Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Father Christmas

110 replies

tryingtosavethemagic · 21/10/2021 19:43

My cousin has told his kids aged 9 and 8 the truth about Father Christmas in October. Not because his kids asked but because his wife believed still when she was in yr 7 and she doesn't want her kids to feel stupid the way she did back then... The kids were really upset apparently this is what they told us.

So after some thought we normally spend Christmas Day together. I think they have ruined the magic for their kids (their choice of course). My kids are the same age as theirs so I have said that this year I don't want to spend the day with them. I don't want to risk my kids finding out. Especially on the actual day when opening and showing each other Father Christmas gifts All kids can be quite spiteful these kids are these kids!!

They are not happy at all with us for saying we wanna do it separate this year. I wanna keep the magic alive for mine as long as I possibly can.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Christmas1988 · 22/10/2021 13:23

YANBU I’d do the same in your position!

countrygirl99 · 22/10/2021 13:20

Just because a child hasn't said they don't believe doesn't mean they do. More likely they are worried spilling the beans will mean the presents stop. I'm 62 and it was only a couple of years ago I confessed to my parents that their trick if hiding our presents at the neighbours and vice versa didn't work, both sets of kids had a full inventory ahead of Christmas. No way were we letting on. It would have spoiled the magic for our parents. Of course the risk of not getting anymore presents played absolutely no role in our strategy at all, definitely not.

Wheelz46 · 22/10/2021 13:18

Did you ask your brother if his children would play along at the pretence of Father Christmas in front of your children?

I spend Christmas with my brother and his family, his children are slightly older than mine and they have always played along that FC is real, never once slipped up.

Same when we were younger, while I still believed, my older siblings went along with it until I no longer did believe.

MrsWhites · 22/10/2021 13:13

I think your family were a bit hysterical in their approach, I understand that your cousins wife felt silly being in year 7 still believing but there is a big difference between 7 and 9 and senior school age, why not have the conversation before senior school if they felt it that important.

I just never understand what the problem is with children believing in something that brings them excitement and happiness, what’s the harm. Has anyone ever really been psychologically damaged by parents telling them Santa is real?

The poster whose son said he wanted to pretend that he still believed is the most reasoned post on this thread - he sounds like a lovely boy!

Fernhilde · 22/10/2021 13:08

Quote fail . That was @OnlyFoolsnMothers

Fernhilde · 22/10/2021 13:07

She just said she was autistic.

Lorw · 22/10/2021 12:50

Oh OP, you should be able to raise your children however you see fit, I just naturally stopped believing, which I think is a much better, though I still refer to getting presents off Santa and getting into the whole spirit of it because that’s the magic of Christmas and I’m in my late 20s 😁

I have SS’s who have quite an age gap, the eldest (in their teens) will maliciously wind up the 6yo that Santa doesn’t exist and make him cry which I think is cruel and I see him breaking his heart and it makes me so sad, so I’d do what you’re doing and refuse to spend the day with them 😁

They have every right to raise their children how they like but so do you 😁

RaisedByPangolins · 22/10/2021 12:44

Yes I agree as an adult with you but for kids the magic is a lot to do with Father Christmas... Advent Calendars, elf on shelf, all the magical Christmas movies, being good, visiting Father Christmas the cookies and milk writing him a letter, reindeers etc all of that is defo magical for kids no?

You said it yourself - there’s a lot more to it than FC himself. Obviously visiting him for a sit on his lap (do they even still do that?!) won’t feature as kids get older anyway, but there’s no reason why you can’t still enjoy advent calendars and Xmas movies, driving or walking round to see all the Xmas lights, making Xmas biscuits (keep one for Santa - wink wink).

The rest of it is very much geared towards younger children so at 9 yours are going to be a bit past that anyway, with or without Santa, so elf on the shelf - maybe come up with a way of doing that for older kids - some of the more naughty things they do for example! They will know the elf isn’t real even at this age, so why not continue it as a way to make them laugh every morning as they get older, rather than pretending it’s magic.

Mine are all teens or older now and although I’ve never explicitly told them it’s just a story, there’s been a lot of “nudge nudge wink wink, if you don’t believe you don’t get any presents” for many years, so I do think it’s sad that your DB has explicitly said it’s not real. But in your shoes I wouldn’t let it ruin family Xmas - just meet up as usual. If the cousins say something then either your kids will ask you straight out or start to question things in a more subtle way. At that point (which WILL come whether from the cousins or friends…Or just growing up) you can decide to go down the route of “some people don’t believe and they don’t get to enjoy the magic of Xmas like we do” or once they’re older just straight up lie to their face that of course he’s real and if they want xyz in their stocking they’d better make sure they’re not on the naughty list.

NavigatingAdolescence · 22/10/2021 12:37

Guess it depends whether the incentive to believe (or parental pressure, “no presents for those who don’t believe”) is greater than their critical reasoning skills (not possible, difference in gifts given, understanding of beliefs elsewhere in the world (Santa not universal, celebrating on different days).

DD has always been worldly wide. Couldn’t work out why a fairy would want children’s teeth, knew the characters at Disney (aged 3) weren’t real, had travelled to different time zones for Xmas by 5. So at 7 when she learned about the speed of light, there was no chance she was going to accept Santa as possible.

80sMum · 22/10/2021 12:36

Chances are that your children are already aware that it's all pretend, OP! Children are not fools, they can usually work things out for themselves.

But anyway don't worry about it. The fun of pretending is part of the "magic" of Christmas. You don't have to take things literally (ie, actually believe that the fantasy is reality) in order to enjoy them.

Most children love fantasy and fairytales, but they know it's just pretend. I think it's exactly the same with Christmas.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/10/2021 12:36

@BlibBlabBlob

Urrrgh this what happens when parents insist in actively lying to their kids and setting up elaborate deception. You can 'do' Father Christmas without explicitly saying that he is or isn't real. Playing the Santa Game at Christmas is just as magical and fun as trying to convince your kids that an elderly stranger is going to break into your house through a chimney you don't have and creep around their bedroom while they sleep to leave presents.

And for those saying it's harmless, for a few kids it really isn't. If you're autistic and value truth above all and take your parents at their word, it really can break your trust in them when they have to sit you down and tell you the truth as you approach the end of primary school. Because you're supposed to be able to trust your parents to tell the truth! And if they actively lie to you and then have to admit to that later, why should you trust them in any other matter. My own parents struggled to convince me of their (genuine) belief in God after that. If Santa and the Tooth Fairy are made up deceptions, why is God any different?

Honestly if your kids still believe, OP, it's probably better that they hear it from their cousins. You really don't want to have to sit them down and tell them yourself one day.

Like I said, most kids gradually figure it out for themselves (if the parents haven't gone OTT with the deception) and it's no big deal. But for some it really, really is a big deal.

BTW I still have a great time watching Santa films and there is still something very magical about watching DD wake on Christmas morning to discover a stocking full of presents. It's magical for her too, and she gets all that without having to worry about a strange MAN ACTUALLY BREAKING INTO THE HOUSE AND INTO HER ROOM WHILE SHE SLEEPS! I mean seriously, examine that idea without the 'magic' of Santa for a sec and it is really disturbing! Certainly enough to freak out my (autistic) DD; she's very happy to know it's a fun game we are playing and that Father Christmas isn't a magical person, he is actually everyone in this world who loves their kid and wants to make their Christmas a little more special. She also thinks it's great fun to put together a stocking for DH and get to be Santa as well as have him 'visit' her.

Lord I do wonder how people get through life when they take everything so literal. Millions of children believe in Santa and aren’t scarred for life- get a grip
tryingtosavethemagic · 22/10/2021 12:29

@SpeedRunParent

It's highly unlikely that kids if that she haven't figured it out already, or at least been told by other, brighter children that it's all pretend. If they are choosing to believe for the fun of it then they will ignore their cousins anyway - there's absolutely no way their cousins will be the first child to say anything about it.
Brighter kids..... Really!!!!

So at 8 if a child still believes they are not as bright as one who doesn't!! Well that's definitely an 'un bright' comment to make.

OP posts:
Saoirse82 · 22/10/2021 12:27

YANBU. I think around the age of 8 you start to question things, that's when I did because my parents still have the letter I left for santa asking him did he 'igsist'. I think gradually I stopped believing but I enjoyed playing along even when i knew he wasn't real so it would have been spoilt for me if my parents hadn't joined in to keep up the charade. My nephew believed til he was 8 and then after that Christmas he started to wonder and googled it, but he enjoys playing along with the magic for his younger brother. This may be the last Xmas your children believe so enjoy it with your kids without worrying that someone will spoil it for them.

BlibBlabBlob · 22/10/2021 12:22

Urrrgh this what happens when parents insist in actively lying to their kids and setting up elaborate deception. You can 'do' Father Christmas without explicitly saying that he is or isn't real. Playing the Santa Game at Christmas is just as magical and fun as trying to convince your kids that an elderly stranger is going to break into your house through a chimney you don't have and creep around their bedroom while they sleep to leave presents.

And for those saying it's harmless, for a few kids it really isn't. If you're autistic and value truth above all and take your parents at their word, it really can break your trust in them when they have to sit you down and tell you the truth as you approach the end of primary school. Because you're supposed to be able to trust your parents to tell the truth! And if they actively lie to you and then have to admit to that later, why should you trust them in any other matter. My own parents struggled to convince me of their (genuine) belief in God after that. If Santa and the Tooth Fairy are made up deceptions, why is God any different?

Honestly if your kids still believe, OP, it's probably better that they hear it from their cousins. You really don't want to have to sit them down and tell them yourself one day.

Like I said, most kids gradually figure it out for themselves (if the parents haven't gone OTT with the deception) and it's no big deal. But for some it really, really is a big deal.

BTW I still have a great time watching Santa films and there is still something very magical about watching DD wake on Christmas morning to discover a stocking full of presents. It's magical for her too, and she gets all that without having to worry about a strange MAN ACTUALLY BREAKING INTO THE HOUSE AND INTO HER ROOM WHILE SHE SLEEPS! I mean seriously, examine that idea without the 'magic' of Santa for a sec and it is really disturbing! Certainly enough to freak out my (autistic) DD; she's very happy to know it's a fun game we are playing and that Father Christmas isn't a magical person, he is actually everyone in this world who loves their kid and wants to make their Christmas a little more special. She also thinks it's great fun to put together a stocking for DH and get to be Santa as well as have him 'visit' her.

FlatteredFool · 22/10/2021 12:10

We need all the magic we can get these days. I still believe and I'm 45. If people can believe in God then they can believe in FC.

Mummyme87 · 22/10/2021 12:06

This is so sad and was unnecessary of them, I wouldn’t be keen to spend Christmas Day with them either for the same reasons.

I was about 10 I think and same as my sister, but I suspect we questioned it the year before. My 7yr old still very much believes, I’m dreading the day he doesn’t.

It’s utterly harmless, and her theory… there’s a big difference between her age kids and a year 7!

SpeedRunParent · 22/10/2021 12:03

It's highly unlikely that kids if that she haven't figured it out already, or at least been told by other, brighter children that it's all pretend. If they are choosing to believe for the fun of it then they will ignore their cousins anyway - there's absolutely no way their cousins will be the first child to say anything about it.

Artie30 · 22/10/2021 12:00

This is why I'm dreading telling Ds. He is 10 and has sen, younger than his peers but I feel like I'll have to tell all before secondary school next year. But I'm worried sick he'll tell Dd who is just turned 6!! He wouldn't do it out of spite but like I said he has sen and worried he'll tell her.

YANBU.

I fully believed until 10/11 (told before secondary school). I don't think I re call ever taking about if Santa is real or not at primary or secondary. I did have one friend that still believed in year 8 but she was never picked on for it.

Dp said he figured it out when he was maybe 7 as his mum was pants at hiding stuff - my mum was ott. She'd hide out Santa stuff down my grans and totally separate paper etc.!

MooseBreath · 22/10/2021 11:27

@WheelieBinPrincess I believed until I was 12. I am not unintelligent. I had good grades, a passion for Celtic mythology, and an aptitude for dance and choreography. However, I was a "young" 12 and didn't hit puberty or get interested in typical teenage behaviour until I was close to 16. There's nothing wrong with keeping a childish innocence past the age of 8.

garlictwist · 22/10/2021 10:53

I don't think that kids of 9 and 8 would have really believed and anyway - even if they did, FC isn't real. Would you really not spend Christmas with your family because of a myth that your children probably won't care about in a year or two anyway?

tryingtosavethemagic · 22/10/2021 10:20

Thanks All!!! Some good points raised to consider that I hadn't thought of!!!

OP posts:
tryingtosavethemagic · 22/10/2021 10:06

@Jennifer3849

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.
What did you say that got removed I missed it!!
OP posts:
AtlanticCityProof · 22/10/2021 07:27

The last thing you want is to have to tell them yourself so contact with children who know can only be a good thing.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 22/10/2021 07:10

You’re planning on not spending Christmas with them because they told their children the truth rather than continue to lie?
Christmas magic is still achievable without lying, it’s likely most older primary know but keep up the pretence for presents if they have been told Santa does the gifting.

PippinStar · 21/10/2021 23:17

YANBU.

Also, the average age for kids to stop believing is 8 apparently so not sure why people think age 7+ is so odd 🤷🏼‍♀️

www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/kids-give-santa-age-8-adults-still-want-believe-180971063/