Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emma Watson Wedding Dresses

185 replies

YearsSinceISawYou · 21/10/2021 15:32

All those at the Earth shot Awards were asked to wear outfits that considered the environment-I suppose this means second hand or worn before. At any rate, that's what they did.

Along comes Emma Watson with her Harris Reed designed dress, made from 10 upcycled wedding dresses from Oxfam.

AIBU to think that if Emma really cared about this sort of stuff-as she often says she does-she would have left the 10 wedding dresses in Oxfam, so that 10 people would have been able to recycle 10 dresses-with the added bonus that they would have been affordable for those people.

Instead, she takes all ten of them and chops them up, thus showing herself to be an over-privileged hypocrite, who cares more about making a headline than 'saving the planet' or thinking about the women who could have made real use of those dresses.

Surely she had something else in her wardrobe that she could have used.

OP posts:
TheUnbearable · 21/10/2021 17:08

I have bought clothes from charity shops for the fabric, the nearest haberdashery shop is a good 15 mile round trip. But the dress is actually bloody awful isn’t it. I was wrapping up my Pippa dolls in paper doilies like that when I was about 5.

amusedbush · 21/10/2021 17:07

@Glitterybug

*Wow, thanks. My wedding dress was from ASOS because I eloped and didn't want to spend thousands on a bespoke dress, plus I was 25 and didn't have a tonne of disposable income. I looked great on the day, even in my cheapo, Oxfam-worthy dress.

But I suppose the best thing for my dress is to be cut up and reused?*

Wow touchy or what. Funnily enough, i don't know you so fucking obviously i wasnt talking specifically about your oxfam dress.

Look at the link. The top 10-20 listings are hideous 80s wedding dresses that no bride in 2021 will wear. Or poorly made fast fashion dresses. If they can be cut up and the components reused then that's better than them being thrown out because nobody is going to be buying that 80s dress with its huge puffy sleeves to wear as it is.

I didn't buy it from Oxfam, I bought it from ASOS but you sounded very sniffy about high street/"fast fashion" wedding dresses in general. I also don't think they are comparable to 80's meringue frocks either, so I found it a bit weird to lump them in the same category.
GingerScallop · 21/10/2021 17:07

I agree op. Surely the first step is to consume less. I have noted that this point is missed by many. As long as they do or buy recycle(d) or buy sustainable or bamboo products many feel they done it. We need to consume less. No need to covert 10 dresses into one. Wear and rewear one dress

Glitterybug · 21/10/2021 17:04

*Wow, thanks. My wedding dress was from ASOS because I eloped and didn't want to spend thousands on a bespoke dress, plus I was 25 and didn't have a tonne of disposable income. I looked great on the day, even in my cheapo, Oxfam-worthy dress.

But I suppose the best thing for my dress is to be cut up and reused?*

Wow touchy or what. Funnily enough, i don't know you so fucking obviously i wasnt talking specifically about your oxfam dress.

Look at the link. The top 10-20 listings are hideous 80s wedding dresses that no bride in 2021 will wear. Or poorly made fast fashion dresses. If they can be cut up and the components reused then that's better than them being thrown out because nobody is going to be buying that 80s dress with its huge puffy sleeves to wear as it is.

inferiorCatSlave · 21/10/2021 17:02

No matter how much good you do.

I do this is a very poor example of re-use - but that's down more to the designer.

Oxfam have got PR that they sell wedding dresses and dresses in case this had escaped some people notice and Emma Watson got headlines which helps her career and the designer - well can't say I'd want to buy from them after that dress but then I'm not their target market.

Cornettoninja · 21/10/2021 16:58

I think it looks like shite but it’s not a principle I can get worked up over, in fact it’s hard not to see it as a good thing from a recycling/repurposing pov.

Charity shops don’t exist for the purpose of providing those without lots of money cheap items so that argument doesn’t really hold water either, even though it’s slightly irritating that as a long haul rummager a good bargain is getting harder and harder to come across. The flip side of that a rise in the popularity of buying second hand is much better for the environment. On balance it’s quite hard work to find something negative in EW wearing recycled wedding dresses and probably just easier to say you don’t like her 🤷‍♀️

IamnotSethRogan · 21/10/2021 16:56

I think if you're a person, particularly a woman who shows any type of environmental /ecological conscious, you're basically open to people ready to jump on you when you slip up environmentally in anyway. No matter how much good you do.

ChargingBuck · 21/10/2021 16:56

To be honest, that woman makes me furious - everything about her is smug!

Interesting, @InPraiseOfBacchus - whenever I have seen her speak as EW rather than a character she's acting, I've felt quite the reverse, that she's not very confident or secure.
I dislike the Wokery, esp with regard to the outrage committed against JKR, but genuinely feel a bit sorry for poor little Emma, looking for a role in life post-Potter. All that money doesn't compensate for some of the horrible negatives of child stardom.

inferiorCatSlave · 21/10/2021 16:55

We had a silk wedding dress in the shop recently, it was a massive puffy 80s thing and was not the sort of thing ANY modern bride would wear.

But people who are in to sewing and fashion are not looking and seeing a 1980s wedding dress. They are seeing 10 metres of ivory silk, some nice pearl buttons, several metres of net underskirt, and lace trim.

Exactly - we looked at one recently - great trim and lace and buttons but DD1 didn't like the feel of the fabric so we decide not to buy in the end - but that was why we looked - lots of fabric.

DD1 repurpose several bed spread into dresses and blouses - it gets quite expenisve to keep her in new bought fabric. DH made a jacket out of linen curtains - a unusal pattern on the fabric and he hates how bland most mens clothing is these days - and I've made a draft excluder from some of those remains.

Glitterybug · 21/10/2021 16:54

*Anyway, I still think she is a virtue waving hypocrite-no, I don't like the persona she puts forward- although I can see that the thread has raised the blood pressure of a few, one or two to a dangerous level.

I'm on the app so I can't see the live blood pressure measurements from posters - can someone tell me how to view them?*

Amazing GrinGrinGrin

asprinklingofsugar · 21/10/2021 16:54

YABU

HesterShaw1 · 21/10/2021 16:54

I've got nothing against her wearing recycled dresses.

But they could at least have been turned into a decent outfit. She looked a mess. Sorry Emma.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 21/10/2021 16:51

I also read she ended up doing her lectures remotely at Brown because every time she answered a question someone would shout '10 points for Gryffindor!'

That's evidence of bullying from other students rather than of Emma Watson being "smug".

I have no strong feelings one way or the other about Emma Watson. I don't agree with what she said about JK Rowling. But laughing at other students bullying her..... just no.

MrsIsobelCrawley · 21/10/2021 16:49

What a tedious OP.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 21/10/2021 16:49

@InPraiseOfBacchus

To be honest, that woman makes me furious - everything about her is smug!

But as much as I want to, I can't do the mental gymnastics which would let me resent her for this. It's an ok gesture. Second-hand wedding dresses are hardly a precious resource, and a great many of them are too outmoded to be worn as they are.

Recycling and updating old occasionwear dresses is a tradition that dates back hundreds of years - even the upper classes used to do it in the Regency period when clothing was well-made, and was loved, mended and respected for generations.

So I'll give her a pass for this.

YES!

She's just so fucking smug all the time.

She refused to wear a corset in little women because she found it demeaning. A fucking corset used to be the equivalent of a bra.

It's the never ending piety of 'I'm so great'.

I also read she ended up doing her lectures remotely at Brown because every time she answered a question someone would shout '10 points for Gryffindor!'

BeetleyCarapace · 21/10/2021 16:47

@KingsleyShacklebolt Absolutely. My friend's son does something like this; he buys dated men's suits and shirts from charity shops and ebay, and cuts them up to make all these daring outfits that you can only get away with when you're 6'3 and 20 years old. It's so creative it makes me want to weep!

He also sends the offcuts to a friend of his who makes teddy bears out of the material, so very little actually gets chucked.

amusedbush · 21/10/2021 16:47

@Glitterybug

Have you had a look at the wedding dresses available on oxfam?

onlineshop.oxfam.org.uk/bridal/category/bridal?N=4131982658&Ns=product.creationDate|1&Nr=AND(product.active:1,NOT(sku.listPrice:0.000000))&No=0

1980s monstrosities and fast fashion high street wedding dresses from places like wed2be and asos.

Best thing for them to be cut up and reused.

Wow, thanks. My wedding dress was from ASOS because I eloped and didn't want to spend thousands on a bespoke dress, plus I was 25 and didn't have a tonne of disposable income. I looked great on the day, even in my cheapo, Oxfam-worthy dress.

But I suppose the best thing for my dress is to be cut up and reused?

KingsleyShacklebolt · 21/10/2021 16:47

I've no love for Emma Watson - but not sure this criticism is warranted- rewearing a dress she already had would have been more in the spirt but probably wouldn' t have helped grab headlines and promote Emma Watson brand which was proably the aim here.

Agree. And think what you like of Emma Watson, she does grab the headlines. Her choosing to wear this creation has guaranteed coverage for her, but also for the designer who made it, and the charity who supplied the dresses/fabric.

I would LOVE to see what Oxfam's online shop web traffic was like last Sunday night compared with the Sunday before.

inferiorCatSlave · 21/10/2021 16:44

It looks awful and unflattering - and can't see how 10 dresses were needed but I don't think it unusual to reuse/re-purpose clothes from charity shops.

We've take taken clothes apart and used for patterns, modifying in some way or just using for fabric for other stuff.

You tube is full of people doing this - with usually much better results - honestly it looks like a parody of the quite popular practice.

I've no love for Emma Watson - but not sure this criticism is warranted- rewearing a dress she already had would have been more in the spirt but probably wouldn' t have helped grab headlines and promote Emma Watson brand which was proably the aim here.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 21/10/2021 16:44

To be honest, that woman makes me furious - everything about her is smug!

But as much as I want to, I can't do the mental gymnastics which would let me resent her for this. It's an ok gesture. Second-hand wedding dresses are hardly a precious resource, and a great many of them are too outmoded to be worn as they are.

Recycling and updating old occasionwear dresses is a tradition that dates back hundreds of years - even the upper classes used to do it in the Regency period when clothing was well-made, and was loved, mended and respected for generations.

So I'll give her a pass for this.

emmaw1405 · 21/10/2021 16:42

Harris Reed has a 10 piece SS22 collection made of 10 recycled Oxfam wedding dresses - it didn't take 10 dresses to make Emma's outfit.

YearsSinceISawYou · 21/10/2021 16:42

@Reallyimeanreally2022

I don't want to distract from the VERY VERY IMPORTANT issue of Emma's dress but when you write, " so many heinous things to get worked up about and you choose this", what did you mean by 'choose' if it wasn't...'choose to start a thread'?

Surely you didn't mean, 'choose to think about'. That would be like, you know, pretty bad if we can only mull over heinous things and not merely irritating or annoying ones.

OP posts:
Chipsinthewoods · 21/10/2021 16:40

(About fashion and up cycling, not sure I agree with EW brand of feminism but that’s another thread entirely)

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 21/10/2021 16:39

Meh.

They do worse things.

I read she donated money to the charity though. She's a big charity giver so I imagine it was a good sum.

That being said though I doubt she was the one who chose it. She'd have been given the brief of 'white dress made from upcycled Oxfam wedding dresses' would have had her measurements taken and then would have turned up for a fitting.

Regardless, the dresses got bought and reused. That's what they're there for.

londonmummy1966 · 21/10/2021 16:39

YABU

It is great that Oxfam and other charities have bridal boutiques which a) help the planet and b) allow brides to buy dresses they might not otherwise have been able to afford. I helped my BF refashion two into her dream wedding dress. However, the concept was not a new one for the designer who used a lot of secondhand wedding dresses in the recent collection. I think it is great to see designers reusing garments instead of buying new fabric and let's face it, few garments have as much fabric in as the average 1980s marshmallow (hangs guilty head in shame).

Swipe left for the next trending thread