Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still feel a bit like I got shafted?

118 replies

Toastandcrumpets · 21/10/2021 16:22

When I left work to go on maternity leave, I received my maternity pay in one lump sum. This meant my tax payments, NI contributions, pension and student loan were all crazy high. I got some tax back but not the rest.

It meant for nine months maternity leave I had less than four thousand pounds.

I still feel annoyed!

OP posts:
Woeismethischristmas · 21/10/2021 18:44

@roarfeckingroarr

I don't understand how it meant you got less.

£100 day x 9 months mat leave = £900

Take 11% NI and 20% tax is going to be the same amount overall whether paid in one sum or monthly.

There’s a monthly threshold for Ni of £520 though so if you get paid in one lump everything above 520 has NI applied. In equal instalments your threshold will effectively be 4680 so op has lost 11% of 4160. Similar calculations for income tax and student loans which op can at least claim back but being down more than 2k (guesstimate) when money is tight would piss me off too.
PinkWaferBiscuit · 21/10/2021 18:43

OP in the kindest way possible is there anything else going on?

I was also thinking of asking but didn't want to get jumped on. I'm not saying this is a certainly but it does really sound like you're struggling with something else and using this thread as a place to redirect your frustration.

We all do similar sometimes like picking an argument that the bin has not been emptied when in reality the bin has nothing to do with why you are pissed off.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 21/10/2021 18:42

@WTF475878237NC

It is the custom on MN to post asking for advice or support or to specify just venting or ranting. It isn't clear what you want from your thread OP.
And god help any poster who doesn’t comply with this dictat!
Doveyouknow · 21/10/2021 18:41

I have had something similar and I did end up paying more NI contributions and student loan payments than I might otherwise. The income tax I could claim back but that isn't possible for NI contributions. It's crap.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/10/2021 18:39

@Toastandcrumpets

I completely refute I am being rude.

Some of these answers are aggressive questioning more suited to cross examining a witness on the stand than a simple moan about something.

It makes me feel really awful, like I must be a horrible person to get responses like this from the offset. Even though I know MN can just sometimes be like this, it feels horrible to be on the receiving end of.

I think I need to just acknowledge it isn’t the supportive place it was once and move on.

OP in the kindest way possible is there anything else going on?
Musmerian · 21/10/2021 18:38

I think if you read all your posts on this thread OP you’ll see that your tone is very abrupt and quite confrontational. People who are venting usually give more details.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 21/10/2021 18:36

@Toastandcrumpets

I completely refute I am being rude.

Some of these answers are aggressive questioning more suited to cross examining a witness on the stand than a simple moan about something.

It makes me feel really awful, like I must be a horrible person to get responses like this from the offset. Even though I know MN can just sometimes be like this, it feels horrible to be on the receiving end of.

I think I need to just acknowledge it isn’t the supportive place it was once and move on.

No one was cross examining you, we were just trying to better understand your situation so we could give you appropriate advice.

You don't want advice you just want to rant and that's fine but it helps to start by outlining that you're not looking for anything other than a sympathetic ear.

If you had said you just want to whinge then no one would have asked you questions and tried to get a clearer picture.

This site can ve very supportive and for someone in your situation who actually wanted help the replies would have allowed them to clarify points and get the support they needed.

Toastandcrumpets · 21/10/2021 18:32

I completely refute I am being rude.

Some of these answers are aggressive questioning more suited to cross examining a witness on the stand than a simple moan about something.

It makes me feel really awful, like I must be a horrible person to get responses like this from the offset. Even though I know MN can just sometimes be like this, it feels horrible to be on the receiving end of.

I think I need to just acknowledge it isn’t the supportive place it was once and move on.

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/10/2021 18:29

@PassTheDutchyUpYrLeftBackside

Everyone.

The OP is on maternity leave. Her company paid her as a lump sum, which has resulted in possible lost income but definite agro.

Give her a break. She's got a small child and less money than expected.

Meh, she's the one being rude to strangers on the internet
lanthanum · 21/10/2021 18:13

If your total earnings for the year are below the threshold for student loan repayments, then apparently you can reclaim anything you've paid due to fluctuating income. However if your total earnings are slightly above, so that you would have paid a couple of quid if the earnings had been split evenly, then it's tough luck if you actually paid a lot one month.

OP - it may be worth making sure your employer knows how much difference it made; they may just not have realised, and thought it was just simpler for everyone to pay the lot up front. I suspect nothing can be done for you, but it might make them less likely to do it to someone else in the future.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 21/10/2021 18:07

It's perfectly legal and you would have paid no more tax had you received it over several months instead ? 🤷🏻‍♀️

roarfeckingroarr · 21/10/2021 18:05

I don't understand how it meant you got less.

£100 day x 9 months mat leave = £900

Take 11% NI and 20% tax is going to be the same amount overall whether paid in one sum or monthly.

underneaththeash · 21/10/2021 18:00

Similar happened to our nanny, we moved when she was about 27 weeks pregnant, so she was made redundant and we paid maternity in a lump sum. Employers NI was huge too. She did get her student load payment back, just not the NI.

Having said that, I think a non-renewed contract in law still equates to a dismissal, so they have to follow employment law regarding redundancy payments and return to work after maternity leave.

Luhou · 21/10/2021 17:59

@Toastandcrumpets

You can’t claim back the SL and as I’ve said I’m back at work now anyway.

It is done. I don’t need several more pages of what a useless piece of shit I am, I know that already thanks.

I'd look into this, just so you're not missing out as I was in the same sittuation and they deffo refunded me.
Toastandcrumpets · 21/10/2021 17:57

That’s the point April. No point claiming it back now. I’m back at work. You couldn’t at the time as no one ever picked up the phone.

OP posts:
Toastandcrumpets · 21/10/2021 17:56

I don’t think I’ll post for a while

OP posts:
Aprilx · 21/10/2021 17:56

@Toastandcrumpets

When I left work to go on maternity leave, I received my maternity pay in one lump sum. This meant my tax payments, NI contributions, pension and student loan were all crazy high. I got some tax back but not the rest.

It meant for nine months maternity leave I had less than four thousand pounds.

I still feel annoyed!

You could have been unlucky on income tax if the lump sum was paid in say March meaning it went into one tax year and you didn’t get the benefit of the following years personal allowance and / or were pushed into a higher tax band. But in many cases, the income tax should correct or be refunded.

A lump sum payment would result in NI being either neutral or favourable as it is a non cumulative tax and there is a much lower rate of NI on larger payments.

I don’t know why you had more pension deducted I would have assumed you make a flat rate of contributions. At least it is going into your personal pension out though. Similarly, the student loan payments are at least going towards paying off your debt.

BubblinTrouble · 21/10/2021 17:55

@GivenchyDahhling

The NI, student loan and pension contribution would surely have been the same whether spread out over a period of time or in one lump sum, unless I’m being stupid? It’s not a variable rate presuming you’re normally over the student loan repayment threshold and your pension contribution doesn’t change with income like eg teaching pensions?

You might still have more tax coming back to you on top of what you’ve had if it doesn’t add up though.

My student loan, NI and pensions go up depending on how much I get paid. So when I get a bonus these payments go up for me. So if a lump payment is made I think they do fluctuate.
Tinkywinkydinkydoo · 21/10/2021 17:55

Op I think you’ve posted this on the wrong board, this is Aibu, it’s an advice forum. Try posting it in Chat and put a disclaimer that you’re venting and you will likely get different responses.

Luhou · 21/10/2021 17:55

Provided that you don't earn over the threashold for paying student loan back for the tax year though (unlikely to on MAT Leave) if you contact student finance they will refund you. You do have to wait until the tax year is up, so they can ensure you won't reach that threshold before the tax year is up

Toastandcrumpets · 21/10/2021 17:54

You can’t claim back the SL and as I’ve said I’m back at work now anyway.

It is done. I don’t need several more pages of what a useless piece of shit I am, I know that already thanks.

OP posts:
TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 17:53

You said you told them you were not returning. That is the definition of terminating your contract.

You just spread your 3,5k out and claim back the SL and tax. Simple and no different to phased payments.

BarbaraofSeville · 21/10/2021 17:53

Tax will work itself out over the year, annoying as it is right now.

Possibly the same for student loan, because it's a percentage over a certain salary, so if you don't earn enough, you should get some of it back.

However, I think NI is worked out weekly, so you might lose out there. You might also want to check if you've had the right amount of NI credits, although if you expect to work most of your adult life, its probably irrelevant as there's plenty of 'spare' years to catch up.

But really annoying and potentially leaving you short right now when you need the money the most.

NeverTheHootenanny · 21/10/2021 17:51

Student loan and NI are calculated on a monthly basis @GivenchyDahhling, unlike tax which is calculated over the whole year, so if you get a large lump sum in one month rather than the same amount spread out over several months, you do end up paying more NI and student loan, and you don’t get it back

I didn’t realise that, I assumed it was just a set percentage regardless. How frustrating OP. I can’t imagine there is much you can do about it now unfortunately but not the stress you need with a small baby.

Pinkdelight3 · 21/10/2021 17:51

I would never turn to AIBU for advice.

But by default you're here asking if you are being unreasonable. And so by not giving the full context, being shot with people and leaving them confused, YABU. While on the matter of shafting, it seems you are also BU because you should've made yourself aware of this consequence of your action as the PP easily found a warning about it on the maternity site. That said, YANBU to be annoyed because losing money is annoying. But you wouldn't need to ask if YABU about that.