Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner's ex wants veto on me seeing their kids at all

185 replies

Stripepuppydream · 21/10/2021 18:33

I am 42 tomorrow, no children, my boyfriend of 1 year is 42, I recently met his kids for the first time (9 and 11, boys) at a small BBQ with other family/friends (not the ex wife) which went really well. We live 1.5 hours apart so I had packed a bag ready to stay elsewhere that evening as my partner had his boys over. However while I was out of earshot they asked if I was staying over, my partner asked them if it was OK, they said yes, and could I come to watch them play football in the morning. All went well, my partner umpired so I walked the dogs around the field and did not chat with any parents, not sure who knew the ex wife, and feeling very aware this was family territory.

That afternoon when the kids were dropped back with their mum, she realised I had stayed and been to football, had not discussed that scenario with my partner in advance and so was upset. I can understand that and was annoyed with my partner for not having checked with her first, included her in the decision and not having made it clear to me she hadn't OKd that. The result is, I am no longer allowed to be in the house around the boys, to stay over if he has them, or to go to football etc. Lets be clear, we've been going out for a year and I have not impacted on their contact and time with their Dad, kids have met me once.

I am incredibly disappointed that my partner is asking me to align with his ex wife's requirements to stay in the background for longer. There are no accusations of anything improper that I am aware of, just that he is prepared to run this at the speed his ex requests because, in his words, she will try to stop him seeing the kids if he doesn't. I cant see this happening as they are both so committed to supporting the boys football commitments which requires both of them to work together for lifts etc. She has a full time job and a business start up (MLM ... but that's another story) so needs the support of my partner to enable the work they both do to continue. She also works in child protection so I dont think could just stop him seeing the kids without a good reason, and there is none. Ive always been prepared to meet her but am not having my life and relationship progress determined by her demands when there is nothing to worry about in terms of impact on the boys. Everyone (their family and family friends) likes me, boys have not been upset etc. by idea of Dad having a girlfriend, they want to come and visit me at some point, love my dog (who they have met more often than me!), it worked out as perfectly as you could have asked for. But ex wife is still not happy and I my partner is not sticking up for what he thinks is right for him, for me, and the only way my relationship remains possible is if I do as I am told.

What do you think? Should I be compliant and jump through more hoops of approval so the ex wife/Mum is happy with the pace etc of my contact with the boys (which I am worried she may never be), do I keep investing months of my time and chunks of my heart with her seemingly having the power of veto over me and power to limit my relationship like this?

The alternative is that I say I can't take part in this any more, I can't do as they ask, and he walks away. I know this for sure as it happened this morning.

OP posts:
TasteTheMeatNotTheHeat · 23/10/2021 04:20

I would take that as the relationship ending, tbh.

You can do much better. Don't put up with this man's pathetic behaviour.

BogRollBOGOF · 23/10/2021 04:14

I was going to say treat it as an amber warning, see how things develop over a period of time and reassess if there isn't progress, but given his reaction it is better to call it a day now.

It's good that he takes his relationship with the children seriously, but there has to be balance and he can't put the ex ahead of your needs as a couple every time. There has to be compromise on all sides, not him compromising you every time.

Fetarabbit · 23/10/2021 04:13

As in, who him and your daughter have contscf with.

Fetarabbit · 23/10/2021 04:13

@Pippy1900

“Relationships break down and people move on. Just because there's a child involved doesn't mean the other parent has any say over who their ex spends time with.”

I wouldn’t have any interest who an ex spent time with. I do however, have the right to have a say in who my daughter would spend time with. I am a Teacher - so I’ve seen all the child protection issues too. I would do whatever my daughter needed - but I’m just saying how hard it would be. Also, this msn may have cheated on the mother and she has unresolved pain - you really need to look at it from her viewpoint too!

Ah bless you. No, you wouldn't be able to dictate who he spent time with during his contact.

OP I know his children are rightfully a big part of his life and probably his time, but a year isn't that long really. He should stand up to his ex, yes, but for whatever reason he doesn't feel comfortable doing so, and that's his choice to prioritise his children- the right choice really. As time passes things might change, they might not, if you aren't happy with that then agree with others that it's best to leave.

Moaning0000 · 23/10/2021 04:11

Oh god this brings back memories.

Run, don't walk away. You don't want this shit in your life trust me. I'm talking from the place of bitter experience. He will continue to dance to her tune at your expense and over time you'll get absolutely sick of it.

She has zero rights to dictate to this extent and the fact he allows her to and panders to it is a massive red flag.

eekbumbler · 23/10/2021 03:47

@Pippy1900

I love this place - everyone gets so excited…. Chil out - I’m playing Devil’s advocate - but hilarious how “emotional” everyone gets. Try not sleeping with your boyfriend the same night you meet his kids! I’m sure that won’t confuse or upset them!
A lot more succinctly put than I did.

Yes OP YABU.

eekbumbler · 23/10/2021 03:45

So meeting the kids, staying the night, going to football the next day all happened in TWO DAYS.

The kids Mum knows nothing about you, she doesn't know you've been together for a year.

YABU - you have done way too much in one weekend. I was going to say too soon - BUT you should have been easing into things over the year.

Did the kids Mum even know you existed before this?

She's reacting unreasonable because the pair of you have behave unreasonably.

I've been there, I've lost count of how many girlfriends my daughters dad has had but at least he didnt keep them a secret and then straight into a weekend.

Elbie79 · 23/10/2021 02:56

@Pippy1900

I assume this man has legal rights formalised in the divorce that mean he is the responsible Parent when the children are with him. She cannot say how he behaves when he is the parent. Is taking it slow going to mean she decides she. You get to move in, or marry or maybe have your own child: I had my daughter at 42! I wouldn’t just leave, I would clarify his legal rights and how much power she has then tell him his life with her is over and starting fresh with you. If he is isnt prepared to accept that then you have your answer!
What does this even mean? I don't think it's helpful to the OP to attempt advice on legalities you don't understand.
SammyScrounge · 23/10/2021 02:38

I think there is some very harsh judgment of the father on this story. He is very unsure perhaps of the law and divorcing men get their heads full of stories about losing access on an ex wife's whim. It might help him to consult a lawyer about access and his rights and about her attaching ridiculous conditions to access.
The wife seems to be an unpleasant woman ready to weaponise the children out of sheer spite. She is paying no mind to the wishes of the children and the damage
to them of not seeing their Dad.
I doubt she'll take it to court . A lawyer would advise against trying to impose conditions on her ex husband.

Pippy1900 · 23/10/2021 01:37

I love this place - everyone gets so excited…. Chil out - I’m playing Devil’s advocate - but hilarious how “emotional” everyone gets. Try not sleeping with your boyfriend the same night you meet his kids! I’m sure that won’t confuse or upset them!

GirlWithAGuitar · 23/10/2021 00:51

It was stupid to stay over and then go to football on the first proper meet. I can understand why their mum had an issue with that. It should be a gradual build up, regardless of them saying they didn’t mind you staying and asking to go to football. You’d waited a decent length of time to meet them and then it was all full on on the first meeting.
It’s wrong for their mum to say you can’t be around them at all though. That sounds much more like her wanting to control rather than act in the kids best interests.
He needs to talk to his ex and come to an agreement. I don’t think you need to have much contact with them at this stage, you’re not living together so it’s easy enough for him to see you when he hasn’t got his kids on the whole. But obviously this should be built up as your relationship continues if you plan on living together at some point.

I do have a friend who’s kids have only met her boyfriend of 5 years a few times. She has them 50/50 with their dad and has no intention of living with the boyfriend at least until kids are adults if ever so there’s just no reason for him to have much involvement.

WorraLiberty · 23/10/2021 00:48

@Pippy1900

I don’t own her, but I would do anything to protect her. Anyway, I’m happily married, so all hypothetical and not at all about the original post! If you sat through the child protection issues I have sat through you may feel differently about new partners!
If you knew as many teenagers/adults of divorced and bitter parents as I do, you might feel differently.

I have 3 grown up sons.

1 of their friends committed suicide, at least 3 have been in trouble with the police due to drug addiction and crime and another one was sectioned before he turned 15.

All of them site their parents divorces and how they were dragged into the middle of their disputes.

WorraLiberty · 23/10/2021 00:44

@Pippy1900

I am married to the father of my beautiful DD, so don’t have this concern. However, I know I would be absolute nightmare mum with anyone who wanted to be near my daughter without me around. I would never ever countenance them calling her step-mum! Just saying it from my view point - giving access of your children to another new person would be intolerable for me. Especially if I was unhappy with the father to divorce him - probably wouldn’t trust his judgement much!
And this is why so many kids of divorced parents end up fucked up.

You call her 'beautiful' but she's clearly not beautiful enough for you to put her first?

Selfish and dangerous for her mental health because your post is all about you.

upupandawaytoday · 23/10/2021 00:35

I read it and agreed with the mum as I'd reacted very similar with my stbxh (but in my defence I wasn't told and he had known her 2 months at that point and only mere months after our separation, worst still he was forcing them to sleep at her flat on a sofa bed whilst breaking lockdown rules)

God I wish my ex and partner were as sensible as you two have been.

I can see her point. First time meeting them is a bit soon regardless of whether the kids were happy about it. My two are too scared of upsetting their dad so would have said the same. They don't like his new partner now but will still not say anything.

Having said that, you have been together a while so it's a slight over reaction on her part.

Like others have said, if I were dating a divorcee who behaved the way he has, I would be questioning my future with him for sure!

Nat6999 · 23/10/2021 00:16

Legally there isn't anything your dp's ex can do to stop you from seeing the children, but morally she can be a pain & stop him seeing the children if you are there. If he wants you to be there when he sees the dc it would be a good idea for him to go through the family courts & get court ordered contact. This isn't a quick process, probably at least a years wait to get to court for the first time after mediation & then it may take several times to get a final order, especially if his ex is being awkward.

Summerdayshaze · 23/10/2021 00:12

You sound great. You can do better than him.

AveryGoodlay · 23/10/2021 00:07

Stripepuppydream He isn't invested enough in your relationship to stand up to his ex. He should be well aware of his parental responsibility and should be able to quote this to her.

She’s using the kids as a weapon. Shame on her. I also agree with this completely.

That said, why on earth would either of you consider staying the night after your first meeting? That rings major safeguarding bells for me.

Pippy1900 · 23/10/2021 00:06

I don’t own her, but I would do anything to protect her. Anyway, I’m happily married, so all hypothetical and not at all about the original post! If you sat through the child protection issues I have sat through you may feel differently about new partners!

choli · 23/10/2021 00:01

I do however, have the right to have a say in who my daughter would spend time with.
Legally you don't. You don't own your kids, they are not your possessions. Their father is your equal legally.

Pippy1900 · 22/10/2021 23:59

Ha ha ha, I would!

TheChiefJo · 22/10/2021 23:55

No you wouldn't.

Pippy1900 · 22/10/2021 23:46

I would move my daughter to the other side of the World if I had to too stop someone I didn’t like being around her!

TheChiefJo · 22/10/2021 23:26

@BananaPB

I do however, have the right to have a say in who my daughter would spend time with.

You only have the right to voice an opinion in extreme circumstances like the new partner being a child sex offender. Your ex would be supported by the legal system to introduce your dd to whoever he wants. If the new partner is unreasonable you can try to appeal to your ex but he has the right to ignore you and allow his new partner to see his dd during his time.

You may privately judge or have an opinion on his new partner which is a different matter but in many cases Mums only have this kind of control because their exes believe it incorrectly

All of this.
BananaPB · 22/10/2021 23:18

I do however, have the right to have a say in who my daughter would spend time with.

You only have the right to voice an opinion in extreme circumstances like the new partner being a child sex offender. Your ex would be supported by the legal system to introduce your dd to whoever he wants. If the new partner is unreasonable you can try to appeal to your ex but he has the right to ignore you and allow his new partner to see his dd during his time.

You may privately judge or have an opinion on his new partner which is a different matter but in many cases Mums only have this kind of control because their exes believe it incorrectly

Pippy1900 · 22/10/2021 23:10

“Relationships break down and people move on. Just because there's a child involved doesn't mean the other parent has any say over who their ex spends time with.”

I wouldn’t have any interest who an ex spent time with. I do however, have the right to have a say in who my daughter would spend time with. I am a Teacher - so I’ve seen all the child protection issues too. I would do whatever my daughter needed - but I’m just saying how hard it would be. Also, this msn may have cheated on the mother and she has unresolved pain - you really need to look at it from her viewpoint too!