnancy is all my fault. She was telling me from March 2020 from the start of lockdown that her sister was sneaking out to see the boyfriend. This, and that her 'liberal' mother would do nothing about it.

Hence, elder sister kept begging me to take Goddaughter to live with me. Elder sister has only just started speaking to me again because of this. Thus, is telling me that if her sister does not complete her A levels and get to University its all down to me.

This is probably her deflecting the blame because she was at home from University and could have stopped the situation. However, she said her liberal mother would do nothing about it. Friend telling elder sister her parenting methods did not stop her becoming Deputy Head Girl @ the Grammar A A A at A level and Durham University. Sister screaming back her mother, yes but I'm not 'Fucking Autistic'.

As for the selfish father and ex husband well he is not interested as long as it does not cost him anything . Yet he could for instance have easily afforded the two private schools up thread that would have benefited Goddaughter greatly.

My head is about to explode...

OP posts:
Funnylittlefloozie · 24/10/2021 21:22

If you think your god-daughter will be a poor mother, can't cope with change and has an awful boyfriend.... why haven't you all encouraged the poor girl to have an abortion? You're banging on about her being at a non-selective grammar school, whatever the hell that is, but frankly the way you're describing her, she is practically incapable of managing her own life.

hedgehogger1 · 24/10/2021 21:00

It sounds like she needs to leave the school and have a fresh start. She doesn't sound academic enough for a levels, and smashing a chair up is not excusable. Imagine how the rest of the class felt. I've taught a lot of autistic kids over the years, you can't just use it as an excuse

Penistoe · 24/10/2021 20:12

Your friend needs to focus on the task at hand rather than deflecting anger towards the school. She has a pregnant teen, her daughters reality is now completely different. Don’t we warn teens all about this?

motherofthelittlescreamingone · 24/10/2021 20:07

WOW

Your Goddaughter doesn't have a chance. Not of achieving decent A levels and further education. She can do that, whether next year or in time.

But of growing up and getting to a place where she is a decent mum and has a good relationship with her own mum.

You seriously think telling your goddaughter that she will be a Crap mum and needs to live with you to continue her education (which is what you are all thinking about doing - suggesting to a mum that she can't/shouldn't raise her own baby or that it isn't really that important that she does so) is in her long term best interests?

Yes, your goddaughter could possibly do A levels at grammar school next year with good support from school and parents/grandparents (though I would have struggled to do a levels alongside DD1 when I was quite a bit older). What you are suggesting/doing is not good support from parents, it's extremely overbearing and pressurising. She would come home on Friday night after five days away and have to watch her mum play mummy to her DD and her DD consider another person her DD's mum? And get good grades or giving up her first year with her DD will be a waste. That is cruel, tbh.

Your goddaughter has chosen to keep a baby, so on some level she does want to be mum. She probably is in denial right now - it is scary. Don't strip this away from her under the guise of wanting her to do well at her education. Support her TO BE THE MUM, not replace her with another more acceptable (to you all) one and try to shoehorn her back in to the same place she was in.

Lockdown was tough for many many teens. But you are all in denial. Your GD missed social interactions and routine of school and fell in with an unsuitable boy, yes, but she also clearly also struggled with studying on her own and has a few issues with her mum (hence why you are suggesting she lives with you) - your proposal that she completes grammar school is likely to mean either more study at home around a baby that seems very close to the situation she couldn't cope with in lockdown OR a non-mum relationship with her baby that she may come to regret (and hate you all).

You know what, I went to a prestigious university at 18. I wish I had gone later, after resolving some mental health issues related to my autism - a more grown up me would have found it easier to adjust to a new learning environment. Studying a bit later (not just a year later) really isn't the end of the world. And nor is going to university - lots of great apprenticeships out there that get you to the same place whilst earning money and not accruing debt.

Back off - make a loose plan if she feels she can study around a baby next year. That's why FE college might be useful - it is more flexible and can be picked up when ready - it isn't a slight on her intelligence. Then try to support her for the Mum bit. That is the important bit. For her AND the baby (who you appear not to have considered fully - it isn't just a question of whether your friend is likely to be an objectively better mum than her DD, but that baby's interests in having the best possible relationship with her actual mother).

Howshouldibehave · 24/10/2021 19:48

I don't see why I should rule out…

You shouldn’t be ruling anything out-it’s not your decision. You are coming across as way too involved and emotionally invested here.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/10/2021 19:20

@redhilary

These are the suggestions of my friend who rightly or wrongly, believes she and her mother are a better parental bet than her 17 year old daughter would be.
I think it would be viable if you had a mature, adaptable, capable young woman who was determined to continue her education and succeed in the face of adversity.

That is not the person you've described here yet you are all still piling on the pressure, shoehorning her onto the path you have all deemed most appropriate and will be faux surprised when she buckled and fails I'm sure.

Can't you just give her a cuddle and tell her that she can park the big decisions until the baby is here? Let her focus on one massive upheaval at a time.

LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 19:20

Poor girl. She doesn’t get to decide things does she.

redhilary · 24/10/2021 19:06

These are the suggestions of my friend who rightly or wrongly, believes she and her mother are a better parental bet than her 17 year old daughter would be.

OP posts:
Whinge · 24/10/2021 19:04

Goddaughter is adamant she wants to continue in full time education. Thus, an option of her mother and youngish Grandmother (62) to care for the baby, from Monday - Friday is not a impossible idea.

and yes she is still in denial about the extent of the dramatic changes to her life, she is about to be faced with.

If she's still in denial I don't think offering a place away from her child 5 days a week is a sensible idea. Education is important, but she made the decision to have the baby, and that means her life will change. Offering her a get out and leaving someone else to parent for 5 days a week isn't a realistic option.

What happens after she finishes her A levels. Will her mum be left with the child while she goes to uni, or will she take the child away from their home and the person who has been the primary carer for 2 years? Confused

Sirzy · 24/10/2021 18:59

You shouldn’t be ruling anything in or out. Your a godparent not a parent. You are way over invested in all of this.

LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 18:57

So your plan is for GD to stay minus baby.

It’s not realistic and if that is what happens - poor baby.

I don't see why I should rule out Goddaughter continuing in fulltime education next year. We will see what she wants to do, and yes she is still in denial about the extent of the dramatic changes to her life, she is about to be faced with.

She’s not the only one.

redhilary · 24/10/2021 18:48

Has sailed away *

OP posts:
redhilary · 24/10/2021 18:47

it is only an potential option and if it does not happen as you say, because Goddaughter is unable to be separated from Monday- Friday. But at the moment Goddaughter is adamant she wants to continue in full time education. Thus, an option of her mother and youngish Grandmother (62) to care for the baby, from Monday - Friday is not a impossible idea. This, is despite posters on here declaring this to be negligent to both the baby and mother. On the contrary you will have in September 2022 a young immature mother of 17 @ 1/2 who might want the option of going to University when she is 19 . She would also have the support of the University via Disabled Students allowance and interventions for looking after her then 'young' child.

I don't see why I should rule out Goddaughter continuing in fulltime education next year. We will see what she wants to do, and yes she is still in denial about the extent of the dramatic changes to her life, she is about to be faced with.
She wishes she was 13 and go back to see me with her mother for Toast and Tea. Unfortunately that boat had sailed away.

OP posts:
2reefsin30knots · 24/10/2021 18:02

@redhilary

Abraxan . That gives me an idea Goddaughter has said she would not mind living with me . Perhaps therefore she could stay with me Monday-Friday from next September if the right childcare is in place. Thus, restart year 12 when 'hopefully' DD 1will begin year 12. I mention this situation to the school to see if they might be open to admitting Goddaughter.. That might be a long shot, but it is worth a go. Anyway if Goddaughter did live with me through the week and attended a Sixth Form College, that would give her the best chance educationally. That would be her choice, though I am a lot stricter than her mother.
Is the baby coming to live with you in this scenario?? If not, how can you possibly think that would be right for the baby? There is a whole new little person in this equation now whose needs should come first. The DD may be young, but she's still the baby's mother.

If the DD bonds with the baby properly, there's no way she would cope with being separated Mon-Fri either. How would you have felt if somebody suggested to you that you shouldn't be with your baby all week because you needed to finish a course for work?

TirednWorried · 24/10/2021 17:09

The bottom line is you are setting this girl up to fail. Thats in no one's interests.

LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 16:25

@redhilary

I think the average is about 8 grade 7s or more..

Well imagine if 50% of students got at least a grade 7 in all their 9 subjects, that leaves in this case 129 grades out of the remaining 648 reported grades as being below grade 7.

648 Grade 7s or above came from 72 pupils (50%) so average of (9)
130 grades below grade 7 came from the other 72 pupils (50%) so 518/72 = 7.19 grades over 7 7.19 + 9 /2 = An average of 8 Grade 7 or above per pupil.

What is the average no of level 7 grades or above for the whole cohort: 7.19+9/2 = 8.095

Confused
LittleBearPad · 24/10/2021 16:24

So you’re planning for a 18 year old and her baby to live with you? Really.

Or are you working on the basis the baby isn’t there. I assume the latter as that’s your general approach to this whole mess.

Howshouldibehave · 24/10/2021 15:52

stay with me Monday-Friday

With a baby? Or do you mean she leaves her baby with her mother for most of the week?!

Hmmmm, I think you should leave it to the pregnant woman to decide what it is that she wants to do, if that even is sitting her A levels immediately. When she gives birth, her baby will be her priority, I would imagine.